Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?

382 replies

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 18:59

I'm 13 stone 7... To my horror! I knew I'd put on a lot rapidly in a short space of time. I'm aware this actually makes me obese. And I need to lose weight for my health

I don't think I look huge though. Definitely not. Might say I'm a bit chubby at a push. Face doesn't look too fat

AIBU to say you can actually be obese and not realise because you don't look 'fat'?

I'm 5'3 so not tall

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
CaribouCarafe · 25/03/2023 22:27

Obki · 25/03/2023 22:23

Did OP say she wondered what 7.5 stone at 5’2” looks like? I must have missed it!

On page 9 OP wrote:

"sayitaintsobow · Today 20:55

Can anyone answer this about BMI?

I know I'm overweight and need to lose it for my health long term, I know it to be true (factually obese actually), but NHS website says the bottom end of healthy for me would be 7 stone 11!

When I was just under 8 stone, I was anorexic. Very low body fat percentage and hardly ate 800 calories a day, usually a lot less. Horrific skin and brittle hair and nails. How is that healthy?"

And later corrects it to 7 stone 6 pounds

SecondhandMuck · 25/03/2023 22:24

You have a lovely shapely figure, @CaribouCarafe. You might want to do a bit of contouring on your face though. It's a bit round if you don't mind me saying so.

Purplesv · 25/03/2023 22:23

I'm "5'3 weigh 11.5 stone and have had 3 babies in the last 5 years. That probably puts me in the obese category or just under. I wouldn't know as I don't check.

I think I look great when compared to my younger, skinnier self. I had an ED and was so gaunt and frail.

I lift weights. Cycle. Swim. I'm very healthy.

There are "plus sized" people who are healthier than size 4-6 people. I'm certainly alot healthier at this weight than I was smaller.

Most of the women I know are between size 12 - 14 and I don't think any one of them look "obese" or awful dispite what the BMI calculator or people on mumsnet says.

It's so sad to see women feeling so shit about themselves at the weights mentioned throughout the thread.

Somebody saying they're overweight at 9 stone, have a day off ffs.

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
Obki · 25/03/2023 22:23

CaribouCarafe · 25/03/2023 22:20

Since you were wondering what 7.5 stone at 5'2" looks like OP here is me.

I'd love to be a bit curvier but don't think I'm skeletal either.

My weight has never fluctuated and I've never been on a diet, just never had a large appetite and am very small framed.

I think OP has a wider frame and an even weight distribution (plus a lovely waist) which is why she carries the weight so well.

Did OP say she wondered what 7.5 stone at 5’2” looks like? I must have missed it!

CaribouCarafe · 25/03/2023 22:20

Since you were wondering what 7.5 stone at 5'2" looks like OP here is me.

I'd love to be a bit curvier but don't think I'm skeletal either.

My weight has never fluctuated and I've never been on a diet, just never had a large appetite and am very small framed.

I think OP has a wider frame and an even weight distribution (plus a lovely waist) which is why she carries the weight so well.

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
blebbleb · 25/03/2023 22:13

Wouldn't that make your bmi almost morbidly obese? I was almost 12 stone at 5 foot 2 and I held the fat quite well but it didn't look great. My bmi was 30. Look and feel much better now I've lost the wight. So bad for your joints and organs.

WhyamIinahandcartandwherearewegoing · 25/03/2023 22:07

One inch taller same weight as you. I look and feel like a big heifer and am trying to shift some weight.

WollyWinka · 25/03/2023 22:06

I don't understand the photos either- if that's you in your knickers.

You look like me, apart from having bigger thighs and boobs and yet I weigh 6 st less. My BMI is normal- just at the low end of normal. I'm old enough to be your mother (or even gran!) and I know I've lost muscle but no way would anyone say I skinny.

Chickenkorma64 · 25/03/2023 22:04

Also 5 ft 3 and about 13stone 2. However Have a very large bust that is immune to diet and exercise. If I chopped them off I’d lose the better part of a stone!
Have to buy tops sometime up to size 22 to fit while lower body is size 16.

It’s hard to look good while the clothing industry designs for people who are in proportion.

Mamai90 · 25/03/2023 22:03

I think it depends. Two of my friends carry weight better than me. When I'm 11 stone and 5'6 I'm a size 12/14 but my friend who is 5'5 is a 10 at 11 stone. Other friend is a 12 at nearly 12 stone but looks amazing in a bikini, she's all boobs and tiny waist. If you feel good that's the most important thing. I'd rather feel good than look good, I've felt repulsive at 10 stone and great at 13 at different times in my life and feeling good is what matters ultimately.

Pointblank2 · 25/03/2023 22:03

I’ve been vastly overweight for years and only 5 ‘2, I think you still can look ok by buying well fitting clothes that suit you and by having your hair and make up done nicely. I can go out feeling totally full of confidence and get compliments. Then someone takes photos and invariably there’s one of me at an unfortunate angle and I look huge, the confidence ebbs away a bit after that.

I try and try to lose weight but to no avail (some medical issues).

