Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel ashamed, embarrassed and not know how to fix this?

468 replies

Avatarthewayofwater · 25/03/2023 18:51

I've taken the image from Google as I'm far to embarrassed to take a picture of myself.

Any weight I gain goes on my stomach and due to emotional binge eating I find myself here.

I did have ultrasound scans to check nothing underlying was going on, but no its visceral fat and only I can get rid if it.

The problem is I've changed my diet completely and calorie counting and eating healthy along with exercise. Yet nothing has changed stomach wise.

I'm so self conscious and I can't wear normal clothes because I constantly look pregnant.

Even at the gym I hide in a big hoodie so no one can see.

It's making me depressed and I don't know how to get rid of the stomach fat.

Has anyone else been like this and managed? I had a c section years ago and have an underactive thyroid if that makes any difference.

Please be kind...

To feel ashamed, embarrassed and not know how to fix this?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
TBOM · 27/03/2023 18:20

MilkToastHoney · 27/03/2023 18:19

You can’t target fat loss from a specific area of the body unfortunately. Doing all/only abs work as your exercise will do nothing to reduce the body fat on your stomach.
The only way to lose body fat is through a calorie deficit. There isn’t a way to control which areas of the body the fat comes off first.

You can target which areas of the body you muscle build. As a woman building stomach muscles that show is incredibly hard. You need very little body fat and a huge amount of training.

Far, far better to work on weight training in all areas or the body - arms, legs, back, shoulders, stomach, bum.

100% - I put weight on my belly first and lose it last.

MilkToastHoney · 27/03/2023 18:19

Grammarnut · 27/03/2023 18:08

Seriously large lunch and not enough breakfast. For breakfast, I either have oats, zero fat yoghurt and fruit (put together overnight) or sometimes grilled bacon fat removed, scrambled eggs and baked beans. Lunch a baked potato with tuna in brine (whole small tine) and a tablespoon of low fat mayo (substitute beans if not had for breakfast) and dinner - which has to accommodate lactose intolerant DH - something like pasta with low fat mince, mushrooms, peppers and using a low fat frying agent etc as a bolognese style sauce. I have lost over a stone since the middle of Aug 22 (and feel much better). Excercise consists of bell ringing 3 times a week, a modicum of housework (more interesting things to do) and some gardening. Losing weight from tums is hard and I doubt 30 minutes a day on a running machine will do it - it needs exercises that involve stomach muscles such as lying on the floor and raising the legs (don't know name for this!) in order to return some tone - but only with GP's advice, esp if have had a C-section.

You can’t target fat loss from a specific area of the body unfortunately. Doing all/only abs work as your exercise will do nothing to reduce the body fat on your stomach.
The only way to lose body fat is through a calorie deficit. There isn’t a way to control which areas of the body the fat comes off first.

You can target which areas of the body you muscle build. As a woman building stomach muscles that show is incredibly hard. You need very little body fat and a huge amount of training.

Far, far better to work on weight training in all areas or the body - arms, legs, back, shoulders, stomach, bum.

Grammarnut · 27/03/2023 18:08

TBOM · 27/03/2023 14:29

That would be a seriously large lunch for me - I'd have either the eggs or tuna, not both, with the veg, and that's on a maintenance eating pattern. I'd never lose any weight if I ate a lunch that size, I'd probably gain.

Seriously large lunch and not enough breakfast. For breakfast, I either have oats, zero fat yoghurt and fruit (put together overnight) or sometimes grilled bacon fat removed, scrambled eggs and baked beans. Lunch a baked potato with tuna in brine (whole small tine) and a tablespoon of low fat mayo (substitute beans if not had for breakfast) and dinner - which has to accommodate lactose intolerant DH - something like pasta with low fat mince, mushrooms, peppers and using a low fat frying agent etc as a bolognese style sauce. I have lost over a stone since the middle of Aug 22 (and feel much better). Excercise consists of bell ringing 3 times a week, a modicum of housework (more interesting things to do) and some gardening. Losing weight from tums is hard and I doubt 30 minutes a day on a running machine will do it - it needs exercises that involve stomach muscles such as lying on the floor and raising the legs (don't know name for this!) in order to return some tone - but only with GP's advice, esp if have had a C-section.

