Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gwyneth Paltrow and the skiing incident

387 replies

BringCathyBack · 25/03/2023 07:14

Why is everything about suing these days?
He’s saying she crashed into him whilst being distracted by her kids. So it was an accident then? It’s not like she ploughed into him on purpose or crashed into him whilst drunk or high … it was an accident

She’s saying he crashed into her by accident and is counter suing him.

AIBU to think this whole suing culture for genuine accidents needs to stop?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Greblegable · 25/03/2023 10:31

SecondhandMuck · 25/03/2023 10:28

Her putting the 'it definitely wasn't sexual assault but for a moment I thought it could have been sexual assault' was a cynical move on GP's and her legal team's part.

Why? It’s a reasonable explanation for why someone might have shouted something like “wtf are you doing get the fuck off me!” Instead of “omg are you ok?”

raincamepouringdown · 25/03/2023 10:31

He's 'only' sued for $300000 I think which isn't much in the grand scheme of things

Actually, he was originally suing for millions. A judge told him he was limited to the $300,000 and knocked down his claim to pursue.

It sounds like he was actually in the wrong, tbh, but can't accept he's done this to himself.

musingsinmidlife · 25/03/2023 10:30

SecondhandMuck · 25/03/2023 10:28

Her putting the 'it definitely wasn't sexual assault but for a moment I thought it could have been sexual assault' was a cynical move on GP's and her legal team's part.

Is this a jury case? That would put me right off as a juror. If you are innocent, no need to try and make this about sexual assault.

Ktime · 25/03/2023 10:29

SecondhandMuck · 25/03/2023 10:28

Her putting the 'it definitely wasn't sexual assault but for a moment I thought it could have been sexual assault' was a cynical move on GP's and her legal team's part.

I suppose IF it’s true and he landed on her, grunting, then one could think he did it deliberately to get to touch her.

SecondhandMuck · 25/03/2023 10:28

Her putting the 'it definitely wasn't sexual assault but for a moment I thought it could have been sexual assault' was a cynical move on GP's and her legal team's part.

MathsNervous · 25/03/2023 10:28

It's the odd facial expressions she has been making in court which I find interesting rather than the case itself. I think there's wrongdoing on both sides. They should just apologise to each other and move on. Life is too short.

Gablonz · 25/03/2023 10:28

Oblomov23 · 25/03/2023 07:43

What about every other person who gets into a skiing accident. In any other country. If they fall over and take you out. You have no come back against them, normally.

snowboarder

Nonsense. That snowboarder is being prosecuted.
In Italy you have to have compulsory personal liability insurance to ski.
I live in Austria and anything like this is classed as a leisure time accident. This means that certain things are not paid for by the "Krankenkassen" - the health insurance companies (these are run by the state, it's not private like the US). You would be treated for the injuries received, but the Krankenkasse does not pay out for things like rehabilitiation and so on. This means that your own leisure accident insurance would need to pay out for the aftermath of the accident. If it was caused by someone else then they would go after the other person's personal liability insurance. The Krankenkasse will also try to recoup the costs of the treatment from the person who caused the accident, rather than it coming out of the public funds.
It's very complicated but if an accident occurs when skiing, blame has to be apportioned and the appropriate insurance company has to pay out.

Mirabai · 25/03/2023 10:27

Greblegable · 25/03/2023 10:26

Having read both sides I can’t see how anyone thinks his is more credible.

I know right. But some will take his side because they think GP is rich, blond and smug, rather than the evidence at hand.

minou123 · 25/03/2023 10:26

Fladdermus · 25/03/2023 10:08

I heard that the medical report says his injuries were consistent with being hit from behind. Does anyone know if that's true? Because if it is, then she hasn't got a leg to stand on.

The xrays taken of his ribs, show he had 4 fractured ribs.
That's a fact.

But, each doctor has a different opinion on how that injury occured.

His doctor says they are consistent from being hit from behind.
GP hasn't presented her case yet, but will bring doctors in to prove the rib injury is consistent with him hitting into her.

Which doctor do you believe?

The brain injury is an interesting one.
He didn't seek medical treatment until 2001 - 5 years after the ski incident.
The scans do show a decline in brain function.

His medical records show he did go for brain scans before the ski accident as he was concerned with his mental/brain functions. And he was seeking treatment for mental health problems before the accident..

His doctors are saying the decline in his brain function is directly related to the ski incident and being concussed.

Her doctors will say, he was having issues with his brain/mental health before the accident. And his current issues, forgetfulness, inability to multi task etc are just normal aging issues.

Which doctor do you believe?

Greblegable · 25/03/2023 10:26

Having read both sides I can’t see how anyone thinks his is more credible.

Mirabai · 25/03/2023 10:25

I’m assuming he’s suing for medical care and because she’s rich.

Originally I assumed it was an accident with no particular fault. But having read the evidence from I think GP is telling the truth, it sounds like he skied straight into her. The way she described it is not what what you would invent if you were going to lie about it.

ShepherdMoons · 25/03/2023 10:25

From what I have read about this, it sounds that Paltrow was negligent and he was badly injured. I also read that she was unapologetic, lacking in care or responsibility for what she had done. I think maybe this is why it has reached this point.

I find her unbearably smug. Not related but just how she comes across.

SeaToSki · 25/03/2023 10:24

When skiing the uphill skier does have more of the burden to avoid people in front of them, but the downhill skiers also have a responsibility to behave reasonably, like stopping on the side of a run in a place that is easily visible from uphill etc. Its a dangerous sport that needs everyone to pay attention to themselves and their surroundings and no one is immune from risk while participating whether up hill or down hill. Skiing with an existing brain injury seems to me to be a very poor choice.

Brightshinylight · 25/03/2023 10:24

From my experience it is men who tend to go/crash into people, I have rarely seen a woman do this. Men think it is funny, women are basically not keen on injuring themselves. Every person I know who has been hit from behind, skied over etc has been by a man.

musingsinmidlife · 25/03/2023 10:23

One thing that is confusing is that she says that Apple and her instructor Eric were already downhill from her and that Moses and his instructor Kerry were uphill from her on the other side of the run. Then they crashed and she got up and left and said that Eric checked on the guy and gave her information etc. But Eric was already farther down the hill and would have needed to walk back up to check on the guy. Kerry who was uphill from her would have been able to ski down to him much faster than Eric could come back up the hill.

The two ski instructors will testify next week. I am curious as to what they say happened. Apparently the ski lessons for the four kids were $8000 USD! That seems exhorbitantly expensive for that ski hill and normal ski instructor rates, even for a week.

KVick · 25/03/2023 10:23

I'm American, so I'll take a stab at this one:
The culture of suing in the U.S. is mostly due to an overabundance of lawyers. So I imagine that the skier whom Paltrow accidentally bumped into on the slopes thought, "Oh! a famous and enormously wealthy person... let me get a lawyer and make a few extra bucks off this....!" though this fellow is probably not poor himself, since skiing a rather expensive sport, and if you're at the same resort as some rich celebrity, you're probably doing ok financially (and not worrying about the cost of healthcare, as another poster posited!)

But I digress.... Once someone threatens to sue her, Paltrow just calls her legal team and they take over.... The team decides to nip this bogus lawsuit in the bud by counter-suing, otherwise every time the woman accidentally brushes up against someone, they'll be trying to sue, as sometimes is easier for the really wealthy party to settle a lawsuit (i.e., just pay $$), and people know this. So the guy found a lawyer who saw this as a quick way to make an extra $200-300K, which is pocket change to her.

Also: Americans are insane.... so that's also a factor....

ArtHistory · 25/03/2023 10:22

Oblomov23 · 25/03/2023 07:43

What about every other person who gets into a skiing accident. In any other country. If they fall over and take you out. You have no come back against them, normally.

snowboarder

I can't comment on all countries, but in many countries you absolutely can sue in these circumstances. Including England. If you could ski in England, obvs.

ZiriForEver · 25/03/2023 10:21

Btw, in that famous McDonald's hot coffee case, there was a real problem on their side.

McDonald's intentionally served about 10degrees hotter coffee than was industry standard and "for drinking" temperature.

They expected people to order more food while waiting for the coffee to cool down.
There were aware that this decision will harm people, it was already harming people and they considered cheaper to pay settlements than reduce the serving temperature. With the famous old lady, they tried to get away without paying, hoping she won't be able to fight back. She did.

DaveyJonesLocker · 25/03/2023 10:21

She seriously injured him and just left him there. Vile.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 25/03/2023 10:17

GP was with an instructor, surely they’re the only independent person here who can give evidence unless other skiers that were in the vicinity stopped and left their details.

There’s absolutely no way that an instructor would ski past anyone who was unconscious on a piste, whether or not they or their group had been directly involved in the incident. GP has says that her instructor swapped details - that doesn’t indicate that he was unconscious! I don’t believe that part of his story.

One person skiing into another doesn’t indicate who will sustain the injury. I was skied into from behind last year. I got away with a stiff shoulder for a few days, the person who skied into me needed assistance to get off the mountain having injured one of their knees. We waited until the pisteurs arrived and gave contact details but never heard any more.

Neighbours87 · 25/03/2023 10:14

It’s America the insurance company force you to sue to recoup the medical costs

Vermin · 25/03/2023 10:11

(Ie his medical report - not an independent one. I don’t know whether there is an independent one or if GP’s expert got to examine him)

this thread very good at showing why one never wants to end up in front of a jury!

Rainbowshit · 25/03/2023 10:10

I find it interesting that the daughter emailed her father saying she can't believe it was all caught on GoPro. where's the footage?

This all rests on who was the downhill skier. The rules are that the uphill skier is responsible as the downhill has right of way.

Vermin · 25/03/2023 10:10

The medical report was done by his mate, the radiographer.

Fladdermus · 25/03/2023 10:08

I heard that the medical report says his injuries were consistent with being hit from behind. Does anyone know if that's true? Because if it is, then she hasn't got a leg to stand on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread