Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents should NOT let primary aged children on messaging/social media?

208 replies

SocialMediaPITA · 24/03/2023 19:31

I'm a primary school teacher in year 6. I spend lots of time having to deal with pupils falling out with each other on messaging apps/social media outside of school hours. They then bring these issues into school the next day, and there are tears, tantrums and, on some occasions, fights. And staff have to give up lunch hours, break time and learning/lesson time to deal with the fall out. Children can't learn if they are brewing on what's happened the night before, eg falling out with their peers.

Why do parents let their children on social media? The min age for WhatsApp is 16 - it's 16 for a reason! Many primary aged children are not emotionally able to deal with issues via messaging - even as adults we can recognise that tone and body language can play a huge part in communicating - social media and messaging removes that important aspect and if we as adults can get it wrong, why do we expect children to be able to deal with it? It's affecting their mental health.

I've mopped too many tears this week and much of it can be avoided.

OP posts:
TorviShieldMaiden · 26/03/2023 10:17

That’s great. I’d love that too. Sadly my dd is currently in a crisis caused by school, pressure of SATs and an obsession with assessments and attendance.

She loved Guides, she loved swimming but she physically couldn’t go anymore it was too much. They out loads of effort into adjustments for her too. I could find loads of things she wants to do, but she can’t. We can’t even leave the house at the weekend as she can’t manage it.

MrsMurphyIWish · 26/03/2023 10:10

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/03/2023 10:07

@MrsMurphyIWish i used to be a teacher, although left 7 years ago so probably not as much as an issue then.

My dd has had to give up all her extra curricular stuff this year, Guides, sports etc because school is so hard for her and she has been school refusing because of autistic burnout. Any further socialising on top was too hard. It’s easy to assume that all children can just do tonnes of extra curricular stuff. Lots of research has shown that autistic young people benefit from online friendship, such as through gaming and chats as they aren’t able to cope always with face to face.

My DS is autistic. I’ve worked hard to find extra curricular he has enjoys. I’ve purposely pushed him to feel uncomfortable and try to overcome that as I know he’ll face many challenges ahead. I don’t want him to get sucked into a world where his only friends are online.

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/03/2023 10:07

@MrsMurphyIWish i used to be a teacher, although left 7 years ago so probably not as much as an issue then.

My dd has had to give up all her extra curricular stuff this year, Guides, sports etc because school is so hard for her and she has been school refusing because of autistic burnout. Any further socialising on top was too hard. It’s easy to assume that all children can just do tonnes of extra curricular stuff. Lots of research has shown that autistic young people benefit from online friendship, such as through gaming and chats as they aren’t able to cope always with face to face.

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/03/2023 10:04

We’ll I don’t have an iPad, and my only laptop is my work one.

Actually I loved a long way from grandparents when I was a child and I didn’t manage to stay in touch much. A phone call here and there wasn’t the same. I hated talking in the phone then as much as I do now. It definitely wasn’t the same as sharing every day chats and photos of what is done in my day like my dc do with their grandparents. If I could work out how she can send pictures via text (her phone always refuses) then we could just do that. She loves sending them pictures of her artwork.

my dd was in one big WhatsApp group. She had an issue, we discussed it and she came out of the group. We talked about how sometimes things can be misunderstood in text, and ultimately if anything was upsetting the best thing to do was to come out of group. So she did.

This thread has made me think about it and I will in particular consider dd’s WhatsApp. Ds is 13 and only in one group which is 3 friends he’s had since he was a baby. Never any drama there.

MrsMurphyIWish · 26/03/2023 09:42

Bucketheadbucketbum · 26/03/2023 09:36

Exactly this.

People claiming "it's the world we live in" just can't be bothered with the hard parenting, don't want to be the adult and have the argument with their child.

No one is saying keep kids technology free, just dont give them a smart phone in primary school.

Sadly the parents bleating "it's the world now, we have to" are the ones who have already handed their kids a smartphone... now they have to desperately attempt to either pretend it's not bad for children and/or invent reasons why its "absolutely necessary ".

All just so they dont have to accept the damage they've done to their child. Its bonkers.

Agree with every word.

i think I’ve had it easier as my children have two teacher parents so we have been strict about phones, devices and social media. We have a family laptop and that is all.

It’s an excuse to say children need social media to communicate with family and friends and Covid … my children also lived through the pandemic and managed to stay in contact by borrowing our phones for video call.

My children do a lot of extra curricular - they communicate face to face. Way better for mental health than messaging. How do you properly converse through text and memes?

Bucketheadbucketbum · 26/03/2023 09:36

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 19:36

My DC use mine and DH's phone to video call relatives. Why do children need their own device?

We're previous generations unable to keep in touch with relatives before smart phones exist?

Most things that primary age children would use a smartphone for can be done on parent phones or family devices, other than giving them personal, private access to the internet and the ability to use social media with their friends, which is ridiculous for children. It seems to boil down to the fact that because some parents give their 7 year olds smart phones everyone else gives into the pressure so by 9/10 almost everyone has them.

Exactly this.

People claiming "it's the world we live in" just can't be bothered with the hard parenting, don't want to be the adult and have the argument with their child.

No one is saying keep kids technology free, just dont give them a smart phone in primary school.

Sadly the parents bleating "it's the world now, we have to" are the ones who have already handed their kids a smartphone... now they have to desperately attempt to either pretend it's not bad for children and/or invent reasons why its "absolutely necessary ".

All just so they dont have to accept the damage they've done to their child. Its bonkers.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:22

no i understand not letting kids have access to phones until secondary school age but i'm more responding to the op's hate of whatsapp and some parents on this post saying that nobody needs technology when that's just not true, technology is now essential for schooling and communication parents can't stop that, parents have been trying to stop the latest craze for decades it's never worked

DanceMonster · 26/03/2023 09:10

Saltywalruss · 26/03/2023 09:02

it’s the world we live in now unfortunately

It's only "the world we live in" because we make it so.

E.g. if parents refused to give their children phones there's no way schools could insist that parents provide them. They are far too expensive and cause too many safe guarding issues for schools to insist that they are compulsory school equipment.

Just because something exists that doesn't mean that you have to let your child use it.

Also, I don’t think there are any primary schools demanding that pupils download apps for school work, and this thread is predominantly about primary aged children.

Saltywalruss · 26/03/2023 09:02

it’s the world we live in now unfortunately

It's only "the world we live in" because we make it so.

E.g. if parents refused to give their children phones there's no way schools could insist that parents provide them. They are far too expensive and cause too many safe guarding issues for schools to insist that they are compulsory school equipment.

Just because something exists that doesn't mean that you have to let your child use it.

LolaSmiles · 26/03/2023 07:57

Lots of people have said similar on this thread. But it's just an excuse really. People managed to stay in touch with friends and family really well even before smart phones existed. And even if you do want to use a smart phone to stay in touch you don't need WhatsApp to do that. Normal texting does the same thing. Or speaking.....
Agree with this.
The idea primary aged children need their own smart phones with access to apps and the internet to stay in touch with their grandparents is an excuse.
Why not just say because DC said everyone else has one?

exLtEveDallas · 26/03/2023 07:46

I wish I could say to parents, "you allowed access, so you deal with it!

After having to deal with issues every single week, (and on a few occasions, every single day) issues that have taken up at least an hour of my time, let alone the teachers, and have twice turned into safeguarding referrals, I have

I’ve told parents that I won’t deal with any issue that has been created on social media outside of school. I’ve taken photos of the worst messages (names redacted), I’ve typed out word for word some others (including swear words, insults and spelling mistakes) and I have blanket emailed the main offenders, followed up with hard copy letters for the sake of those parents that say they don’t get school emails.

It is still happening of course, but sympathy has gone for a number of children. It has caused backlash, but I just keep repeating the message that I’ve been sending since September “Your children are under age for these apps and are showing daily that they do not have the maturity to navigate the minefield that is Social Media. Whilst you allow them access it falls to you as parents to deal with the fallout”

VestaTilley · 26/03/2023 07:40

@Icannoteven in an ideal world parents would parent their children properly, and not absolve all responsibility to schools or let their children use devices that the tech bosses don’t even allow their own children on.

DanceMonster · 26/03/2023 07:28

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 02:42

that's exactly what i think@Lifeadjustments you can talk and talk till the cows come home about how phones are evil and technology is ruining the world but unfortunately technology and phones are a part of life, sending letters is a thing of the past and emails are becoming of the past too with the existence of teams which is now used in schools so another reason for kids to need phones, texts are all well and good except not everyone has the money for a contract phone and group chats are immensely useful when you have more than one friend that you want to plan something with, you cannot keep kids from technology, it's their world, and to be honest it has been since the late 90s pretending it's a new age thing is just burying your head in the sand

Agree with a lot of what you’re saying, but we’re talking about primary school aged kids. 7 year olds in my DD2s class are having these issues. No 7 year old needs to be in group chats arranging meet ups.

Phoebo · 26/03/2023 04:40

Agree 💯

Vanderlayinfustries · 26/03/2023 02:53

hoophoophooray · 24/03/2023 19:42

Because during covid it was the only way of getting any social contact for kids. Now the habit is there.

Natural consequence of insisting that children could cope with online learning, online socialising and online friendships for months on end. Can't put that genie back in the bottle.

I'm guessing you didn't know any kids before COVID. My nieces and nephews were having these issues more than a decade ago. I avoid it by banning social media, messages in other apps and only with best friends and asking frequently how things are. No phone use in bedroom so I can guage any reactions or spiralling.

The habit has been there for 15 years. Sick of tiresome parents blaming everything on lick down. Learn some responsibility

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 02:42

that's exactly what i think@Lifeadjustments you can talk and talk till the cows come home about how phones are evil and technology is ruining the world but unfortunately technology and phones are a part of life, sending letters is a thing of the past and emails are becoming of the past too with the existence of teams which is now used in schools so another reason for kids to need phones, texts are all well and good except not everyone has the money for a contract phone and group chats are immensely useful when you have more than one friend that you want to plan something with, you cannot keep kids from technology, it's their world, and to be honest it has been since the late 90s pretending it's a new age thing is just burying your head in the sand

Lifeadjustments · 26/03/2023 00:56

Why are people getting so bent out of shape about people getting thier kids phones, it’s the world we live in now unfortunately. Yes I’m an 80’s kid, we managed without phones, but we live in a world where technology is the means for practically everything. Dd is 10, she has a phone because I want her to, she’s had a phone since she was about 7 (family old ones) only to play games on, she only back in September got a sim because she walks halfway to and from school by herself. She has what’s app, we have rules and I check her phone every night which she is unaware of which means anything said on the group chat it available for me to see, so far so good, sometimes there’s a bit of drama between her friends on video call and she will usually leave as soon as any drama starts. She’s not allowed her phone in bed. DS is 15, he’s only just started taking his phone to bed. It doesn’t matter if it’s what’s app, tik tok, Instagram, if bully’s want to get someone, they will find a way. They just do it in school. I agree it’s not fair for teachers to sort out drama not happening at school, but this is where parents need to be more alert to what kids are doing on thier phones.

MsJD · 26/03/2023 00:43

How do the parents get round the age limit. Enter a fake DOB

kwetu · 26/03/2023 00:35

hoophoophooray · 24/03/2023 19:42

Because during covid it was the only way of getting any social contact for kids. Now the habit is there.

Natural consequence of insisting that children could cope with online learning, online socialising and online friendships for months on end. Can't put that genie back in the bottle.

👏👏

Vitriolinsanity · 26/03/2023 00:23

My dc use their phones to also keep in touch with their grandparents who live a distance away

Why can't they use your phone? Or your iPad. Or desktop or laptop?

It's the same stupid argument as people who only ever use FB or whatever to "keep up n touch" and then bleat their stuffs been shared.

Take some bloody accountability. You wouldn't put a gun in your kids hands. Why put a device that can lead to so many mistakes in their hands.

Vitriolinsanity · 26/03/2023 00:16

@lailamaria who do you expect not call upon when these things go tits up.

If it's you and the parents fine. The majority will rope the school on to deal with it. Not fine.

I'm part of the SLT. Of my working week would you really appreciate that stupid amounts of my time, time that is supposed to be educating and improving the school is sunk dealing with what could be avoided if parents actually did their bloody job.

Saltywalruss · 25/03/2023 23:22

My dc use their phones to also keep in touch with their grandparents who live a distance away

Lots of people have said similar on this thread. But it's just an excuse really. People managed to stay in touch with friends and family really well even before smart phones existed. And even if you do want to use a smart phone to stay in touch you don't need WhatsApp to do that. Normal texting does the same thing. Or speaking.....

DanceMonster · 25/03/2023 21:38

gloov · 25/03/2023 20:44

There's quite a lot of research connecting the increase in depression, self-harm, and mental illness in children to social media use.

https://jonathanhaidt.substack.com/p/social-media-mental-illness-epidemic

And this is exactly why I won’t give in to the ‘but all my friends have it’ arguments.

TorviShieldMaiden · 25/03/2023 20:30

Well when she’s with her dad she needs another device to contact me. And I’d rather is wasn’t her dad’s, but I suppose that’s about me.

My son has a lovely relationship with his grandmother, party built through them texting each other privately.

@Raineth my dd does sometimes play after school, but mostly she is too exhausted from all the face to face contact at school.

I actually thought WhatsApp was 13 not 16. And I just thought of it as a messaging app, rather than social media.