TBOM · 27/03/2023 17:44

And yes on weights. If I want to dump a few pounds I hit the weights.

TBOM · 27/03/2023 17:43

MilkToastHoney · 27/03/2023 17:40

Completely agree with this.

Unless you are in a very active job then doing intensive sports on top, I would never deduct exercise calories.
As a whole, we are far more sedentary than we are designed to be as humans. Doing several hours of walking/physical exercise should be the norm, not something extra in order to eat extra food!

100%. I walk over 2 hours a day to and from work (I like walking) and it wouldn't even occur to me to log those calories. I can easily do 15-20k steps a day. That's just compensating for a sedentary office day.

MilkToastHoney · 27/03/2023 17:40

TBOM · 27/03/2023 16:48

Roughly how many calories net are you aiming for a day? I need to get to 1200 net to lose weight - and I tend to put on weight in exactly the same place as you. Looking at your meal plan - that breakfast alone must be pushing close to 500 calories. I wouldn't even eat 500 calories for lunch, let alone breakfast, if I was aiming to maintain or lose weight. Add on probably another 500 for lunch, assuming you had more than just eggs in your scrambled eggs. That's 1000 calories before you have dinner, without snacks. And people can massively overestimate how many calories they're burning through exercise - you'd need to do an awful lot of exercise to create a calorie deficit with a diet like that. My DP does a serious amount of sport (ex pro Rugby player) and he wouldn't eat that much for breakfast and lunch.

Completely agree with this.

Unless you are in a very active job then doing intensive sports on top, I would never deduct exercise calories.
As a whole, we are far more sedentary than we are designed to be as humans. Doing several hours of walking/physical exercise should be the norm, not something extra in order to eat extra food!

MilkToastHoney · 27/03/2023 17:35

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 16:29

Yes I am logging everything on mfp and my smart watch is linked too so it works out when I need extra calories from exercising.

But are you WEIGHING everything?
Not just logging 2 eggs as scrambled eggs. Are you WEIGHING how much oil you cook in? Weighing how much milk in your coffee? Weighing butter on your toast? Weighing nuts/fruit/yoghurt you eat? Weighing mayonnaise you put on things, dressing on salad?

I wouldn’t deduct the calories from exercise. Unless you are working out at very intensive levels. Walking for 30 minutes on a treadmill is pretty insignificant in terms of calories and will often be overestimated on smart watches/mfp.
Body fat loss will come from what you eat. Cardio is great in lots of ways but I wouldn’t subtract from your calorie expenditure. It can also make you hungry and make sticking to a deficit difficult/miserable. Weight lifting doesn’t do this.
Get lifting those weights ASAP, even if it’s just your body weight resistance for now - push ups, plank etc. Getting up at 4am could be MUCH better spent by doing shorter amount of time on weights. Sleep is also important for weight loss.

Keep drinking masses of water - loads and loads! X

TBOM · 27/03/2023 16:49

I don't mean to sound unkind BTW - it's hard. I know, I've been there.

TBOM · 27/03/2023 16:48

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 16:29

Yes I am logging everything on mfp and my smart watch is linked too so it works out when I need extra calories from exercising.

Roughly how many calories net are you aiming for a day? I need to get to 1200 net to lose weight - and I tend to put on weight in exactly the same place as you. Looking at your meal plan - that breakfast alone must be pushing close to 500 calories. I wouldn't even eat 500 calories for lunch, let alone breakfast, if I was aiming to maintain or lose weight. Add on probably another 500 for lunch, assuming you had more than just eggs in your scrambled eggs. That's 1000 calories before you have dinner, without snacks. And people can massively overestimate how many calories they're burning through exercise - you'd need to do an awful lot of exercise to create a calorie deficit with a diet like that. My DP does a serious amount of sport (ex pro Rugby player) and he wouldn't eat that much for breakfast and lunch.

