Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the majority of teenagers would benefit from going away to boarding school

215 replies

Covidisstillanissue · 24/03/2023 09:08

I’m just musing based off those who I know personally. Clearly, this is unlikely to ever become a widespread idea but thinking hypothetically. Also, while I think for the majority of teenagers this would be beneficial it wouldn’t be for everyone.
First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised. I think with boarding often you become far more independent than your peers who live at home and go to day school.
Secondly, socially I think it would be beneficial as they live with their friends and often form far stronger friendships and (tied in with independence) a bit more maturity in terms of how they deal with their friendships. In schools nowadays it feels like parents and pastoral staff are constantly dragged in to even the most minor disputes between friends, sometimes with kids age 15/16 - an age you would expect them to be gearing up to be behaving more like adults.
To be clear, I do not think that boarding school is good for children under the age of about 13 (year 9) however, for teenagers I do think they would benefit.
There’s other things I could say but overall Aibu to think that for most teenagers boarding school would be beneficial?

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 24/03/2023 09:29

I am not anti boarding but no I don’t think boarding would have helped me.

The boarding near us the children have homework clubs, sports etc all until 7pm then straight to dinner. Including on Saturdays

I went past them the other day and thought my god it really is non stop and they are training them also militarily to work work work and fill their days. Whilst this would be hugely beneficial for many and is nearly a different breed - the one thing I am so proud of about my upbringing and education is that I learnt how to learn by myself with no input. In evenings when I needed to do homework or coursework, no one to copy or take lead from, no one to assist or encourage, no one to tell me to or block a time to do anything so if I procrastinate it’s my problem to deal with.

I consider myself a self starter, happy with my own company and can sit and do nothing without anxiety without having to fill my days. These are all important traits I wish to pass to my son. And I don’t think boarding would necessarily instill these.

GOODCAT · 24/03/2023 09:28

Agree with the person above who said that independence can be achieved without sending a child to boarding school.

I got it by being able to work as a child and generally by being able to get myself to places. I was also expected to do my share of jobs around the home.

My neighbours kids are just like this and are great. Others seem to never go anywhere without their parents, don't do anything like paper rounds and their parents run themselves ragged to do everything at home too.

Brefugee · 24/03/2023 09:28

I went to boarding school

I hated so much of it. The food, always having someone around all the time
just - urgh

ladygindiva · 24/03/2023 09:28

BeetyAxe · 24/03/2023 09:15

No I don’t think most teens would benefit from it. I think most teens would benefit from proper parenting, being given responsibility in the home and at school, taking part in physical activities, reading a variety of fact and fiction, and having part time jobs. All that would teach them how to behave as adults and to hopefully grow into mature reasonable adults who can think for themselves. No school is a substitute for proper parenting and life experience.

This. My brother is still scarred from his two term boarding experience. I was too young to be sent thankfully, parents worked abroad.

alexaisrising · 24/03/2023 09:28

The points you raise are valid in regards to ensuring greater independence, less infantilising etc.

Assuming that boarding school is the route to improve this is batshit crazy. Can't we just parent differently?

The 4 most emotionally repressed people with the worst relationships with their family I know all went to boarding school. Their adult lives reek of what they went through.

You might improve independence but it will come at a cost of something else for young developing children.

premicrois · 24/03/2023 09:28

Oh dear OP, good luck! Mumsnet is full to the brim of posters OUTRAGED at the notion of boarding school,

I mean it's just a discussion, nobody is OUTRAGED

Cheeseandlobster · 24/03/2023 09:27

Yes. Strong bonds with your friends until you all leave and your support network doesn't exist anymore. I think leaving boarding school and all you have known could actually be classed as trauma

PeekAtYou · 24/03/2023 09:27

My kids were surprised when they went to uni and met people who weren't uni ready in terms of self care. They moaned about having to practice those skills as they grew up but knowing stuff like how to change a duvet cover or cook will hopefully gave meant more time for fun and a nicer quality of life during term time because they didn't actively have to think about it and it was more automatic .

Maybe it's time for uni readiness to be considered as important as reception readiness?

My kids would not have benefitted from boarding school. This is primarily because teen friendships are hard and 24/7 thanks to technology so a break from that at home was considered a massive relief for them. I actually went to boarding school and a room on your own wasn't an option until year 13. My kids like to be left on their own for some peace sometimes.

StillMedusa · 24/03/2023 09:27

No.
I've parented 4 kids to adulthood. Oddly enough they can cook, budget,work travel independently (barring youngest who has special needs) without ever being sent away.
They also had us to turn to when life felt rough, when they needed help to cope with teen stuff, or when they needed someone who loved them to say no, you can't do that.

They are all close as adults, and we have a lovely relationship with all of them. Because we parented.

I dated a guy who had spent his entire childhood boarding and he was unbelievably repressed. Independent, yes, but not in a way I'd want for my family.

WarmWinterSun · 24/03/2023 09:27

The solution to poor parenting is not to send children away to boarding school.

GrouchyKiwi · 24/03/2023 09:27

Mincedpies · 24/03/2023 09:25

Oh dear OP, good luck! Mumsnet is full to the brim of posters OUTRAGED at the notion of boarding school, despite never having attended one themselves. And yet most will claim to know, or indeed be married to someone who attended boarding by school and will spend a decent amount of time regaling you with how damaged they are as a result.