Dummycrusher · 25/03/2023 22:03

Ultimately BMI is a broad brush calculator. Anyone whingeing about it needs to take a step back and realise that it's used as a flag for an unhealthy weight - if a person is very athletic or a very small frame, sure, disregard it. If you have a muffin top and a double chin and big folds where your bra strap sits, chances are you are overweight and look overweight. You don't need a number to tell you when you have excess fat. And ultimately, it doesn't really matter if you 'look' overweight or not - it's about whether you feel healthy and are fit and capable. Carrying loads of excess fat isn't good for you, and I'd imagine at the weight you've described you probably have a lot of excess fat.
I looked fine at 5'7 and 11st10 but felt lardy and wasn't fit. I look much better at 11st and am a bit fitter. By 10st7 I won't have significant rolls and will be able to run 5k in less than 30 mins. That's my goal.

artimesiasfootsteps · 25/03/2023 22:00

I’m five foot four and weigh 8.8 stone. I’m slim but skinny fat, not toned at all and soft tummy (recent c section). I think you can look gorgeous at all different weights, one of my best friends is obese in medical terms, but she’s gorgeous, thick bouncy blonde hair, amazing posture etc, I’d trade places with her in a heartbeat.

Flowersinthewindowstill · 25/03/2023 21:58

To get back to 13 stone would be a dream now. At 13 I was generally 10 in shirts and dresses. 14 ish on the bottom.

I'm on the tall side though (5ft 8). The lowest weight of my adult life was 11st 9 and I was an 8 then and quite gaunt looking.

Nothing2lose · 25/03/2023 21:58

I’m 5ft 2 and anything over 10 stone I’m getting chubby/curvy and I hate it. That being said it’s however you feel sexy or comfortable.
Oh and I’ve not got big boobs, I feel like that adds weight to scales.

Wexone · 25/03/2023 21:56

God I am 5ft 5inches I would look dreadfull if was 13 stone. I am currently about 9 stone. walk every single day and dint over do food. does go up a few pounds especially on hols or Xmas buy always get it donw but getting harder as get older (early 40s) my heaviest was 10 and a half stone..I felt dreadfully constantly tired sluggish skin terrible state plus huge belly ( that's where my weight shows ) manged to loose it all during lockdowns ( I know one of the few ) and feel so mich better. clothes fit me better more energy ect no way going back there

polka6 · 25/03/2023 21:50

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 20:57

I stand corrected, not 7st 11 but 7st 6! As previously said, at a similar weight before I was clinically unwell so why does the BMU calculator tell me 7st 6 is fine for my height? Sad it really wasn't

Because it is for some of us. I'm your height and I would look healthy at about 8 stone, even a little less perhaps. We are all built differently. I weight 9 st now. That pic you posted of yourself with a baby, I dont think I look dissimilar to that general size, perhaps only slightly smaller. Yet were 4 stone apart? and the same height. Obviously shows we carry weight so differently. You also have a lovely flat tummy and toned calves! My fat goes straight to the tum/thighs unfortunately. I noticed the other day on the bus, a lady who was significant larger than me, as in literally about 3-4 of me around the middle, had skinnier legs than me. We are all made so differently!

Obki · 25/03/2023 21:43

Plock · 25/03/2023 21:40

What's with all the weight bait threads on here recently?

Of course you can look lovely if you're overweight, just as you can look bloody awful at a healthy weight. All these threads do is invite loads of extremely smug, patronising "well I am Xfeet tall and if I go above eight stone I look DISGUSTING". It's boring and sad. I haven't got a clue how much I weigh and nor could I care less what others weigh.

Yeah the ‘I’m a whale at 9 stone’ post was a bit much 😳

Viviennemary · 25/03/2023 21:42

Its too heavy. Lose 2 stone and you will look a lot better. 3 stone better still.

Plock · 25/03/2023 21:40

What's with all the weight bait threads on here recently?

Of course you can look lovely if you're overweight, just as you can look bloody awful at a healthy weight. All these threads do is invite loads of extremely smug, patronising "well I am Xfeet tall and if I go above eight stone I look DISGUSTING". It's boring and sad. I haven't got a clue how much I weigh and nor could I care less what others weigh.

polka6 · 25/03/2023 21:40

I'm your height too and weigh 9st. No idea when I went from 7st to 9st. I have tummy rolls. I look fat in certain clothes, anything tight around the lower tum. I am technically a healthy weight but I dont have the figure I did 5-10 years ago. I think I need to be around 8 stone. I am naturally a petite frame though so maybe you carry the weight better. I have wobbly thighs and a tum that I want rid.

NicolaSturGONE · 25/03/2023 21:37

Why not just keep your weight to yourself and simply say "I need to lose weight" or "I don't like how I look". There are many people much bigger at your height on here who already feel pretty shit. If you don't like your weight, change it, but weight loss is not some kind of f*cking competition. Even the slimming clubs don't announce your weight to the rest of the group.

RatesWillRise · 25/03/2023 21:23

weepingwinnie · 25/03/2023 21:12

How do you know what she looks like?

I'm 5 foot 2 and would look like a whale at 9st, never mind a "bit chubby". My optimum weight is about 7 stone 6.

We all carry weight differently.

I am almost an identical build to you. I don’t generally comment about my stats on threads like this (even though I have kind of just done so!) as I can’t be bothered ‘defending’ my shape from ‘accusations’ like that person has just posted.

As you say, we are all different with how we carry weight. And people should not be so arrogant as to tell others how they look from some numbers written down.

Bebabelouba · 25/03/2023 21:22

Op you look gorgeous.

pagopago · 25/03/2023 21:21

weepingwinnie · 25/03/2023 21:18

More evidence for us all being different. I was 4 stone something in Year 7 (so aged 11), when what I weighed never crossed my mind until school decided it was a good idea to weigh us all. Which is how I found out that I weighed 4 stone something. I looked perfectly normal, though - I'm just very slightly built. Confused

I clearly remember a weighing session in a GCSE Biology class at the age of 15. I was 5.6 and 10 stone, very slim, and remember my classmates being shocked that I weighed as much as 10 stone.