Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents should NOT let primary aged children on messaging/social media?

208 replies

SocialMediaPITA · 24/03/2023 19:31

I'm a primary school teacher in year 6. I spend lots of time having to deal with pupils falling out with each other on messaging apps/social media outside of school hours. They then bring these issues into school the next day, and there are tears, tantrums and, on some occasions, fights. And staff have to give up lunch hours, break time and learning/lesson time to deal with the fall out. Children can't learn if they are brewing on what's happened the night before, eg falling out with their peers.

Why do parents let their children on social media? The min age for WhatsApp is 16 - it's 16 for a reason! Many primary aged children are not emotionally able to deal with issues via messaging - even as adults we can recognise that tone and body language can play a huge part in communicating - social media and messaging removes that important aspect and if we as adults can get it wrong, why do we expect children to be able to deal with it? It's affecting their mental health.

I've mopped too many tears this week and much of it can be avoided.

OP posts:
Raineth · 25/03/2023 20:08

Totally agree.

My child is yr 6 and there’s huge pressure to give her a phone so she isn’t left out of wattsapp groups. Yet the groups keep having big arguments I hear.

I’m so angry at all the lazy parents who can’t be bothered to comply with the various app age restrictions and can’t be bothered to arrange playdates for after school socialisation.

Even if a child needs a phone for eg commuting safety it doesn’t need to be a smart phone and even if they need to be able to send messages there is nothing weing with text messages it doesn’t need to be wattsapp.

Itstarts · 25/03/2023 20:06

lailamaria · 25/03/2023 19:39

your mention of whatsapp being 16+ makes me laugh do you expect a high school aged child not to message their friends to organise meet ups until they're 16 but i agree that they shouldn't have social media until they are in year 7

Text? Phone call? Email?

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 19:55

lailamaria · 25/03/2023 19:39

your mention of whatsapp being 16+ makes me laugh do you expect a high school aged child not to message their friends to organise meet ups until they're 16 but i agree that they shouldn't have social media until they are in year 7

I've been quite specific here that I'm talking about primary aged children. I dare say my secondary school colleagues could add in their own points of view if they wish, but I won't speak for them.

WhatsApp collect your info, your phone number for example, which is why the age restriction exists. Anyone can be added to group chats and then they too have your child's phone number. Whilst you can block individuals from contacting you directly, if they are on the group chat you can still see their messages.
More info here: www.parliamentfederation.co.uk/MainFolder/Documents/KPS/Parents/Apps-Info/What-is-Whatsapp.pdf

I'd far rather the individual messaging service on phones which helps the phone owner/user maintain much more control, than WhatsApp.

OP posts:
DanceMonster · 25/03/2023 19:45

lailamaria · 25/03/2023 19:39

your mention of whatsapp being 16+ makes me laugh do you expect a high school aged child not to message their friends to organise meet ups until they're 16 but i agree that they shouldn't have social media until they are in year 7

Do they need WhatsApp to do that?

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 19:40

@Fifi1010 it's not just kissing, it's intimacy and sex in many cases. Did she tell you that?

OP posts:
lailamaria · 25/03/2023 19:39

your mention of whatsapp being 16+ makes me laugh do you expect a high school aged child not to message their friends to organise meet ups until they're 16 but i agree that they shouldn't have social media until they are in year 7

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 19:36

My DC use mine and DH's phone to video call relatives. Why do children need their own device?

We're previous generations unable to keep in touch with relatives before smart phones exist?

Most things that primary age children would use a smartphone for can be done on parent phones or family devices, other than giving them personal, private access to the internet and the ability to use social media with their friends, which is ridiculous for children. It seems to boil down to the fact that because some parents give their 7 year olds smart phones everyone else gives into the pressure so by 9/10 almost everyone has them.

TorviShieldMaiden · 25/03/2023 19:07

Bucketheadbucketbum · 25/03/2023 18:42

@poshme

Look up the functional mri results of children given access to smart phones. Terrifying.

Sounds like you think DC need emergency phone access- pager / walkie talkie (can range 20k) / old school non smart phones all options, but no-one wants to hear it

If you convince yourself it's necessary under faux principles don't have to feel guilty about bringing it into their lives

My dc use their phones to also keep in touch with their grandparents who live a distance away. We have a family group and they chat separately with the gps. They use them to call me when they are at their dad’s.

I really struggled to allow it, but my dd is also very aware of fitting in. If I stop her being on WhatsApp (I do monitor it), then I worry that she will feel even more isolated as the rest of her friends do.

As to MRI scans, one of my dc suffered terrible isolation during lockdown. He became agoraphobic afterwards. A smart
phone was the only way to see his grandparents, communicate with his friends.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 25/03/2023 18:42

@poshme

Look up the functional mri results of children given access to smart phones. Terrifying.

Sounds like you think DC need emergency phone access- pager / walkie talkie (can range 20k) / old school non smart phones all options, but no-one wants to hear it

If you convince yourself it's necessary under faux principles don't have to feel guilty about bringing it into their lives

Fifi1010 · 25/03/2023 18:38

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 16:48

That's another huge problem because kids say they know what 69, Sugar Daddy etc means but they are just parroting what they have heard elsewhere; they are not emotionally able to actually understand what it means and neither should they because it makes them vulnerable. As a teacher I can tell this because they get very silly when we do sex ed - the questions that they ask show that a lot of things they say they 'know' are in fact rumour and inaccurate because "Miss, it says so on TikTok/YouTube!"

She did because she repeated exactly what a sugar daddy is an old man who younger women kiss in exchange for gifts and money 😳😳.

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 16:48

Fifi1010 · 25/03/2023 15:57

My DD has it to keep in touch with relatives and friends. I have filters , blockers, time limits and inspect the phone very regularly. Shutting off all things will mean a big shock. It's about teaching responsible use. To be honest kids know loads my DD was saying one of the kids in class called their sport teams the 69ers 😳 and one called himself a sugar daddy. I asked her did she know what it meant and she said yes.

I think it's important to educate my DD is incredibly open with me. Late primary seem to know roo much already.

That's another huge problem because kids say they know what 69, Sugar Daddy etc means but they are just parroting what they have heard elsewhere; they are not emotionally able to actually understand what it means and neither should they because it makes them vulnerable. As a teacher I can tell this because they get very silly when we do sex ed - the questions that they ask show that a lot of things they say they 'know' are in fact rumour and inaccurate because "Miss, it says so on TikTok/YouTube!"

OP posts:
Fifi1010 · 25/03/2023 15:57

My DD has it to keep in touch with relatives and friends. I have filters , blockers, time limits and inspect the phone very regularly. Shutting off all things will mean a big shock. It's about teaching responsible use. To be honest kids know loads my DD was saying one of the kids in class called their sport teams the 69ers 😳 and one called himself a sugar daddy. I asked her did she know what it meant and she said yes.

I think it's important to educate my DD is incredibly open with me. Late primary seem to know roo much already.

OhmygodDont · 25/03/2023 15:48

Cherryblossoms85 · 25/03/2023 14:42

Any windows device can be controlled with Microsoft family safety. Family link should work on a Chromebook. Don't know about Apple products. The way you connect makes no difference, it's not based on provider, it's full control of the child profile that is linked to your profile. I know someone will come along in a minute and tell me something about how they can still access Twitter etc. It can be set up to authorise every website, link and app, rather than just some ineffective content filter from the ISP. But yeah obviously not giving them devices is the best way of ensuring they do something more useful with their childhoods!

Apple has the same, you can set all apps to requests, set down time, block numbers, check webpages etc all from your own phone.

AFriendToEveryoneIsAFriendToNoOne · 25/03/2023 14:46

The fall out from this happens even for children whose parents don't allow them to have phones in year 5/6!

My nephew (my sisters son) doesn't have a phone. He's Y6. My sister has had to go into school several times because of whatapp bullying where children are being vile about her son in the children's group chat. Things like planning to 'have a go' at him in the playground the next day, one boy egging the others on to not speak to him or sit with him, and exclude him from the lunchtime football match, etc etc etc. She became aware on each occasion as one of the children who was part of this group showed his mum, and the mum sent a screenshot of it to my sister as a 'you should be aware that this is being said' sort of thing.

So even by stopping your own child from accessing this - it still gets to them! And yes, as OP said it has to be sorted out by the school.

No children under secondary school age should have access to social media, messaging services etc, IMO. I'd go so far as to say Y7 too. Unless a child is regularly travelling alone I see no reason for them to have a phone prior to secondary school at all. Mine will not be!

Cherryblossoms85 · 25/03/2023 14:42

Any windows device can be controlled with Microsoft family safety. Family link should work on a Chromebook. Don't know about Apple products. The way you connect makes no difference, it's not based on provider, it's full control of the child profile that is linked to your profile. I know someone will come along in a minute and tell me something about how they can still access Twitter etc. It can be set up to authorise every website, link and app, rather than just some ineffective content filter from the ISP. But yeah obviously not giving them devices is the best way of ensuring they do something more useful with their childhoods!

Avarua2 · 25/03/2023 14:37

We also operate those devices on a combination of wifi and mobile (paid) data.

If anyone has a solution I'm all ears.

Avarua2 · 25/03/2023 14:36

Cherryblossoms85 · 24/03/2023 21:43

Are people not using the stuff like family link? That prevents access to age inappropriate apps and I have full supervision and screen time management.

Family link only works if you all have the same type of device. In my family we have some Apple, some android, PCs and Chromebooks. Nightmare.

denpark · 25/03/2023 14:32

Bucketheadbucketbum · 25/03/2023 13:04

Smart phones for kids is a cancer.

They should be illegal under 16, and licence and registration required under 25

I'm amazed what some parents allow, either naive or stupid or jist want an easy life so allow it rsther than hard parenting. Very sad.

I completely agree. I'm a teacher like the OP & it astonishes me just just how much my non teacher friends allow their children to go on phones. It's scary as hell - so many parents don't understand the damage that can be caused and exactly what they're opening their children up to. Smartphones are really not great for children

poshme · 25/03/2023 14:17

@Bucketheadbucketbum that's just ridiculous!

My kids got phones from year 7. We live rurally- there is very little phone reception and we don't have a landline. I let them have WhatsApp so I can contact them- it's incredibly useful. They all know I can check their phones whenever I like- they have to agree before they get a phone.

They make their own way to/from school and having a phone means they can contact me if necessary. When I was a kids there were phone boxes- no they have defibrillators instead of phones in them.

All phones downstairs before bedtime- so no phone use late at night.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 25/03/2023 13:04

Smart phones for kids is a cancer.

They should be illegal under 16, and licence and registration required under 25

I'm amazed what some parents allow, either naive or stupid or jist want an easy life so allow it rsther than hard parenting. Very sad.

SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 12:59

@TorviShieldMaiden

One set of children I had to sit down with this week and unpick the social media messages and resulting fall out included autistic children who really struggled with this kind of interaction - they felt isolated because they didn't understand the subtleties of reading between the lines, were taking things literally and reacting, and there seems little support from parents to help them navigate this. Some parents, being neurodivergent themselves, are struggling too with this kind of interaction but they don't want their kids to miss out so let them access it.

Far better for kids to learn how to interact in person and be supported to do so, which we do at my school, but we can't support these vulnerable children on social media, neither would we recommend it. It's too much of a minefield for them. It's very important too that autistic kids have down time away from all this to process and have that safe space at home, but they can't do that if on social media.

OP posts:
SocialMediaPITA · 25/03/2023 12:38

I think there's been a misunderstanding @MissDollyMix as I asked "Does the local High School ask the pupils to download social media apps that are age restricted?" and your first word in reply was "Yes"

Perhaps you could clarify?

(My issue is primary aged children using social media, which for many children that age causes issues as they are not emotionally mature enough to deal with this kind of interaction - not high schools using online portals to access work, which is different.)

OP posts:
MrsMurphyIWish · 25/03/2023 12:29

OP, teacher here too and I agree!

My DD only has a phone at the start of Yr 7 due to travel but we would have so many letters/communication from her primary head about class whatsapp groups. My DD never felt left out because she didn’t have a phone - she has many friendship groups due to lots of different extra curricular. My son is Yr 4 - there are children in his class with phones.

My teacher friends never let their children have phones until high school because we know how toxic social media is. You can’t escape the drama. Children should be spending hours on a screen. Such a miserable existence.

My children have never been bullied or been involved in any friendship issues. I’m sure it’s because they are out of the social media drama.

TorviShieldMaiden · 25/03/2023 11:49

SocialMediaPITA · 24/03/2023 20:35

Video messaging would've been much better, you could've sat close by to monitor and the other aspects of communication, like body language and tone, could've been seen - it makes such a difference. Young children need that visual aspect to develop their communication skills; messaging conveys neither of these visual cues and even adults can read written text messages wrong and interpret them the wrong way.

Video messaging also wouldn't happen sporadically throughout an entire evening, like messaging does. Therefore with video messaging there's a break away from each other after school, giving time to process and manage emotions/reactions. With messaging there's none of that - it's instantaneous.

My children used WhatsApp to video message. We didn’t have a monitor, as my only laptop was a work one.

My dd is autistic and finds video calls to difficult and much prefers text, but I get that video is better go neurotypical children.

denpark · 25/03/2023 11:26

I actually think that if parents allow children on apps underage and something bad results from that then the parents are liable. They have the capability to protect their children and are failing to do so. The inability of parents to parent effectively online astounds me. You are responsible for their safety. It's that simple.