Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did I steal their cat? (Sorry long)

284 replies

Babbitybowsters · 25/03/2023 10:09

Apologies for the long post but don't want to dripfeed.

I fostered a cat for 2 years for a woman and two kids, because they didn't have anywhere to live that would accept cats. The woman actually didn't contact me for 1 whole year so I thought he was actually my cat now.

She did however get in touch at Xmas to ask for him back. I didn't want to upset her kids and thought it was the right thing to do so I gave him back in January and we kept in touch.

After two weeks (early Feb) the 12 year old let him out and he ran off and then the family went out for the day. He then went missing for 5 weeks and was found by them emaciated and near death having been trapped in an outdoor store cupboard for that time. During that time I couldn't eat or sleep for worry and did everything I could to get him back. I even begged them for the chip number to update his details as they hadn't done it. And I registered the details in my name as they still don't really have permanent address or reliable phone number (long story).

The day after he was found they took him to the PDSA vet came to see me as I lived next to the PDSA vets and we all went together to see him. The vet asked someone to visit in the morning to move him to another vets. The woman asked me as she lived a 30 min train journey away and didn't want to have to get up so early because she is on her own and heavily pregnant. I agreed and picked him up last Thursday and transported him from the night vet to the day vet. At that point he had a seizure and the vet was suggesting putting him to sleep. I begged him not to. It was agreed that we give him to 5pm that day to make a decision. The woman said she wouldn't come unless there was a definite decision and again asked me to go. To my amazement he had perked up and the vet said I could take him home and, being so in shock, I took him to my flat 2 mins from the vets.

As soon he got there he was purring and going back to all his old spots (even though he could barely walk). It was like he had never left and all his things from the past 2 years are here. He is sleeping on my chest everynight.

Last Friday I asked the woman if they would like to come and visit him and they said they would and then didn't turn up. At that point I decided it would be wrong to move him again, as he is so settled here and I'd miss him so much. I also feel they were a bit irresponsible letting him out so soon etc.

I've now spent £400 at my own vets getting home blood tests etc and getting him special food which I know they can't afford as they are currently using food banks.

I wrote the family a nice letter asking if he could stay with me and saying I felt it would be cruel to unsettle him again. The family have responded saying the 12 year is crying every day and he "needs to come home!". But surely his home is here, where I kept him safe for the last 2 years?

Thanks for reading as I am so very torn, particularly as I don't want to upset a child.

OP posts:
Over40Overdating · 31/03/2023 14:17

@Babbitybowsters they sound more and more feckless and not fit to have a pet rock.
Temp housing, mum about to go to hospital, kids shipped off but they need the cat now. A cat they would have happily PTS not long ago.

I’d block them to be honest and be done with it. You’ve got proof of how they cared for the cat last time. They don’t have a leg to stand on.

Novatherova · 30/03/2023 18:42

Whyyyyyy!! Don't give them the cat back. He?? Loves you and safest with you.

CatChant · 30/03/2023 17:55

I still wouldn’t give him back. I would not trust them with a tamagotchi, let alone a living creature.

His chip is in your name, you paid for the treatment that saved his life. He trusts you.

I think he will die from neglect if he goes back to them.

Babbitybowsters · 30/03/2023 17:38

Hi, for those who have given advice, thank you.

I've messaged them a compromise - to say that I that I'll hold onto the cat until he is off meds and when they are in their permanent home (at the moment they are in temporary accommodation through the council and I'm not sure if they are allowed pets to be honest).

They are still very hostile and demanding the cat immediately. But as the mum is about to go into hospital anyway the other two children will have to go to the grans for a while, so surely I'm doing them all a favour (and, crucially, I'm advocating for the poorly cat)?

OP posts:
TomeTome · 25/03/2023 20:32

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 19:34

Are you the incompetent cat owner @TomeTome ?

What because I don’t steal cats? Yeah totally incompetent. 🙄

MinBins · 25/03/2023 20:19

Keep the cat, it's yours and has bonded with you. If it goes back likely they'll do the same thing again. And a 12 year old will get over it.

Don't ask them, tell them. 💪🏼🙌🏼

TheNestedIf · 25/03/2023 19:37

I think I'd be upfront about it. You're keeping the cat.

They cannot care for the cat, and they have not been caring for the cat. They don't have the right food. They don't have money for vet bills. Their address isn't permanent so the cat could end up being fostered again anyway (if they don't manage kill it with neglect in the meantime). For the cat's health and happiness he needs to stay with you. What are they going to do about it if you just say "no" to having him back, with those reasons? They can't afford to take you to court, and I suspect if they tried you would win.

As for the child, it's sad for them, but they need to learn that a cat is not a toy and comes with responsibility. If the family will not or cannot fulfil that responsibility, the kind thing to do is let the cat go somewhere he will be happy and cared for.

mumoffourminimes · 25/03/2023 19:34

Are you the incompetent cat owner @TomeTome ?

threwitout · 25/03/2023 18:59

I really wouldn't lie because you will have a low level of stress about being caught in the lie for the rest of your life in case she just turns up

My suggestions are above - either go silent or directly ask for payment for the vet - they won't pay £££

TomeTome · 25/03/2023 18:11

Her name is on the chip because they agreed she could do that as they didn’t have a phone. It sounds like you offered to give it a home while they were homeless and didn’t ask for money because you thought having the cat was reparation enough, but then you fell in love with it and have managed to run up extra vets bills and get your name on the chip to position yourself to keep it.
It belongs to a 12 year old who has been homeless and now is about to have a new sibling and you think taking her cat is justified because she’s poor and let it out after two weeks but it got trapped somewhere. I think you are blinded by wanting a cat that doesn’t belong to you. Sorry @Babbitybowsters you are not being kind or reasonable.

verdantverdure · 25/03/2023 17:29

If your name is on the chip then legally the cat is yours.

You gave him back.

They lost him.

Sassyfox · 25/03/2023 17:23

@WestendVBroadway but OP agreed to this.

The vet said the cat should be PTS and the OP didn’t want it and so paid extra, again it was her choice to do so.

I do think OP could provide a better home but the facts are that they had an agreement that she would foster it until the owner got a permanent home and then return it.
You cannot just decide to want to keep it.

WestendVBroadway · 25/03/2023 17:04

@Sassyfox , I think you miss my point. Yes you fostered animals and yes you gave them back. However you did not incur any costs for their care and maintenance. The OP has spent a considerable amount of her own money, so it does not really compare with you being reimbursed for caring for your mindees.

LouisCatorze · 25/03/2023 16:49

Is there any reason to lie though? I think everyone is correct in thinking that once presented with a £400 vet's bill, the woman will run for the hills and you'll not hear another peep from her, ever!

TomeTome · 25/03/2023 16:33

WarningToTheCurious · 25/03/2023 14:45

From the OP:

After two weeks (early Feb) the 12 year old let him out and he ran off and then the family went out for the day. He then went missing for 5 weeks and was found by them emaciated and near death having been trapped in an outdoor store cupboard for that time.

Hence the question - whose store cupboard was it?

If it was their cupboard - they didn't do a very good job of looking for a period of 5 weeks, did they?

Though we’re obviously still searching weeks later?

mybeautifuloak · 25/03/2023 16:20

diddl · 25/03/2023 11:28

I'm not sure why the woman should have to pay a vet's bill for stuff that Op chose to have done after she decided to keep the cat herself because the woman didn't turn up for a visit.

That said it does sound as if there is a lot going on & the woman isn't able to afford/prioritise the cat.

Because otherwise the cat would likely be dead. So there would be no cat. If they want the cat they need to accept the bill that resulted in the cat being alive.

mybeautifuloak · 25/03/2023 16:19

Tell them the cat has had more seizures and is going to need a lot of treatment. The vet suggests to pts. So far they owe you £400 for vet bills so. Would they like to register the cat at a practice nearer then for ongoing treatment? Meanwhile here's my back details for the £400.
You won't see them or hear from them again.

Sassyfox · 25/03/2023 15:14

WestendVBroadway · 25/03/2023 15:00

@Sassyfox Fostering pets is a very common thing.
I fostered a dog for almost 3 years and will have small animals like mice or rabbits for months or years at a time.
I have to give them back because they’re not mine.

Who paid all the expenses above basic food eg vets bills, treatments etc?

Mine is through a domestic violence charity and they pay all of the costs.

If I could afford it then I wouldn’t mind paying them but I wouldn’t be able to do it if I paid the costs myself.

I don’t know how other places do it though.

I fostered my dog for a few weeks through a rescue centre and they paid for her vaccinations and neutering and I paid for her food.
If there was a vets bill then they would have paid.

There was the option to keep her but the plan was to look after her until she found a new home and then get another one, so they didn’t have to stay in kennels for too long but I ended up keeping her and so I’ve not done it again as I know I’d end up keeping the next one too 😁

LoobyDop · 25/03/2023 15:11

Keep him. He’s happy with you, you’re giving him the care he needs, they weren’t. He’s better off with you, and that trumps a 12 year old being upset.

Un7breakable · 25/03/2023 15:09

Don't lie just point out vets bills etc and ask for the money. You won't hear back.

WestendVBroadway · 25/03/2023 15:00

@Sassyfox Fostering pets is a very common thing.
I fostered a dog for almost 3 years and will have small animals like mice or rabbits for months or years at a time.
I have to give them back because they’re not mine.

Who paid all the expenses above basic food eg vets bills, treatments etc?

Treaclemine · 25/03/2023 14:55

A friend had a cat adopt them, as they do, turning up wanting food until it came in and was effectively theirs. Then a family from a street away claimed it was theirs and took them to court for theft. The court found that you cannot steal a cat if it goes off and adopts you, and it stayed with the friend,
You have a much better case, because of their neglect.

TheGoogleMum · 25/03/2023 14:53

If they're relying on food banks they won't afford any future vets bills or specialist food.
The best thing for the cat is to stay with you but I see they probably won't see it that way. I think if you insist on being reimbursed for vet bills that will stop them claiming cat back.
I do feel a little sorry for them to lose their cat but to not be in touch for a year how bothered about cat can they be really?

leilani83 · 25/03/2023 14:50

Don't give him back! They don't care about him!

WarningToTheCurious · 25/03/2023 14:45

TomeTome · 25/03/2023 14:23

and then didn’t search for it adequately (whose outdoor store was he locked in?), they effectively abandoned the cat
how can you know that? Cats get locked in to garages and sheds all the time round here. Honestly OP there are LOTS of cats in the UK, why do you have to take this child’s cat?

From the OP:

After two weeks (early Feb) the 12 year old let him out and he ran off and then the family went out for the day. He then went missing for 5 weeks and was found by them emaciated and near death having been trapped in an outdoor store cupboard for that time.

Hence the question - whose store cupboard was it?

If it was their cupboard - they didn't do a very good job of looking for a period of 5 weeks, did they?