PousseyNotMoira · 27/03/2023 16:34

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 16:29

Yes I am logging everything on mfp and my smart watch is linked too so it works out when I need extra calories from exercising.

I know I keep asking, but what are you logging as ‘mixed veg’? What vegetables.

And are you logging all sauces/condiments/add ins? For example, if you scrambled the eggs with butter, black pepper and some milk, don’t just log the eggs.

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 16:29

Yes I am logging everything on mfp and my smart watch is linked too so it works out when I need extra calories from exercising.

OP posts:
MilkToastHoney · 27/03/2023 16:07

Are you weighing everything? The oil you cook with, sauces/mayo you put on, spoonfuls of cottage cheese/yoghurt, milk in coffee, etc, etc.

Most people (especially those who are overweight and have past of disordered eating) massively underestimate calories.

It’s essential you are in a calorie deficit for body fat loss. Going to the gym every day, cutting things out your diet, walking loads etc is all pointless if you aren’t weighing your food/accurately tracking calories.

Cottage cheese, 2 eggs and a tin tuna seems like a massive lunch in all honestly. Plus your dinner. I’d have either tuna, cheese or eggs personally.
Fair enough if you are weighing and accurately tracking and it’s small portions and coming in as a deficit though. If you are just estimating without weighing though you could easily be over based on the food you’ve described.

Hayliebells · 27/03/2023 15:33

Fair play to you for getting up and doing it, but a 4am start to go to the gym before work is quite extreme! Why don't you just put a fitness video on and jump about your living room for 30 mins? The FitOn app is a good shout, I'd forgotten about that. Fair enough on the days that you're lifting weights you need to be in the gym (although you could do that at home too, if you bought some), but that won't be every day, more like 3x a week. The hassle of going to the gym just to use the treadmill is pointless imo. Are you really going to do this every day? I'd worry it's unsustainable, and you'd end up packing it all in.

Inwiththenew · 27/03/2023 15:32

You might have a bacterial imbalance. Looks like you’re not digesting food properly. Gluten intolerance can make it very hard to lose belly fat. Maybe get some probiotics, quit gluten and do more exercises that will work your abdominal muscles, some resistance training. Walking is great but it isn’t enough to lose belly fat. You’ll feel better if you make sure to get a sweat on.

TBOM · 27/03/2023 14:29

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 13:34

So I got up at 4am and went to the gym. I managed 30 minutes on the treadmill doing rolling hills and 15 minutes spinning. I'm going to try and go everyday and up the intensity bit by bit before my PT session on Sunday.

To eat I've had:
Breakfast
1 cup of grapes
2 low fat yoghurt
1 handful of cashew nuts

Lunch
Cottage cheese
2 eggs scrambled
Steam bag of mixed veg
1 tin of tuna

For tea my partner is cooking tacos with low fat minced beef.

I've also tried really hard to up my water intake.

That would be a seriously large lunch for me - I'd have either the eggs or tuna, not both, with the veg, and that's on a maintenance eating pattern. I'd never lose any weight if I ate a lunch that size, I'd probably gain.

Cerealkillerontheloose · 27/03/2023 13:59

BatshitCrazyWoman · 27/03/2023 07:46

I am aware, I have Graves' Disease. A bit of digging will find the NICE guidelines which can be used to talk to your GP. It may not have anything to do with the OP's issues, but lots of people seem to be on tiny doses of levothyroxine and have woefully low thyroid hormones as a result.

I have no advice, OP, except to say I don't recommend planks, Pilates is excellent for ab muscles, and Lucy Wyndham Reed's standing ab workouts are excellent too.

I agree. I work with endocrine doctors and they would agree. However she can’t go changing her medication and it’s dangerous advice to suggest she do so.

RunningShoe · 27/03/2023 13:46

And are you weighing and tracking your food? Tacos with minced beef could be anywhere between a few hundred and over a thousand calories, it depends on the portion size and what else is going into it.

I tend to do well in the day and then fuck up in the evening if I am being strict with my diet, I manage fine in the day time when Im busy at work then overeat when DP cooks tea. Right now I am consciously aiming for higher calories (2,000) which based on my exercise should still result in weight loss, so I don’t feel deprived and don’t binge.

