Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Zero tolerance schools and slant techniques for send - good, okay or terrible

283 replies

Zerotolerancetofun · 24/03/2023 23:46

Dd is starting secondary next year. The school has a zero tolerance behaviour policy so very strict about everything (uniform, homework, behaviour etc). They are also bringing in this new teaching technique called slant that the kids are meant to follow - about how they sit/pay attention/look at the teachers - it sounds very Draconian.

Dd has ASD and significant levels of anxiety and I am concerned how this environment will work for her. I think she will be terrified of making a mistake and getting detention for minor mistakes, but of course if this approach stops bullying etc then that is a good thing for her.

I'd love to know how other people's DC have got on with this type of school. Particularly if they have ASD, but also NT children too.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 13:36

@EpicBanana

Common sense applies here though doesn’t it? They’re really not going to expect it for 100 percent of the lesson.

Spendonsend · 25/03/2023 13:36

SLANT isn't just sitting and listening which Is a basic expectation. In my sons school it was a very specific limited way of demonstrating 'active listening'. It was very much a very particular sitting position meant you were actively listening. You had to sit slightly leaning forward rather than resting your back on the back rest. Hands had to be by your side, you couldnt rest one on you lap. And you couldnt adjust position like crossing and uncrossing legs. For Looking you had to move your head to track your teacher, not just your eyes (or perhaps the other way round) They recently dropped it and have come up with 'ready to learn' and 'respectful' and everything is a lot less prescriptive. Like you can be listening resting on you chair back and still be listening if you then cross you legs.

EpicBanana · 25/03/2023 13:32

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 12:52

For those not familiar; SLANT stands for

Sit up
Listen
Ask and answer questions
Nod your head (active listening)
Track (look at) the speaker

I know that people are picturing this as very robotic and dystopian but surely that's how most polite people behave in any meeting, or setting when information is being explained. I don't see what is so wrong about that. Isn't it basic social ettiquette?

If a majority of NT students are doing this in a classroom, then a couple of ND children who find one or more of those behaviours difficult is more manageable. I doubt that a whole room of children with heads on the desk, staring out the window, fiddling with pens, rummaging in bags and paying no attention to the teacher is comfortable for ND children either.

There are lots of ways to actively listen though. In a meeting I might not constantly track the speaker. I might write myself some notes. I might occasionally look away as I consider something the speaker has said. I might slightly shift in my seat because it's not the most comfortable seat.

I'm not slumped on the desk. I'm not staring out the window constantly. I'm not getting up and moving around or jiggling the whole time. But I'm also not following the SLANT rules. And if the teacher notices the one time I make a note or shift because my bum cheek has gone numb, and not the 100 times I was sitting fine, then I've got a detention. For being entirely human. Wtf?

Also really, neurotypical people just need to accept that eye contact is a cultural norm and we can change those.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 25/03/2023 13:28

It seems to be exactly what I expect from my kids at home. I want classrooms that’s are calm, well ordered and where the kids look at you and actually engage.

3WildOnes · 25/03/2023 13:26

One of my children is an anxious perfectionist and possibly asd. I think a school like this would have caused him to either school refuse or have a nervous breakdown or both. School refusal is really common in asd children without the added anxiety rules like these provoke.
However, my child also wouldn't have thrived in a noisy chaotic environment either.
Is moving an option?

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 13:25

You've said you work in an alternative setting. I teach some very low ability groups in a mainstream secondary, and so I obviously don't have the same expectations of those groups as some of my other classes.

But in a mainstream secondary school (or even KS2), where the overwhelming majority of children have no SEND that affects their behaviour, then I think it's a very reasonable expectation to be able to sit and listen to someone delivering information. That means that the teacher has the capacity to give more help and attention where it is needed, not crowd controlling children who are perfectly capable.

I would find a school that expected KS4 or lower students to listen for a full lesson without at least answering a few questions in their exercise books very odd.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 13:24

@goldfootball

Exactly. I guess one big issue here could be some areas don’t have many schools to pick from, so some kids are going to end up in schools that are absolutely not right for them. Thankfully in my particular area there are quite a few to pick from.

goldfootball · 25/03/2023 13:21

@Chilloutsnow

i know what you mean about choosing for your own kids - the last place I worked in, with a huge emphasis on listening, was great for bright kids with supportive parents who just knew when to crack on and get their head down. It served them really well and set them up for the future. I always recommend it to local parents with kids like that. For parents of kids with send… I don’t!

Florenz · 25/03/2023 13:20

I think schools these schools are a great idea. Parents who don't think their children would benefit from a strict learning environment should probably send their children to another school.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 13:17

@goldfootball

Well that is impressive. I have worked in many, many schools that have tried and failed and quite frankly just haven’t got a clue on what the concept even means. Now I’m not blaming schools for this, hell even clinical services might need a refresher or two on how to implement a trauma informed service.

I worked clinically in health and social care, mainly mental health services before entering the profession to teach H&S care. I do have high standards in terms of a holistic education. However, as a mother I can compartmentalise and I have no issue with sending one of my children to a school which isn’t inclusive. For him, in the context of where we live and his attributes it was the right decision.

For a child who may have SEN, ND or MH issues I would think twice.

goldfootball · 25/03/2023 13:17

@Littlecamellia im pretty sure the school would have been aware of a Looked After Child with a PTSD diagnosis 🤦🏻‍♀️ Really on them if they weren’t!

goldfootball · 25/03/2023 13:15

@PetitPorpoise id definitely plan for most lessons to have a mix of listening and activities but I’ve worked in an academy chain where active listening was expected for most of every lesson and they were looking to move towards even more of a ‘lecture’ style teaching model. 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don’t think having the expectation that children sit and listen is the same as teaching them to be able to do it. In one sense it’s demonstrating to them that there’s is something they ought to be able to but if they can’t do it they can’t do it. The 20 mins of sustained attention I can expect from my class is after two terms of effort! I have had to explicitly teach and practice stuff like - if I say your name I want you to look at me. As in we have done entire lessons of games based on that. I know it sounds a bit like a joke but that’s the reality of my class!

Littlecamellia · 25/03/2023 13:12

mixedrecycling · 25/03/2023 12:27

From her birth family. Do I need to go into details about how a child can have PTSD by the age of 3?

Diagnosed by CAMHS

In that case, I think you should have made certain that the school was aware of it, do that they could adjust their expectations accordingly.

goldfootball · 25/03/2023 13:09

@Chilloutsnow

”Some teachers and SLT believe that being trauma informed means we should allow certain children to be abusive because they’ve experienced trauma. Even in the realms of clinical work, the concept of being “trauma informed” is woefully misunderstood, and quickly just becoming the next buzz word.”

yes I feel like I’ve certainly come across this. I get how difficult it is to roll out genuinely trauma informed policies and I’m grateful to work somewhere that has resources to do it.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 13:08

I agree with you, and so having this expectation that for listening parts of the lesson, this is how we should behave surely we are teaching helpful behaviours and social skills. Most lessons wouldn't have huge chunks of time of pure listening without being interspersed with other tasks anyway.

MichelleScarn · 25/03/2023 13:07

Agree @PetitPorpoise when did behaviour like this stop being as standard in a school setting? That it's now an actual 'thing' to sit and pay attention to the teacher?
If its seen as such a dramatic thing to be doing at school I'd absolutely send DC to a school that had these 'rules'! What are other classes like then, if sitting and listening is out of the ordinary?

goldfootball · 25/03/2023 13:03

@PetitPorpoise some children have to be explicitly taught those skills and practice them like anything else they are learning to do. Lots of SALT interventions in my school are essentially this. Attention and listening comes naturally to most of us but not all and some children will be literally incapable of sitting still and listening for 5/6 hours a day. In my class (special school) I will insist on all the slant stuff for max 20 minutes at a time because that is very genuinely the upper limit for how long the pupils can do it. Throughout the day there are lots of ways I create opportunities to develop attention and listening skills so they are getting better but it’s about 50% of what I’m actually “teaching” them tbh. And loads of it would look like we were just playing a game or having a chat but those are foundational skills to be able to interact with people. It’s actually fascinating how much I was taking for granted before I started this job and got interested in SALT.

kezzieliza · 25/03/2023 12:58

As a former teacher I would love to send my children to a school like this. Behaviour is so bad in some schools and children find it really stressful and impossible to learn in such an environment. My children don't have sen so I don't know from that perspective but I would say the structure, order and predictability would be a good thing for a child with anxiety.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 12:55

@goldfootball

Some teachers and SLT believe that being trauma informed means we should allow certain children to be abusive because they’ve experienced trauma. Even in the realms of clinical work, the concept of being “trauma informed” is woefully misunderstood, and quickly just becoming the next buzz word.

