Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?

382 replies

sayitaintsobow · 25/03/2023 18:59

I'm 13 stone 7... To my horror! I knew I'd put on a lot rapidly in a short space of time. I'm aware this actually makes me obese. And I need to lose weight for my health

I don't think I look huge though. Definitely not. Might say I'm a bit chubby at a push. Face doesn't look too fat

AIBU to say you can actually be obese and not realise because you don't look 'fat'?

I'm 5'3 so not tall

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
19
PurpleAirGuitar · 01/04/2023 18:58

It depends what you mean by "look OK." I look visibly overweight at that weight, there's no doubt about it. But I think I still look attractive.

BelindaBears · 01/04/2023 16:52

I look bloody great at 13.5 stone. I’m 5’10” though.

lljkk · 01/04/2023 16:51

I don't care if ML16 is fat or not.
You can project your own insecurities as much as you like. Knock yourself out.

I am curious what a high % skeletal muscle mass is. The skeletal muscle mass number is what I'm interested in but wasn't obvious, only one number I could find possibly useful because it left 73% of other body composition not described.

Low SMI is <5.7 kg/m2 ... I'm not as easily finding what is a high # is.
I think I worked out that a 60 kg BMI 20 woman (172 cm tall) would be expected to have 12.7 kg of skeletal muscle, or about 21% of her total mass.

An 80 kg 5'8" woman would be expected to have SMI 42.3, which turns into... 14.3 kg of muscle, or 18% of her total mass, but... what is the 95th %centile for the 80 kg 5'8" woman's muscle (and is that 'abnormal').

The muscle mass thing intrigues me because you hear it a lot on MN, people saying they "gained muscle" but I am sure there is a biological limit, women can't gain more than a small kg count of muscle. Probably.

The women in that chart had SMI ranging 30-60. So our hypothetical 80 kg female would be maximum ... 20.3 kg as skeletal muscle mass, or 25% of total mass = skeletal muscle. I think I'm coming up with a natural range of ~10-20 kg as humanly possible range for the 80 kg female, but then there is the 5.7 figure I also found above, which seems crazy low.

If I were ML16 I'd want to know my SMI. They must have calculated it.

mummylondon16 · 01/04/2023 16:22

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

lljkk · 01/04/2023 16:12

I am guilty of not reading every post carefully to find out ML16 previously said she had 35% fat. I did understand one statistic on ML16's chart, though.

I'm just kind of working it out...

This link says up to 73% of female body being non-fat is expected, not that unusual.

This says about 30% of female body is typically skeletal muscle. This also says about 30% as typical for females...... but the neat bit is a woman who had 50% of her mass as skeletal muscle in 2nd chart. If ML16 was 37% body composition fat, I doubt she had 50% skeletal muscle, because 13% for rest of her mass seems too small. But we don't know what threshold is called "abnormal" by who. This study has cool skeletal muscle index per BMI plot too, but I don't really understand it. There is a predictive formula, so basically BMI 30 female expected to have 42.3 SMI, BMI 20 female expected to have 37.5 SMI. There must be some way to back calculate from SMI back to predicted kg total of skeletal muscle.

What Your Body Composition Metrics Actually Say About Your Health

And why you want a scale that measures more than just your weight.

https://www.menshealth.com/health/a27242669/what-your-body-composition-metrics-say-about-your-health/

LunaNorth · 01/04/2023 15:15

Some people on this thread are mind-bogglingly rude.

mummylondon16 · 01/04/2023 14:43

lljkk · 01/04/2023 14:21

Body fat % = 37.2% ?

Ok 37%…. I said 35%…,, As I mentioned in my first and second comment I was overweight and my fat was too high. You asked about % muscle to which I posted the details and screen shot of the report. My point was that previously at. 11 stone I was tiny and the report helped me to understand why ( because I had high muscle so at 11 stone I weighed heavier, I looked gaunt & I was a small size 10). If the point of your replies was to tell me I was fat in this scan I’m well aware I was. I told you in my reply the context of my fatness. What’s your point? Making yourself feel better for the day?

lljkk · 01/04/2023 14:21

Body fat % = 37.2% ?

mummylondon16 · 01/04/2023 14:16

lljkk · 01/04/2023 14:05

@mummylondon16, what was your % muscle mass in that scan, what was your % body fat?

It’s not a percentage as such it’s a very detailed report but they advised me my muscle mass was abnormally high for a woman. See photos attached
I was doing 3 sessions of resistance training there each week and running 3 times a week (15-20,000 steps on average daily). My fat at this time was too high at 35 %. I have lived with undiagnosed hashimotos which destroyed my thyroid and early menopause at 40, so I was fighting against it constantly despite being on a calorie controlled high protein diet and working with a trainer.
Since then I lost 2 stone but only yh by taking ozempic and basically under eating.I’m a qualified personal trainer so if there was an easy answer I would have found it, my body is ultimately very damaged by having no treatment for years & the result being destruction of Thyroid gland. I hope this brief explanation is a tonic for those who tell others it’s easy. Currently I’m paying £300 a month for thyroid medication that includes t3 because the nhs can’t prescribe plus £150 for oxempic. I’m doing 22,000 steps a day which includes running 5 times a week, I use a standing desk, I drink tons of water, don’t drink and eat a very low calorie diet- despite this I’m gaining weight.

