Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents should NOT let primary aged children on messaging/social media?

208 replies

SocialMediaPITA · 24/03/2023 19:31

I'm a primary school teacher in year 6. I spend lots of time having to deal with pupils falling out with each other on messaging apps/social media outside of school hours. They then bring these issues into school the next day, and there are tears, tantrums and, on some occasions, fights. And staff have to give up lunch hours, break time and learning/lesson time to deal with the fall out. Children can't learn if they are brewing on what's happened the night before, eg falling out with their peers.

Why do parents let their children on social media? The min age for WhatsApp is 16 - it's 16 for a reason! Many primary aged children are not emotionally able to deal with issues via messaging - even as adults we can recognise that tone and body language can play a huge part in communicating - social media and messaging removes that important aspect and if we as adults can get it wrong, why do we expect children to be able to deal with it? It's affecting their mental health.

I've mopped too many tears this week and much of it can be avoided.

OP posts:
denpark · 25/03/2023 11:24

tootiredtospeak · 24/03/2023 21:33

What's app is 13 not 16 as is snapchat. I dont disagree with your point it's just not correct.

In the UK it's 16.

Vitriolinsanity · 25/03/2023 11:14

My son's school makes it clear that it will not engage in disputes that happen outside school where the SM is higher age than the child in question.

JustKeepSwimmingJust · 25/03/2023 10:56

DS got a basic phone just before he started walking to/from school alone in y5. I was always very clear that he should always have it in his pocket and I was happy to replace if there was an accident. After one incident where the phone did break, and I cheerfully said “never mind, it didn’t cost much so I’ll get you a new one” he was glad that he wasn’t in trouble for breaking an expensive smart phone. Since then he’s happily stuck to just texting: doesn’t even want a smart phone for 11th birthday.

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 10:56

I agree completely. It's appalling that schools expect and rely on children having smart phones
I agree too.
I don't think schools should expect students to have certain apps and anything digital should be able to be accessed on a family or parent device (eg laptop or computer or if needed web browser on a phone)

I understand why some schools have got homework apps though. Huge amounts of time is lost when students don't write their homework, don't do it, then parents call school complaining that nobody told Tommy he had homework so he won't be doing the detention.

FranticHare · 25/03/2023 10:50

And I should say - parents should be all over how the phone is being used and aware what’s going on and helping the child navigate social situations, just as they were when their child as a toddler went to a play group. There is no excuse not to.

FranticHare · 25/03/2023 10:38

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 10:13

@FranticHare but having a phone to text and call parents is one thing - that I feel is acceptable use of a phone and you can use a bog standard phone for that. Allowing them access to WhatsApp or other social media and use it to create and carry on drama with it is another.

I wish I could say to parents, "you allowed access, so you deal with it!" In year 6 there are whole class groups and the behaviour from some on there is like it's a bun fight, everyone pitching in. As a teacher we don't allow children to play at break and lunch unsupervised and for good reason, because they need support when things go wrong. We deal with it then, I don't feel parents would like it if we handed them back an upset child telling them to sort it. But that's what a lot of parents are asking us to do, for choices parents are making.

But it’s just the start. In my eldest class, I’d say a third of parents were split by yr 4. That’s 10 kids with mobile phones. It’s not difficult to see how Bob and Sam are best mates and share their numbers - where’s the harm in that? Then Chis wants to join, and then harry - and suddenly why don’t the kids use Whatsapp - that’s easier than using text messages for the 4 of them isn’t it?

Then those kids are putting pressure on their class mates - and also parents are passing around comment in the playground how poor Evan can’t join in cos his poor parents haven’t got him a phone yet…. Of course you shouldn’t give in to peer pressure - but we’ve all done it one way or another.

Then it’s the knowledge they need to have a phone for yr 7, and know how to use it, so they need a phone by yr6 so they are ready for secondary.

it all adds up to a headache for yr 6 teachers!

MissDollyMix · 25/03/2023 10:14

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 10:03

Wow @MissDollyMix I can't believe a school would leave themselves open to encouraging pupils to break terms of service like that.

I’m not sure what you mean… I’m not talking about WhatsApp!

Saltywalruss · 25/03/2023 10:14

Perhaps if schools weren’t relying on it, it would be easier to hold back

I agree completely. It's appalling that schools expect and rely on children having smart phones.