RunningShoe · 27/03/2023 13:42

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 13:34

So I got up at 4am and went to the gym. I managed 30 minutes on the treadmill doing rolling hills and 15 minutes spinning. I'm going to try and go everyday and up the intensity bit by bit before my PT session on Sunday.

To eat I've had:
Breakfast
1 cup of grapes
2 low fat yoghurt
1 handful of cashew nuts

Lunch
Cottage cheese
2 eggs scrambled
Steam bag of mixed veg
1 tin of tuna

For tea my partner is cooking tacos with low fat minced beef.

I've also tried really hard to up my water intake.

I think you should consider carefully whether this is sustainable for you, do you have an idea of how many calories you need a day and how much of a deficit you’re creating with this? You want to put something in place that you can sustain long term so anything that’s too punishing is a mistake IMO, unless you have iron willpower!

Avatarthewayofwater · 27/03/2023 13:34

So I got up at 4am and went to the gym. I managed 30 minutes on the treadmill doing rolling hills and 15 minutes spinning. I'm going to try and go everyday and up the intensity bit by bit before my PT session on Sunday.

To eat I've had:
Breakfast
1 cup of grapes
2 low fat yoghurt
1 handful of cashew nuts

Lunch
Cottage cheese
2 eggs scrambled
Steam bag of mixed veg
1 tin of tuna

For tea my partner is cooking tacos with low fat minced beef.

I've also tried really hard to up my water intake.

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 27/03/2023 12:29

Hayliebells · 26/03/2023 21:30

You need to add in some carbs. The protein and veg content is good, but you do need carbs for every. How about overnight oats for breakfast, with yogurt, and fruit? And carbs with your lunch and dinner too. It doesn't need to be white starchy carbs. Have the eggs on granary toast, green lentils would be nice with that pork. If you're exercising particularly you need fuel.

Nuts carry lots of calories. Try something else. Chicken is good.

FacebookFun · 27/03/2023 11:39

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

Giletjaune · 27/03/2023 11:30

Sucrose is a disaccaride, which breaks down into glucose and fructose which are monosaccarides. All of these 3 sugars can be found in fruits. Too much fructose is not a good thing despite it being “natural”.

benten54 · 27/03/2023 09:37

@Hayliebells "Your body cannot access the energy it needs quickly during exercise from fat alone. You cannot workout intensely and rely on fat to provide that energy. You can do low intensity exercise, but not strength training, or a spin class."

Nonsense. I have trained for and ran several marathons and numerous quarter marathons while very very low carb. As long as your body has turned into and is acclimatised to fat burning and not sugar burning there is plenty of easy access energy.

ukgone2pot · 27/03/2023 09:13

Divorcedalongtime · 27/03/2023 06:54

I am so sick of peoples inability to believe that fruits are not always good for you.
grapes have a higher than usual sugar content .
sugar is bad for us. Especially if you are trying to loose weight.
I see people do this all the time, where they are dieting and dieting and loosing nothing because they are under the impression that fruits and berries are nothing but healthy.

also portions, people assume that since fruits and berries are healthy they can eat as many as they want but 1 serving of grapes is liken 10-15, any more than that is far too much sugar for a person living normally and exercising. Again, for anyone dieting there is just no reason to add sugar full stop.
why make it harder for yourself?

And I'm sick of people's inability to know the difference between what's good and what's not. Fruit is not bad for you. It's a natural sugar - i.e. fructose. It is broken down differently than refined sugar, i.e. - sucrose. Does that mean I would suggest the OP should ate 10-20 pieces a day? No. But as long as she's in a calorific deficit then she should lose. Period.

RunningShoe · 27/03/2023 08:46

The other thing OP, is that if your stomach is like mine and like the photo in the OP the DR thing is a cause but also maybe a distraction to the real issue, which is the layer of fat sitting on top of and hanging off it.

i can live with the DR, it’s the fat I want to shift - I don’t really care if my stomach still sticks out a bit at the end of that process. I just want to be healthy and not be so squishy.