Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Year 6 children weigh in and measurements

198 replies

Yoyo2021 · 24/03/2023 18:47

Hi all,

Just received a email about the nhs coming in to weigh my child’s year group and measure height etc.

It said this will be done in a private room.

I’ve opted out following the link.

I just think what’s the point my child isn’t under weight or over weight!

If I had cause for concern I would go to the doctors!

AIBU

Year 6 children weigh in and measurements
OP posts:
Natsku · 25/03/2023 07:11

The government could do something with this data they collect, it was successfully done in Finland some years ago (but needs doing again as overweight children have increased greatly again).

Natsku · 25/03/2023 07:09

underneaththeash · 24/03/2023 22:42

@meditrina no you’re confused by how they measure. Under 18s are based in centiles, so how their weight differs from others at the same age. There isn’t an allowance for height just age. At one stage he was a little overweight, but I didn’t know how much as his age range’s height was way below his.
He’s still outside his range if I put in his correct date of birth, but we’ll within it, if I make him 2 years older.

They relate the weight to their age because overtall children generally become overweight so growing far taller than the rest of their age group is an indicator not a reason to measure their results with an older age. The problem is there are children that grow overtall for other reasons - basically if both parents are over 6ft tall then probably safe to ignore the overweight designation but if parents are average height then be prepared for them to stop growing taller sooner and instead put on more weight. Basically the extra energy from excess food is going into growing height first for these children.

bellac11 · 25/03/2023 07:06

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:32

Doesn't mean they should have to be weighed at school. It's my opinion that's all!

So where else then? Schools are also used for education, health and wellbeing, immunisations etc etc

You can give your opinion and others can question it. Thats rather the nature of discussion forums.

Onthenosecco · 25/03/2023 06:57

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:32

Doesn't mean they should have to be weighed at school. It's my opinion that's all!

But loads of public health things happen in school, like vaccinations for example. If it was done outside school so many parents just wouldn’t bother as they think their chubby children are “fine”

EggBlanket · 25/03/2023 06:56

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:25

I suggest you have a coffee. I just expressed my opinion and personal experience, nothing controversial. I didn't suggest anything from the 'taxpayer' or special suggestions for my kids.

but if you don’t think it should take place at school you must have a view that there is somewhere better to do it? Why don’t you share it?

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:32

bellac11 · 25/03/2023 06:29

Well where else do you get children en masse?

Doesn't mean they should have to be weighed at school. It's my opinion that's all!

bellac11 · 25/03/2023 06:29

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:21

I get that, I just don't think it's appropriate in a school setting

Well where else do you get children en masse?

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:25

EggBlanket · 25/03/2023 06:22

It’s in a private room. How else could they collect data on school children en masse? Should they come to your house? Would you be happy for tax payers money to cover that cost?

I suggest you have a coffee. I just expressed my opinion and personal experience, nothing controversial. I didn't suggest anything from the 'taxpayer' or special suggestions for my kids.

Sortinshit23 · 25/03/2023 06:23

Plus, my children will never ever see the results or know what they are, no matter what the outcomes are.

EggBlanket · 25/03/2023 06:22

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:21

I get that, I just don't think it's appropriate in a school setting

It’s in a private room. How else could they collect data on school children en masse? Should they come to your house? Would you be happy for tax payers money to cover that cost?

Sortinshit23 · 25/03/2023 06:21

I just opt in as it's a data collection exercise. I don't really care about at an individual level.

EggBlanket · 25/03/2023 06:21

HostessTrolley · 25/03/2023 06:07

Because she asked - I'm not going to lie to her, and at that age she was curious rather than anxious. I don't think it caused her ED, but I don't think it helped either.

If you knew it was because she was muscular and not fat you shouldn’t have mentioned it to her. She was too young to process the information rationally. In fact, even if she was fat you shouldn’t have mentioned it to her, you should have just encouraged healthier choices.

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:21

I get that, I just don't think it's appropriate in a school setting

EggBlanket · 25/03/2023 06:18

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:17

Not in the UK, but similiar initiative here. I did opt out, because I already knew my DC was overweight and I had a frank discussion and plan with our doctor. It wasn't nice to hear, but I'm so glad she highlighted it to me.

DC had no idea, she spoke to him about how important vegetables are etc. but no mention of his weight. He now swims 3x a week and thinks it's a massive treat everytime🥰Even if there are concerns, I still don't think a child needs to know. DC is now much healthier and DR is super happy.

Not something for the classrom IMO.

The point isn’t to identify individual cases, it’s to gather population level data.

EggBlanket · 25/03/2023 06:17

The government has to collect data otherwise what do they base policy making on? If they didn’t do mass data collection they wouldn’t know that 40% of year 6 kids are overweight.

So many people on this thread have completely missed the point and seem to be taking the request for a weigh in as an attack on their parenting. People are dense.

WinedropsOnMoses · 25/03/2023 06:17

Not in the UK, but similiar initiative here. I did opt out, because I already knew my DC was overweight and I had a frank discussion and plan with our doctor. It wasn't nice to hear, but I'm so glad she highlighted it to me.

DC had no idea, she spoke to him about how important vegetables are etc. but no mention of his weight. He now swims 3x a week and thinks it's a massive treat everytime🥰Even if there are concerns, I still don't think a child needs to know. DC is now much healthier and DR is super happy.

Not something for the classrom IMO.

HostessTrolley · 25/03/2023 06:07

Bigminnie1 · 25/03/2023 06:01

But why did you even discuss it with her? When my DD was weighed in year 6, I don't think it was even mentioned.

If a child mentions they are getting weighed then the parents should be saying it's just for statistics . If they get a letter back saying their child is over or underweight then why share that information with their 10/11 year old, especially if they know it could make them anxious?

Because she asked - I'm not going to lie to her, and at that age she was curious rather than anxious. I don't think it caused her ED, but I don't think it helped either.

Bigminnie1 · 25/03/2023 06:01

HostessTrolley · 24/03/2023 19:28

My d was a gymnast, training several
times a week by year 6, and rather muscular. We got a letter saying she was obese.

She brought it up for discussion with her therapist when she was an inpatient in an eating disorder unit at the other side of the country, with a BMI of about 13, as a 17 year old.

At the time of the letter we didn't make a big deal about it at home. She was aware of it, and we talked about how flawed BMI is as a measure. But it clearly got inside her head to a degree. It didnt 'cause' her ED but it certainly didn't help.

But why did you even discuss it with her? When my DD was weighed in year 6, I don't think it was even mentioned.

If a child mentions they are getting weighed then the parents should be saying it's just for statistics . If they get a letter back saying their child is over or underweight then why share that information with their 10/11 year old, especially if they know it could make them anxious?

bellac11 · 25/03/2023 05:47

Loads of people on here saying 'Im not going to lie' when talking about why they told their children about the letter

Well sometimes information does need to be witheld from children, its part of protecting them from information that they dont need to know and in some cases might actually be harmful for them. Whether you want to call that a lie or not is up to you but its just good parenting to ensure they're not exposed to things they dont need to be.

bellac11 · 25/03/2023 05:45

notafruit · 24/03/2023 22:55

For those saying I am incorrect, It must be fairly new that they include height. It was only a couple of years ago that my friend had a lot of trouble as her almost 6ft at age 11 child was classed as obese, despite being like a bean pole. She fought to get the "diagnosis" (can't think of a better word) removed from his records. Maybe some health authorities are a little behind the times.

No its not new. Height has always been part of the data gathering

InWalksBarberalla · 25/03/2023 01:23

Seems these days people won't do the most basic thing if there isn't something directly in it for them. These surveys are to gather data for public health reasons.

TheOrigRights · 24/03/2023 23:14

notafruit · 24/03/2023 22:55

For those saying I am incorrect, It must be fairly new that they include height. It was only a couple of years ago that my friend had a lot of trouble as her almost 6ft at age 11 child was classed as obese, despite being like a bean pole. She fought to get the "diagnosis" (can't think of a better word) removed from his records. Maybe some health authorities are a little behind the times.

Where do you live?
Even the most dim person would realise that you need to look at at least height and weight to see if someone is overweight.
And if someone made a conclusion w/o either of those I'd throw it in the bin.

Morecrimblecrumble · 24/03/2023 23:03

WeCome1 · 24/03/2023 22:48

Many recent studies have found that parents can’t tell if their own child is overweight.
eg
https://www.contemporarypediatrics.com/view/child-overweight-parents-dont-see-what-you-do

Such a good point. And Even more reason to support healthy habits via government policy.

If parents have a recognised difficulty in seeing the overweight child for what they are (I’ve not read the paper, only your post) then perhaps upping phys Ed at school or making swimming cheaper and more accessible would just make sense? Working on the junk food advertising? Better outdoor spaces

If the whole class is doing more running then it’s really not a case of obese child’s mum having to acknowledge her child isn’t in the perceived healthy weight bracket..it just becomes the normal activity level.

Like it was.. back in the day.. when kids were skinnier

notafruit · 24/03/2023 22:55

For those saying I am incorrect, It must be fairly new that they include height. It was only a couple of years ago that my friend had a lot of trouble as her almost 6ft at age 11 child was classed as obese, despite being like a bean pole. She fought to get the "diagnosis" (can't think of a better word) removed from his records. Maybe some health authorities are a little behind the times.

WeCome1 · 24/03/2023 22:48

PastaLaVistaBabee · 24/03/2023 22:43

Personally I think it's a massive waste of money. Most people with chubby kids know their kid is chubby without having to get a letter about it. Equally, most parents with skinny kids know their kid is skinny and don't need to be told. It's usually fairly obvious who the sky nny kids in the class are, and who is carrying a bit extra. I'm sure the parents have eyes and can see for themselves. I think the NHS would have better things to spend their money on than this ridiculous mass weigh-in. Bonkers IMO.

(my son was '50th centile' so average. Completely unenlightening and I can tell by looking at him there's no probs. My other son is quite thin (though eats more than his 'average' brother and does less exercise!!). He's not year 6 yet, but I won't need a letter to tell me his BMI is a little below average, as it's obvious. I can see. Totally don't get the point in these letters and this mass weigh-in)

Many recent studies have found that parents can’t tell if their own child is overweight.
eg
https://www.contemporarypediatrics.com/view/child-overweight-parents-dont-see-what-you-do

Is this child overweight? Parents don’t see what you do!

Most parents of young children who are overweight or obese think their child’s weight is “just right,” according to a study conducted in Sweden. However, as their child grows older, more parents recognize when their child is too heavy-especially if he...

https://www.contemporarypediatrics.com/view/child-overweight-parents-dont-see-what-you-do

Swipe left for the next trending thread