Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely it should be possible to get an insurance quote anonymously?

59 replies

krummyday · 25/03/2023 16:42

When getting car/home insurance quotes, you have to enter a lot of personal information. Most of the information is relevant to the quote, but personal details like your name, contact details and exact address (rather than just postcode) usually aren't. They don't need to email me the quote - I'm happy to just see it on screen and perhaps download it - but of course they want my contact details for profiling and data mining. I'd prefer to only give these details to the company I decide to purchase from, not all the others.

In the past I used false names and throwaway email addresses, but now they seem to recognise that and tell me (after filling in the whole form) that they can't give me a quote.

Does this bother you too? I feel it should be a legal right to get a quote with only the minimum data required.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VeniVidiWeeWee · 26/03/2023 23:39

krummyday · 26/03/2023 10:52

It used to be possible. Then it changed. Is it ok if I mourn that?

Yes.

But completely irrelevant today.

OrangeFluff · 26/03/2023 23:38

Also it has already been explained that the soft credit check (not hard which is fine when paying monthly) is to help identify you. They help build a profile of your risk. If you’ve missed payments regularly then statistically you have a more chaotic life and more likely to have an accident. Yes it’s legal to do a soft check. It does not impact your score and can only be seen by yourself, no lenders can see it.

OrangeFluff · 26/03/2023 23:33

EnthENd · 26/03/2023 20:50

I vote YANBU.

The insurance industry in Britain has repeatedly proven itself untrustworthy. I think it's more likely than not that name is being used as a proxy for discrimination based on sex and race, no doubt hidden behind claims about "statistical analysis".

You may well find that people who default on their credit cards are more likely to suffer a loss event, so this is relevant information for the insurers.

If I pay for insurance up front then it is not a credit product. So genuine question, is it even legal for the price of something I buy to be set based on a credit check when I am not borrowing any money?

When have you ever inputted your race into a comparison site? Data is not gathered on the race of previous claimants so how would it be rated on? 🙄

It’s quite well known that women used to get cheaper insurance than men (quite rightly because statistically accidents caused by men cost the UW more than accidents caused by women) but this was changed due to equality. The ONLY thing insurers can’t rate on is sex/gender.

Every other detail is rated on. It’s all calculated by statistics based on many many factors compiled by evidence.

Insurers are highly regulated by the FCA. Anyone who says otherwise does not have a clue.

Saschka · 26/03/2023 21:06

CeliaNorth · 26/03/2023 13:18

I always invert a couple of numbers in the phone number. It's not necessary for the actual quote and stops me getting a load of nuisance calls when they sell your info.

So someone else is getting them instead?

Isn't there always a box to check to say whether you do or don't want to be contacted?

Often no - you can’t get to the quote without putting the number in, and if you tick the “please contact me by email” box, that doesn’t mean you don’t get multiple phone calls as well, IME.

EnthENd · 26/03/2023 20:50

I vote YANBU.

The insurance industry in Britain has repeatedly proven itself untrustworthy. I think it's more likely than not that name is being used as a proxy for discrimination based on sex and race, no doubt hidden behind claims about "statistical analysis".

You may well find that people who default on their credit cards are more likely to suffer a loss event, so this is relevant information for the insurers.

If I pay for insurance up front then it is not a credit product. So genuine question, is it even legal for the price of something I buy to be set based on a credit check when I am not borrowing any money?

CeliaNorth · 26/03/2023 13:18

I always invert a couple of numbers in the phone number. It's not necessary for the actual quote and stops me getting a load of nuisance calls when they sell your info.

So someone else is getting them instead?

Isn't there always a box to check to say whether you do or don't want to be contacted?

DaveyJonesLocker · 26/03/2023 11:15

Businessflake · 26/03/2023 10:57

They get most of it by charging the insurance companies a fee per policy.

Absolutely but if you don't sign a policy then they don't earn money

Businessflake · 26/03/2023 10:57

DaveyJonesLocker · 26/03/2023 07:59

It's not a free service, they need to make money for the software and time that is required to provide you with a quote. They earn that money by selling your data.

They get most of it by charging the insurance companies a fee per policy.

krummyday · 26/03/2023 10:52

It used to be possible. Then it changed. Is it ok if I mourn that?

OP posts:
Slaistery · 26/03/2023 10:23

krummyday · 25/03/2023 22:11

I always pay my insurance up front - and I ticked a box to say that is the option I would choose - so there is no excuse for the insurer to credit check me. I filled in the form once only, using correct but depersonalised details, because I genuinely wanted an anonymous quote. I don't think that's an unreasonable expectation, and I wasn't asked to agree to any terms and conditions that might have had small print.

You can’t get an anonymous quote. It doesn’t exist. I understand that you wish it did, but it doesn’t.

Insurers are in the business of aggregating and underwriting risks. Your risk profile is built from multiple pieces of information - including your soft credit check. You may well find that people who default on their credit cards are more likely to suffer a loss event, so this is relevant information for the insurers. It’s individual, not your post code based information. the more information insurers have about you, the better they can assess your risk.

Your actions, in lying about your name and details is indicative of a poor risk for them. Congratulations - they now think you’re a fraud risk. Which you are, statistically, because you’re a proven liar.

VeggieSalsa · 26/03/2023 10:20

If you’re not paying for the product, you’re the product.

The reason comparison sites can be free is because they want your data. That’s what makes them their money. Putting false or incomplete data in is useless to them, and so they have a built a system that doesn’t allow it.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 10:18

Saschka · 26/03/2023 10:08

Unfortunately as far as I can see, their real business is getting your personal details and flogging them on to other companies Angry

Yea. Exactly.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 26/03/2023 10:17

Saschka · 26/03/2023 10:06

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts we’re talking about people changing their personal details because they don’t want their inbox flooding, or a tonne of spam calls, or multiple credit checks on their file, when they are just trying to work out the best quote.

Nobody is complaining about putting their real details in when they are actually applying.

I know that.

But you won't get a truly accurate quote without putting in your personal details - that's the whole point.

SpecialControlGroup · 26/03/2023 10:16

I always invert a couple of numbers in the phone number. It's not necessary for the actual quote and stops me getting a load of nuisance calls when they sell your info

Saschka · 26/03/2023 10:08

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 10:03

A comparison site is a service. They provide quotes as their service, they don’t provide insurance. So, no, they aren’t touting for business, that is their business.

Unfortunately as far as I can see, their real business is getting your personal details and flogging them on to other companies Angry

Saschka · 26/03/2023 10:06

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts we’re talking about people changing their personal details because they don’t want their inbox flooding, or a tonne of spam calls, or multiple credit checks on their file, when they are just trying to work out the best quote.

Nobody is complaining about putting their real details in when they are actually applying.

Badbudgeter · 26/03/2023 10:04

Saschka · 25/03/2023 17:59

I agree with you OP - I’ve been looking at life insurance recently, put my details into Money Supermarket, and as a result have been getting multiple calls a day from various brokers trying to flog me stuff (not just life insurance, they’ve been trying to get me to sign up for their mortgage services, new phone contract, change gas suppliers - Money Supermarket have obviously passed my details on to anyone who wants it).

It is really offputting - I got 10 calls on Friday alone. Honestly I’ll put fake details in next time and then apply directly with the company once I’ve got a quote.

Yes. That happened to me. It was actually really sneaky the way some of them operated. They'd call me by name and say things like we want to check whether this life insurance product is still the right one for you. I asked the name of the firm and they told me the correct one. It was implied that they were calling from my insurance provider. I was really annoyed and now make sure I uncheck all the contact me by phone/ email options.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 10:03

QuitRunningForThatRunawayBus · 25/03/2023 22:19

But it's not a service, it's merely a quotation. They are touting for your business, nothing more.

A comparison site is a service. They provide quotes as their service, they don’t provide insurance. So, no, they aren’t touting for business, that is their business.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 26/03/2023 09:54

But why would checking how the premium changes if I put the excess up, or take off accidental damage cover, etc be “potentially fraudulent” and need flagging?

That's not what this thread is about though. Of course you can do all those things - and most comparison websites will adjust the quote as you go along so you can chop/change what cover you ask for and how much you want your excess to be.

We're talking about people changing their personal details when they're getting a quote.

DaveyJonesLocker · 26/03/2023 07:59

It's not a free service, they need to make money for the software and time that is required to provide you with a quote. They earn that money by selling your data.

MisogynyNonConforming · 26/03/2023 07:56

Research has shown that even your name impacts the quotation an insurer will give you. There doesn't seem to be any regulation to prevent insurers from discriminating on such unreasonable bases, which is pretty outrageous given that insurance is a legal requirement/necessity for the majority (if not all) people for something in their lives.

OrangeFluff · 26/03/2023 06:31

People on this thread were talking about changing occupation, address, name, dob- I was referring to that. Not changing excesses.

Saschka · 26/03/2023 03:45

OrangeFluff · 25/03/2023 21:25

I work in car insurance. Yes we do need to know your name. A soft credit check is run every time you run a quote. The CUE database is also checked.
Every single piece of information you put into your quote is a rating factor for the UW. The only thing we cannot rate on sex/gender. That’s it.
When we see policies set up by people who have done numerous quotes changing details on each one, it will trigger our review team to run additional checks as it can be seen as quote manipulation and potentially fraudulent.

But why would checking how the premium changes if I put the excess up, or take off accidental damage cover, etc be “potentially fraudulent” and need flagging?

If I book a holiday, I’m not banned from asking how much the hotel will cost room-only compared with B&B. If I buy a new car, I can ask how much with and without alloy wheels etc. Why the lack of transparency when I want to buy insurance?

Talulah29 · 25/03/2023 22:39

Talulah29 · 25/03/2023 22:37

You can generally see a quote on the screen if using companies websites directly as opposed to the comparison site. It then usually gives you the option to save or email yourself a copy if you want to.
My friend feels the same as you and doesn’t like putting her personal information in unless she’s buying the policy, so she usually puts a different date of birth/ initial etc (eg 10/01/85 instead of 09/02/95) into the information box if she is just looking for quotes and has never had an issue. She sees the prices and then when ready goes back to whoever she’s going to purchase the policy from and then puts her real information in. She said the price is pretty much always the same as whatever the quote was.

Sorry that meant to say (eg 10/01/85 instead of 09/02/85*)

She obviously doesn’t put 10 years apart!

Talulah29 · 25/03/2023 22:37

You can generally see a quote on the screen if using companies websites directly as opposed to the comparison site. It then usually gives you the option to save or email yourself a copy if you want to.
My friend feels the same as you and doesn’t like putting her personal information in unless she’s buying the policy, so she usually puts a different date of birth/ initial etc (eg 10/01/85 instead of 09/02/95) into the information box if she is just looking for quotes and has never had an issue. She sees the prices and then when ready goes back to whoever she’s going to purchase the policy from and then puts her real information in. She said the price is pretty much always the same as whatever the quote was.