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
lljkk · 01/04/2023 14:05

@mummylondon16, what was your % muscle mass in that scan, what was your % body fat?

DaveyJonesLocker · 01/04/2023 13:51

I'm the exact same weight and height as you. I'm fat, sure. But I don't feel obese. I was actually a stone heavier! I want to lose at least 3 stone so I'm a quarter of the way there already!

mummylondon16 · 01/04/2023 12:50

Flowersinthewindowstill · 31/03/2023 20:43

I'm also 5ft 8. At this size I was 10/12 in dresses and tops and 12-14 in trousers. I think it's mostly fat distribution. I'm more pear shaped. At 11 stone 10 I varied from 8-10.

I’m 5ft7/8 and when I was 11 stone people thought I was unwell. I had no boobs or bum, and prominent collar bone.
recently I had a dexa scan as part of investigating other health issues and you could see why I was so heavy : very high muscle mass( see photo attached) the red part of the scan is muscle. I’m 13st8 on this and for me overweight in terms of fat. My ideal weight is 11st7
everyone is made up differently and those who obsess over numbers on here and especially those who make nasty comments don’t realise the damage they do.

you look great btw!

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
LuluLehman · 01/04/2023 11:34

Flowersinthewindowstill · 31/03/2023 19:12

This was me at around 13 stone 7 give or take a few pounds. While I could have done with slightly slimmer legs and arms, I don't think I either looked or felt huge at this size. In fact, would love to get back to that now. 😂

I would say you look like a size 14 in that picture. You look great, by the way. The dress is lovely.

SallyWD · 31/03/2023 21:02

Flowersinthewindowstill · 31/03/2023 20:43

I'm also 5ft 8. At this size I was 10/12 in dresses and tops and 12-14 in trousers. I think it's mostly fat distribution. I'm more pear shaped. At 11 stone 10 I varied from 8-10.

That's interesting. I'm also 5ft 8 and pear shaped but really do look bigger than you in that picture when I'm 11 stone. I think it's because I have no muscle so am quite doughy when I put on a few pounds!

Flowersinthewindowstill · 31/03/2023 20:43

SallyWD · 31/03/2023 19:37

How tall are you? I was surprised how slim OP looked at 5ft3. I'm 5ft8 and look chubby at 11 stone!

I'm also 5ft 8. At this size I was 10/12 in dresses and tops and 12-14 in trousers. I think it's mostly fat distribution. I'm more pear shaped. At 11 stone 10 I varied from 8-10.

SallyWD · 31/03/2023 19:37

Flowersinthewindowstill · 31/03/2023 19:12

This was me at around 13 stone 7 give or take a few pounds. While I could have done with slightly slimmer legs and arms, I don't think I either looked or felt huge at this size. In fact, would love to get back to that now. 😂

How tall are you? I was surprised how slim OP looked at 5ft3. I'm 5ft8 and look chubby at 11 stone!

Flowersinthewindowstill · 31/03/2023 19:12

This was me at around 13 stone 7 give or take a few pounds. While I could have done with slightly slimmer legs and arms, I don't think I either looked or felt huge at this size. In fact, would love to get back to that now. 😂

To say you can still look okay at 13 stone?
Stugs · 30/03/2023 09:06

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 29/03/2023 22:41

I’m 5’7 and 13 stone and look fairly slim apart from a massive 40 inch waist.

I must admit I'm struggling to picture this.

I am same height and weight give or take a pound and I also have a huge waist.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 29/03/2023 22:41

I’m 5’7 and 13 stone and look fairly slim apart from a massive 40 inch waist.

I must admit I'm struggling to picture this.

Whipmuncher · 28/03/2023 20:24

JaneFondue · 26/03/2023 13:32

For me, it's because I have unwisely decided to carry my weight on my tummy:)
Everyone who has posted looks better than me because their weight is spread evenly. I have a classic peri-menopausal apple shape.

Same here. I’m 5’7 and 13 stone and look fairly slim apart from a massive 40 inch waist. Menopause. I’ve gained just over half a stone in the past 2 years and from that 6 inches round the middle!

surreygirl1987 · 28/03/2023 20:17

To me, any woman under 6'2 foot tall weighing 13.7 stone, would look fat.

Hmm... I'm a little above that and don't think I look fat, but maybe I am deluded!

yogaretreat · 28/03/2023 20:12

I was around this weight after my son, I'm 5ft 8 and I felt really big. Thighs chaffed, flabby tummy, huge boobs. I'm much happier at 11/12 stone.

SallyWD · 28/03/2023 19:58

Dacadactyl · 28/03/2023 19:39

Didnt realise she had posted one. What page is it on?

I'm on the app on my phone so no pages. She posted it Saturday 25th March at 19.28

Dacadactyl · 28/03/2023 19:39

Didnt realise she had posted one. What page is it on?

SallyWD · 28/03/2023 19:34

Dacadactyl · 28/03/2023 19:20

To me, any woman under 6'2 foot tall weighing 13.7 stone, would look fat.

That's what I used to think but look at OP's photo!