Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did I steal their cat? (Sorry long)

284 replies

Babbitybowsters · 25/03/2023 10:09

Apologies for the long post but don't want to dripfeed.

I fostered a cat for 2 years for a woman and two kids, because they didn't have anywhere to live that would accept cats. The woman actually didn't contact me for 1 whole year so I thought he was actually my cat now.

She did however get in touch at Xmas to ask for him back. I didn't want to upset her kids and thought it was the right thing to do so I gave him back in January and we kept in touch.

After two weeks (early Feb) the 12 year old let him out and he ran off and then the family went out for the day. He then went missing for 5 weeks and was found by them emaciated and near death having been trapped in an outdoor store cupboard for that time. During that time I couldn't eat or sleep for worry and did everything I could to get him back. I even begged them for the chip number to update his details as they hadn't done it. And I registered the details in my name as they still don't really have permanent address or reliable phone number (long story).

The day after he was found they took him to the PDSA vet came to see me as I lived next to the PDSA vets and we all went together to see him. The vet asked someone to visit in the morning to move him to another vets. The woman asked me as she lived a 30 min train journey away and didn't want to have to get up so early because she is on her own and heavily pregnant. I agreed and picked him up last Thursday and transported him from the night vet to the day vet. At that point he had a seizure and the vet was suggesting putting him to sleep. I begged him not to. It was agreed that we give him to 5pm that day to make a decision. The woman said she wouldn't come unless there was a definite decision and again asked me to go. To my amazement he had perked up and the vet said I could take him home and, being so in shock, I took him to my flat 2 mins from the vets.

As soon he got there he was purring and going back to all his old spots (even though he could barely walk). It was like he had never left and all his things from the past 2 years are here. He is sleeping on my chest everynight.

Last Friday I asked the woman if they would like to come and visit him and they said they would and then didn't turn up. At that point I decided it would be wrong to move him again, as he is so settled here and I'd miss him so much. I also feel they were a bit irresponsible letting him out so soon etc.

I've now spent £400 at my own vets getting home blood tests etc and getting him special food which I know they can't afford as they are currently using food banks.

I wrote the family a nice letter asking if he could stay with me and saying I felt it would be cruel to unsettle him again. The family have responded saying the 12 year is crying every day and he "needs to come home!". But surely his home is here, where I kept him safe for the last 2 years?

Thanks for reading as I am so very torn, particularly as I don't want to upset a child.

OP posts:
PurpleFlower1983 · 25/03/2023 12:21

missmollygreen · 25/03/2023 10:15

As much as I dont really agree with people stealing cats.... in this instance I would tell them the cat has died and never speak ti them again.
They are using you and clearing dont give a toss about the cat anyway

I would tell them the cat has died and the bill for the cremation is waiting for them. My guess is you will never hear from them again.

CrystalCoco · 25/03/2023 12:16

FrostyFifi · 25/03/2023 12:12

It's very sad that he died. I hope your new cat that happens to look very similar is a comfort to you.

😂

CrystalCoco · 25/03/2023 12:15

You're an animal lover and in a position to love and look after the cat.

I have no idea if the family are animal lovers but they don't sound in a position to look after him - and he nearly died under their 'care'.

No brainer from me, tell whatever fib you need to and enjoy the rest of your days together 😻

Emotionalsupportviper · 25/03/2023 12:15

The 12 year old needs a guinea pig or something instead.

The 12 year old probably doesn't need any pet at all. They seem to be quite cavalier in the way they treat/look after their pet, and when the new baby is born the mum won't have the time or the energy to fill any gaps in the animals care.

12 year olds "forget" to feed, water and clean out animals, and they often lose interest as they get older and develop teenage pursuits. My kids had rabbits and guinea pigs, but 9 times out of 10, Mr Viper or myself were the ones cleaning out hutches and checking water bottles, and I don't believe my kids were more lax than most other people's.

FrostyFifi · 25/03/2023 12:12

It's very sad that he died. I hope your new cat that happens to look very similar is a comfort to you.

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 25/03/2023 12:09

Don't lie.

Tell them you will reconsider when they have repaid the £400 you spent on saving his life.

Emotionalsupportviper · 25/03/2023 12:07

Ktime · 25/03/2023 10:24

I agree tell them he died.

If they come for him, tell them they owe you £400, they will disappear.

Is your name on his chip?

This.

You updated the chip, didn't you? Your cat now - let them sue you for his return.

<spoiler alert: they won't>

CaveatmTOR · 25/03/2023 12:04

I'm pretty confident that cats are not owned in law like a dog can be.

I too would lie my ass off but would get elaborate with it.

I would ring her really early one morning to say the cat has had a seizure and that you are taking it to the vet. I would then ring back after 45 minutes and say that he has died as you were loading him into the car and that you are burying him in blah spot, with this place being in a wood or park (not on your premises) so they can visit the grave. I would dig a bit of a grave in said spot.

I would also ask for the vet bill money and then do nothing expecting to never hear from these people ever again.

I would make sure the cat could never get out but as the chip is in your name. although it does not confer ownership, you would be alerted anyway.

The chances are the cat won't live much longer after his ordeal so it's only a lie in time shift mode. If she never pays the vet bill and she won't, in the unlikely event this all ends up in court, you have your reason for all of the above.

