Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Zero tolerance schools and slant techniques for send - good, okay or terrible

283 replies

Zerotolerancetofun · 24/03/2023 23:46

Dd is starting secondary next year. The school has a zero tolerance behaviour policy so very strict about everything (uniform, homework, behaviour etc). They are also bringing in this new teaching technique called slant that the kids are meant to follow - about how they sit/pay attention/look at the teachers - it sounds very Draconian.

Dd has ASD and significant levels of anxiety and I am concerned how this environment will work for her. I think she will be terrified of making a mistake and getting detention for minor mistakes, but of course if this approach stops bullying etc then that is a good thing for her.

I'd love to know how other people's DC have got on with this type of school. Particularly if they have ASD, but also NT children too.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CryHavok · 26/03/2023 16:34

cansu · 26/03/2023 16:24

The funny thing CryHavok is that I have two children with asd for whom I have advocated for the last twenty odd years. In all that time I can only think of one time I complained and that was nothing to do with a sanction. I don't know enough about SLANT to have an opinion on this but I do know that many kids' education is blighted by the poor behaviour of others. I know that there are many kids whose parents are themselves aggressive and confrontational. They turn up at schools shouting or ring up swearing. They often sound very like you. They think they are standing up for their kids but are often actually harming their kids through inadequate parenting.

Well, you would be wrong. I’m very courteous. But I don’t allow myself to be fobbed off.

However, the modern snowflake HT often takes this as being abusive, so as everyone at my son’s school is aware, I record all my phone calls and everything is backed up by email.

cansu · 26/03/2023 16:24

The funny thing CryHavok is that I have two children with asd for whom I have advocated for the last twenty odd years. In all that time I can only think of one time I complained and that was nothing to do with a sanction. I don't know enough about SLANT to have an opinion on this but I do know that many kids' education is blighted by the poor behaviour of others. I know that there are many kids whose parents are themselves aggressive and confrontational. They turn up at schools shouting or ring up swearing. They often sound very like you. They think they are standing up for their kids but are often actually harming their kids through inadequate parenting.

ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 26/03/2023 16:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

miniaturepixieonacid · 26/03/2023 15:56

I just watched the documentary and think it seems like a great school. Not inclusive of all, by any means, but I wouldn't call it discriminatory because it will be a full range of children that it suits and doesn't suit. Some children with AN would love it and thrive there, others would not be able to cope and would hate it. Some children without AN would love it and thrive there and others would not be able to cope and would hate it. The key thing is choice in state education, just like parents in private education have. I work in a private prep school and had never experienced private education before. I went to a decidely below average comprehensive. I was astounded by early conversations with parents about which senior school 'suited' their child and what the right 'match' for their child would be. I'd only ever experienced, 'this is your catchment secondary, everyone goes to it'. I thought it was ridiculous to put so much time and effort into choosing between characteristics of individual schools. But now it's natural to me and I think all parents deserve that choice. Michaela style schools should be available to those who want them and they shouldn't have to be apologetic about not suiting every child. But only if other types of school are also available to all children as a choice. And it doesn't sound like that's the case.

I would have adored a school like Michaela. I was bullied for doing well in lessons and eventually stopped putting my hand up and joining in because it just caused trouble for me. Even Slant would have been a good thing for me because, although I was not disruptive, I find active listening very hard and end up in fairy tale la la land in 2 minutes flat given half a chance. Watching someone's face and giving visible indiciations that I'm listening helps me stay present in a conversation and be able to learn.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 15:51

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 15:39

You are. I’ve felt similar once about a previous primary school so I took real action and removed my child. The issues were systemic, I haven’t got time to be whinging about things such as uniform. I quickly changed my child’s environment and moved forward.

The secondary choices I have are:

The really bloody brilliant LEA school (I posted about this one previously) which is so oversubscribed that I couldn’t get my kid into it, I keep checking in to see if any spaces have come up but they haven’t.

The current Academy that my young ‘un is in, another secondary school in the same MAT which is run in the same way.

There is a recently opened academy, ran by someone that self styles themselves as my city’s strictest head teacher (vom), but only has year 7 and 8, mine is year 9.

What choices do I have? I’m not the only one that feels like this. We’ve literally had academies foisted on us (like everyone else in England).

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 15:39

You are. I’ve felt similar once about a previous primary school so I took real action and removed my child. The issues were systemic, I haven’t got time to be whinging about things such as uniform. I quickly changed my child’s environment and moved forward.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 15:38

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:47

A lot of employers, some in the private sector and a lot in the public sector will pretend to listen to your views and then quietly just tick the box.

No stereotyping here I’m afraid, just realism. You can move you child. Even schools under the same umberella are different. Well they are in my locality. Schools within the same trust are all different depending on their leadership, demographic intakes etc. Parents have much more say than they do in private schools.

If you had an issue with the uniform fair play for raising it but expecting the head to leave over it, is a bit silly.

I’ve had employers like that myself, when it became clear that nothing was going to change I found another job, with a pay rise, handed in my notice and told them exactly why in my exit interview. Luckily I had a variety of unconnected organisations in my area to choose from. I’m now with a much better employer. Families in areas that have been lumbered with Scrotemax MAT or what ever don’t have that luxury.

I noticed your dig implying that I was in a low skilled job. I’m actually a professional and am handsomely rewarded for what I do.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 15:31

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 15:20

@CryHavok

Hostile? Do you usually catastrophically describe places? It’s school. It isn’t actually a prison. Lots and I mean lots of children cope just fine.

So I’m not allowed to advocate on my child because some parents are fine with it? The school in question actively looks for things to catch children out on. It’s not a nice environment. And I’m allowed to say that.

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 15:20

@CryHavok

Hostile? Do you usually catastrophically describe places? It’s school. It isn’t actually a prison. Lots and I mean lots of children cope just fine.

cyclamenqueen · 26/03/2023 14:54

I do think it’s worth remembering that this thread is about children with additional needs not badly behaved children . It’s interesting and sad that some people on this thread basically think they are one and the same

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 14:53

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:49

@CryHavok

Well I’m with you there. I’ve enjoyed many a demise of certain SLT, however I still wouldn’t blindly believe what my year 8 son ever had to tell me about his school life and I’ve got better things to do with my life and time than nit picking over every single decision that the school makes. Yes I am on my child’s side but ultimately my child does have to conform to their rules if he is to stay and progress at his school. So yes it’s a case of don’t like it, lump it cos they sure as hell ain’t gonna please even parent or child.

Ultimately my child is entitled to an education, so I’m not going to tolerate a hostile environment.

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:49

@CryHavok

Well I’m with you there. I’ve enjoyed many a demise of certain SLT, however I still wouldn’t blindly believe what my year 8 son ever had to tell me about his school life and I’ve got better things to do with my life and time than nit picking over every single decision that the school makes. Yes I am on my child’s side but ultimately my child does have to conform to their rules if he is to stay and progress at his school. So yes it’s a case of don’t like it, lump it cos they sure as hell ain’t gonna please even parent or child.

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:47

A lot of employers, some in the private sector and a lot in the public sector will pretend to listen to your views and then quietly just tick the box.

No stereotyping here I’m afraid, just realism. You can move you child. Even schools under the same umberella are different. Well they are in my locality. Schools within the same trust are all different depending on their leadership, demographic intakes etc. Parents have much more say than they do in private schools.

If you had an issue with the uniform fair play for raising it but expecting the head to leave over it, is a bit silly.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 14:46

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:38

@CryHavok

We have no idea as individuals his level of resilience but you’re not coming across too hot yourself trying to break a head to the extent that he would like to leave because you didn’t like the polyester uniform. It’s a bit sad really. Being resilient, and being able to reflect on your day to day working life are actually two different concept. Things go wrong all the time and the shit hits the fan, it’s how you reflect and move forward that models true human resilience.

This particular head is all about “no excuses” until it’s him that fucks up. He’s driven several parents to off-roll their kids so I hope you’ll forgive me for enjoying him getting a taste of his own medicine.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 14:44

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 13:33

@CryHavok

Actually I think plenty of workplaces have quite ridiculous rules, regulations, ridiculous policies, red tape and plenty of other annoying and pointless shite depending on the sector. The helicopter parents are flying high on this thread I see. ❄️

Its really interesting that you and @Florenz resort to stereotypes when arguing with people you disagree with.

You are correct that employers can have nonsensical policies, however, people can ultimately move employer. Most of the employers I have are aware of this and are receptive to their staff coming up with ways of improving. Unlike schools which will spuriously argue that parents who “don’t like” their rules are “free to move their children elsewhere” despite every school nearby being part of the same MAT.

