Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did I steal their cat? (Sorry long)

284 replies

Babbitybowsters · 25/03/2023 10:09

Apologies for the long post but don't want to dripfeed.

I fostered a cat for 2 years for a woman and two kids, because they didn't have anywhere to live that would accept cats. The woman actually didn't contact me for 1 whole year so I thought he was actually my cat now.

She did however get in touch at Xmas to ask for him back. I didn't want to upset her kids and thought it was the right thing to do so I gave him back in January and we kept in touch.

After two weeks (early Feb) the 12 year old let him out and he ran off and then the family went out for the day. He then went missing for 5 weeks and was found by them emaciated and near death having been trapped in an outdoor store cupboard for that time. During that time I couldn't eat or sleep for worry and did everything I could to get him back. I even begged them for the chip number to update his details as they hadn't done it. And I registered the details in my name as they still don't really have permanent address or reliable phone number (long story).

The day after he was found they took him to the PDSA vet came to see me as I lived next to the PDSA vets and we all went together to see him. The vet asked someone to visit in the morning to move him to another vets. The woman asked me as she lived a 30 min train journey away and didn't want to have to get up so early because she is on her own and heavily pregnant. I agreed and picked him up last Thursday and transported him from the night vet to the day vet. At that point he had a seizure and the vet was suggesting putting him to sleep. I begged him not to. It was agreed that we give him to 5pm that day to make a decision. The woman said she wouldn't come unless there was a definite decision and again asked me to go. To my amazement he had perked up and the vet said I could take him home and, being so in shock, I took him to my flat 2 mins from the vets.

As soon he got there he was purring and going back to all his old spots (even though he could barely walk). It was like he had never left and all his things from the past 2 years are here. He is sleeping on my chest everynight.

Last Friday I asked the woman if they would like to come and visit him and they said they would and then didn't turn up. At that point I decided it would be wrong to move him again, as he is so settled here and I'd miss him so much. I also feel they were a bit irresponsible letting him out so soon etc.

I've now spent £400 at my own vets getting home blood tests etc and getting him special food which I know they can't afford as they are currently using food banks.

I wrote the family a nice letter asking if he could stay with me and saying I felt it would be cruel to unsettle him again. The family have responded saying the 12 year is crying every day and he "needs to come home!". But surely his home is here, where I kept him safe for the last 2 years?

Thanks for reading as I am so very torn, particularly as I don't want to upset a child.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LuckyPeonies · 02/04/2023 20:56

Babbitt, please, please, continue to do what is best for the cat, which is for you to keep him and not ever give him back to these people. He needs to be with the person who cares and will take the best care of him and keep him safe. And that is YOU, not these irresponsible morons !!

Over40Overdating · 02/04/2023 16:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 14:18

Yes he's definitely not allowed out for the foreseeable. @JingsMahBucket

OP posts:
JingsMahBucket · 02/04/2023 14:04

@7eleven good point. @Babbitybowsters I wonder if it might be best to have him be an indoor cat for a while during his recovery and the family’s resettlement so they can’t nab him.

7eleven · 02/04/2023 12:41

It doesn’t sound as if they care about the cat at all. It’s about possession and control. Be careful they don’t just try to come and take him.

FrostyFifi · 02/04/2023 12:24

Cats like their own patch and entrenching it in yours any longer than necessary is unkind. 12 year old lonely girls often have beautiful gentle relationships with cats that are mutually satisfying

As the cat has been with OP since 2020 I'm pretty sure it considers OPs home to be its patch.
I doubt a cat would find a relationship where it ends up dead "mutually satisfying".

mybeautifuloak · 02/04/2023 12:16

TomeTome · 02/04/2023 10:11

I think it’s best for the cat to be with its owners rather than passed from one to the other. Cats like their own patch and entrenching it in yours any longer than necessary is unkind. 12 year old lonely girls often have beautiful gentle relationships with cats that are mutually satisfying. I understand you have bonded with it but it isn’t yours and it has owners who love it. When is the baby due? I’d want it with them and settled as soon as possible if I loved it really.

Had the OP not had the cat, it would be dead. I think it's weird to return an animal to people who are not capable of keeping it alive don't you?

youveturnedupwelldone · 02/04/2023 11:56

Keep the cat. Tell them it took a turn for the worst and you had to have it put down.

My brother is like this - he used to have two cats that he neglected horribly. He wouldn't give them up as they were his and he'd be too upset, but didn't actually want to bother looking after them. We got them off him eventually and they live with my parents now.

Do what's best for the cat and sod the owners.

CatChant · 02/04/2023 11:48

OP, the cat is safe and happy with you. In their hands it would already be dead.

These people took advantage of your good nature and have ended up setting the police on you because you said the cat needed to time to recover from the neglect which nearly killed him.

Yes, cats can get themselves shut in but if he was in an outhouse nearby for five weeks they were hardly scouring the streets and knocking on doors for him. And when it came to his veterinary treatment they left it all to you, both organising it and paying for it.

Then, without a word of thanks or an acknowledgement of your time, effort and expense, they expect you to hand him over, and when you hesitate they set the police on you!

CFs of the highest order, I’d say.

This is AIBU where you will always find posters who are going to argue night is day, water is dry, etc. Don’t pay any heed. A living animal is not a toy to be handed over regardless of what will happen to it.

In your shoes I would sooner give the cat to a rescue centre then back to them.

Keep them blocked. He’s your cat now, and very lucky to have you.

mumoffourminimes · 02/04/2023 10:19

Could you offer to buy the cat? When everything settles down. For a token amount (and where the payment can we tracked/letter signed to say it's transferred and the passport) what would mean there'd be no question about ownership in the future.

Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 10:19

Sorry this was to @TomeTome . I think you're being incredibly naive and romanticised about cat ownership.

OP posts:
Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 10:17

The baby is due in 2 weeks.

OP posts:
Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 10:16

It's been here since 2020! Before that it was moved all over, missing several times, and initially came to me because the mum's boyfriend didn't want it. How is giving it back, while it's still sick, from my home where it's lived for over half it's life, to a temporary accommodation where it's not permitted, and full of hazards, the right thing to do for the cat at this point in time? Seriously ????

OP posts:
TomeTome · 02/04/2023 10:11

I think it’s best for the cat to be with its owners rather than passed from one to the other. Cats like their own patch and entrenching it in yours any longer than necessary is unkind. 12 year old lonely girls often have beautiful gentle relationships with cats that are mutually satisfying. I understand you have bonded with it but it isn’t yours and it has owners who love it. When is the baby due? I’d want it with them and settled as soon as possible if I loved it really.

mumoffourminimes · 02/04/2023 10:11

The cats welfare comes first. End of

Rigsby2023 · 02/04/2023 10:01

Have you tried telling them that nobody ever really owns a cat?

Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 09:58

TomeTome · 02/04/2023 09:31

They’ve asked you to give him back and you’ve refused.
He was found by them after weeks of searching but in the meantime you’d changed his chip.
He perked up and the vet said he could go home. You then got bloods done at home and specialist food to the tune of £400 and decided you were the better owner.
Their daughter appears to have lost her school, home, be expecting a new sibling in a new country and presumably has been longing for the day she can have her cat back.

I’m sorry you love it now. I expect they do too. It isn’t yours though.

I didn't say I owned it, I said I have a duty of care towards it. I gave it back once already!

I want to keep it safe until they are in a better place. What do you genuinely think is best for the cat?

OP posts:
gininthejar · 02/04/2023 09:45

I can’t believe it took them 5 weeks to find the cat nearby! They can’t have looked very hard. That cat must have been making a lot of noise at first. I’d be keeping permanently for the cats welfare.

TomeTome · 02/04/2023 09:31

They’ve asked you to give him back and you’ve refused.
He was found by them after weeks of searching but in the meantime you’d changed his chip.
He perked up and the vet said he could go home. You then got bloods done at home and specialist food to the tune of £400 and decided you were the better owner.
Their daughter appears to have lost her school, home, be expecting a new sibling in a new country and presumably has been longing for the day she can have her cat back.

I’m sorry you love it now. I expect they do too. It isn’t yours though.

user1471538283 · 02/04/2023 09:27

Good I'm glad they won't speak to you!

Tell them they owe you £400 and the cat needs continuing medication of £. Or just ignore them back.

They couldn't be arsed to look for the cat when he went missing.

Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 09:21

To make matters worse they refuse to meet or speak with me!

OP posts:
Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 09:20

How am I taking it from them? When I've literally offered to give him back when they have accommodation that allows cats? You obviously think that you are able to cut through the moral quagmire, but I can assure you that it's not so black and white, here in the real world where an animal's life is in danger.

OP posts:
TomeTome · 02/04/2023 09:02

@Babbitybowsters I understand it comes from a good place but I don’t think you can just take someone’s cat because you feel it’s owners aren’t the sort of people it should be living with. If they came back all the way from Germany two years ago, which would have been early 2021 or late 2020 that would have been mid pandemic and lockdown. Of course they have found it difficult to get back on their feet. You offered to care for it as a favour, and insisted on changing the details on the chip to your own presumably also as a favour, and then have used that to substantiate a claim on their pet. The police coming and telling you it’s a civil matter, isn’t them saying you are right, it’s that they can’t get involved. It’s easy to take things from people who have little but it doesn’t make it right, it’s just using your privilege.

Babbitybowsters · 02/04/2023 07:17

@TomeTome the woman brought him over because the child made it a demand of moving here. But the child isn't able to be responsible for the welfare of the cat. And the woman's life at the moment is too chaotic for me to feel comfortable giving him back just now. Not sure what part of this isn't clear.

OP posts:
TomeTome · 02/04/2023 01:26

It was touch and go, and I believe if I didn't have the chip papers they would have taken him as I couldn't prove ownership. but of course you couldn’t prove you owned a cat you don’t own. If they brought it home all the way from Germany with a passport they aren’t really going to let you keep him are they?