This covers all bases. You get to keep the cat and the cat gets ongoing love, support and veterinary attention. She thinks the cat is dead. There is a grave to visit if the kids wish to do so. You no longer have to interact with this total CF ever for the rest of your life.

QuinnLovesEris · 25/03/2023 12:04

I'd say it's run away again rather than died. At least that way they won't turn up for something to bury.

Noshowlomo · 25/03/2023 12:02

This is 100% your cat. He wants that, you want that.
Enjoy life with your little cat friend who is clearly very well looked after with you 😊😊

Batiqueattic · 25/03/2023 12:02

Another vote for keep the cat. He nearly died under her "care". I wouldn't bother asking for the vets' bills as arguably that shows you have a willingness to return him. Tell her he died.

He loves you & his home is with you.

Over40Overdating · 25/03/2023 12:01

Absolutely keep the cat! This woman is clearly still struggling to provide a stable environment for the whole family and has repeatedly relied on you to provide the care for the cat, even when you’ve given him back.

Cats have a right to care - people do not have a right to cats because a 12 year old who can’t close a door to keep a cat safe is crying about it. They’d have had the cat PTS without the OP so what would the 12 year old have done in that instance?

And I disagree with a PP who said the woman is poor not feckless. Getting pregnant again whilst being financially on the bones of her arse IS feckless. She sounds chaotic and reckless.

CoconutJamSpongeAndPinkCustard · 25/03/2023 12:00

I would make it clear that you expect to be reimbursed before he is handed back.
Also, give her a breakdown of the costs involved in his day to day care and frequency/ cost of his vet treatment. Explain that this needs to be kept up to as the vet says that he would go down hill quicky if this quality of care wasn't kept up to.
Ask her to think carefully about whether she can manage this before insisting that he comes home.

I have a feeling that she would realise that she isn't in a position to care for him.

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 11:55

Clearly the cat should stay with you. You cared enough to microchip it for a start.

I would ask your vet to intercede on your behalf and call them. DM's vet did this for her under similar circs.

Indoorcatmum · 25/03/2023 11:50

100% keep him.

She didn't give a toss for a year and didn't respond to you?

I can't imagine doing that.

You haven't stolen him, he's yours and deserves a home that can love him and look after his health needs.

Bournetilly · 25/03/2023 11:47

Do you keep him indoors? If yes then definitely tell them he ran away or died as they are never going to find out.
Either way you shouldn’t give him back.

MissBattleaxe · 25/03/2023 11:47

How can she feed the cat then if she cannot afford to feed herself and her children? The cat needs quality of life too

Exactly. A pet is a privilege not a birthright and they cannot provide what he needs.

2bazookas · 25/03/2023 11:46

@TomeTome I think you should give him back. You did a favour to a woman with small children who was homeless and is even now dependent on food banks to feed herself. She’s poor and heavily pregnant not feckless.

She's been homeless for over two years; now dependent on food banks to feed the kids she's got. In that situation, pregnant again IS feckless

TisTimes · 25/03/2023 11:46

Don't lie about death.. But say the cat needs extensive care and ongoing daily medication plus special diet of expensive vets food due to being near death. Put up a sum. And set up a date plus ask for reimbursement of vet bills (all this to stop the demands to give him back)

dementedpixie · 25/03/2023 11:43

TomeTome · 25/03/2023 11:39

I think you should give him back. You did a favour to a woman with small children who was homeless and is even now dependent on food banks to feed herself. She’s poor and heavily pregnant not feckless. The cat got out and got locked in, it didn’t run away.

Certainly don’t lie to her and tell her it’s dead 😮.

How can she feed the cat then if she cannot afford to feed herself and her children?
The cat needs quality of life too

2bazookas · 25/03/2023 11:43

You missed your chance; you could just have sent a message saying "Tibbles is in a better place, RIP" and let her think the vet put him down.

I'd reply now "well, if he's your cat so is the vets bill I just paid I've got the receipt, £400. Let me know when you're bringing it, and you can take him home.".

Or if that's too mean for you; tell the 12 yr old you'll buy his beloved cat for 50 quid.

Either way, I wouldnt be doing any more running around and transport for the CF mother.
MissBattleaxe · 25/03/2023 11:41

Harsh as this sounds, if you can't afford a pet, you shouldn't have a pet. They cost money and need food, monthly de-fleaing, booster jabs, cat litter, and vet bills or insurance. If you can't provide that, you shouldn't have one. As much as this family seems to be struggling, it is not in a position to provide this, especially with a newborn due.

I'm a lifelong cat lover and I say keep him.

TomeTome · 25/03/2023 11:39

I think you should give him back. You did a favour to a woman with small children who was homeless and is even now dependent on food banks to feed herself. She’s poor and heavily pregnant not feckless. The cat got out and got locked in, it didn’t run away.

Certainly don’t lie to her and tell her it’s dead 😮.

JustAnotherUsey · 25/03/2023 11:35

I would reply saying that the vet suggested putting the cat to sleep, but you paid £400 to try and save it. So if they want the cat back they need to reimburse you £400 first.

Let's face it, if they had to make that decision, she would have said put to sleep. So surely it's your cat from the point of you paying to try and save it. So id say it already your cat now

Sierra26 · 25/03/2023 11:34

ask when they want to come and collect him, and can they bring along with the repayment for vet bills, special food and chip you paid for as you’re out of pocket / will need it before end of month