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:38

@CryHavok

We have no idea as individuals his level of resilience but you’re not coming across too hot yourself trying to break a head to the extent that he would like to leave because you didn’t like the polyester uniform. It’s a bit sad really. Being resilient, and being able to reflect on your day to day working life are actually two different concept. Things go wrong all the time and the shit hits the fan, it’s how you reflect and move forward that models true human resilience.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 14:35

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:31

@CryHavok

So he lost his shit, had a tantrum and you expect him to quit his prestigious no doubt long-standing career? I mean sure, it sounded like he acted like a bit of an arsehole but throwing the towel in after one incident isn’t resilient. That’s just giving up. Perhaps he can reflect on his behaviour and move forward.

If he had true resilience he would have reflected that maybe the parents had a point and not lost his rag. It was funny though because he argued that his stringent rules were all about helping children develop resilience.

3WildOnes · 26/03/2023 14:34

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 13:33

@CryHavok

Actually I think plenty of workplaces have quite ridiculous rules, regulations, ridiculous policies, red tape and plenty of other annoying and pointless shite depending on the sector. The helicopter parents are flying high on this thread I see. ❄️

Helicopter parents?! This thread was about children with additional needs and how they cope in these super strict schools. Comments like this are so ignorant and discriminatory.

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 14:31

@CryHavok

So he lost his shit, had a tantrum and you expect him to quit his prestigious no doubt long-standing career? I mean sure, it sounded like he acted like a bit of an arsehole but throwing the towel in after one incident isn’t resilient. That’s just giving up. Perhaps he can reflect on his behaviour and move forward.

Needmorelego · 26/03/2023 14:30

@Florenz you do realise that most parents do not have a 'choice' of Secondary school. In 'Average Town England' the choices are basically School A or School B. The OP said her 2 local schools are the same Academy chain. That is not a choice. At all.
Many towns now have no Local Authority run schools. If you don't like the style of a specific academy chain there is no alternative.
In my opinion every town/area should have a LA run school that are true comprehensive schools for every single child whatever their learning methods are.
This doesn't mean no rules and discipline - just treating everyone with respect.

WhatNoRaisins · 26/03/2023 14:07

This won't sound nice but I'd be thinking if a school has to resort to that sort of heavy handed policy it must be a really bad environment. I'd avoid it.

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 14:05

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:50

Parents who don't like SLANT schools have a range of other schools to choose from. If parents don't choose to send their children to SLANT schools, they'll go away. But in fact the opposite is true and they are massively oversubscribed.

That’s simply not true in my experience. In my city the school that is oversubscribed is the one that has minimal school uniform (students can wear anything they want as long as it’s not impractical, revealing, dirty, ripped or emblazoned with anything offensive, there is an optional polo shirt) has common sense rules that promote decency and respect for others, and only give detentions as a last resort. It has excellent GCSE results and behaviour. Parents support it because they are confident their children are being treated fairly. Notably this school is LEA.

Meanwhile, the local academies that do SLANT aren’t nearly as popular, with one offering what amounts to free wrap around care in a bid to attract working parents.

If the market was truly allowed to decide my area would have loads of schools like the former and none like the latter, because that’s what parents want. However, academies are being forced on parents and children by Government.

cyclamenqueen · 26/03/2023 13:53

What about supporting children to come up with the adaptations that work for them. These young people will have to deal with their neurodiversity for life, they need to be supported to be able to function outside the rigid school environment .

It really doesn’t matter how many times you punish a person child with AS for not making eye contact it will not make a difference. It’s the same as punishing someone for having red hair or short sight. Why do people think that terrifying an anxious child will turn them into a functioning fulfilled tax paying member of society .

CryHavok · 26/03/2023 13:50

Chilloutsnow · 26/03/2023 13:48

@CryHavok

Should he have gone back to school cos a couple of parents weren’t too happy about uniform? I should imagine so yes lol.

The tantrum when he realised that no one was going to cough up £50 for cheapo polyester trousers with naff piping down the leg was a site to behold. Was that resilient or?

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:50

Parents who don't like SLANT schools have a range of other schools to choose from. If parents don't choose to send their children to SLANT schools, they'll go away. But in fact the opposite is true and they are massively oversubscribed.