In addition to all the other issues already mentioned there' s also a problem with this from a money point of view. School is meant to be free! Of course parents have always had to provide uniform, calculators etc but smart phones ( and the cost of running them) is in a different league!

In the "olden days" schools would never have asked parents to buy their children a porn magazine because it had a good educational supplement, would they?

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 10:13

@FranticHare but having a phone to text and call parents is one thing - that I feel is acceptable use of a phone and you can use a bog standard phone for that. Allowing them access to WhatsApp or other social media and use it to create and carry on drama with it is another.

I wish I could say to parents, "you allowed access, so you deal with it!" In year 6 there are whole class groups and the behaviour from some on there is like it's a bun fight, everyone pitching in. As a teacher we don't allow children to play at break and lunch unsupervised and for good reason, because they need support when things go wrong. We deal with it then, I don't feel parents would like it if we handed them back an upset child telling them to sort it. But that's what a lot of parents are asking us to do, for choices parents are making.

OP posts:
cassgate · 25/03/2023 10:11

I am a year 6 TA and agree. I have spent most of this week trying to deal with an issue that occurred last weekend. Still not resolved as the girls refuse to accept responsibility for anything they have done. I also found out that a group of girls in my class saw me out shopping last weekend and took pictures of me and posted them on the class group chat. The girls told me themselves what they had done and had no concept that this was unacceptable behaviour. This is what happens when children are given technology that they are not mature enough to handle.

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 10:03

Wow @MissDollyMix I can't believe a school would leave themselves open to encouraging pupils to break terms of service like that.

OP posts:
DeadButDelicious · 25/03/2023 09:58

I agree with you OP. My DD is in year one and there are 5 and 6 year olds with their own mobile phones, like it's a completely normal thing, to be fair they are mostly FaceTime-ing grandparents/cousins/close school friends or watching youtube kids but the fact that at such a young age they are being given such a device at all worries me. It's one thing using my phone to FaceTime a mate when one of them has been off sick and they miss each other when I'm sat next to her and can monitor the call, it's quite another for a child to have their very own iPhone.

If I could get away with giving DD a basic Nokia when the time comes she needs one then I would. It's such a minefield. Kids can be mean and I don't want her to be singled out, I know how that feels. But I will definitely be very firm on social media. No games consoles in rooms, laptops will be as locked down as possible. There are enough adults who can't handle it, never mind expecting kids to reign themselves in.

I will also be instilling the idea that she only give her number to the people she wants to have it. Obviously that doesn't stop others giving it out so I will also be stressing how you shouldn't just hand out other peoples numbers as well. When I think about how badly bullied at school I was and how much worse it would have been if they had had a number to contact me outside of school
as well I don't think getting her onboard with the idea that she can choose who she allows to contact her is a terrible idea.

FranticHare · 25/03/2023 09:52

But the days of playing out won’t come back. Due to a few horrendous and well published events, there are perceived threats around every corner. Plus huge increase in traffic.

The world has moved on, and unfortunately it is geared towards tech. Like a previous poster, my eldest was allowed a phone for the last term of yr6 to get used to it and collect numbers of friends etc before moving off to secondary school. She was of an age where I could help her start to navigate the minefield of social media (WhatsApp) before yr 7.

I’m glad we did - we navigated some drama together, which has given her the tools of dealing with stuff going forwards. Also, secondary school seem to rely on the kids having online access on their phones for numerous things - school email, notifications, homework. Perhaps if schools weren’t relying on it, it would be easier to hold back.

At our primary school, the kids who had phones earlier (yr 3 or 4) where often from families where the parents weren’t together. It was initially at least a way of the child talking to whichever parent they weren’t with at the time.

From our limited experience, the kids that are going to cause drama, will cause drama however they can. Remove phones, and they’ll find another way.

Tiredmum100 · 25/03/2023 09:48

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 09:31

For every parent saying their primary aged children are responsible and all has been ok on it, there are children that are not.

And it's specifically issues that are happening online, therefore outside of school, not being dealt with by parents themselves but instead passed to the school to deal with. Every week, sometimes more than that, we have parents tell us other children are bullying, name calling, arguing online, and then expect the staff to deal with the fall out. If parents are choosing to allow their children on social media underage, then surely they should take that responsibility on, not leave it to school?

If you suggest the child come off social media the parents insist that it's not their child that's the problem, but fail to see how allowing them underage access exposes them to just this kind of unhealthy interaction. Children this age are still learning how to communicate effectively and need to read body language and facial expressions to help them get it right. Messaging doesn't allow for that.

I wish the days that kids did play out after school could come back, it really did help their emotional development.

I posted earlier on in your thread OP. I agree, I believe as a parent its my responsibility if I give my year 6 child access to these apps not the schools. My son has no apps, and he's not having them any time soon. I think it's unfair on teachers being left to deal with this during school time. I want my child to be learning in school, not having to wait so the teacher can sort out arguments from the night before.

He was playing fortnite with some dc from his class once, that turned in to a bit of a nightmare, where certain people were doing things to annoy him, kicking him off the game/ or making a loud explosion or something, not sure what really. He was getting upset so he came off it. I was cross, home is his safe place, and I feel once things start going wrong online, home doesn't feel so safe either. Technology can be great for young children, but it does need to be monitored by adults!

MissDollyMix · 25/03/2023 09:47

SocialMediaPITA · 24/03/2023 22:36

Does the local High School ask the pupils to download social media apps that are age restricted? (Because it sounds from your post that it's an age appropriate app they school have asked them to download in order to access their learning. And those interactions are monitored by the school.)

Yes. I have no issue with this particular app or the school asking the children to use their phones for school work. I was pointing out to the poster who said that kids didn’t need smart phones until they were 16 that that’s an unrealistic expectation.

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 09:31

For every parent saying their primary aged children are responsible and all has been ok on it, there are children that are not.

And it's specifically issues that are happening online, therefore outside of school, not being dealt with by parents themselves but instead passed to the school to deal with. Every week, sometimes more than that, we have parents tell us other children are bullying, name calling, arguing online, and then expect the staff to deal with the fall out. If parents are choosing to allow their children on social media underage, then surely they should take that responsibility on, not leave it to school?

If you suggest the child come off social media the parents insist that it's not their child that's the problem, but fail to see how allowing them underage access exposes them to just this kind of unhealthy interaction. Children this age are still learning how to communicate effectively and need to read body language and facial expressions to help them get it right. Messaging doesn't allow for that.

I wish the days that kids did play out after school could come back, it really did help their emotional development.

OP posts:
DanceMonster · 25/03/2023 09:27

I don’t understand why WhatsApp is needed for them to text individual friends, if that’s all you’re letting them do?

Itstarts · 25/03/2023 09:18

UndertheCedartree · 25/03/2023 08:55

Do you not ever make your own decisions around parenting? I've let her watch a 12 film that was appropriate for her, but there may be a PG I wouldn't let her watch. All children are different and things aren't black and white. I don't have an issue with her phoning or messaging a friend (WhatsApp) but I do have an issue with her posting photos etc. for other people to judge.

Then let her text a friend.

WhatsApp is 16+ because of group messaging and the potential for bullying, ability to delete messages to cover it up.
Sharing photos, videos is the main feature of WhatsApp so your reasoning is illogical.
One of the worst WhatsApp problems I've had to deal with this year was a child sharing porn videos (he'd been sent from older brother).

I can almost guarantee that if you let your child use WhatsApp in primary school they will be exposed to porn and cyberbullying. Maybe just as a bystanders rather than directly, but they will. If you're happy with that...

Ignorify · 25/03/2023 09:14

I get why people don’t supervise or set up appropriate controls. It’s taken me and tech savvy DH ages to get it set up, and lots of fiddling around to make simple things work, as the Apple controls don’t interact well with the net nanny software. And every time we think it’s sorted, there’s some other problem to solve (eg suddenly an app she needs for school doesn’t work on the private VPN) which takes a frustrating evening of googling and trying different settings to sort out.

I took a hard line on phone use compared to other parents I know, including no web browser or WhatsApp at primary school age (just calling friends in her address book, texting and location finding, as she was walking to school by herself). But for secondary, where a phone is needed for the commute and because all social event arranging is done via WhatsApp, it’s much harder.

I could (but won’t, it would be damaging to her ability to do homework and contact her train friends) go down the no phone / dumb phone route. Or I could make my life much easier and just hand her a fully internet enabled smartphone and leave her to it. Actually supervising, putting in controls, debugging the resultant problems, keeping on top of who she’s in chats with etc is quite time consuming.

Teatime55 · 25/03/2023 09:07

I allowed DD to use my messenger in year 6 because we went into lockdown. So she could message her friends and they played online games together etc.
We still had grief though and we had to block one girl as she started to become very controlling of DD and when she wouldn’t do what she wanted, so started group chats calling her names. The whole thing was ridiculous and I can’t believe people can be bothered with the grief.
We went to a party when DD was in year 4 and the girl got an iPhone and the mum started complaining no one else hands phone for her to message people on.

UndertheCedartree · 25/03/2023 09:04

fairywhale · 25/03/2023 06:40

Roblox and Fortnite aren't suitable either as they are 13+. Why don't you just let your kids play in real life and be kids, it's better for their development? Presumably for an easier life for yourself? Kids are saturated with media consumption and online gaming and other lazy, dumbing stuff, and then parents say when the kids is 6 or 7, oh they don't play any more. No shit, they have no imagination, ability or interest, all destroyed by this media consumption since almost birth.

Roblox is from 7 with automatic restrictions if under 13. My DD plays it sometimes. I don't let her play it for an easier life (not sure what is easier for me by her playing it?) I let her play it because it is fun. It doesn't mean she doesn't play in real life. She is almost 11 and still plays with her toys and has a great imagination.

UndertheCedartree · 25/03/2023 08:55

Itstarts · 24/03/2023 23:09

Do you not wonder why fb is 13+ and WhatsApp is 16+ and why that might be? How can she be too young for a 13+ rated SM if you let her use a 16+ one?

Do you not ever make your own decisions around parenting? I've let her watch a 12 film that was appropriate for her, but there may be a PG I wouldn't let her watch. All children are different and things aren't black and white. I don't have an issue with her phoning or messaging a friend (WhatsApp) but I do have an issue with her posting photos etc. for other people to judge.

fairywhale · 25/03/2023 06:40

PastaLaVistaBabee · 24/03/2023 23:00

My boys, and their friends, all seem to use WhatsApp responsibly. Maybe we r fortunate with the kids in our school, but there don't seem to have been any issues with WhatsApp in either of my boys classes. They enjoying texting friends on WhatsApp and I check their phones regularly and can see the threads of conversation which are all quite sweet and harmless. They sometimes use WhatsApp video call to chat to friends while playing Roblox or something online. I honestly can't see the harm if it's being used responsibly and parents are monitoring and supporting and taking to children about safe use of apps etc...

Yes I do allow other things. They've both watched a couple of 12 films with me checking content before hand. They both play Roblox and have played Fortnite (not so much now as it's boring apparently, and older one has moved on to some airplane simulator thing and a new online chess game!) which I think are rated at 13 or more.

As a parent I take these ratings as guidelines, and ultimately believe it's up to me as a parent to make the decision on what I think is safe for my children. Children will be exposed to more and more things as they get older, and I like to teach safe and responsible use of tech now to ensure when they are more independent they will have that foundation of knowledge.

Roblox and Fortnite aren't suitable either as they are 13+. Why don't you just let your kids play in real life and be kids, it's better for their development? Presumably for an easier life for yourself? Kids are saturated with media consumption and online gaming and other lazy, dumbing stuff, and then parents say when the kids is 6 or 7, oh they don't play any more. No shit, they have no imagination, ability or interest, all destroyed by this media consumption since almost birth.

ifyougochasingrabbits · 24/03/2023 23:45

Agree !! Mine weren't and aren't allowed phones til y7

Soproudoflionesses · 24/03/2023 23:33

Howdoesitworkagain · 24/03/2023 21:00

What’s App is 12+ not 16+ btw.

I have no objection to my 10/11 year olds having it, but am very cognisant of the potential for issues so make a lot of effort to make sure they use it appropriately and get them to step away from it in some cases. I’d rather they learn about proper, safe use of messaging now while they’re at an age they will be open to me helping them work it out, than drop them in it later when they’re at an age they won’t tolerate me sticking my oar in.

Same here0