Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents should NOT let primary aged children on messaging/social media?

208 replies

SocialMediaPITA · 24/03/2023 19:31

I'm a primary school teacher in year 6. I spend lots of time having to deal with pupils falling out with each other on messaging apps/social media outside of school hours. They then bring these issues into school the next day, and there are tears, tantrums and, on some occasions, fights. And staff have to give up lunch hours, break time and learning/lesson time to deal with the fall out. Children can't learn if they are brewing on what's happened the night before, eg falling out with their peers.

Why do parents let their children on social media? The min age for WhatsApp is 16 - it's 16 for a reason! Many primary aged children are not emotionally able to deal with issues via messaging - even as adults we can recognise that tone and body language can play a huge part in communicating - social media and messaging removes that important aspect and if we as adults can get it wrong, why do we expect children to be able to deal with it? It's affecting their mental health.

I've mopped too many tears this week and much of it can be avoided.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itstarts · 28/03/2023 16:51

@TTeachingteacher I've refused to collect phones at the beginning of the day because I have no where to lock them. If one went 'missng' no way in hell am I going to take the fall!

Teachingteacher · 28/03/2023 12:46

I’m finding this discussion really interesting. Thanks for raising it OP!

Just a note about schools relying on smart phones in lessons - this annoys me so much! If my DS’s primary school demanded that we have access to apps on a phone for learning I would consider changing schools. This is a hill I will die on.

I work at a school which is a ‘phone free campus’. We have strict rules and signs everywhere about ‘NO PHONES’. We have permission to confiscate them if we see them and the parents are sent it to pick them up.

However, all the kids have phones (I teach secondary). They film tic toks in the bathroom at lunchtime. They take insta stories during class. What annoys me more is when a teacher will post on slack ‘so and so has permission to use his phone to film a Spanish assessment’. We’re a phone-free campus, why does your Spanish assessment rely on a phone!? The management never say anything.

So, being ‘phone free’ and saying that you’re ‘phone free’ are two completely different things in my experience.

Also, I hate confiscating phones. Many years ago, I confiscated a phone from a student and accidentally dropped it while taking it to the Head’s office. The parents raised hell and tried to make me pay for a new one (it wasn’t even damaged btw). The head had my back but it was a really horrible situation. Since then I’ve been so wary of taking phones, especially since they’re so expensive now.

My fellow teachers, solidarity with you as we navigate this minefield!!! 😂😭

Ignorify · 27/03/2023 17:34

I found that my approach (no social media, no YouTube, no internet browser use without an adult being present) in primary school made other parents a bit defensive, so I stopped talking about it unless asked.

BusyMum47 · 27/03/2023 17:33

@SocialMediaPITA Fellow yr6 Teacher here & I completely agree - it really grinds my gears!!!!

DanceMonster · 27/03/2023 17:21

That is a very good point @TorviShieldMaiden , you’re right.

TorviShieldMaiden · 27/03/2023 16:16

I've definitely thought about it more because of this thread. But, you never get people to change their minds by telling them they are thoughtless idiots.

My dc don't have access to their phones all evening. I monitor it via Family link and it gets turned off in the evening.

OhmygodDont · 26/03/2023 21:05

Do I love that my 14 year old travels an hour for school on public transport nope. Does he want to move schools? Nope.

Do I love that my 11 year old will be walking near 30minutes to school in September alone nope. There is no secondary closer for dd. Then I have my third a year 3 then. Certainly she cannot walk her self. So my middle has a phone to get used to having a phone ready for September.

My oldest has a phone because he travels so far and it has his bus ticket as well as his multiple homework apps. Also because secondary don’t tell you if they have a detention where as he could then text me to let me know rather than me worrying my 14 is lost, dead or missing in general. Would school let him ring me for a detention nope.

OhmygodDont · 26/03/2023 21:01

User98866 · 26/03/2023 20:41

And the idea that they need a phone to walk to a from school! Our head has the line that if your not happy with your child walking alone then they shouldn’t be doing it. Absolutely agree.

How does that work if you have multiple children at multiple schools don’t drive and they all start within 5-15minutes of each other anyway.

User98866 · 26/03/2023 20:41

And the idea that they need a phone to walk to a from school! Our head has the line that if your not happy with your child walking alone then they shouldn’t be doing it. Absolutely agree.

User98866 · 26/03/2023 20:36

It’s completely disgusting that parents do this. There is no need. There is no justification. All the agro and that’s without the major safeguarding risks.

ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 26/03/2023 20:32

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LolaSmiles · 26/03/2023 19:39

No one is saying keep kids technology free, just dont give them a smart phone in primary school.

Sadly the parents bleating "it's the world now, we have to" are the ones who have already handed their kids a smartphone... now they have to desperately attempt to either pretend it's not bad for children and/or invent reasons why its "absolutely necessary ".

Exactly this.

This thread had me thinking that as an adult I mute various group chats, and left some others, and I removed work emails from my phone because as an adult I found the endless notifications was creeping too much into my offline life, and turning a phone on to lots of backed up messages was stressful, but people defend how essential it is for their primary aged children to be pinged at all hours in various group chats. How else will they manage to have friends if they don't have social media in KS2? How can they keep in touch with their grandparents if they don't have their own smart phone?

It's funny that given how apps and social media are specifically designed to give quick release highs and keep you engaged on the platform for longer, and it works, it seems there's a lot of parents who think their primary aged child has a better grasp of appropriate tech and social media use than most adults. I highly doubt all these 9/10 year olds really do have such special powers.

Cracklingcrocus · 26/03/2023 17:44

I think, ultimately, far from being the bleeding edge of cool that parents panic their kids will feel left out from… social media is just a bit naff.

Cracklingcrocus · 26/03/2023 17:41

My DC13 has a brick phone and they are fine. Heaps of friends, extra curriculars, reads a lot. DC9 has no phone at all. I work in media and God knows I’m addicted enough to social media (because I have to stay across it for work). I want to preserve my kids’ brain space as long as possible. It’s really telling that teachers and people who work in tech don’t let their kids have smartphones (eg Melinda Gates gave phones to her kids at 14 - and wishes she’d waited longer).

I really think social media is this generation’s tobacco. We will look back and wonder what the hell we were thinking.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 17:01

@UsernameMcUsername i don't think sexism, homophobia and ableism is comparable to thinking technology is necessary honestly but btw most teens still smoke, they still get made fun of for being gay and by some posts on here still get questioned on whether being gay is appropriate, also you could say the same thing about the trans issue, so many people are transphobic especially on here and yet in 20-30 unfortunately for transphobes it'll be normal

Itstarts · 26/03/2023 15:47

And parents can't prevent other children typing something nasty. Once it's sent and seen you can't unsee it. A parent checking the phone every evening doesn't help.

SocialMediaPITA · 26/03/2023 15:34

@OhmygodDont
Whilst I agree with parents keeping an eye on things, even with doing that, there are issues.

Instead of the children being unpleasant to each other just at school, it now continues (or even starts up) at home online. There is no 'safe space' at home anymore to just chill and have downtime away from friendship issues at school. It's not bullying that I'm dealing with as such, it's friends falling out online, people taking sides, or words taken the wrong way. Things that are better dealt with in person with adults to support on the playground (or in class). Also we see people type things they wouldn't say face to face. Things get whipped up on the group chats and then these children are coming into school the next day feeling anxious about what happened on the chat and having to see their classmates.

OP posts:
UsernameMcUsername · 26/03/2023 14:45

I hate "that's just the way the world is" arguments. When I was a kid in the 80s / 90s you couldn't be openly gay, half the teens I knew smoked, girls were expected to just shrug off 'dirty old man' stuff and 'spastic' was the insult of choice. I'm sure people then shrugged off any attempt to debate whether those things were what we wanted for our society.

SocialMediaPITA · 26/03/2023 14:01

It's worth mentioning here that anyone using social media reads the Terms of Service and understands how their information is stored and used.

With WhatsApp your phone number is used in any group you belong to, whether you know those people or not. If someone in the group adds someone else, someone you don't know, they too can then see your number, even if you block them.

OP posts:
DanceMonster · 26/03/2023 13:53

It absolutely shouldn’t be up to you and your colleagues to sort @SocialMediaPITA . If problems have arisen through use of an App that parents have decided to allow their children to have despite age guidelines, it should be up to the parents to resolve issues arising from it.
My 9 year old was frustrated a few weeks ago as half a PE lesson had been taken up with their teacher resolving a WhatsApp issue with a large group of the class.

SocialMediaPITA · 26/03/2023 13:37

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 02:42

that's exactly what i think@Lifeadjustments you can talk and talk till the cows come home about how phones are evil and technology is ruining the world but unfortunately technology and phones are a part of life, sending letters is a thing of the past and emails are becoming of the past too with the existence of teams which is now used in schools so another reason for kids to need phones, texts are all well and good except not everyone has the money for a contract phone and group chats are immensely useful when you have more than one friend that you want to plan something with, you cannot keep kids from technology, it's their world, and to be honest it has been since the late 90s pretending it's a new age thing is just burying your head in the sand

I'm not a Luddite. Tech is great (but we don't need it for everything).

I'm talking specifically again about primary aged children and social media, particularly WhatsApp, because the responsibility of sorting out the issues that are affecting children's well-being is falling on me and my colleagues.

People can communicate in a variety of different ways that don't involve social media.

OP posts:
Saltywalruss · 26/03/2023 13:10

. If I could work out how she can send pictures via text (her phone always refuses) then we could just do that

There's probably a setting you have to change. Ut will probably be something like "allow phone to send,/receive mms when connected to wifi"

MrsMurphyIWish · 26/03/2023 11:42

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/03/2023 10:20

Sorry, I’m a bit sensitive about it at the moment. There are loads of things she wants to do, but can’t.

I’M not disagreeing that social media is bad, I’m defensive about why I let my dd use it. But agree maybe I shouldn’t.

@TorviShieldMaiden It’s difficult being a parent of an ASD child isn’t it? I’m sorry if my post read insensitively. We do what we think is best for our child and what works for one ASD child won’t for another. I know unless I push DS to be uncomfortable he would be speak to another child. I hope your DD finds something she can be happy doing.

OhmygodDont · 26/03/2023 11:41

By end year 6 most children have phones ready for secondary school. I don’t understand those in year 4 or early year 5 having them I will admit.

Whatapp gets used to bridge the gap between iPhone/android users for easy free group messaging. If it wasn’t whatapp it would be kik or some other platform they used or you just end up with an Apple / android divide in friendship groups.

The problem again comes back to parents not keeping at eye on what their children are doing. Not the app itself. Whatapp doesn’t make someone say something bitchy, but a parent not keeping an eye and then not handing out suitable punishments etc for being a bully is the problem.

A bully will bully regardless of how they bully, a parent who is willing to step up and deal with their bully child again will regardless of it being WhatsApp/in person/paper airplanes fighting or words.

Same as when you get parents saying Minecraft good fortnight bad not realising both let you play with strangers and chat to strangers. However you can turn chat off in both.

Parents need education on today’s technology because lots of children are running laps around them because they just lack the knowledge or just plan old don’t care.

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/03/2023 10:20

Sorry, I’m a bit sensitive about it at the moment. There are loads of things she wants to do, but can’t.

I’M not disagreeing that social media is bad, I’m defensive about why I let my dd use it. But agree maybe I shouldn’t.