Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MH issues in 5 year olds other than ASD?

64 replies

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 14:04

If anyone has a child around 5 with a diagnosed MH issue thats not (typical) ASD. Could you pls tell me about the most telling signs (or quirks) that prompted the specific diagnosis?

My 5 year old seems to be struggling a lot and it has really impacted our lives. It’s been going on for years and I gave up on hoping he’ll outgrow it. Of course, I thoroughly read up on ASD and ADHD but quite frankly these don’t seem to fit (even at a stretch).

I know I’ll need a professional to diagnose him but I’d at least like know what direction to look. Any kind of professional diagnosis will be years away as he’s high functioning and it’s normally the “wait and see” advice I’m getting.

Family members think it’s only due to bad parenting and I agree that’s very much a possibility. But, still, there’s a possibility he has some underlying problem that would need a specific approach to manage, so I’m just trying to gather more info.

OP posts:
Crumpetdisappointment · 25/03/2023 17:45

what does school say op?
you dont have to diagnosis but you can ask for a referral to a paediatrician

Whatwasthepoint · 25/03/2023 17:44

There is no point handing out consequences when kids are terrified because they can't take any information in.

no but you can calmly remove the missiles as they land and reassure them in a soothing tone while you do so. The discussion around consequences can happen when the meltdown has passed.

"Ok I get you were scared, let's hug it out. You know there are better ways of managing big feelings don't you? Let's get you some of these toys back shall we? Let's get ready for bed and you can have X toys back..."

Ilooklikesusiedent · 25/03/2023 17:43

Yes DS had diagnosed anxiety at aged 5 and the NHS waiting list was LONG! He started hurting himself as punishment for feeling anxious so we panicked (self harm) and started private play therapy.

It was incredible and the school said he's back to his usual self within 2 sessions!! We stuck with it for 6 sessions and then reduced the frequency.

It was £45 per session. And about 45 mins (I think!)

Spendonsend · 25/03/2023 17:41

Geneticsbunny · 25/03/2023 17:39

He sounds like he is in fight or flight mode all the time. There is no point handing out consequences when kids are terrified because they can't take any information in.

Try reading the explosive child by Ross greene and the out of sync child and see if they ring true for you.

I would agree with this.

Spendonsend · 25/03/2023 17:40

When you say tantruming. Is this behaviour is response to being told no to something such as sweets and would it stop of you gave him the sweets?
Or is it more like a meltdown in response to something and stopping that thing dorsnt instantly stop the behaviou, the behaviour just has to work its way through?

Geneticsbunny · 25/03/2023 17:39

He sounds like he is in fight or flight mode all the time. There is no point handing out consequences when kids are terrified because they can't take any information in.

Try reading the explosive child by Ross greene and the out of sync child and see if they ring true for you.

Whatwasthepoint · 25/03/2023 17:36

Put everything up on shelves that he can't access and have his room pretty bleak/safe for him to trash. Everything he throws out/smashes pick up calmly and put in a bin liner. Everything gets put in a bin liner and he earns them back. First thing goes back when he calms down has a cuddle and says sorry (and means it). The rest he earns back over a period of tasks that he completes without a fight. It's tedious but he needs to know you mean business and he's not in charge of calling the shots.

Even if he had a diagnosis of some description you would still need to take a firmer line with your parenting and give him safe places to meltdown without you getting cross. Calmly repeat "you're safe you're loved it's ok I know you're feeling sad but I'm here for you" and lay down the foundations when he's calm. Get a squashmallow type toy that he can pummel when he's cross and encourage him to use it when he's calm.

Then, as time goes on, try and unpick what's going on. Is he anxious about school? Has something scared him (an unexplained noise at night) and he can't process it? Has he over heard a conversation and has turned it into a big thing like 5 year olds are prone to do?

This may not work, and I'm sorry if you've already tried it all! I wish you luck. It's horrible when they're scaring themselves and you can't fix it quickly

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 17:25

@Whatwasthepoint no matter what, he doesn’t care (things people often suggest, like take away a toy, say ur not going to the park if you don’t put on your shoes; these don’t have any effect as he just says ok, don’t care and he really doesn’t care.). If he gets sent to his room he just trashes it, this only frightens him but nothing improves. I’m open to suggestions of course, but I haven’t found anything that works.

OP posts:
Jules912 · 25/03/2023 17:21

Meant to add OT said most autistic children also have sensory issues but the reverse isn't necessarily true.

Whatwasthepoint · 25/03/2023 17:16

What consequences are there to his actions?

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 17:15

@Whatwasthepoint thanks, I realise this works for a lot of families, but it’s completely unfeasible with DS. It really doesn’t matter if we set out a “bed time”, this will not be respected, he just won’t sleep or be quiet in his room, he will just scream in fright and trash the room. Same with dressing up etc, he just won’t cooperate, dressing up can take any time between 5 minutes to an hour depending on how lucky we are… it’s not like we haven’t attempted more structure, it’s that he just won’t go along with the routine and I can’t make him comply with these kind of demands.

