Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend wanting me to pay legal fees

167 replies

msbees · 25/03/2023 10:12

I primarily live in SF, CA (am British, but lived here for years). My friend lost her job and is convinced she's got a shot a filing a lawsuit and suing for wrongful termination. I don't know the ins and outs of the case because we've only exchanged a few texts on the matter. She is looking at hiring lawyers and as is common knowledge, Americans love litigation. However, she asked me over text if I could 'donate' to her legal costs. I asked what her costs would be and how much she had to hand anyway. She quoted $20k - and said that she had only $15k to her name. She said her own money (the $15k) would be next to nothing soon enough due to loss of health insurance and her general outgoings (healthcare is not like it is the UK in regards to insurance costs). So she really asking for $20k - but that's just to engage the lawyer/draft up a case. When I asked for more information about the actual case, she didn't go into much detail at all and just ranted about her hatred of the CEO and his dodgy behaviour. She did say she would shed more light on it when she had more time. So I said ok (to talking about it another time). She then left it at the same question (would I be willing to pay for the costs).

She knows I can 'afford it' due to my previous company sale being public information, yet I can't help but feel uneasy about it. I also think it's my British nature to be more reserved about money, whereas Americans are a lot more open about it. Also, when a company is sold, most of the money goes to paying shareholders etc... so what she might have seen online is nowhere near close to what we each have. (Each being management team).

I'm only too happy to get more details about the case, but she sounds incredibly angry at her previous employer and is out for blood. I can't help but think it is a waste of money, but that's only going off what little information I have.

Legal costs have a way of quickly rising into the 0000's. I don't think she has thought this through... or frankly cares. AIBU to say no, even before hearing her out at a later date?

OP posts:
2bazookas · 25/03/2023 11:58

Surely even in USA, there are pro-bono lawyers, and lawyers who offer "no win, no fee"?

I reckon this ex employer is that Nigerian politician with a cancer diagnosis who's been robbed and stranded on holiday in Rome. Poor guy; it's a miracle he's survived so long. Thanks for all your prayers.

I wouldn't send a penny.

CremeEggThief · 25/03/2023 11:57

Who on earth are the 3% in the poll who think YABU?!

MissConductUS · 25/03/2023 11:56

Anyonebut · 25/03/2023 11:31

If she actually has a good case, she should go with a no-win, no-fee lawyer (unless that’s just a Hollywood thing and they don’t really exist) 😄.

Yank here. They exist, and there are ones that specialize in employment law. The problem is that unless you have an employment contract, you are an "at will" employee, meaning you can quit at will, and they can terminate you at will. There are few narrow grounds for a wrongful termination suit, and it's very much an uphill climb.

When these suits are filed, it's usually a tactic to negotiate a better outcome, like letting the person resign instead of being fired for cause or to get more severance pay.

OP, this is a lost cause. Don't fund it. She will eventually realize this isn't going anywhere.

MadeofElephantStone · 25/03/2023 11:54

No. If she is so sure she would win she wouldn't have any issues contributing her own money. It's easy to risk away others people's money.

ScottBakula · 25/03/2023 11:33

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 10:36

This plan of hers has got 'will end in tears' written all the way through like a stick of Blackpool rock.

What is she hoping to gain? Is she expecting to be awarded millions for defamation/hurt feelings etc., or is it more likely to just be lost earnings - and so probably more than eaten by by the legal fees? Surely she realises that $20K is only going to be the start and isn't a fixed price? What would she do when that $20K vanishes, with barely anything to show for it? If you were to give it to her, it would be "But we've gone too far to stop now!" and then she'd have her hand out for goodness knows how much more from you.

Even without the costs for the legal case, it sounds like she's not going to have enough to live on and pay her health bills for very long anyway, so I have a pretty good idea where she will come looking for money to pay for that....

I can only see your friendship being irreparably damaged by this - it's just whether you 'split up' now by saying "Sorry, no" at the outset or whether later, having lost a truck-load of cash, when the judge/lawyers say "Sorry, no".

All of this with bells and whistles on.

As pp have said tell her to go to a no win no fee lawyer .

You said she hasn't told you much about the 'case' , dont ask for info or she may draw you in / pull at heart strings ect.
Also how well do you know her , could if be a scam ? Or does she normally blow up about small / strange things.
Do uou keep in touch much ? If so has her hatred been building for a while ( so possibly genuine) or has she got in touch out of the blue because "you have money "

If you find it hard to say a blunt no , tell her you have reinvested your cash into another company so cant donate ( and was considering asking her for a lone 🤔)

Beaverbridge · 25/03/2023 11:33

Straight forward. No.

Anyonebut · 25/03/2023 11:31

If she actually has a good case, she should go with a no-win, no-fee lawyer (unless that’s just a Hollywood thing and they don’t really exist) 😄.

Rainbowshine · 25/03/2023 11:25

No way would I donate or lend a cent

I’d reply soon to nip it in the bud, and no sorry or ifs or anything like that

“I will not be giving any money towards this. I recommend that you call a no win no fee attorney as they will also help you understand how likely it is that you will get compensation and how much money that might be so you can decide if it’s worth it. “

Emmamoo89 · 25/03/2023 11:24

Don't do it

Riverlee · 25/03/2023 11:24

Another resounding No from me, and what a cheeky mare.

I’d like an all expensive trip to the Seychelles, but don’t go around routinely asking my more wealthy friends to pay for me.

Has she commented how and when she would pay the money back, or is it dependent on whether she would win the case.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 11:23

.

Friend wanting me to pay legal fees
L3ThirtySeven · 25/03/2023 11:20

Don’t! The US has thousands of no win no fee lawyers out there for all kinds of employment law. They only reject cases that haven’t a leg to stand on.

Don’t give her any money. She’s either not approached any no win no fee lawyers or she has and has no case.

TomatoSandwiches · 25/03/2023 11:19

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 10:52

For all you know, she could be looking into how much she can tap you for and then not even go down the legal route - just take your money as her 'compensation'!

I can see the thinking now:
CF: "Right, I've got $20K towards my legal costs."
CF's lawyer: "Well, we can proceed, but It's risky - there's no guarantee that you would win and the legal costs could end up much higher than that, maybe higher than the amount you would be awarded if you are successful."
CF: "I see. In that case, it's probably not worth the risk - it's very frustrating, but I'd probably be wiser to just keep MY $20K and not proceed any further."

This is where my mind first went op, how long ago did your sale go through or figures listed?

MissConductUS · 25/03/2023 11:19

If she had a strong case, an attorney would take it on a contingency agreement. The fact that she's being asked to pay upfront means that there's no realistic chance she'd win.

BMW6 · 25/03/2023 11:15

Disaster written all over it. NO.

HoneyPotBee · 25/03/2023 11:12

Just because you can ‘afford’ something doesn’t mean you have to do it.

I say no to many things I can afford. Just give them another reason for declining. If they don’t take it well then it’s their problem and they never saw you as a friend in the first place.

QueSyrahSyrah · 25/03/2023 11:10

butterfliedtwo · 25/03/2023 10:58

Why all the suggested explanations? It's perfectly fine to just say. "no, I'm not paying your legal fees."

It's an outrageous request.

Totally agree. Always staggered by how many 'just say [insert lie here]' suggestions are made on Mumsnet about all kinds of topics, where often the basic truth is a perfectly acceptable response.

Knittedfairies · 25/03/2023 11:05

Don't engage with her at all about the case; the more she tells you, the more chance she has to reel you in. Surely selling a company means you'll have some legal costs of your own? Just say no.

Hankunamatata · 25/03/2023 11:05

Nope. Say your assetts are tied up in long term investments and you can't access them

TheNoodlesIncident · 25/03/2023 11:04

She's not a friend, she's a user. And you won't see a penny of your money ever again.

You'd be crazy or an idiot to do this.

Wfhwannabe · 25/03/2023 11:03

If you were in the UK I'd say hear her out. We have many more employment protections in the UK than the US. The fact she's trying to get your commitment in writing (via text message) without properly discussing things first makes it seem a bit suss to me. Especially given the fire at will nature of most of the US meaning no matter her complaint, the employer may still not be liable.

loislovesstewie · 25/03/2023 11:03

Say no. If you want to chuck money at anyone I'm crowd funding for my kitchen. ( that is a joke BTW). She isn't using any common sense and is letting her emotions get in the way. Better to lose her than your money.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 11:01

However, the sale of my business doesn't lead to me ending up with the value that's around.

Yes, I think she's also seeing the amount that OP did receive from the sale as a windfall from out of the blue and not earnings from years of hard work, shrewd investing and calculated risk-taking.

When you run a business, you don't just get a regular amount to take home every month, like an employee would - it's a long game, which doesn't always pay off. It's all very nice for people to come with their begging bowl once you finally see the fruits of all of your efforts, but those same people are strangely absent during all of the lean years in the run-up to your eventual payday. It's absolutely nothing like chucking an ignorable few quid on the lottery every week and then suddenly scooping the jackpot out of nowhere.

ItsTimeToWine · 25/03/2023 10:59

God no, friends don't do this. She's so cheeky for even suggesting this, I can't believe she thinks you'll send 20k over just like that!!! Absolutely not.

butterfliedtwo · 25/03/2023 10:58

Why all the suggested explanations? It's perfectly fine to just say. "no, I'm not paying your legal fees."

It's an outrageous request.