Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Gwyneth Paltrow and the skiing incident

387 replies

BringCathyBack · 25/03/2023 07:14

Why is everything about suing these days?
He’s saying she crashed into him whilst being distracted by her kids. So it was an accident then? It’s not like she ploughed into him on purpose or crashed into him whilst drunk or high … it was an accident

She’s saying he crashed into her by accident and is counter suing him.

AIBU to think this whole suing culture for genuine accidents needs to stop?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Emotionalsupportviper · 25/03/2023 11:00

MoonriseKingdom · 25/03/2023 07:28

I saw a documentary about that case that often gets referred to about the woman who sued McDonalds over the hotness of their coffee. It sounds frivolous but the alternative was being bankrupted by medical bills as she had had a long hospital stay with skin grafts. I think Medical bills in America can drive a lot of litigation.

People scoffed at that case, but if you saw the photos of her injuries it wasn't a minor, just-being-a-fanny-about-it thing. You are right that it was her medical bills ($10,000) that forced her to sue - she'd tried asking McDonalds to recompense her and they effectively told her to piddle off! Jurors decided that McDonalds need to learn a lesson, and awarded huge punitive damages.

The coffee was, and McDonald's knew it was, at a ridiculous heat. I've scalded myself with coffee before ( a minor scald) and still have a small keloid scar on my stomach 30 years later - it was agonising. And my coffee had milk in it - hers was black and had nothing to lower the temperature. If it spills onto clothing (as mine did) the heat is held against your skin and you can't immediately cool the area.

https://www.caoc.org/?pg=facts

https://vahdatlaw.com/the-hot-coffee-lawsuit-irvine-personal-injury-lawyer/

Mrs Liebeck deserves every penny.

"Know the Facts:" Resources for Consumers

https://www.caoc.org/?pg=facts

SgtCatherineCawood · 25/03/2023 10:59

Is there a glitch? I keep seeing people reposting the YouTube video with big spaces underneath but no text

Ktime · 25/03/2023 10:59

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 25/03/2023 10:52

Same story Minou and your reporting is more accurate than mine.

Sorry I’m just not charitable enough to believe this is an act entirely outside Gwyneth Paltrows radar/decision making. Why ask her lawyer to raise it? Why not just wait till after the trial and sort it then.

Raising “could we bring some baked goods as a treat” during a personal injury claim is inappropriate and crass. She should have told her kind personal security staff to hold off until the claim was complete.

Judge wasn’t that bothered by it.

Lawyers for Mr Sanderson swiftly objected, prompting Judge Kent Holmberg to say: "OK, there's an objection so thank you, but no thank you."
But he said either party could "decide to do that later" if they wished

NevieSticks · 25/03/2023 10:58

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 25/03/2023 08:18

It’s just another case of a man bullying a woman and blaming her. Good on Paltrow for not accepting it. If you read the evidence it’s clear why previous judges have chucked this out. And it’s clear he skied into her.

shocked by those hurling abuse at her, she’s lying, she’s a spoiled brat, she’s smirking etc. cluelessly rushing to believe the man and attack the woman. Shameful

so we always have to support a woman in anything because of her sex? Other women are not allowed to have a different opinion because they are the same sex?

musingsinmidlife · 25/03/2023 10:57

She is also suing for attorney fees and all related court costs so much more than $1. The $1 is punitive damages.

I think she might have run into him but I doubt the injuries were caused by the collision. Given all her bizarre ideas and his loss of the go pro footage, I wouldn't trust either of them!

MsFogi · 25/03/2023 10:57

I have no time for people who 'ski into' people - it is totally unacceptable. You are responsible for not ploughing into anyone below you on the slope and being in control of your speed so you can stop. There are too many people who think they are 'great' skiers or who brag about how fast they can ski (which for some reason they think make them a good skier rather than someone on a downhill trajectory with gravity helping them) who injure (not to mention kill) people every year.

Ktime · 25/03/2023 10:54

bruffin · 25/03/2023 10:53

You forget that american's have to pay for health care and if they have insurance they still have excesses and the insurance companies want to get their money back.

I could see this if it was say the hot coffee incident but if your going skiing you take out the insurance as it's a known risk!
Have you seen what actually happened in the hot coffee incident.It was truly horrendous!

