Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go on holiday with my son without partner

180 replies

carrotk1 · 24/03/2023 19:29

Hi everyone

I've got a 15 year old son and 19 year old daughter from previous relationship and a 1 year old girl in my current relationship that I've been in for 4 years.

We met in 2019 and didn't have a chance for a holiday together and since covid we've only been on breaks away in this country.

In a few months in being given a very small section of inheritance early, enough for a few holidays maybe but nothing mad.

My ex partner has taken my son on all amazing holidays like florida and lapland which although great for my son, I've always felt a bit sad not to be able to see his excitement etc.

So I thought since I would have this money that I'd take him to Japan as he's always wanted to go and is obsessed with it. The attention the past year has been very baby focused and I'd like him and I to go on this amazing holiday together.

I asked my partner this week, since I want to do this for my son, what did he want as part of this money eg would be like us to go somewhere to have some him and I time? Am amazing experience? Even pay off his credit card? Whatever he wanted to do I said I'd like to keep a section that's going to make him happy too.

He's really cross with me, he couldn't really figure out why to begin with and started guilt tripping me about being away from the baby for 7-10 days which I didn't think was fair. I have other children too who would like their mum to focus on them too.

He said he'd always liked to go to Japan so why didn't I include him? I said because this was a holiday solely about my son and I having us time and if he did come I guess I'd be ok with that but that I was coming from an angle of I'd rather my partner and I do a holiday that's just for us to focus on us. Rather than have a very 'parenty' holiday.

This wasn't good enough and he's been cross with me all night really. He's hardly speaking to me and I'm not sure what I've done wrong.

I feel like I'm allowed my time with my son but I always asked him what he would like to spend a section of the money on that I'll keep for just him and I. This wasn't good enough and I want to check if I was being unreasonable? It came from a good place of wanting dedicated time with my son and him.

OP posts:
EmmaDilemma5 · 25/03/2023 00:49

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:36

Of course they wouldn't! They'd be villifying him for not discussing it with her first!! And he absolutely should be able and willing to look after the baby for a week, but for op to make that decision for him without even discussing it first is bang out of order.

She's tried to discuss it and her partner is shooting the idea down. Because he feels jealous.

I highly doubt many would villify him. Putting children first is good parenting. Putting your partner of 4 years above your teenage kids, not so much.

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:49

carrotk1 · 25/03/2023 00:41

@Lizzt2007 what decision am I making "for him"? I'm making a decision for my son and I.

A decision I've wanted to make since before my partner came along and not one I believe my son and I should miss out on because of a relationship I've decided to have.

I agree with a PP, he's an adult, I would have no problem in him taking his daughter away for something that he's wanted to do for years before I came along, to further bond with his daughter one on one.

Just because we have relationships doesn't mean our most important relationships, our parent-child ones, should be treated any differently.

You've decided that you're going away just with your son and that you're not taking the baby so he has to look after her. No your parent child relationships shouldn't be treated differently because of a partner, but can you honestly not understand that not even having a discussion with your partner about it before you decided is unfair? That's mind boggling. I've been with my partner 13 years, last year I wanted to take my grandson on holiday, and the first thing I did was discuss it with my partner because we're a partnership, his feelings and opinions matter to me, as I would expect mine to matter to him.

carrotk1 · 25/03/2023 00:48

Newusernameaug · 25/03/2023 00:43

I’d be really hurt and upset if I was him as your not sharing it as a family, very much as a single person who’s then ‘generously’ gifting each person something that involves you at the centre.
it’s a totally different mind set to sharing your finances equally as a family unit.

But none of the other children would want to go to Japan? But it's my sons dream holiday. In that case isn't it thinking of each child and what they'd prefer by not forcing them on a holiday they'd hate? His two for example would just want a sunny holiday with a pool to swim for a couple of weeks - they'd hate being dragged round Tokyo for sure! My partner has already said a holiday like that would be a waste and totally lost in his two and my daughter would hate it. But that's not fair for my son to miss out because the other children don't want to go?

OP posts:
carrotk1 · 25/03/2023 00:46

SarahDippity · 25/03/2023 00:38

I think the inheritance is the perfect, and possibly only, opportunity for you to have a very special holiday with your DS. I’m a zealous believer in equality for children’s opportunities, but not all opportunities have to be simultaneous, particularly when your family setup involves children of vastly differing ages: when your DS is older, you can bring your younger child on a special holiday.

Exactly this.

My daughter for example said she'd hate Japan and will either choose Greece or money towards a car. Something that's for her only rather than force everyone to enjoy the same thing.

My partner said he'd like to go to Japan too, which I wouldn't say no to, but I think I'd like it just my son and I really. We have a lovely close mother son relationship and next year he will be 16 so I'll be bordering on the last few years he'll be happy to do a holiday just him and I. Plus like I said to my partner, for my partner and I to have a truly nice break that's all about him and I, surely it would be better that he and I do our own romantic holiday? As Japan will just be doing what my son wants and there'll be no time for my partner and I as the Japan holiday is about my son.

I'd be so happy with a suggestion of a holiday of just my partner and I to connect with no children as my mum can have the baby for a week, she's pretty good.

But he's not and even he can't put his finger on why me going to Japan with his son has made him so cross!

OP posts:
Newusernameaug · 25/03/2023 00:44

Oh and I don’t think going away with your son in wrong per se, but the way you’ve told him and gone about it and your justification is what’s screwed up, not the actual taking a trip!

Newusernameaug · 25/03/2023 00:43

I’d be really hurt and upset if I was him as your not sharing it as a family, very much as a single person who’s then ‘generously’ gifting each person something that involves you at the centre.
it’s a totally different mind set to sharing your finances equally as a family unit.

carrotk1 · 25/03/2023 00:41

@Lizzt2007 what decision am I making "for him"? I'm making a decision for my son and I.

A decision I've wanted to make since before my partner came along and not one I believe my son and I should miss out on because of a relationship I've decided to have.

I agree with a PP, he's an adult, I would have no problem in him taking his daughter away for something that he's wanted to do for years before I came along, to further bond with his daughter one on one.

Just because we have relationships doesn't mean our most important relationships, our parent-child ones, should be treated any differently.

OP posts:
SarahDippity · 25/03/2023 00:38

I think the inheritance is the perfect, and possibly only, opportunity for you to have a very special holiday with your DS. I’m a zealous believer in equality for children’s opportunities, but not all opportunities have to be simultaneous, particularly when your family setup involves children of vastly differing ages: when your DS is older, you can bring your younger child on a special holiday.

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:36

EmmaDilemma5 · 25/03/2023 00:33

I completely disagree. Mumsnet would be saying he sounds like a lovely dad who puts his children first.

OP doesn't have to get permission from her 4 year partner. She can raise her children how she sees fit. And he shouldn't have a problem having his own child for 7-10 nights. Especially when he can see how his step son will benefit.

Of course they wouldn't! They'd be villifying him for not discussing it with her first!! And he absolutely should be able and willing to look after the baby for a week, but for op to make that decision for him without even discussing it first is bang out of order.

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 25/03/2023 00:34

Exactly @EmmaDilemma5

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 25/03/2023 00:34

@Lizzt2007

And therein lies the problem.

Its become acceptable to prioritise the relationship the step parent over the child.

OP has it spot on. If more people parented by putting the child first I wouldn't see so many messed up and unhappy young adults in my work.

OPs partner is an adult. He can cope for ten days.

EmmaDilemma5 · 25/03/2023 00:33

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:24

It's not about the money, it's the disrespect of deciding to go away on holiday without even discussing it with her partner first, despite the fact that it has an impact on him. If a man did this Munster would be absolutely crucifying him for not treating her as a equal partner in family decisions.

