Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not breastfeed the third child?

271 replies

cityle · 25/03/2023 12:29

So I have a 5 year old and a 2 year old.
I breastfeed my 5 year old till 2 (actually when I got pregnant with the second then my milk diminished)

And now I'm still breastfeeding my 2 year old and I'm 18 weeks pregnant (waiting for the milk to stop because I'm going insane and it's painful now)

My husband thinks I'm being completely hypocritical that I've decided I don't want to breastfeed my third baby.

But honestly, I've never been able to lose weight until ironically when I stopped BF and was pregnant!

And I've found it very suffocating for basically 5 years now!

This baby was not planned and my 2 year old still doesn't sleep through the night. My 5 year old did when she stopped feeding!

And if I'm frankly honest, all my friends with FF babies tend to live easier stress free lives. The babies appear more content and happier and the thought of my breast not being my own again for another 2 or so years is daunting!

I've also started getting Bf aversions and I think it's contributed to post natal depression in the past!

Would I regret it?! Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 25/03/2023 21:18

Peppadog · 25/03/2023 21:15

@LuckySantangelo35 yes but she asked the question didn't she? What would be the point in those of us who think it's a bad idea lying?
I would rather someone told me if they thought I might regret something, I know I would regret it.

@Peppadog

fair enough

lots of us wouldn’t regret not breastfeeding though

I hope op does what’s best for her

Peppadog · 25/03/2023 21:15

@LuckySantangelo35 yes but she asked the question didn't she? What would be the point in those of us who think it's a bad idea lying?
I would rather someone told me if they thought I might regret something, I know I would regret it.

LuckySantangelo35 · 25/03/2023 21:12

Peppadog · 25/03/2023 20:47

Ok seeing as you asked I'll be honest. I do think YABU and I think you might regret it. It sounds like you're struggling at the moment and feeling overwhelmed. I think you will have an urge to feed your newborn baby if you've fed the other two. It doesn't need to be for a long time, just see how it goes.
I would find it strange if my mum had fed my brother and not me (unless she tried and couldn't for some reason) lots of people on here clearly wouldn't, but you don't know what camp your child will be in.

@Peppadog

her kids don’t even need to know

it’s her body - she doesn’t have to do anything she doesn’t want to do

LuckySantangelo35 · 25/03/2023 21:11

Pinkdelight3 · 25/03/2023 14:25

Seems a bit one extreme to the other. Just do six months for DC3. No need to do two years for any of them, but can start drawing a line now with DC2 and set your boundaries for DC3. You needn't be a martyr BFing beyond weaning, but equally to do so much for the first two and nothing for the third is OTT.

@Pinkdelight3

says who? You?

it’s her body, she doesn’t have to do anything she doesn’t want to do

Peppadog · 25/03/2023 20:47

Ok seeing as you asked I'll be honest. I do think YABU and I think you might regret it. It sounds like you're struggling at the moment and feeling overwhelmed. I think you will have an urge to feed your newborn baby if you've fed the other two. It doesn't need to be for a long time, just see how it goes.
I would find it strange if my mum had fed my brother and not me (unless she tried and couldn't for some reason) lots of people on here clearly wouldn't, but you don't know what camp your child will be in.

Cherrysherbet · 25/03/2023 20:38

As you’ve fed your first two, I really think you will feel a natural urge to feed your new baby.
I know I did with my third.

If I were you, I’d at least do it for the first few months, so your baby gets all the good stuff.

LuckySantangelo35 · 25/03/2023 20:29

ferntwist · 25/03/2023 12:54

I hear you OP but I really think you have to at least give a few weeks or months of breastfeeding to baby 3. I know it’s so tough. Could you consider mixed feeding? Good luck momma

@ferntwist

why does she have to?

Darktowers · 25/03/2023 19:46

With each of my dc I LOVED breastfeeding at first and found it easy. What I found incredibly hard was past 6 months - they had got so attached to breastfeeding and suddenly I was trapped as it was the number 1 comforter for any problem and they got more clingy the longer I breastfed for .
With my youngest I combi fed from day 1 and it was amazing. Total game changer. No panicky feelings, I felt less touched out and under pressure and ds loved his formula SO much that stopping bf was easy. I didn’t get pnd either which looking back now I really think breastfeeding was a big factor

Albiboba · 25/03/2023 19:42

It honestly says more about your friend that she’s got to the point of being a 40something year old adult and she resents her mother for not breastfeeding her!! Absolutely mental.

