Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

25k in the bank

94 replies

supermario10 · 25/03/2023 00:04

I have joined the PTA at my twins school and at a recent meeting found out there is 25k in the pta bank account. They are at a small school and this seems excessive, shouldn't it be spent on the children rather than sat in a bank? They are looking for new fundraising ideas but surely they should be spending some too? How do I raise this or is it normal. Thanks in advance for any advice.

OP posts:
Whatevercanbedone · 25/03/2023 07:54

It likely been raised over several years or from donations.
Our PTA fund is healthy. The PTA want to keep it that way as know one knows what is coming in at next fundraiser.
At meetings we discuss and agree how to spend the money. Pupils put forward ideas of what they want. If feasible this is done. If it's costly item pupils want then we would agree to work towards that target.

Pupils definitely benefit through in last couple of years bigger items include outdoor learning area, climbing equipment. Discounted school trips, a gift at Christmas, books for every child to keep, Easter hunt prizes and lots of other things that really make the school nice. Pupils voice is a big thing and the pupils definitely get to voice their opinions

If all the money is spent now just for sake of it then the bigger items /more costly things aren't going to happen as by the time the funding is raised the pupils who wanted / needed it won't be at the school

Fluffodils · 25/03/2023 07:50

Ask them what they are doing with it?

Littlewhitecat · 25/03/2023 07:49

eternalopt · 25/03/2023 04:15

Have the got an constitution? That will say what the money should be spent on and, as long as there's a need for that sort of thing, you should be spending it! What's your annual income (not profit - income so all money)? If it's more than £5k per annum you have to register with charity commission and then you have to have a constitution

^ this. The charity commission have very strict rules about how much money can be sat on. I was chair at our pre-school PTA and we had over 50k in the account at one point because we were building an extension. You should familiarise yourself with how a PTA actually works and what projects they have planned before assuming they are hoarding cash.

Dailywalk · 25/03/2023 07:48

MeinKraft · 25/03/2023 00:08

It seems sensible to have an amount in the bank that would cover significant emergency expenditure like repairs?

PTA money shouldn’t be spent in repairs.

Equimum · 25/03/2023 07:48

OP I totally get your frustration. I was secretary of the PTA at my son's old primary school. When I took the role, we were doing almost weekly fundraisers for a piece of playground equipment which cost around £6k. Parents were being asked to sponsor things like NatGeo magazine for the library, as there was no money to pay for this, but there was already over £15k in the bank, and the HT wouldn't let us spend any of it in case something major came along. It was ridiculous!
I would ask what the money is there for and try to encourage the chair to ask the school what they need.

HoppingPavlova · 25/03/2023 07:23

@Tuilpmouse sorry, maybe was not clear. The funds from P&C were not used to pay teachers per normal employment, I.e. if the school is meant to employ 15 teachers then 15 teachers are employed, and paid for by the Dept of Education. That 15 will fit the number of kids at the school per ratio/required allocation. The school and P&C wanted more teachers again to enable smaller class sizes than prescribed minimum so the school employed them on a direct contract rather than them being employed by the public system teacher employer, being Dept of Educ.

Badbudgeter · 25/03/2023 07:00

We have lots of money in our account too. A big chunk of it is ringfenced for community projects as it was fundraised from the local council. The people who did that fundraising have left though. (Kids at high school). No one really wants to run with it so the money might have to be returned. It does seem like more parents are working full time these days in comparison with five years ago when people had more free time and were keen to help.

I'm the same to be fair. I work full time if I can I will help out at evening events but I don't want responsibility for a "project".

thirdistheonewiththehairychest · 25/03/2023 06:50

ACynicalDad · 25/03/2023 00:13

PTA funds usually has to be spent on enrichment and extras, not to cover budget shortfall, repairs or salaries.

Hahahahahaa!!!!

MRex · 25/03/2023 06:48

Our PTA is targeting £38k for a specific project, and two years ago spent similar sums on another large project. Computer room, Music room and instruments, Playground climbing equipment, Forest school, outdoor classroom, physio room for additional needs, updated library and tech resources, science lab... There are lots of projects that can cost more than £25k. Check the school newsletter as that often says what money is being raised for, or ask someone.

Bunnycat101 · 25/03/2023 06:37

Why not have a look on the charity commission’s website. You’ll see the annual income and expenditure for a few years. Our income dipped during covid as couldn’t have events so they may have been trying to recover their reserves a bit ahead to help with cash flow. The last published accounts for our one showed a cash reserve of about £20k which was then depleted during covid as expenditure was greater than income. It isn’t necessarily a bad thing to have reserves.

Tuilpmouse · 25/03/2023 06:33

Even if your are new to being on the PTA, I'd expect that if they had £25k sitting in reserves that it would be for a significant project, and if that's the case then I'd expect that parents would be well informed of the PTA's intentions.

It's not appropriate to raise £10s of £000s from parents and not be clear what it's for, especially if you are looking to fundraise even more!

If it is just an unallocated balance well in excess of your annual spend (and in my
experience PTAs don't spend this amount of money annually on routine stuff) it's massively excessive.

Tuilpmouse · 25/03/2023 06:23

@HoppingPavlova

In my experience U.K. PTA's don't generally have anything like the remit your P&Cs. They don't fund staff salaries for instance!

icypompoms · 25/03/2023 06:20

How long has it been there? My issue with it is that parents and kids will have left the school who have contributed to the funds.

Coffeetree · 25/03/2023 06:16

The amount of reserves you're required to have is relative to your income/expenditure so we can't really say whether £25K is too much or too little to be sitting in the bank.

But do ask your treasurer or chair! It's a valid question and good that you're actually reading the numbers.

weebarra · 25/03/2023 06:10

You should ask. Like pps have said, we have money earmarked for specific things the school needs: subscriptions to learning software, earphones to go with the kids' chromebooks, money for each class for STEM week, or specific big projects. We part funded an outdoor classroom and now we're supporting the refurbishment of the school library.
Parents don't like continually being asked to support the school financially without an idea of where the money is going.
We have a float but nothing like £25k!

Coffeetree · 25/03/2023 06:03

It's a reasonable question OP, because on first glance it looks like a lot of money just sitting there.

If it's a charity, there is a requirement to have a certain amount of "reserves" in the bank. Without it, your accounts might not get approved by the Charity Commission, and you'd find it difficult to get insurance or fundraise. The concept is that it's there for emergencies or if your income is suddenly gone.

If you're not a charity, it's still good governance to have reserves.

HoppingPavlova · 25/03/2023 04:43

@HirplesWithHaggis Not sure what your P&C is, but I'm pretty sure it's not the same as an English school PTA

It’s Australian. Theoretically it’s Parents&Citizens Association for the school but same as US PTA. It’s where parents (and community) raise funds for the school the children attend. My experience is with public school. Essentially the parent group raise money via sausage sizzles, fetes, putting on disco’s at the school, raffles etc. The ‘community’ bit comes in where you try and get local businesses to do their bit by donating, e.g. prizes for raffles, sausages or bread for sausage sizzles to decrease outlay and increase profit. Then there is annual ‘voluntary contribution’ the parents can make, it’s requested but not mandatory. The school has a ‘wish list’ which the principal or delegate puts forward and the P&C members (those who can be bothered turning up to meetings) vote yes or no and the money raised goes to those things voted yes. At our school it was always additional staffing as schools first priority, then infrastructure/equipment (being public school they would never get it that funding from government) as second priority then stuff like new readers, sports equipment or so forth as last priority. P&C accounts had to be externally audited annually.

eternalopt · 25/03/2023 04:15

Have the got an constitution? That will say what the money should be spent on and, as long as there's a need for that sort of thing, you should be spending it! What's your annual income (not profit - income so all money)? If it's more than £5k per annum you have to register with charity commission and then you have to have a constitution

Joystir59 · 25/03/2023 04:13

OP you are too daft for words raising the question on mn- ask your PTA this question.

HirplesWithHaggis · 25/03/2023 03:51

HoppingPavlova · 25/03/2023 03:13

Depends really on how the school and P&C works. When mine were young and at primary school the P&C paid for capital works (air conditioning, huge outdoor covered area one year that cost approx 170K, smart boards etc), as well as additional staff salaries, plus the obligatory bench here and there for a child who died or parent and who had been a huge contributor to school in whatever way. You needed the full salaries for the next year sitting there about a quarter before the current school year ended so that those teachers could be told their contracts could be renewed. The P&C then shifted the money for salaries in bulk right to the school at the end of the year.

Not sure what your P&C is, but I'm pretty sure it's not the same as an English school PTA.

Phoebo · 25/03/2023 03:26

Seems smart to me to have a good chunk of money in the bank, especially of they want to do something big at one stage

HoppingPavlova · 25/03/2023 03:13

Depends really on how the school and P&C works. When mine were young and at primary school the P&C paid for capital works (air conditioning, huge outdoor covered area one year that cost approx 170K, smart boards etc), as well as additional staff salaries, plus the obligatory bench here and there for a child who died or parent and who had been a huge contributor to school in whatever way. You needed the full salaries for the next year sitting there about a quarter before the current school year ended so that those teachers could be told their contracts could be renewed. The P&C then shifted the money for salaries in bulk right to the school at the end of the year.

WitheredandOld · 25/03/2023 02:56

Why would you assume as a brand new member that it is not earmarked for something, and why not ask for heaven’s sake?

Threeboysandadog · 25/03/2023 02:01

Our primary has a very active parent council. They organise regular fundraisers, apply for grants for larger projects and approach shops and businesses for sponsorship, raffle prizes and food for fundraising or for special school events.

The parent council meets monthly with the headmaster and deputies with a list of things they would like money to go towards and depending on what it’s requested for, money comes out of the pot, it’s decided to do a special fundraiser or it’s checked if there is a specific grant that could be applied for.

Recently money has gone towards P7 leavers hoodies, P7 trip, busses for a whole school trip to the pantomime, books for the library, the building of an outside classroom, football strips, teachers “out of pocket” expenses to name but a few. 25k is a lot to have sitting in an account if it’s not earmarked for something.

Raindancer411 · 25/03/2023 02:00

As someone else said, we tend to raise for certain things required by the school but if we have excess, then ask the school what they need help with funding. £25k is a lot to be sitting there...