He sued for £5m initially though.

chevvyroo · 25/03/2023 10:53

Some of the responses on here are mind boggling. It just goes to show that some people will believe what they want to believe.

bruffin · 25/03/2023 10:53

pinkbaglady · 25/03/2023 07:20

I thought the same OP.

im sure someone who’s more well versed in American culture will come on and tell us why he’s suing for what seems to be an accident

You forget that american's have to pay for health care and if they have insurance they still have excesses and the insurance companies want to get their money back.

I could see this if it was say the hot coffee incident but if your going skiing you take out the insurance as it's a known risk!
Have you seen what actually happened in the hot coffee incident.It was truly horrendous!

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 25/03/2023 10:52

I won’t go so far as to say she’s being manipulative…

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 25/03/2023 10:52

Same story Minou and your reporting is more accurate than mine.

Sorry I’m just not charitable enough to believe this is an act entirely outside Gwyneth Paltrows radar/decision making. Why ask her lawyer to raise it? Why not just wait till after the trial and sort it then.

Raising “could we bring some baked goods as a treat” during a personal injury claim is inappropriate and crass. She should have told her kind personal security staff to hold off until the claim was complete.

Markasread · 25/03/2023 10:48

ShepherdMoons · 25/03/2023 10:25

From what I have read about this, it sounds that Paltrow was negligent and he was badly injured. I also read that she was unapologetic, lacking in care or responsibility for what she had done. I think maybe this is why it has reached this point.

I find her unbearably smug. Not related but just how she comes across.

I think she was unapologetic because someone had just skied into her back. It wouldn't occur to me to be apologetic.

minou123 · 25/03/2023 10:47

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 25/03/2023 10:39

Well thats the news story I read.

Do tell us what really happened….

Gwenyth didn't ask if she could bring in treats for court staff.

If you have a link to the news story that says that, I'll be interested in reading it.

I'm watching the trial. Personal security would like to bring court bailiffs treats as a thank you for sorting some incidents that have been happening outside the court. The judge said they could do it after the trial.
Not very exciting.

MathsNervous · 25/03/2023 10:43

GP doesn't need to hide her face in court either. We all know what she looks like due to her occupation 🙄 talk about being theatrical...

Markasread · 25/03/2023 10:43

I think she's counter suing (for one dollar) I'm self defense.

It looks like his neurological problems had already begun before the accident and he was a prolific risk taker. Prior to the accident he drove erratically and had been known to read a book while driving at 70mph. Skiing into someone's back seems plausible for an elderly person losing their focus. His eye witness account testifying she skied into him comes from his friend who was 40ft off and has altered over time.

GP has a ski instructor's report testifying that he skied into her back but this has been suggested to be unreliable because the instructor was in her employment. Yet what is she supposed to do if that's the report that she has? There's nothing else to suggest he is lying.

The radiologist thought it unlikely from his injuries that he skied into her because he would have been shielding himself. Yet someone without the neurological function to react quickly and the ineptitude to ski into someone else might not have a quick reaction time. GP's description fits with a collision where both parties were taken completely by surprise.

GP left the scene to join her young children after ascertaining that her instructor would give her details and do whatever necessary.

I think they're trying to make a buck and in denial that he shouldn't have been on the slopes in the first place.

smashinggrapes · 25/03/2023 10:42

"Agreed and as an actress, she possibly has trained her face into a resting small smile. Meghan has this look. It could be natural of course. Idk"

Fucking hell 🤣 yep, must be Meghan's fault

Greblegable · 25/03/2023 10:41

Mirabai · 25/03/2023 10:27

I know right. But some will take his side because they think GP is rich, blond and smug, rather than the evidence at hand.

Exactly. A brain injury he didn’t know he had till years later despite having had a scan to investigate potential mental decline BEFORE the accident. A daughter who says he’s always been an angry man who’s obsessed with GP since the accident. insisting that he was abandoned on slope and left unconscious whereas a ski instructor says he had a chat with him.And the only doctors who are testifying to his injuries are also his friends. oh and the friend who claims to have witnessed GP ski into him has also testified that a ski instructor told him that he’d just seen Sanderson ski into her .

but lots of posters saying she should just pay up and is just a rich cow.

GonnaBeYoniThisChristmas · 25/03/2023 10:39

minou123 · 25/03/2023 08:38

That's not what the News story said.

It's also not what happened.

Well thats the news story I read.

Do tell us what really happened….

Grumpybutfunny · 25/03/2023 10:39

Ofstedareunsafe · 25/03/2023 10:33

It’s partly because of the states not having free medical care, so you could be out of pocket for thousands and thousands in medical bills. So it creates a culture of litigation. With the break down of the NHS and fewer legit employers paying sick pay I hope we don’t see it come over here.

I could see this if it was say the hot coffee incident but if your going skiing you take out the insurance as it's a known risk!

minou123 · 25/03/2023 10:37

Fladdermus · 25/03/2023 10:32

I have absolutely no idea. Maybe there needs to be an independent court expert who examines both reports and makes a professional judgement and it's that that gets presented to the jury.

That'll be lovely, but that's the problem.

In the US, there is no independent court expert.
We have it in the UK

But in the US, each side gets to pay for thier own expert, who naturally will side with the person who is paying them.
The jury then have to decide which expert they agree with.

In my opinion, I think this is a massive problem with the US civil law.

jenjenlinks · 25/03/2023 10:35

BringCathyBack · 25/03/2023 07:14

Why is everything about suing these days?
He’s saying she crashed into him whilst being distracted by her kids. So it was an accident then? It’s not like she ploughed into him on purpose or crashed into him whilst drunk or high … it was an accident

She’s saying he crashed into her by accident and is counter suing him.

AIBU to think this whole suing culture for genuine accidents needs to stop?

You don't actually know anything about it, do you? You don't know why he is suing. You don't know if it was a genuine accident, you don't know if someone was at fault, or liable.

So really, what the fuck are you doing questioning it?

Ofstedareunsafe · 25/03/2023 10:33

It’s partly because of the states not having free medical care, so you could be out of pocket for thousands and thousands in medical bills. So it creates a culture of litigation. With the break down of the NHS and fewer legit employers paying sick pay I hope we don’t see it come over here.

OhmygodDont · 25/03/2023 10:33

I think it’s hard to tell with the ribs. My dh iceskating he broke his ribs. Not because someone hit him from behind because he hit a hard object in front of him.

So the ribs could be was smashing into the back of gp, older peoples bones do break at more easily which is why it’s always so much more damaging when they fall over. She could have gone into the back of him but then I’d of expected bruising on his back from her impact at speed to him again being a more elderly person who will sustain injury’s easier.

I can’t imagine either making up a story about someone’s skis between between your legs and grunting sounds in your ear.

The man’s already tried before and failed to sue, the daughter says his become obsessed by this issue. He already had many medical issues prior which makes the skiing alone much more risky even if he had of just fallen over.

Then there’s apparently an independent instructor who it’s being claimed to of said he ran into her where as his witnesses/doctor are friends.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 25/03/2023 10:33

It’s all about insurance in the US. The same way your car insurance provider is technically suing another when you have a crash.

It’s all VERY bizarre though. I am NOT a GP fab especially when she seems to be constantly promoting her eating disorder. It it’s a ski slope FFS don’t be faffing around stopping and fannying on to the point someone crashes into you. He must have been fairly still for a tiny women, who’s probably about 4 stone wet through, to band into him so hard as to give him brain damage.

Fladdermus · 25/03/2023 10:32

minou123 · 25/03/2023 10:26

The xrays taken of his ribs, show he had 4 fractured ribs.
That's a fact.

But, each doctor has a different opinion on how that injury occured.

His doctor says they are consistent from being hit from behind.
GP hasn't presented her case yet, but will bring doctors in to prove the rib injury is consistent with him hitting into her.

Which doctor do you believe?

The brain injury is an interesting one.
He didn't seek medical treatment until 2001 - 5 years after the ski incident.
The scans do show a decline in brain function.

His medical records show he did go for brain scans before the ski accident as he was concerned with his mental/brain functions. And he was seeking treatment for mental health problems before the accident..

His doctors are saying the decline in his brain function is directly related to the ski incident and being concussed.

Her doctors will say, he was having issues with his brain/mental health before the accident. And his current issues, forgetfulness, inability to multi task etc are just normal aging issues.

Which doctor do you believe?

I have absolutely no idea. Maybe there needs to be an independent court expert who examines both reports and makes a professional judgement and it's that that gets presented to the jury.