Most teachers I’ve had the pleasure of working with do take a holistic approach to children and their individual needs, bar the odd one of course. It doesn’t always mean the approaches will work. I personally know a head who is trying to change around an SEMH school which can truly, truly be likened to a prison environment. They often do go into young offenders at some point after they leave. The funding just is not there to provide a therapeutic setting as well as an educational one. It’s a mess.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 12:52

For those not familiar; SLANT stands for

Sit up
Listen
Ask and answer questions
Nod your head (active listening)
Track (look at) the speaker

I know that people are picturing this as very robotic and dystopian but surely that's how most polite people behave in any meeting, or setting when information is being explained. I don't see what is so wrong about that. Isn't it basic social ettiquette?

If a majority of NT students are doing this in a classroom, then a couple of ND children who find one or more of those behaviours difficult is more manageable. I doubt that a whole room of children with heads on the desk, staring out the window, fiddling with pens, rummaging in bags and paying no attention to the teacher is comfortable for ND children either.

goldfootball · 25/03/2023 12:47

My experience of this is that although in theory schools can have a strict behaviour policy and adapt it for children with SEND in practice they don’t. I think there’s an indirect effect in that you don’t meet that many teachers who can be mainstream-y, behaviourist approach advocates and trauma informed, send specialists. They don’t have to be mutually exclusive mindsets but ime they are generally distinct approaches. The teachers I met who could do both are now mostly retired.

Also I worked as a TA in a school a bit like this and behaviour was good but the pupils with SEND were overall learning absolutely fuck all but because they were sitting quietly no one was interested. It was a disgrace tbh but the exam results were good overall so… 🤷🏻‍♀️

mixedrecycling · 25/03/2023 12:27

Littlecamellia · 25/03/2023 12:01

How has your daughter got PTSD? Isn't that post traumatic stress disorder? It seems unusual for a child to have it. Who has diagnosed her with it?

From her birth family. Do I need to go into details about how a child can have PTSD by the age of 3?

Diagnosed by CAMHS

Seashor · 25/03/2023 12:16

These schools are calm, organised places. Expectations are high and adhered to. The teacher’s focus is on teaching and learning not behaviour management.

Drifta · 25/03/2023 12:02

Zerotolerancetofun · 25/03/2023 10:42

@MichelleScarn they get detentions or isolation for bad behaviour. What I meant really was that a child who is generally well behaved can get a detention for a mistake such as forgetting their pe kit or loosing something. That is the sort of thing that will worry my DD.

Worry her? Ok, lots of kids are anxious, and/or perfectionists. The question is how you approach this, what YOU do to help her deal with that. One option is to avoid the school. Others are:

  • With DC1 we worked with her to lose the fear of detentions. At her school you can get one for a forgotten ruler or homework. It was going to happen at some point. Decatastrophise. We set her a joke challenge of getting a detention as an essential teenage experience. So when she did, she could join in with the joke of achieving this "goal". She has learned a lot about perspective. It's healthy to learn to handle these small bumps in the road without self flagellating.
  • With DC2 it's totally different. At both his secondary schools he has simply been excused from all detentions. This is a thing. School know he is doing his best.
  • DC2's school is very strict with detentions but it goes alongside a narrative of "you'll make mistakes, everyone does. Here we take responsibility for our mistakes and move on from them". Again, decatastrophising. Getting a detention does not make them a horrible person or a failure.

It really isn't as simple as "my child can't cope with detention therefore this school will be awful for them." You just need to find a way forward so that they can cope and thrive. And that starts IMO with talking to the staff to find out more about the culture and implementation of the policies in practice.

Littlecamellia · 25/03/2023 12:01

mixedrecycling · 25/03/2023 11:51

Yes, DD once got the punishment for being 'disrespectful to an adult' because she shut down and was unable to defend herself for not turning to the right page in a book. I had already told the (primary school) teacher that DD has PTSD and will freeze in a confrontational situation.

The teacher, exasperated, asked 'why didn't you turn to the right page' and DD froze.

It was the same punishment that children would have received for swearing at a teacher or getting into a physical fight.

When challenged by me in a meeting that involved the HoY, the teacher said that they didn't know what else to do as DD was 'incapable' of following instructions and they were so frustrated.

The children that couldn't conform to this inadequate teacher's need were labelled as 'disrespectful' and bullied out of the school

How has your daughter got PTSD? Isn't that post traumatic stress disorder? It seems unusual for a child to have it. Who has diagnosed her with it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread