Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?

382 replies

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 18:59

I'm 13 stone 7... To my horror! I knew I'd put on a lot rapidly in a short space of time. I'm aware this actually makes me obese. And I need to lose weight for my health

I don't think I look huge though. Definitely not. Might say I'm a bit chubby at a push. Face doesn't look too fat

AIBU to say you can actually be obese and not realise because you don't look 'fat'?

I'm 5'3 so not tall

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
weepingwinnie · 25/03/2023 21:18

pagopago · 25/03/2023 21:13

I haven't been 7st since I was 7!

More evidence for us all being different. I was 4 stone something in Year 7 (so aged 11), when what I weighed never crossed my mind until school decided it was a good idea to weigh us all. Which is how I found out that I weighed 4 stone something. I looked perfectly normal, though - I'm just very slightly built. Confused

owiz · 25/03/2023 21:16

OP I am simply stunned, how much muscle do you have?! I am 3 stone lighter, 2 inches taller and yet probably look similar to your photos!

Mari9999 · 25/03/2023 21:16

OP, obesity is a medical term ; I don't think it is related to how you like.

OldFan · 25/03/2023 21:14

NHS website says the bottom end of healthy for me would be 7 stone 11! When I was just under 8 stone, I was anorexic. Very low body fat percentage and hardly ate 800 calories a day, usually a lot less. Horrific skin and brittle hair and nails. How is that healthy? BMI says it is which is what I don't like with BMI

@sayitaintsobow It just gives a really generous range. I suppose because someone would have to be quite skinny to be genuinely at risk of health problems as a result of their weight. The BMI is a measure of when someone's weight is actually a health risk to be that weight in itself.

This isn't about that a person might be starving themselves to be that weight etc. If you think of some Japanese women or whatever their frame is absolutely tiny so they could be seven and a half stone and still be healthy.

I agree with you, I was that size and my eating habits were bad and I felt anaemic. But some people genuinely have a very small frame, and they are part of the range.

Some Asian people are considered at risk of diabetes etc at a BMI of over 23. Partly because their frames are small.

pagopago · 25/03/2023 21:13

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:57

I stand corrected, not 7st 11 but 7st 6! As previously said, at a similar weight before I was clinically unwell so why does the BMU calculator tell me 7st 6 is fine for my height? Sad it really wasn't

I haven't been 7st since I was 7!

weepingwinnie · 25/03/2023 21:12

Blossomtoes · 25/03/2023 19:55

No you’re not.

How do you know what she looks like?

I'm 5 foot 2 and would look like a whale at 9st, never mind a "bit chubby". My optimum weight is about 7 stone 6.

We all carry weight differently.

TeenLifeMum · 25/03/2023 21:12

I’m 5’ 4” and in 2018 I was 11st 8, really unhappy with my wobbly fat body. I then lost it and was 9st 12 - so happy. I kept exercising but also ate lots through the pandemic. This morning I was 11st 9… but my bigger body is nothing like it was in 2018. I’m more toned and my hour glass shape isn’t too bad. I would love to get under 11st but only because I miss some of my lovely clothes that don’t fit.

magicthree · 25/03/2023 21:09

I've just seen your photo OP - you look lovely, and slimmer than I do, even though you are shorter and heavier! (grumbles at the unfairness of life.....)

RatesWillRise · 25/03/2023 21:08

It’s how you hold your weight. Pear shaped and muscly types will look better than apples like me.

I have a BMI that only reached 19 after the menopause. Naturally thin like my whole family. But have skinny limbs and bigger boobs and belly.

All the women here genuinely look much better than I do. You all look fabulous!

I have good self-esteem and dress well. Looks aren’t that important to me. But I know I don’t look as good as the ‘overweight’ women pictured here.

EffortlessDesmond · 25/03/2023 21:08

5 feet and five inches for clarification.

EffortlessDesmond · 25/03/2023 21:07

I am %'5" and 62kg, at 67 years old. It feels about right.

pagopago · 25/03/2023 21:06

I am 5.8 and was still slim and gorgeous at 13 stone. I look back at old photos sometimes and would love to be that weight again.

CreepingCrone · 25/03/2023 21:05

I think we are the wrong people to ask. I'm 5' 6. I've been 13st 7lbs and felt like a whale, to the point where I refused to be in photos. Felt dreadful and really low. I'm now 13st 3lbs after losing 3st 3lbs and feel amazing. Fit sz 14 jeans, feel so much better. Love the way I look. I definitely feel much better and more confidence than when I starved myself to 9st!!! (And I still had the family double chin in photos then). It's all relative. I honestly dont think anything anyone else tells you will change the way you feel. That comes from you 🖤

Tessabelle74 · 25/03/2023 21:04

I'm 5ft 6 and 11st and I'm a 14. I don't think you can actually be a 14 if you're only 5ft 3. I suspect you're wearing leggings or similar that have stretched with you. Your BMI is 33.4 so it's also extremely unhealthy for you to be so big unless you're very muscular of course.

magicthree · 25/03/2023 21:04

BeretRaspberry · 25/03/2023 19:02

I was a size 12/14 at 13 stone and 5’6”.

I'm 5'7" and when I was 13 stone I was a size 16, which I still wear at 12 stone. I might be able to wear some size 14 things, but 12 - not a chance. I did manage to wear size 14 at 11 stone, but once again, not 12.

Lastnamedidntstick · 25/03/2023 21:04

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:55

Can anyone answer this about BMI?

I know I'm overweight and need to lose it for my health long term, I know it to be true (factually obese actually), but NHS website says the bottom end of healthy for me would be 7 stone 11!

When I was just under 8 stone, I was anorexic. Very low body fat percentage and hardly ate 800 calories a day, usually a lot less. Horrific skin and brittle hair and nails. How is that healthy?

BMI says it is which is what I don't like with BMI

Exactly the same here.

At just over 8st I had an eating disorder. Took 800 cals/day and a lot of exercise.

yet there’s posters on here at my height saying they’d look flabby at 8st.

although at 8st I had a lot of people telling me I looked great and had the “ideal” body. Nobody really noticed my disordered eating or the fact I’d lost stones in a couple of months.

I think the whole “lost sight of normal” thing works both ways.

EffortlessDesmond · 25/03/2023 21:02

I doubted posting at all on this thread because on a cursory read, which is all I have done, all the posts seem to want to excuse being overweight. If you want a license to eat you heads off, then fine, go ahead and fill your boots.

I won't be joining you.

MamaDollyorJesus · 25/03/2023 21:02

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:55

Can anyone answer this about BMI?

I know I'm overweight and need to lose it for my health long term, I know it to be true (factually obese actually), but NHS website says the bottom end of healthy for me would be 7 stone 11!

When I was just under 8 stone, I was anorexic. Very low body fat percentage and hardly ate 800 calories a day, usually a lot less. Horrific skin and brittle hair and nails. How is that healthy?

BMI says it is which is what I don't like with BMI

This is what I get putting in 5'6" & 11.5st & the pic is what I looked like last time I was at that weight... but any less than that & I look gaunt & unhealthy. There's no way on earth I could ever be 8st3lb - I'd be a bag of bones!

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
Grapewrath · 25/03/2023 20:58

I’m just over 8st at 5ft 4 and at 11st was chunky. I think I look average now, not skinny or fat. 11st is not fat, I just didn’t carry it well.
You might look a million times better. It’s all subjective and body shape dependant

Obki · 25/03/2023 20:58

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:55

Can anyone answer this about BMI?

I know I'm overweight and need to lose it for my health long term, I know it to be true (factually obese actually), but NHS website says the bottom end of healthy for me would be 7 stone 11!

When I was just under 8 stone, I was anorexic. Very low body fat percentage and hardly ate 800 calories a day, usually a lot less. Horrific skin and brittle hair and nails. How is that healthy?

BMI says it is which is what I don't like with BMI

It says the same for me but you need to use your personal judgement as well to see that is too thin. For my friend who is smaller framed than me but the same height, that would be fine.

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:57

I stand corrected, not 7st 11 but 7st 6! As previously said, at a similar weight before I was clinically unwell so why does the BMU calculator tell me 7st 6 is fine for my height? Sad it really wasn't

OP posts:
TellHimDirectlyInDetail · 25/03/2023 20:56

I think you have a great body.

Isnt abese only one more than overweight? I feel like it should be:

Underweight
Ideal
Overweight.
Very overweight
Then obsese
....but it isn't

RatesWillRise · 25/03/2023 20:56

BCBird · 25/03/2023 19:47

I was 23 stone fir most of my adult life avd got down to 13. Felt and looked phenomenal. Curves,boobs and shapely legs. Shame I now 4 abdca half stone heavier.im an emotional.eater: one break up,death of parent and suicide of new partner have contributed to this. Got to get my shit together. I agree re the confidence comment. Not nice undertones.

So sorry you have been through all this. Xx

grafittiartist · 25/03/2023 20:55

I go between 12.5 and 13.5, and always look pretty similar.
5 ft7. Size 16.
I don't look slim, but wouldn't describe myself as fat. I carry weight quiet easily. Would look lots better if I lost a stone, but can't be bothered.

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:55

Can anyone answer this about BMI?

I know I'm overweight and need to lose it for my health long term, I know it to be true (factually obese actually), but NHS website says the bottom end of healthy for me would be 7 stone 11!

When I was just under 8 stone, I was anorexic. Very low body fat percentage and hardly ate 800 calories a day, usually a lot less. Horrific skin and brittle hair and nails. How is that healthy?

BMI says it is which is what I don't like with BMI

OP posts: