Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gwyneth Paltrow and the skiing incident

387 replies

BringCathyBack · 25/03/2023 07:14

Why is everything about suing these days?
He’s saying she crashed into him whilst being distracted by her kids. So it was an accident then? It’s not like she ploughed into him on purpose or crashed into him whilst drunk or high … it was an accident

She’s saying he crashed into her by accident and is counter suing him.

AIBU to think this whole suing culture for genuine accidents needs to stop?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
musingsinmidlife · 26/03/2023 17:22

An interesting part of the testimony is that the allegation is that Gwyneth was watching Moses ski with his instructor Eric and that Moses had been asking Gwyneth to watch him. Howver that testimony that Moses had been asking and that Gwyneth was watching came from Kerry Oakes deposition. According to the testimony yesterday, Keery Oakes and Apple were already much farther downhill than Gwyneth and that Eric and Moses were slightly uphill and on the other side of the run. So there is no way Kerry heard what Moses was saying at that time and nor is it likely that gwyneth could hear what Moses was saying if anything (especially with helmets). Teh lawyer tried to make it seem like it was deposed testimony that at that time of the collision Kerry heard Moses asking Gwyneth to watch him and she was doing so...but that doesn't fit with the facts of the case. Both Eric and Kerry are expected to testify next week. Eric should also be able to speak to Sanderson's level of consciousness shortly after the collision considering he was the one who skiied over to him.

minou123 · 26/03/2023 17:11

Cheers @Mirabai

Sirius3030 · 26/03/2023 17:08

Ktime · 25/03/2023 21:49

She didn’t say she can ‘think faster than your nervous system responding to a physical threat’ though.

OK, I give up. You tell me what ‘thinking at 1000% miles an hour’ means then.

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 16:32

minou123 · 26/03/2023 13:35

I think the point @blitheringblackberriesis you came up with your explanation for what likely happened based on Paltrow and Sanderson testimony.

I can't access the Times article because I haven't subscribed, so I dont know what they have reported.

Paltrow has testified. But Sanderson hasn't yet. We only know what Sanderson might say, based on his complaint when he filed his law suit. But that's not testimony. He could say all sorts on Monday.

So, I'm not sure how Mirabai can tell you the ways your explanation isn't consistent or based on Paltrow or Sandersons testimony

I wouldn't be able to tell you either.

Here is the relevant section of The Times article in question, summarising the 2 versions. I also attach the diagram provided:

In the early afternoon, Paltrow claimed, she and her group were heading down to a restaurant for lunch when she felt someone skiing into her back. At first, she alleged, she feared the person behind might have been sexually assaulting her.She told the court last week: “Two skis came between my skis, forcing my legs apart, and there was a body pressing against me. And there was a very strange groaning noise.”

The actress said: “Is this a practical joke? Is someone doing something perverted?”She continued: “It was probably a few ... seconds and then we fell to the right. Somebody must have caught an edge. I fell on his body.”
The pair tumbled to the ground together and were almost “spooning” as they crashed, she said.

After recovering from the collision, Paltrow screamed: “You skied directly into my effing back!” — language for which she apologised in court last week and which, at the time, she feared her young son might hear.She said that Sanderson, still on the ground, responded by “mumbling” apologetically: “I’m sorry, I’m sorry.”

Sanderson has provided a diametrically different story. He says it was Paltrow who ploughed into him and is even said to have compared her to the prehistoric reptilian monster Godzilla.His lawyers argue that the actress was skiing recklessly at the time as she was distracted by Moses, who was further up the slope from her. According to the deposition of one person present, her son, who was skiing with his own instructor, Eric Christiansen, had been pleading for her attention, exclaiming: “Mama! Mama! Watch me!”

It is suggested that Paltrow then turned around to look at him, causing her to lose focus.

Paltrow crashed into him from behind, leaving him unconscious face down in the snow, according to the testimony of Craig Ramon, 48, a member of Sanderson’s skiing group, the sole eye-witness to the crash. He is being treated by the prosecution as their star witness.He told the court: “She slammed him. Very hard. She hit him directly in the back. The tips of his skis go out and he goes face down, spreadeagled, with Gwyneth on top of him.”

Gwyneth Paltrow and the skiing incident
minou123 · 26/03/2023 14:47

Oblomov23 · 26/03/2023 14:37

If the nature of the collision is so disputed, as it is claimed here, won't the judge be forced to conclude that GP can't be punished. If his ski instructor was there but didn't really see it. If her ski instructor didn't really see it. No one saw it. No real witnesses.

Plus his supposed lying. He got up, GP asked him if he was ok, then her ski instructor told her to ski off and see to her children and that he, ski instructor would deal with it. Yet the man later claimed he was lying down in the snow for 5 to 10 minutes and couldn't get up. none of this rings True.

Unless there's more evidence to come. Concrete. Persuasive. I just can't get my head round, what actually really happened. And if we can't, surely judge can't rule in favour of man. If no solid evidence.

Its a jury who is deciding.

Civil trials work on the balance of probability.
Only criminal court is "beyond all reasonable doubt"

So, in civil trials jury's can decide based on the evidence which story is more likely to be true or credible.
Only in criminal trials do jury's have to take into account any "doubt", so to speak.

You're right, there could be 3 outcomes.

  1. Jury finds Sandersons story more credible. He wins and is awarded $300,000
  1. Jury finds Paltrows story more credible. She wins and is awarded $1.
  1. The jury finds that neither story is credible and sends them both home with nothing.
Oblomov23 · 26/03/2023 14:37

If the nature of the collision is so disputed, as it is claimed here, won't the judge be forced to conclude that GP can't be punished. If his ski instructor was there but didn't really see it. If her ski instructor didn't really see it. No one saw it. No real witnesses.

Plus his supposed lying. He got up, GP asked him if he was ok, then her ski instructor told her to ski off and see to her children and that he, ski instructor would deal with it. Yet the man later claimed he was lying down in the snow for 5 to 10 minutes and couldn't get up. none of this rings True.

Unless there's more evidence to come. Concrete. Persuasive. I just can't get my head round, what actually really happened. And if we can't, surely judge can't rule in favour of man. If no solid evidence.

AngeloMysterioso · 26/03/2023 13:44

EmmaDilemma5 · 25/03/2023 17:12

What's your obsession with giggling? Does every woman you know giggle constantly? What a strange thing to fixate on when talking to another woman about a basket bumping them. We must be on different planets.

@EmmaDilemma5

Every time @Ktime describes this incident she says the guy “shoved” his basket into her. That’s the adjective she uses each time. Shoved.

Even though you weren’t there and didn’t see it, you keep unilaterally downgrading it to “nudged” or “bumped” or “hit”.

Why?

minou123 · 26/03/2023 13:35

I think the point @blitheringblackberriesis you came up with your explanation for what likely happened based on Paltrow and Sanderson testimony.

I can't access the Times article because I haven't subscribed, so I dont know what they have reported.

Paltrow has testified. But Sanderson hasn't yet. We only know what Sanderson might say, based on his complaint when he filed his law suit. But that's not testimony. He could say all sorts on Monday.

So, I'm not sure how Mirabai can tell you the ways your explanation isn't consistent or based on Paltrow or Sandersons testimony

I wouldn't be able to tell you either.

Ktime · 26/03/2023 13:12

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 10:25

Sorry, cba. Read them for yourself.

Ha, thought as much!

If you postulate a theory, the onus is on you to show how it corroborates with GP and TS’s accounts. @Mirabai is right to refuse to do your homework for you.

NevieSticks · 26/03/2023 13:06

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 12:57

Sorry I don’t respond to goading.

😂😂😂

Ktime · 26/03/2023 13:04

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 08:34

I've been skiing since the 1970s and can honestly say I have never been involved in a collision. I have, however, had a couple of very nasty falls and can definitely just remember lying in the snow in a profound state of shock, wondering what on earth just happened.

In a collision, that sense of confusion would be understandable from the person that was hit. You'd assume the person who made contact would be more aware of what had happened - but that would only apply if they were paying attention.

This is why for me, the only explanation that makes sense is that they were both skiing in the same direction on the traverse (across the slope) with Gwyneth slightly above but parallel to the other skiier. She was looking over her shoulder towards her children or otherwise distracted and suddenly they collided. In this scenario, both would feel shocked/confused and not immediately aware of what had happened.

Weird that you’ve decided GP was the one who was distracted / looking at her children, but not that TS was distracted / looking at his friend.

You are not credible.

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 12:57

Sorry I don’t respond to goading.

NevieSticks · 26/03/2023 12:49

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 10:25

Sorry, cba. Read them for yourself.

Ha, thought as much!

This posting style is very reminiscent of another bolshy poster - she would also use this approach.

NevieSticks · 26/03/2023 12:45

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 10:21

Sorry, cba. Read them for yourself.

@blitheringblackberries this is the second time @Mirabai has used this come back - she did the same to me. It's because she can't answer your response.

minou123 · 26/03/2023 12:45

Florenz · 26/03/2023 12:34

It's so obvious what has happened here. The smug look on Paltrow's face says more than so-called "real evidence" ever could. I think she deserves at least 5 years in the LA county slammer. Hopefully she isn't allowed to wriggle out of it like so many wealthy celebrities seem to.

I love a saltire/piss take post. Well done 😁

Florenz · 26/03/2023 12:34

It's so obvious what has happened here. The smug look on Paltrow's face says more than so-called "real evidence" ever could. I think she deserves at least 5 years in the LA county slammer. Hopefully she isn't allowed to wriggle out of it like so many wealthy celebrities seem to.

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 12:24

Very easy therefore for you to identify where your narrative diverges from both versions.

So very easy that you are completely incapable of pointing them out?

The nature of the collision is in dispute on both sides (hence the court case, doh!) so a version that diverges from two disputed accounts is neither here nor there. I am merely positing one possible explanation of what may have happened based on my own experience.

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 10:30

It’s not my job to stand over you and ensure you read an article properly. There are plenty of other articles and news sources all over the internet which cover the same ground. Very easy therefore for you to identify where your narrative diverges from both versions.

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 10:25

Sorry, cba. Read them for yourself.

Ha, thought as much!

Clymene · 26/03/2023 10:22

I have had someone ski into me. What you do is toy speak to the other person. You don't just ski off and leave them lying on the ground. That's sociopathic

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 10:21

Sorry, cba. Read them for yourself.

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 10:16

There are two versions both clearly stated in the Times article and your version bears no relation to either.

In which respect?

Mirabai · 26/03/2023 10:14

It’s not me who needs to keep up. There are two versions both clearly stated in the Times article and your version bears no relation to either.

minou123 · 26/03/2023 10:13

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 09:59

@Mirabai

It is based on both of their testimonies. Obviously, the truth is somewhere in between. Assuming you are a capable skier, it is very difficult to crash into anyone on a relatively quiet slope - unless looking away/distracted.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/gwyneth-paltrow-everything-you-need-to-know-about-her-ski-crash-trial-mhqcln0hl

It wasnt a relatively quiet slope.

GP testimony was it wasn't crowded either.
But it was busy - She said something like medium busy.

We havent heard from TS yet.

blitheringblackberries · 26/03/2023 10:11

@mirabai The whole point is that the nature collision is disputed, keep up!