As for the ‘if you’re going to treat your kids differently don’t be surprised they hold onto it into adulthood’ 🙄 you’re hardly sitting them both down and giving one cake and making the other watch.
People regularly treat their kids differently because they are different people. Some babies are sleep trained while the siblings aren’t, some are in a stricter routine because they needed it whereas their siblings aren’t.
An adult who doesn’t understand why their mother might not have been able to breastfeed sounds like they haven’t grown up much.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 25/03/2023 19:34

YANBU at all because they’re your breasts and your body. However, you don’t need to decide until the baby’s here.

There’s also a whole world of options between exclusively formula feeding from day one and what you’ve done with your older two (ie exclusively breastfeeding until 2 years old). You could combi feed from the get go, you could exclusively breastfeed until 6 weeks then introduce formula, etc etc.

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 19:33

Think there is a long history of the 2 siblings being treated differently @secretllama . I think the OP needs to consider is this just about how they will be fed or does she somehow feel differently about the 3rd baby, will they always be treated differently to the others. If so maybe get some counselling. Mumsnet is full of women who wish their own DMs had!

kirsty2023 · 25/03/2023 19:28

cityle · 25/03/2023 12:37

I know!

I just know my in-laws will say how I'm being unfair etc but ironically even though there is a new baby coming.. I need to put myself first!

It's not about ur in laws it's about you it's your body and it's up 2 you if bf or ff I bf my first 3 and ff the other 2 new baby is only 13 weeks and only just got my 3year old off milk at night it's a nightmare

HousePlantNeglect · 25/03/2023 19:20

Do what feels right for you. Breastfeeding is a relationship and both Mum and baby have to be onboard with it.

I fed all three of mine differently but due to two of them struggling with breastfeeding. First one exclusively breastfed over a year, second one breast fed a couple of months and then formula, third one is mixed fed. I can’t possibly imagine the way they were fed being a topic of discussion much beyond young childhood!

secretllama · 25/03/2023 19:06

weststreet · 25/03/2023 17:22

@mumoffourminimes

My brothers were breastfed, I wasn't.

I have absolutely no ill feelings towards it. It would be an insult to my mother if I was offended on how she thought was best to feed me at the time, just because my brothers got breast milk and I didn't.

Anyone who has an issue around not receiving boob milk over formula because their siblings did / did not get fed the same method is really weird. If an adult child is upset that they didn't receive breast milk from their mum it's almost a bit enmeshed. I can't imagine any adult being upset that their sibling was breasted and they weren't.

You can pretend it's not weird to be upset about it, but really it is 🤷🏼‍♀️

I know right! Imagine disrespecting your mother by commenting that your angry over how she fed you. Get a grip. They wouldn't have known how they were fed unless their mother told them so pretty much being angry over nothing.

DelphiniumBlue · 25/03/2023 17:44

I agree it would be best to stop feeding the 2 year old now. You don't have to wait for the milk to stop ( what does that even mean?)
You just say " You're a big boy/girl now, only babies feed from Mummy, time for a cup. You can just have it ( x time in the morning) for this week, then we are going to stop."
Make sure you stop night time and bed time feeds first, those might be the hardest, just start to run it down so it doesn't get too uncomfortable for you. Should only take less than a week.
It might help if you go out or even stay away for a few days, and Dh should deal with night waking till you've stopped producing milk. Buy some special big boy cups/water bottles, make a big deal out of it, and start talking about big boys soon won't need nappies either (maybe only if if they are nearer to 2 1/2 than 2).
It would seem a bit strange not to bf new baby at all, could you not limit it to ,say, 6 months? Or combi feed?

weststreet · 25/03/2023 17:24

@Megifer I agree. Can you imagine your partner coming home from work and wanting to discuss his ill feelings about not being breastfed and how it's unfair that his siblings were? We're talking about ADULTS here.

PP either has a back story, or a borderline enmeshed partner when it comes to his mum breastfeeding him.

weststreet · 25/03/2023 17:22

@mumoffourminimes

My brothers were breastfed, I wasn't.

I have absolutely no ill feelings towards it. It would be an insult to my mother if I was offended on how she thought was best to feed me at the time, just because my brothers got breast milk and I didn't.

Anyone who has an issue around not receiving boob milk over formula because their siblings did / did not get fed the same method is really weird. If an adult child is upset that they didn't receive breast milk from their mum it's almost a bit enmeshed. I can't imagine any adult being upset that their sibling was breasted and they weren't.

You can pretend it's not weird to be upset about it, but really it is 🤷🏼‍♀️

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 15:54

Ha no -friend!

Megifer · 25/03/2023 15:53

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 15:44

Oh yes hilarious 🙄

DF considers BF an important aspect of their own parenting duty. They have genuine feelings about their DM's behaviour even as a 40+yo adult.

If you're going to treat your children differently from each other then it's highly likely they will grow up having feelings about that.

If you want to pretend otherwise than that's on you 🤷‍♀️

Is that DF as in fiance?

That would be a bit of a worry if my DP was harbouring ill feelings about their DM not BFing them, I'm guessing there's a lot more to it and it wasn't just the BF thing though otherwise....yikes!

Parker231 · 25/03/2023 15:50

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 15:44

Oh yes hilarious 🙄

DF considers BF an important aspect of their own parenting duty. They have genuine feelings about their DM's behaviour even as a 40+yo adult.

If you're going to treat your children differently from each other then it's highly likely they will grow up having feelings about that.

If you want to pretend otherwise than that's on you 🤷‍♀️

I was Bf - my DSis, two years younger was ff. She has no issues with it as it hasn’t made any difference to her life. You can’t tell which of us was bf v ff.

PTAProblems · 25/03/2023 15:49

Two of my siblings were, myself and another were not. None of us give two fucks how we or the others were fed and it only came up when I was pregnant with my first and speaking to my mum about baby feeding. Your kids won't care!

PTAProblems · 25/03/2023 15:47

These threads make me so angry! Why should you do something with your body that you don't want to do? If your husband wanted more regular sex posters wouldn't try to convince you that you should just give it a try and see how it went! If a friend wanted you to spend more time with them they'd advise you to put up boundaries but this site has a strange view when it comes to breastfeeding. The benefits of breastfeeding are completely unproven. To prove them, you would have to take babies at birth, bring them up identically other than feeing one formula and on breastmilk and that would be unethical and impossible. What's best for yourself and your babies is a Mum that is mentally well and not strung out and stressed to death. Do what you can to provide that stable happy mother to your children, no matter how you feed them.

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 15:44

weststreet · 25/03/2023 15:39

My DF was FF, their elder sibling BF, their DM just said she didn't want to, DF still comments on it. The DC may well know and care that they were treated differently.

It's of course still the OP's choice, but it's not true to say it won't have an impact, no one knows this
@mumoffourminimes

You really think one of the kids when they've grown up is going to care that their siblings were breastfed and they were formula fed? Oh give over. That's the most ridiculous comment I've seen on here 😂😂😂😂

Imagine sitting down with your mum 'I'm so disappointed that I didn't get to feed from your nipple and you fed me from a bottle and I feel like I missed out' it'd be pretty funny tbh

Oh yes hilarious 🙄

DF considers BF an important aspect of their own parenting duty. They have genuine feelings about their DM's behaviour even as a 40+yo adult.

If you're going to treat your children differently from each other then it's highly likely they will grow up having feelings about that.

If you want to pretend otherwise than that's on you 🤷‍♀️

weststreet · 25/03/2023 15:39

My DF was FF, their elder sibling BF, their DM just said she didn't want to, DF still comments on it. The DC may well know and care that they were treated differently.

It's of course still the OP's choice, but it's not true to say it won't have an impact, no one knows this
@mumoffourminimes

You really think one of the kids when they've grown up is going to care that their siblings were breastfed and they were formula fed? Oh give over. That's the most ridiculous comment I've seen on here 😂😂😂😂

Imagine sitting down with your mum 'I'm so disappointed that I didn't get to feed from your nipple and you fed me from a bottle and I feel like I missed out' it'd be pretty funny tbh

Megifer · 25/03/2023 14:49

I BF one for 2 years and FF the other. I thought I'd feel guilty but i genuinely never have, they were both fed 🤷‍♀️

Definitely found FF far easier though and I was generally happier (might be other factors there though, although I can't think what!)

Your DH needs to pipe down its not his body, nor does he know what hypocritical means 😬