I completely disagree. Mumsnet would be saying he sounds like a lovely dad who puts his children first.

OP doesn't have to get permission from her 4 year partner. She can raise her children how she sees fit. And he shouldn't have a problem having his own child for 7-10 nights. Especially when he can see how his step son will benefit.

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:32

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:24

It's not about the money, it's the disrespect of deciding to go away on holiday without even discussing it with her partner first, despite the fact that it has an impact on him. If a man did this Munster would be absolutely crucifying him for not treating her as a equal partner in family decisions.

Mumsnet . Not Munster, hate bloody predictive text.

EmmaDilemma5 · 25/03/2023 00:31

I think it's lovely you're giving your older children some 121 time. I know my partner wouldn't begrudge it.

YANBU, your partner sounds like the jealous selfish type.

And no, you shouldn't spend your money on his credit cards either.

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:24

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 24/03/2023 23:45

Im so suprised so many are in support of your partner.

Your inheritance- is your inheritance no one else's. You have been very generous telling him you will allocate some money to make him happy.

I received a large inheritance last year and I been married 20 years but my DH didn't utter a word about what he might like with it because he understood that it was left to me.

The vast majority i have put away for my DCs future.

Go on holiday with your DS. It will be an incredibly bonding experience.

If your DP can't cope with little one for 10 days without being grouchy he isn't a particularly generous or thoughtful partner.

Nourish your relationship with DS. It is a difficult age and will do you both the power of good.

It's not about the money, it's the disrespect of deciding to go away on holiday without even discussing it with her partner first, despite the fact that it has an impact on him. If a man did this Munster would be absolutely crucifying him for not treating her as a equal partner in family decisions.

Lizzt2007 · 25/03/2023 00:21

carrotk1 · 24/03/2023 23:21

I guess my issue with this is, if he's unhappy with me taking my son to Japan for 10 days, what, my son and I don't go?

This is somewhere I've dreamt of taking him for years, before my partner came along, as been obsessed since he was little. I don't think because I'm now in a relationship that my son and I should miss out on this experience.

As for competing with my ex, the salary difference between us is insane, I could never compete but he's loved in both houses, my ex is a good Dad and earns a lot. The only feelings I have towards that is missing out on seeing my sons face and reactions during some amazing firsts.

Not necessarily no. If he's unhappy you discuss it with him , consider his feelings and opinions then ultimately decide how valid you feel they are. You might decide his feelings on the issue were unreasonable, but you'd at least done him the courtesy of considering them.

imadeitnice · 25/03/2023 00:06

I've regularly taken my son and daughter on separate holidays to places they're interested in that the other wouldn't have much interest in visiting. Without my DP. We've also regularly taken holidays for all four of us, plus separate ones just for DP and I.
I think it's lovely to spend one on one time with people you love, be that your child, partner, parent or sibling.

IfOnlyOurEyesSawSouls · 24/03/2023 23:45

Im so suprised so many are in support of your partner.

Your inheritance- is your inheritance no one else's. You have been very generous telling him you will allocate some money to make him happy.

I received a large inheritance last year and I been married 20 years but my DH didn't utter a word about what he might like with it because he understood that it was left to me.

The vast majority i have put away for my DCs future.

Go on holiday with your DS. It will be an incredibly bonding experience.

If your DP can't cope with little one for 10 days without being grouchy he isn't a particularly generous or thoughtful partner.

Nourish your relationship with DS. It is a difficult age and will do you both the power of good.

carrotk1 · 24/03/2023 23:21

Lizzt2007 · 24/03/2023 23:17

im sorry but I'm with your partner on this one. You're supposed to be a family and your first thought was to exclude 2 (3 if you include adult daughter) members of that family from an amazing trip. You highlight the trips your ex was able to take your son on, and maybe you need to consider that you're unwittingly trying to compete with him now you're in a position to do the same. You're not being ungenerous and in your eyes offering to pay credit card or go on an adult holiday was treating him equally, but it really isn't. You mention not taking the baby, so he'd presumably have to look after the baby while you were away too. It sounds like you've basically presented it to him as a 'this is what I'm going to do whether you like it or not' and not actually sat down and had a discussion about what you'd like to do and why before deciding to do it. You havent considered his feelings and opinions at all. You've made it all about you and your son and that shouldn't be how families work. As for your daughter having a different reaction, she's not the one who should be an equal partner in family decision making. She's not your partner, he is. And it absolutely should be a family discussion /decision as it affects the whole family.

I guess my issue with this is, if he's unhappy with me taking my son to Japan for 10 days, what, my son and I don't go?

This is somewhere I've dreamt of taking him for years, before my partner came along, as been obsessed since he was little. I don't think because I'm now in a relationship that my son and I should miss out on this experience.

As for competing with my ex, the salary difference between us is insane, I could never compete but he's loved in both houses, my ex is a good Dad and earns a lot. The only feelings I have towards that is missing out on seeing my sons face and reactions during some amazing firsts.

OP posts:
Lizzt2007 · 24/03/2023 23:17

im sorry but I'm with your partner on this one. You're supposed to be a family and your first thought was to exclude 2 (3 if you include adult daughter) members of that family from an amazing trip. You highlight the trips your ex was able to take your son on, and maybe you need to consider that you're unwittingly trying to compete with him now you're in a position to do the same. You're not being ungenerous and in your eyes offering to pay credit card or go on an adult holiday was treating him equally, but it really isn't. You mention not taking the baby, so he'd presumably have to look after the baby while you were away too. It sounds like you've basically presented it to him as a 'this is what I'm going to do whether you like it or not' and not actually sat down and had a discussion about what you'd like to do and why before deciding to do it. You havent considered his feelings and opinions at all. You've made it all about you and your son and that shouldn't be how families work. As for your daughter having a different reaction, she's not the one who should be an equal partner in family decision making. She's not your partner, he is. And it absolutely should be a family discussion /decision as it affects the whole family.

TheIsleOfTheLost · 24/03/2023 23:12

I don't think the comparison of adult daughter is fair. I would pay for school and pre-school children, but not adult choldren. Your partner is the co-adult in your relationship. I would be annoyed at my dp going off on a long jolly and leaving me with the baby too. Especially as you have decided this without him and just dropped it on him after the decision. It's not really treating him as a partner is it.

carrotk1 · 24/03/2023 23:12

Houseplantmad · 24/03/2023 23:09

Don’t go to Japan for less than 2 weeks, you’ll miss out on so much.
I don’t see the issue with you going away with your DS though.

I thought about this but 2 weeks may be pushing it without my one year old, so I thought about 10 days?

OP posts:
carrotk1 · 24/03/2023 23:11

@Forgetaboutme maybe there's 2 types of people in the world, this who are ok with this and those who aren't.

He has 2 children from previous relationship also and I offered to include them in to a separate activity/holiday so that he and I could get some much needed us time.

But if the roles were reversed and he said to me that he's taking his youngest on a holiday he's been dreaming of taking her since before I came along and did I want a holiday just him and I too, I'd be so excited! I'd be so happy he'd get to finally take his daughter on holiday to somewhere she's always wanted to go and I wouldn't bat an eyelid being sole carer of the baby for a week... Maybe I need to accept we're very different in how we are happy for the other person even if they're doing something without us?

OP posts:
Houseplantmad · 24/03/2023 23:09

Don’t go to Japan for less than 2 weeks, you’ll miss out on so much.
I don’t see the issue with you going away with your DS though.

Forgetaboutme · 24/03/2023 23:06

I sort of see his point. Its not just about the time away from your baby but he has to be sole carer in that time. I wouldnt be happy if my dh went away for a week or so and I was left at home with a baby while he holidayed. A long weekend maybe but 7 - 10 days is a lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread