Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Zero tolerance schools and slant techniques for send - good, okay or terrible

283 replies

Zerotolerancetofun · 24/03/2023 23:46

Dd is starting secondary next year. The school has a zero tolerance behaviour policy so very strict about everything (uniform, homework, behaviour etc). They are also bringing in this new teaching technique called slant that the kids are meant to follow - about how they sit/pay attention/look at the teachers - it sounds very Draconian.

Dd has ASD and significant levels of anxiety and I am concerned how this environment will work for her. I think she will be terrified of making a mistake and getting detention for minor mistakes, but of course if this approach stops bullying etc then that is a good thing for her.

I'd love to know how other people's DC have got on with this type of school. Particularly if they have ASD, but also NT children too.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CoffeeWithCheese · 25/03/2023 16:32

Think it depends on the way their neurodiversity is wired. For DD2, with Autism, inattentive ADHD and other issues - it would be an utter and unmitigated disaster. We learnt during the pandemic when she was taught by a teacher who absolutely did not feel schools should ever have reopened and implemented so many rules of that kind in her class regarding never moving from seats, never not looking forward etc - that all that she learnt over the course of that awful year was that she spent the entire year worrying about remembering all the rules and not breaking them... to the point that she (she has continence issues) wouldn't even dare ask to go to the toilet which she had agreed permission to do, and would end up sat in her own shit for days on end. She would fall apart emotionally every night with the cumulative strain of having to follow all these incredibly controlling rules and her desperation to please the staff (who never ever praised her at all) and it absolutely shredded her mental health. It's taken that lost year of learning, most of last year where she had to re-learn how to behave well but not in a terrified manner, and we're only getting back on track this year really.

So much so that we're adamant there is no way she's going to the local "outstanding" secondary that behaves this way (but also has a raging bullying problem).

She also is a fidget, and really struggles with eye contact - but from nursery age (apart from the awful period) she has had teachers who have rapidly understood that she is listening to absolutely every fucking word going... SLANT school and I can guarantee that all would be going in from lesson content would be an internal monologue of "oooh there's a noise up there... can't look to see what it is... I need to look at Miss... need to be looking at Miss... my foot feels funny... can't move to wiggle it... need to be looking at Miss and following the rules right... Mr S says we have to do SLANT all the time... I've kept looking at Miss now..." and all the lesson content will be in a circling pattern somewhere miles away from DD2's brain.

Think it's fucking abusive to be honest - but society seems to be determined to go back to trying to lock ND kids away as dunces and demonise them and a sector on MN seem to be gleefully cheering them on.

MichelleScarn · 25/03/2023 15:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh behave, when you start with the ridiculous hyperbole like this @Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie it just makes no sense. Not a single person has used horrible discriminatory language like this. Unless you think we shouldn't be talking about how different ways of learning work for different people?

PoorOldHorse · 25/03/2023 15:41

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie, your analogy of car-parks is pretty feeble. Try teaching a class where half the students are EHCP or have serious learning challenges - as I do, every day, in an FE college - and you'd soon see how facile it is.

And your discriminatory language disgusts me. I've reported your post.

Busybody2022 · 25/03/2023 15:35

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 15:14

@Busybody2022

I see schools that have a ridiculously high percentage of SEN/SEMH students as being discriminative, particularly when they have low expectations for behaviour. My NT, academic child wants to learn free from constant disruptions.

My heart bleeds for children with the privilege of not having additional needs having those with additional needs in their lives. It is also a very good life skill to learn to work despite distractions. It is a vital life skill to learn empathy and compassion.

Florenz · 25/03/2023 15:27

Schools waste too much time pandering to the needs of individual students. Employers aren't going to want to do this, it's up to workers to adapt and fit in with the companies needs, not the other way round.

At the end of the day, let SLANT schools and other schools compete, see which ones come out best, which one produces successful school leavers and let parents make their choice. It will all work out in the end. There's no need to talk about banning schools that expect children to behave professionally.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 25/03/2023 15:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

saraclara · 25/03/2023 15:19

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 14:51

No, @saraclara but i'm sure they understood the social etiquette of the situation, which sounds pretty informal. Maybe you have other meetings, or courses where there would be different expectations and would adjust accordingly.

Quite the opposite. One was a formal quarterly board meeting, the other was a sub group addressing a serious issue.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 15:14

@Busybody2022

I see schools that have a ridiculously high percentage of SEN/SEMH students as being discriminative, particularly when they have low expectations for behaviour. My NT, academic child wants to learn free from constant disruptions.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 15:03

I've said consistently, that this helps students with SEN because:

  1. Non SEN students have clear expectations and are not misbehaving. The teacher is not wasting any of his or her time dealing with their misbehaviour. The focus is on a lovely, calm learning environment.

  2. Because the other children are getting on nicely, the teacher has greater capacity to be mindful of and get to spend extra time with SEN students not on constantly 'policing' the room. Seating plans can be made with their specific needs in mind, not built around keeping disruptove students separated. This benefits SEN students. The reduction in distractions also helps SEN students.

  3. ND students can be exempt from some or all of the SLANT expectations within an orderly context. Most students are actually really understanding of SEN and why some students have adjustments. Maybe it's enough that a particular student is able to remain seated.

Busybody2022 · 25/03/2023 14:55

I have an autistic/adhd DD. She would love a zero tolerance, quiet and predictable environment.

She wouldn't cope with SLANT and I see SLANT as highly discriminatory against neurodivergent individuals.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 14:51

No, @saraclara but i'm sure they understood the social etiquette of the situation, which sounds pretty informal. Maybe you have other meetings, or courses where there would be different expectations and would adjust accordingly.

saraclara · 25/03/2023 14:43

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 13:40

@EpicBanana

That's what I mean about the exaggeration that this means having ramrod straight backs, frozen stillness and eyes boring into the very soul of the teacher.

It doesn't.

This idea is precisely to tackle children who: lounge across the desk, randomly get out of their seat to put something in the bin, rummage endlessly in their bag, crinkle their plastic bottle and pick the label off, doodle all over their hands and exercise books, take their pens to bits, pull faces at other people, pass notes, whisper and giggle and talk over the speaker.

Would YOU want to sit next to that person in your next meeting? Wouldn't you be distracted by them?

I was in a meeting where people were eating the other evening. And in a virtual meeting where other participants had their cameras off and could be doing anything. One answered their phone. Others were (reasonably) making notes, but missed information while doing so.

Hardly even close to SLANT.

EpicBanana · 25/03/2023 14:38

@PetitPorpoise I'm not trying to ban it. But the OP was asking about it specifically in the context of SEN and I was answering in that context. You sound like you'd be fairly reasonable about it, but your approach still wouldn't work for my child because she probably wouldn't be looking at you when you happened to look at her. She would be participating and have her hand up to answer every question though. So maybe you'd make an exception, I don't know. But even if you did, can I guarantee that every teacher in that school would? No. So in the context the OP asked, I would not send my child to a school that was using SLANT.

Other parents can make other decisions. The difficulty comes when there is no choice, as the OP is concerned about, because every school is run by the same academy with the same approach. I'd hope that parents have a choice so those of us with children who can't learn in that sort of environment have another option.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 25/03/2023 14:37

I think I'd try it out and fact find before I made any conclusions.

My daughter has ADHD, ASD and hypermobility. She struggles to sit still and sit upright in a normal position because it's a stress position for her. Rather than relying on the limit of her range of movement to keep her upright it is literally a stress position.

HOWEVER, the ensuing calm classrooms and engaged learning style would be a huge benefit as there would be fewer distractions. Her attention span is really low, if she is not interested she can focus for about 10-15 seconds before her attention wanders. No amount of sanctions will change that. She is working 3 times as hard as the rest of her class to achieve half the result. So much of her mental energy would be spent staying still and upright.

I can only assume that she'd benefit from the outcome but struggle with the methods to get there.

Have you got any local Facebook groups where you can ask other parents of SEN children what their recent experiences of the school have been? You could also contact the school's SENCO to ask how they handle additional needs in the environment without damaging self esteem or mental health. Their response will probably be very telling! If they put tools in place in the classroom to give movement breaks, wobble cushions, weighted blankets, that sort of thing then I'd be all for it. If they are of the "if you fuck up it's a sanction" mindset I'd look elsewhere.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 14:35

If you’re letting someone doodle, you haven’t got a leg to stand on when you insist on someone else who’s vacantly staring out the window to fix up and listen. They’ll happily tell you their friends are sitting there doodling and also not listening (according to them). Kids are smart, smart as fuck. They know fine well what they can and cannot get away with, and often that starts with the same rules for all. They hate what they perceive to be any sort of injustice.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 14:31

@EpicBanana

The opposite can be very chaotic actually judging from the schools around me, and also the ones I’ve worked in. SLANT is a simplistic method that usually sets the tone for the whole behavioural management system of the school. Parents know before applying that there will be high expectations for all behaviour.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 14:28

I'm sure there are other similar approaches but lots of people like this one for it's simplicity. You can demonstrate what "good sitting" looks like when the children join the school. I wouldn't say anything to a child who was looking at me or the board pretty much everytime I looked at them. If they were looking around the room in an attempt to distract others, or staring vacantly into space and then couldn't answer any questions, then that would be a problem.

All teachers want students to learn. Cutting out low level disruption is a really good way to enable more actual teaching and learning to take place.

Do you teach yourself, and if so, what age group?

EpicBanana · 25/03/2023 14:18

The opposite of SLANT isn't chaos though, is it @PetitPorpoise? So if we are over exaggerating the tracking you are not allowing for the fact that other approaches can also work. And exactly how much tracking is enough then? What posture is sitting up straight enough? Because it doesn't actually sound that clear what the rules are if there is some slack to the slant.

And I still don't see why someone quietly doodling is a distraction for another person. Give the doodling kid a spare piece of paper and let them get on with it if it is helping them concentrate on the words that are being said. I'd rather have kids who are actually learning then giving an impression of it.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 14:09

@EpicBanana in my scenario you're surrounded by room full of people, most of whom are doing some of these behaviours for most of the time the person is speaking.

Yes, a teacher can intervene and give a quick reminder or cross the room to remove an item that someone is fiddling with. But every minute or so? It would (does) get annoying very quickly.

You repeating the exaggeration that ones eyes must not flicker from the teacher is unfair and not what this is about.

All SLANT is, is being really explicit about what the expectation is. It's more explicit than "you need to behave" or "stop messing about". As @goldfootball says, a surprising number of children don't know what that actually means.

The method advises using a phrase like "check your SLANT" with maybe a visual poster in the room rather than endlessly saying "Jimmy, put that down, Jonny, look at me, please, Jenny, now is not the time to be brushing our hair."

Great if doodling all over her hands helps your daughter, but it might be distracting for the people sitting next to her. Great that you wouldn't be bothered by someone slouching face down on the desk when you're trying to tell them something important, but if I was that person's boss, I'd find that pretty rude. It's not always about the individual.

Winter41 · 25/03/2023 14:07

My sons school has a strict behaviour policy and uses slant. He hasn't found a problem with it though he doesn't have any additional needs. It suits him as he is is a rule follower and keeps the classroom environment orderly. By contrast, I know someone at a school with a more lax approach. Behaviour is horrendous and in some lessons no learning takes place. My son would find this much more stressful.

He gets the odd warning for chatting but has never had a behaviour detention as most ofnthr expectations are reasonable. He had had one detention for forgetting equipments (he has forgotten equipment including books and PE kit several times and has managed to blag it by borrowing odds and ends from.friends!) and said it was fine. Just sat in a room and got his hwk done and had a chat with the teacher.

I am not saying zero tolerance is for everyone, but i think it is important to remember that detentions aren't the end of the world. A bit boring perhaps , but nothing horrendous or traumatising is happening to the kids whilst in them.

It depends what your options are but I would chose a perhaps unnecessarily strict school over a chaotic one. I work in schools and when behaviour policies haven't been well enforced an awful lot of kids are getting their time wasted in lessons and would likely be feeling quite intimidated to boot.

WhatNoRaisins · 25/03/2023 14:06

I don't think I could cope with SLANT as an adult. At 11 it would have made me really nervous, I'd worry I wasn't nodding the right amount of times or something. Doubt I'd take much in while focusing on all that.

Chilloutsnow · 25/03/2023 14:03

@EpicBanana

Yep they’ll be doing pretty much all of them in some chaotic schools. Doodling is quite frankly the least of some schools concerns.

Round here parents must be all for it because my sons school is heavily over subscribed at a ratio of around 8 applications to 1 place. You can easily get into the other schools.

EpicBanana · 25/03/2023 13:45

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 13:40

@EpicBanana

That's what I mean about the exaggeration that this means having ramrod straight backs, frozen stillness and eyes boring into the very soul of the teacher.

It doesn't.

This idea is precisely to tackle children who: lounge across the desk, randomly get out of their seat to put something in the bin, rummage endlessly in their bag, crinkle their plastic bottle and pick the label off, doodle all over their hands and exercise books, take their pens to bits, pull faces at other people, pass notes, whisper and giggle and talk over the speaker.

Would YOU want to sit next to that person in your next meeting? Wouldn't you be distracted by them?

Are they doing all those things or just some? I don't care if someone is doodling. Doodling helps loads of people concentrate. My child has drawings all over her hand and is still the one who has her hand up to answer every question. I don't really care about lounging across the desk either. And you can tackle the getting up and rummaging in your bag without having to use SLANT. That's a "tools out on the desk at the start of the lesson and you don't touch them until the end" rule. It's got nothing to do with sitting up straight and tracking the teacher at all times.

PetitPorpoise · 25/03/2023 13:40

@EpicBanana

That's what I mean about the exaggeration that this means having ramrod straight backs, frozen stillness and eyes boring into the very soul of the teacher.

It doesn't.

This idea is precisely to tackle children who: lounge across the desk, randomly get out of their seat to put something in the bin, rummage endlessly in their bag, crinkle their plastic bottle and pick the label off, doodle all over their hands and exercise books, take their pens to bits, pull faces at other people, pass notes, whisper and giggle and talk over the speaker.

Would YOU want to sit next to that person in your next meeting? Wouldn't you be distracted by them?