Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH needs to plan better or deal with the consequences

205 replies

BluetheBear · 24/03/2023 14:01

My DH can be a bit disorganised and lack planning. He is intelligent and has a professional job, which requires him to use his brain and his diary, but at home he just seems to fail to think ahead.

An example today is he worked this morning from home, has the afternoon off and is going out with work colleagues later. His daughter (20) lives near where he works so he planned to meet her at 2pm this afternoon for lunch.

I am home as I don't work Fridays and have a toddler at home who is napping. I'm in the room with toddler while he is asleep just reading a book.

DH asked at about 1:30 if I could give him a lift to the train station. I said yes when child wakes up. No time discussed except he did ask how long child would sleep and I said hopefully another half hour to an hour. I said I could take him on the way to the supermarket. He said ok.

DH rushes into the room quite stressed at 1:45 saying he needs to get to the train station for 2:15 and can I give him a lift and get him there. I hesitated as he seemed so stressed and sometimes he gets annoyed if I say no to things. He did acknowledge he was wrong to have not checked train times earlier as it will take him over an hour to get there. We don't live in a city so it's two trains he needs. I said well child is asleep and I still need to feed him before we go.

He was fine with it and has called a taxi but it seems the taxi is taking it's time and I feel bad that he might not get to see DSD but also can't deal with how everything is always last minute. It's 2pm now and child is asleep so I'd have to put sleeping child into the car, drive to the station, then drive back home and feed him before going out again to the supermarket. It's not the end of the world but I can't imagine not looking at train times until half an hour before I'm supposed to be meeting someone and I know it's an hour away!

OP posts:
Bunnyhascovidnoteggs · 25/03/2023 08:36

As long as he didn't blame you to dsd for not giving him a lift....

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/03/2023 08:32

@Crumpetdisappointment surely it was HIS responsibility to discuss with her the actual details? So when op responded, "after nap, maybe half an hour' (which still would have been too late anyway) that was the point for him to say something about when he was meant to be there etc. It's his trip. Otherwise it's putting the onus on the op to figure it all out for him.

ssd · 25/03/2023 08:32

@BaBadbadbunny , that sounds outside the normal levels of planning. They both sound extremely anxious. It must be exhausting.

Op, it sounds like your dh bullies you. Thats more of a worry than his lateness. Although i felt bad for his dd waiting ages for him.

Badbadbunny · 25/03/2023 08:25

@Connected1

I remember hearing on some TV show, the mum said "boys can only see 20 mins into the future" and it's something I quote to my husband all the time.

Some boys are like that, but so are some girls, so not really true.

My DH is a planner in the extreme and he gets stressed/anxious about even small and irrelevant things. Planning something like a holiday or a day out is a nightmare because he plans for every eventuality. We always, literally always, arrive early because he's planned for all kinds of unlikely disasters! We have a sat nav in the car, but he also has printouts from google maps "just in case", and he also plots alternative routes through one of those large car road maps! Same with trains or buses, we never get the one that gets us there in time, we get the one before that (just in case the later one is cancelled or running late). We've got a mini survival kit in the car, drinks, snacks, blankets, torches, spare clothes, tool box, etc. For Christmas or birthdays, he's always bought his presents, literally, months ahead, so there's no opportunity for anyone to make a suggestion closer to the occasion as they're all bought and wrapped! He spends hours on google before we go anywhere to look at, say, a plan of an attraction like a zoo, looking at pictures/videos of it, so that he can "route march" us round it in an efficient manner, planning the optimum route so that we arrive at the food court/cafe around the "right" time for lunch, etc. There's no scope at all for any spontaneity. If he's going to do some DIY, he buys every conceivable tool and material he may need and then takes/sends most of it back unused (of course he checks the returns policy before he orders anything online to make sure he can return it freepost! - he'd never get caught out buying something that he couldn't return or would cost him postage!).

DS is the same. He did his homework on the day it was set, not the night before it was due so was never late with handing anything in, never got a bad score in a test because he'd forgotten to revise, etc. He's always on apps "planning" journeys, planning his day trips to away football matches, etc. - if the journey looks difficult or connections etc are tight, he'll decide not to bother going. He must have picked it up from DH.

'm pretty well organised, but DH and DS are on a different scale of pre-planning, worst case scenario planning, etc. Of course, it means things aren't forgotten, mistakes aren't made, etc., but, by God, it's exhausting living with them, and their constant "withdrawing into their shells" as they concentrate on the minute detail of whatever future event they're obsessing about!

bussteward · 25/03/2023 08:19

DP is a bit like this with planning as he has ADHD (not saying this applies here!) – medication helps but what really helps is he recognises he is like this and takes responsibility for it and puts the effort in to combat his worst tendencies. He would know if he’s working in the morning he wouldn’t be able to multitask and look up the train times, book a taxi and make a plan (note: he’d know what time the toddler napped!), so he’d faff about talking about it for days going over and over the same information look up the train a few days beforehand, put it in his phone as an alarm, look up a taxi number, etc, all during times when he can focus on that. He’d still be running around with his bum on fire seconds before the taxi arrived but he’d be on time for the lunch. His birthday cards to family are always late but he does do them.

Practice saying “I don’t know, what do you think?”, shrugging, “I dunno”, “not right now” and other vague, slightly obstructive responses. You’re not actually being obstructive because you’re protecting you and your time. Someone will be along to tell me this is awful and it’s a marriage and why wouldn’t I help my partner out? But I, like I imagine OP did, bargained on parenting my children and looking after my own needs, plus having a give and take relationship, not “parenting my children and putting my needs second to constantly parent an adult who’s capable of ordering a taxi or buying a card or a million and one other things”. The only way to stop the pattern is to refuse to participate: to shrug and dunno the stupid requests and the lack of planning. If he came to you in advance and asked for a lift, you can say “Yes, it’s during nap time so we need to set off at X o’clock for toddler to fall asleep in the car and I won’t set off later than that, he’ll have a cot nap instead and you’ll have to sort yourself out”. If he comes to you last minute like this, tough. You have plans! A book and a napping child IS a plan.

KnittingNeedles · 25/03/2023 07:59

Arranges to meet at 2pm, takes over an hour to get there, and he's still at home at 1.45?

His poor daughter. Shows how much he values going to see her.

Crumpetdisappointment · 25/03/2023 07:51

i wonder why you didnt discuss with him when he wanted the lift, or he you?
yet you knew his plans?
you said after the nap,
like its a moveable event?

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 25/03/2023 07:50

NeedToChangeName · 25/03/2023 07:23

If I was happy to give a lift to the station, I would have woken the toddler. If you had an older child to pick up from school, you wouldn't leave them waiting at the gate cos toddler was still sleeping

I wouldn't get a mothers day card for MIL. he's a grown adult and should do that himself

A child waiting to be picked up is a regular, predictable event that OP would already know was her responsibility. (I would bet my arse that it's never her DH's ....)

OP, knowing that, would be timing her younger child's nap so as not to interfere with the school pick up.

It's not remotely comparable to a grown man who can't look up a train schedule, or predict that leaving for a 2pm appointment at 1.30 when your travel time is over an hour is going to make you very late.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/03/2023 07:31

I read somewhere years ago habitually late people are optimistic about how long things will take.

Yes, this used to be me absolutely. I was terribly disorganised and regularly very late to meet friends. I was fine to do something like go to work because that was something I could plan for. Be in front of the tv at 6.30. Eat breakfast. Walk the dog for eg 1/2 hour. Leave at x time to arrive by y time.

The only thing, which cured me was a having dd. Her sleep was all over the place and I was a mess. The neighbour suggested Gina Ford, which gave minute by minute instructions. I followed them to the letter. Dd thrived on a strict routine and so did I because life became relatively predictable.

I know people have said to leave your dh to work it out for himself. For me, this is leaving him to ‘adult’ but it’s also leaving the status quo, which is causing conflict. Personally I would have appreciated having a lesson in how to make routines. The one for your dh would have looked a bit like this to work for me:

Plans made, Ask Blue for lift on the day plans are made. Agree a time to leave to get to the station for say a 12.50 train.
12.00 stop work
12.05 get changed
12.15 check wallet and phone
12.20 put shoes and coat on
12.25 get baby in car seat
12.30 leave house

Idk if this is something your dh would be willing to think about?

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 25/03/2023 07:29

Excuse me OP am only on page 1 yet have seen you mention how bad you feel about him running late 3 times.

Most people wouldn't feel bad about somebody else's disorganisation.
Irritated, frustrated, sorry for his DD who will be kept waiting for no reason - yes.
But bad?

How much of this bad feeling is connected to him getting annoyed if I say no to things? ie if you don't step in & compensate for his lack of planning by fixing it for him?

TaunterOfWomenInGeneralSaysSayonarastu · 25/03/2023 07:26

H's wilful refusal to organise himself isn't your problem.
THIS is your problem -
I hesitated as he seemed so stressed and sometimes he gets annoyed if I say no to things.

Can you say more about how he expresses that annoyance, how frequently, & how much it makes you change your own behaviour or plans?

NeedToChangeName · 25/03/2023 07:23

If I was happy to give a lift to the station, I would have woken the toddler. If you had an older child to pick up from school, you wouldn't leave them waiting at the gate cos toddler was still sleeping

I wouldn't get a mothers day card for MIL. he's a grown adult and should do that himself

pencilpot99 · 25/03/2023 06:54

“I remember hearing on some TV show, the mum said "boys can only see 20 mins into the future" and it's something I quote to my husband all the time.”

^ This is BS male propaganda. I have two sons. They are entirely capable of planning ahead, looking up train/bus times and getting themselves ready so as not to be late. They understand how annoying and disrespectful it is to be late for things. And also that unforeseen things can happen that mean having a few extra minutes to hand is a good idea. Being late = bad planning. It’s not “because they’re male and biologically incapable of planning/being able to see into the future” 🙄

MistyFrequencies · 25/03/2023 06:52

Botw1 · 24/03/2023 14:24

You seem to be vastly over thinking this

It's worrying you're so concerned about him being annoyed with you

Agree with this. This is a non issue, he didnt ask in advance, baby sleeping, you just say no. That you are worried enough to make a thread is worrying.

HelloBunny · 25/03/2023 06:44

It’s why I do all of the life admin at home. Don’t want to. But the bills simply wouldn’t be paid of I left him to it. Nothing would get done! It’s really annoying as I work too, and do most of the child-rearing.

WitheredandOld · 25/03/2023 06:33

My DH is the same. I caught myself last weekend rescuing him because he has very little concept of time. If I’d said nothing he would have been over an hour late. I let this happen most of the time but sometimes can’t help but wade in.

ASimpleLampoon · 25/03/2023 06:10

Massively disrespectful of his DD's time and to you

I would say dont rescue him and let him work it out. Up to him if he learns or not.

I am ND confirmed autistic and suspected ADHD and am not naturally organised. It takes a lot of effort for me to get things right but i do. I am so fed up of hearing of men who do nothing to help themselves leaving others to solve the problems they cause.

iloveeverykindofcat · 25/03/2023 05:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

user1492757084 · 25/03/2023 05:39

Calmly react the same way, should it happens again.
Over time DH will understand more about planning and also that calling you selfish gets him no where.

mathanxiety · 25/03/2023 03:59

BluetheBear · 24/03/2023 14:26

@Botw1 Yes this is part of it when it comes to thinks likes lifts and I was surprised when he said it's fine as he's called a taxi but I did wonder how he'd be if the taxi didn't arrive on time. I'm not scared of him but he makes a big deal and it's not nice if he decides it's my fault and I'm just being selfish. He can be like that sometimes!

You need to turn that around on him.

His lack of forethought is the selfish element here.

He gets to simply not engage his brain but then dumps his problems in your lap with no thought to how that ends up inconveniencing you.

It's selfish to be so lazy and it's self centered to assume you're there to pick up the pieces for him.

YoungBritishPissArtist · 25/03/2023 03:02

BluetheBear · 24/03/2023 14:24

I don't want MIL not to get a card but yes you are right!

I refuse to do it for the whole family.

Your DH needs to take responsibility for sending his mum cards. He could easily have done the Moonpig order, I’m guessing it took a matter of minutes.

OP, if he can be a functional adult in the workplace; he can be one at home.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 25/03/2023 01:44

He's quite OK with you opting out and leaving him to it. He won't hold it against you.

You might be. He clearly is not - read what the OP has written about him getting angry and saying she is selfish for not helping.

JudgeRudy · 25/03/2023 01:05

Some things to consider (from someone similarly afflicted)
He does get stressed but it looks worse to an outsider as your using his sticatto talk n flying arms as a gauge. He's much calmer inside but it can look alarming.
He doesn't expect you to bail him out, but he'll ask coz you might.
If you do help it mustvbe free help. He'll likely be nice to you another time coz he loves you, but he doesn't want you to tell him the baby will cry/daughterr will wonder where he is...he knows. Either help or don't
He's quite OK with you opting out and leaving him to it. He won't hold it against you.
It won't teach him a lesson. This is how he is
You cannot change another person's behavior. Just don't let it affect you. Learn to switch off.

user1477391263 · 25/03/2023 00:22

Deffo, let him deal with it.

We (mothers) all struggled with organizing the demands of parenthood when we were first dropped into it, because wrangling little kids is hard, but we got on with it and learned how to think ahead, plan backwards in your head, think in terms of meals and naps and work around these things, and so on. Your husband has probably been slower to learn because you (like so many of us) have probably been rescuing him a bit too often! Let him get dropped in the shit, he’ll learn. We all did!

Notamum12345577 · 24/03/2023 23:31

Out of interest, is the toddler his or from a previous relationship? Only ask because if his, and he doesn’t know how long nap time is, or when toddler needs feeding, sounds like he could be leaving too much up to you to deal with