Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend wanting me to pay legal fees

167 replies

msbees · 25/03/2023 10:12

I primarily live in SF, CA (am British, but lived here for years). My friend lost her job and is convinced she's got a shot a filing a lawsuit and suing for wrongful termination. I don't know the ins and outs of the case because we've only exchanged a few texts on the matter. She is looking at hiring lawyers and as is common knowledge, Americans love litigation. However, she asked me over text if I could 'donate' to her legal costs. I asked what her costs would be and how much she had to hand anyway. She quoted $20k - and said that she had only $15k to her name. She said her own money (the $15k) would be next to nothing soon enough due to loss of health insurance and her general outgoings (healthcare is not like it is the UK in regards to insurance costs). So she really asking for $20k - but that's just to engage the lawyer/draft up a case. When I asked for more information about the actual case, she didn't go into much detail at all and just ranted about her hatred of the CEO and his dodgy behaviour. She did say she would shed more light on it when she had more time. So I said ok (to talking about it another time). She then left it at the same question (would I be willing to pay for the costs).

She knows I can 'afford it' due to my previous company sale being public information, yet I can't help but feel uneasy about it. I also think it's my British nature to be more reserved about money, whereas Americans are a lot more open about it. Also, when a company is sold, most of the money goes to paying shareholders etc... so what she might have seen online is nowhere near close to what we each have. (Each being management team).

I'm only too happy to get more details about the case, but she sounds incredibly angry at her previous employer and is out for blood. I can't help but think it is a waste of money, but that's only going off what little information I have.

Legal costs have a way of quickly rising into the 0000's. I don't think she has thought this through... or frankly cares. AIBU to say no, even before hearing her out at a later date?

OP posts:
BrioNotBiro · 25/03/2023 12:43

So I said ok (to talking about it another time). She then left it at the same question (would I be willing to pay for the costs).

Do you think she thinks you've said OK to paying towards the costs OP? She may sue you too for breach of promise/contract! (I'm not entirely joking, she sounds very litigious).

Carlycat · 25/03/2023 12:42

Nope
She's a cheeky fucker of the highest order. And certainly not your friend

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:38

Absolutely it's a no! Can imagine her then suing you for hurt feelings when you're not an never ending source of funds for her!
"You said you'd pay for it so you need to pay whatever it costs!"

I don't think that is necessarily too far-fetched, actually. She's clearly entitled and feels that she is owed a living from somebody (who cares who?), so I wouldn't put it past her at all. Even if she didn't go down the suing route, your name would be absolute mud when the funds eventually run out - "Some friend she is, promising me her support all the way and then just stabbing me in the back and dropping me like a hot poop when we were so close to winning".

Sassyfox · 25/03/2023 12:35

Bonjovispjs · 25/03/2023 10:18

Don't go there 0P, I have a rule of never borrowing or lending money, it often ends in tears.

First reply has nailed it.

Just text her saying no I’m not going to lend you the money as I’m not comfortable lending people money.

If she falls out with you then it’ll do you a favour as she’s shown her true colours and it’s one less person trying to get money off of you.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:34

As for your question... a quick Google search will bring up the sale information as well as the price unfortunately. Certainly not something she would have to dig any deeper for.

Ah, right - thanks - but it's still something that you'd have to deliberately look for, from what you say. She has deliberately Googled it, when it's nothing to concern her at all. It wouldn't just pop up on your general news feed.

You know what, I'm sure that she's thought this through carefully and she's planning on making this never-ending vexatious law suit her new 'job', with your money paying her 'wages' - i.e. her living costs whilst she is 'heroically' fighting the case. Effectively, she has an irrational malicious case against her former employers, so she's hatched a plot to punish them AND YOU for it, whilst keeping her own lifestyle ticking over nicely, indefinitely.

Everybody knows that legal costs are a bottomless pit, so there's no telling how much she might be intending to tell you that this, that or the other has/will cost, and so you will need to hand her $X,000 to pay for it at each stage.

MichelleScarn · 25/03/2023 12:32

Absolutely it's a no! Can imagine her then suing you for hurt feelings when you're not an never ending source of funds for her!
"You said you'd pay for it so you need to pay whatever it costs!"

rookiemere · 25/03/2023 12:29

I wouldn't give her a cent, and - although maybe this is more of a British thing - I'd reevaluate the friendship. Good friends don't text others to ask them for $20k.
The way she's going about this suggests they might have been right to fire her, if that's her negotiation and reasoning skills in action.

googlejourney · 25/03/2023 12:26

She is not a good friend to be putting you in this position. Absolutely not, she needs to find a no win no fee lawyer. I suspect when you tell her 'no' the friendship might fizzle anyway because she seems like a user.

sonjadog · 25/03/2023 12:25

Absolutely not. It would be lunacy to give her this money. You wouldn't see a penny of it again.

chocorabbit · 25/03/2023 12:25

Just say sternly that you don't want to give away your savings and are extremely uncomfortable doing so.

She can work 2-3 low paid jobs temporarily until she finds something similar like everyone else does, but you don't have to tell her that if you don't feel comfortable.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:24

She was an "at will" employee

Yes, I'd never heard of that term either (sounds like it's US-specific), but I just looked it up online and it's quite straightforward that the employer holds all the cards and the employee none, apart from the right to say No/leave them at any time.

She is absolutely insane if she genuinely believes that she has any case against them. She's just trying to make trouble for the sake of it, funded by your money. If it were up to her, she literally would keep it going forever until your last penny was gone - and then, she would also be gone.

msbees · 25/03/2023 12:24

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:17

Do you know why she got fired? I mean the real reason? Does she have a genuine grievance or was she let go fairly?

Might 'unfair dismissal' in her mind equal 'I wanted to keep the job and the pay and I'm annoyed that they fired me for being rubbish/negligent/hands in the till/services no longer needed' ?

This is what I wanted to know. She just said she got fired (I'm assuming services no longer needed based on what I know of her role/project), but then went on a text rant about everyone there and their bad traits etc... so it became less about the firing and more about ranting about people. Which made the request even more outrageous.

Just because someone is angry about being fired, doesn't mean they necessarily have a case. Part of me wants to know more, the other part of me wants to just ignore. I feel like Americans watch too much TV and think they can 'crush' everyone with expensive lawyers. Life isn't an episode of 'Suits'.

OP posts:
msbees · 25/03/2023 12:19

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:13

Is the info about your company sale public knowledge in that it was reported widely in the general press, or in a sense that the details are on public record if people with a need to know or an interest in the field look for them?

If (as I suspect) the latter, what was she actually doing going looking for them in the first place, if not to stake her 'claim'?

What a CF extraordinaire to be insisting only on the top lawyers that YOUR money can buy! It really is the equivalent of offering to buy somebody a drink in the pub and them ordering a quadruple brandy - then saying they might as well take the whole bottle for later!

Agreed!

As for your question... a quick Google search will bring up the sale information as well as the price unfortunately. Certainly not something she would have to dig any deeper for.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:17

Do you know why she got fired? I mean the real reason? Does she have a genuine grievance or was she let go fairly?

Might 'unfair dismissal' in her mind equal 'I wanted to keep the job and the pay and I'm annoyed that they fired me for being rubbish/negligent/hands in the till/services no longer needed' ?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2023 12:17

She was an "at will" employee

I'm no expert in UK law never mind the US version, but that sounds as if she'd got few rights in the first place and that - as you suggested - she's just worked herself into a state and wants to "punish them"

In other words, yet another reason to say no

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 12:13

Is the info about your company sale public knowledge in that it was reported widely in the general press, or in a sense that the details are on public record if people with a need to know or an interest in the field look for them?

If (as I suspect) the latter, what was she actually doing going looking for them in the first place, if not to stake her 'claim'?

What a CF extraordinaire to be insisting only on the top lawyers that YOUR money can buy! It really is the equivalent of offering to buy somebody a drink in the pub and them ordering a quadruple brandy - then saying they might as well take the whole bottle for later!

ThinWomansBrain · 25/03/2023 12:13

is no win, no fee an option is she has a strong case?
certainly don't put your own money to this

FiddleLeaf · 25/03/2023 12:11

Hell no

msbees · 25/03/2023 12:10

MissConductUS · 25/03/2023 11:56

Yank here. They exist, and there are ones that specialize in employment law. The problem is that unless you have an employment contract, you are an "at will" employee, meaning you can quit at will, and they can terminate you at will. There are few narrow grounds for a wrongful termination suit, and it's very much an uphill climb.

When these suits are filed, it's usually a tactic to negotiate a better outcome, like letting the person resign instead of being fired for cause or to get more severance pay.

OP, this is a lost cause. Don't fund it. She will eventually realize this isn't going anywhere.

This is what I'm thinking is the case. She was an "at will" employee. The company does exist and yes she did get fired. So it's not about lying or anything. It's more about the hysterical nature of it all. She is scrambling for money and just desperate, I think.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/03/2023 12:09

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/03/2023 10:36

This plan of hers has got 'will end in tears' written all the way through like a stick of Blackpool rock.

What is she hoping to gain? Is she expecting to be awarded millions for defamation/hurt feelings etc., or is it more likely to just be lost earnings - and so probably more than eaten by by the legal fees? Surely she realises that $20K is only going to be the start and isn't a fixed price? What would she do when that $20K vanishes, with barely anything to show for it? If you were to give it to her, it would be "But we've gone too far to stop now!" and then she'd have her hand out for goodness knows how much more from you.

Even without the costs for the legal case, it sounds like she's not going to have enough to live on and pay her health bills for very long anyway, so I have a pretty good idea where she will come looking for money to pay for that....

I can only see your friendship being irreparably damaged by this - it's just whether you 'split up' now by saying "Sorry, no" at the outset or whether later, having lost a truck-load of cash, when the judge/lawyers say "Sorry, no".

All of this - especially the bit about the fees inevitably spiralling and the later point about her probably just keeping the money if she's advised not to sue

In any case "going to law" is best done with a clear head and not just because you're pissed at someone; if she wants to play tthat game tell her to start a crowdfunder and hope there'll be mugs willing to pay

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 25/03/2023 12:08

If it’s a sure thing she can find a no win no fee lawyer. Do not do it. I can’t believe she asked you.

BCfan · 25/03/2023 12:08

You'd be insane to agree to do this

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 25/03/2023 12:06

A very wise decision.

msbees · 25/03/2023 12:04

Thank you for all your responses. Our Co was sold in 2019. Announced in May 2019, everything went through by Oct 2019. So very much public knowledge.

In answer to questions, she's deliberately choosing the most expensive lawyers in order to put the frighteners on. In the US, money talks. But the problem is, it wouldn't be her money anyway. Some of the lawyers will be people like you and me would have seen on TV. (I hate that hysterical nature RE: US lawyers ).

I've also decided to not engage in conversation about it via the phone. Texts can just go unanswered after a hard no.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 25/03/2023 11:58

Friendships and money don’t always mix well.

Don’t they have no win, no fee lawyers in the US? If her case is that strong, they’d take it on, surely?