Which is mostly made up internet bullshit but that’s the way Mumsnet is I’m afraid.

But to give you a response from someone who DID go to boarding school (and from a younger age than 13!) I think your suggestion is an excellent one. I and all my peers who attended boarding school loved it and grew as individuals so much more than my non boarding school friends. I think more children should have the experience, I really do.

Haha, this is funny coming directly after my post. Grin

Mincedpies · 24/03/2023 09:25

Oh dear OP, good luck! Mumsnet is full to the brim of posters OUTRAGED at the notion of boarding school, despite never having attended one themselves. And yet most will claim to know, or indeed be married to someone who attended boarding by school and will spend a decent amount of time regaling you with how damaged they are as a result.

Which is mostly made up internet bullshit but that’s the way Mumsnet is I’m afraid.

But to give you a response from someone who DID go to boarding school (and from a younger age than 13!) I think your suggestion is an excellent one. I and all my peers who attended boarding school loved it and grew as individuals so much more than my non boarding school friends. I think more children should have the experience, I really do.

GrouchyKiwi · 24/03/2023 09:25

Absolutely not.

DH went to a boarding school. He was horribly bullied and still bears the scars even though he's nearly 40. There's never enough oversight, and being thrown in full time with people you wouldn't necessarily choose as friends isn't good for emotional health.

Nevermind31 · 24/03/2023 09:25

Isn’t this what uni does?

RudsyFarmer · 24/03/2023 09:24

865Code · 24/03/2023 09:22

No. Parents just need to actually parent, support their children but encourage age appropriate independence. Family life is important and teens need guidance from parents. If you have to send them away to become functioning humans, something is wrong.

Absolutely. Parents need to actually parent their children and stop buying them electric babysitters and trying to be their best friends.

Greenfinch7 · 24/03/2023 09:24

IF you are at home as you go through the process of becoming an adult you have to deal with the messiness, complexity and truth of life with people you love . At boarding school you are at once protected from sincere emotion by a bunch of rules and traditions and hierarchies, and also the victim of those same things. No one actually loves you, so you have to figure out a way to cope with the coldness and meaninglessness of life at a moment when you are not ready to do that, emotionally- the results are leading our country

Iguessyourestuckwithme · 24/03/2023 09:24

I went to boarding school and remember having to share my room with my bullies and being forced up against a door with a chair. And this is presocial media bullying.

So NO.

WhatALightbulbMoment · 24/03/2023 09:23

I think it's really weird to separate children and teenagers from their families for their education. Children need their parents around until they're in their late teens in my experience. There's this idea that some people have that schools are responsible for everything children should be taught. That's just not the case. Basic manners, independence, self confidence etc. are all things that teenagers learn primarily at home, from their family. Sending kids to boarding school is basically a cop out for the parents.

RudsyFarmer · 24/03/2023 09:23

am so self reliant that I can't cry - 11 year old me realized early on that no one is going to help, it won't change anything, what's the point. In my dreams I often cry as an emotional outlet, but haven't cried irl for the last 12 years. It is very emotionally damaging in my opinion.

I posted my reply, then read yours. My OH said exactly the sane to me. You learn very early on that crying is futile. So you stop.

865Code · 24/03/2023 09:22

No. Parents just need to actually parent, support their children but encourage age appropriate independence. Family life is important and teens need guidance from parents. If you have to send them away to become functioning humans, something is wrong.

Spendonsend · 24/03/2023 09:22

I am not sure I equate boarding with independence though? I mean they arent using public transport to get to and from school, their time can be quite structured - like supper is at x, lights out at y, tonight is games night, prep is until 6 etc with supervision. I also dont think they independently sort out friendship issues. The pastoral staff at boarding do that with them. The have boarding house parents, pastoral leads and so on. They are possibly better equipped to sort out issues than parents but its intense support.

Phoebo · 24/03/2023 09:22

I think alot of dodgy sexual 'stuff' happens at boarding schools for that reason alone YABU. But as far as learning independence goes, that's only going to happen at boarding school if your own parents are useless. In fact, boarding school is only going to be better if your parents are useless....

RudsyFarmer · 24/03/2023 09:21

Im
also with someone who went to boarding school from seven. Never seen this man cry in eleven years. Not one drop even when both parents died. If you want another generation of emotionally shut down adults then crack on.

IndiganDop · 24/03/2023 09:21

I went to boarding school. I enjoyed it. I certainly became very independent.

I am so self reliant that I can't cry - 11 year old me realized early on that no one is going to help, it won't change anything, what's the point. In my dreams I often cry as an emotional outlet, but haven't cried irl for the last 12 years. It is very emotionally damaging in my opinion.

All of mine are at or went to local schools.

My uni kid rings me up to ask how to use the washing machine or oven. I love that he doesn't feel abandoned to have to learn to cope alone in the way I did.

EdgeOfACoin · 24/03/2023 09:21

No I don't.

I think most teenagers could benefit from better relationships with their parents. I also think parents should recognise that teenagers still need their guidance and protection as they become independent.

I've spent enough time with people who went to boarding school. Put me off the idea of ever sending my own children to one (although I loved the idea when I was a child reading the St Clare's and Malory Towers school books!)