OP posts:
Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 17:04

@Jules912 just looked up interoception and this is definitely an issue with our DS too.

OP posts:
Whatwasthepoint · 25/03/2023 17:03

One of mine is exactly like this. A really really rigid routine with firm boundaries have helped with behavioural regulation. Contrary to modern parenting beliefs children thrive off strong boundaries and push you until you provide them. I hate being so firm but my child has become so much more settled when life has become more predictable. They know what to expect and when, there are no surprises sprung on them, bedtime is always at the same time every night.

It's extremely restrictive but we are looking at an ASD diagnosis here however by being so rigid it's led to almost no violent meltdowns. I have got one of those picture charts where you can plan the day for them - up, washed and dressed, breakfast, TV while mummy gets ready, when mummy comes downstairs it's shoes on and out the door etc etc.

So that would be my advice. Give them security in routine.

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 17:00

@BertieBotts thanks for the link, i’ll have a read. I think he may have some extra sensitivity to noise, touch and lights in some situations but not really consistently.

OP posts:
Jules912 · 25/03/2023 16:58

My DD is awaiting an ASD assessment but has a lot of sensory issues which are the cause of most ( not all) her meltdowns. I took her to an Occupational Therapist who picked up the obvious ones and some more subtle ones like issues with intoception ( think that's the right turn) and weak postural muscles do it actually causes her pain to sit up straight like they expect in school.

Feeling100 · 25/03/2023 16:55

If it’s any consolation this particular boy has improved since he started in reception. Chairs getting flung across the class was a regular occurrence, he can now often take himself to a quiet space instead of just exploding in class.

BertieBotts · 25/03/2023 16:49

Sensory issues can present very similarly and are not always part of ASD/ADHD.

This for example could have described my eldest and describes my 4.5yo very well. I'm currently looking into possible accommodations for him:

https://theotbutterfly.com/sensoryseeker/sensory-processing/

What is a Sensory Seeker and How Can I Support Them? -

How to spot a sensory seeker and some helpful tips to avoid becoming dysregulated even more as well as how to best support self regulation.

https://theotbutterfly.com/sensoryseeker/sensory-processing

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 16:42

@Feeling100 yes, this discription sounds familiar…

I’m fairly certain the typical, main ASD and ADHD symptoms are not there (like preference for routine, disinterest in relationships or lack of attention, hyperactivity etc), so was just thinking maybe it’s something else like, PDA, Ocd, Tourette’s or bipolar… In all honesty, I still hope it’s just ineffective parenting and he will eventually outgrow it, but I’m so worried there’s more to it.

OP posts:
Feeling100 · 25/03/2023 16:30

There’s a little boy in my sons year 2 class that sounds similar. He’s on a special timetable currently doing just mornings.

He’s an angry child, explosive temper and very controlling in his friendships which is all part of his condition. Unfortunately I don’t know what he’s been diagnosed with to help direct you. But def a possibility that your son has an identifiable condition to work with.

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 16:25

The thing is with the PDA type autism, we’ve pretty much done this kind of low demand parenting even before reading about it (whenever we tried being stricter it got even worse), we don’t have many rules, only very basic ones, don’t have a hectic life. Still, he seems so unhappy. Things are not perfect and I don’t have endless patience and can get emotional from it all but we really have tried to be understanding.

OP posts:
Mosaic123 · 25/03/2023 16:14

Could be be in pain? My friend's son had Crohns and was very difficult when young.

Also his eyes and hearing tested in case there is a problem with either of these.

And teeth need checking too.

Unlikely but you never know.

Flyingwasp · 25/03/2023 16:13

@catlitterinmyturnups I had a look at that before and that’s obviously a possibility.

I was just wondering if adhd, ocd or other conditions can have similar presentations too.

@LeafHunter it’s hard to know. This is where the “bad parenting” comes in, I just think even if I did everything wrong and didn’t teach him these things properly, by this time he should have just learnt on his own…

OP posts:
Bunnyhair · 25/03/2023 16:08

Haha cross posted with all the other PDA parents 👋

Bunnyhair · 25/03/2023 16:07

This sounds quite a lot like my DS, who has a diagnosis of PDA (pathological demand avoidance) which is on the autistic spectrum. He’s very sociable, not particularly attached to routine, etc. and so everyone dismissed the possibility of autism early on. We had to try again and again to get to the bottom of what was making life so tough. Traditional parenting approaches - consistency, rewards & sanctions, rigid boundaries and routines - made family life a fucking nightmare. Meltdowns constantly, lasting hours.

Life has been SO much calmer since we started low-demand parenting (I.e. doing pretty much the exact opposite of all the parenting advice you’ve ever been given). It has meant restructuring our entire lives, though, and developing a very thick skin as to the untrained eye we look like shit parents whose lack of boundaries have caused the minor difficulties our child has, rather than parents who’ve responded to the child we have, making the enormously distressing, disabling difficulties he used to have much more manageable.

Read The Explosive Child, and check out the FB group The B Team for a really helpful framework for ways to problem solve with your child. These were life-changing for us.