Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the majority of teenagers would benefit from going away to boarding school

215 replies

Covidisstillanissue · 24/03/2023 09:08

I’m just musing based off those who I know personally. Clearly, this is unlikely to ever become a widespread idea but thinking hypothetically. Also, while I think for the majority of teenagers this would be beneficial it wouldn’t be for everyone.
First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised. I think with boarding often you become far more independent than your peers who live at home and go to day school.
Secondly, socially I think it would be beneficial as they live with their friends and often form far stronger friendships and (tied in with independence) a bit more maturity in terms of how they deal with their friendships. In schools nowadays it feels like parents and pastoral staff are constantly dragged in to even the most minor disputes between friends, sometimes with kids age 15/16 - an age you would expect them to be gearing up to be behaving more like adults.
To be clear, I do not think that boarding school is good for children under the age of about 13 (year 9) however, for teenagers I do think they would benefit.
There’s other things I could say but overall Aibu to think that for most teenagers boarding school would be beneficial?

OP posts:
WordtoYoMumma · 24/03/2023 09:50

Hey there, you've hit puberty now, yeh it's all sorts of confusing and scary, your hormones are all over the place, you feel angry and lost, sad sometimes and you don't know why. Yes we know you are at a vulnerable time in your life where the risk of low self esteem, mental health issues, self harm and eating disorders are at their highest, but what we're gonna do is tell you your parents don't want you living with them anymore, so you can learn to pick up laundry and make soup. That'll end well.

MatildaTheCat · 24/03/2023 09:49

My father was part of a scheme in the late 1940s that gave children the opportunity to experience boarding school for one year. State run. Obviously completely optional.

It sounded quite a tough regime but it was an enjoyable experience that stayed with him all his life and definitely expanded his horizons which were, as was normal then, quite limited.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 24/03/2023 09:47

You’re right in respect that it teaches them independence and builds their self confidence. They also learn how to interact and network effectively

😂😂😂🙄

All mine who went to state school are like that. Such a silly statement.

Skyliner1 · 24/03/2023 09:47

It absolutely wouldn't be good for my DD. She needs to have home where she can come and get away from school and friends. She finds socialising difficult and having nowhere to be alone, not being able to come home and talk to us about her problems would be very difficult for her.

GobbieMaggie · 24/03/2023 09:45

You’re right in respect that it teaches them independence and builds their self confidence. They also learn how to interact and network effectively. My husband went to public school and he had to learn two languages and a musical instrument. Heavy on sport too.

But it’s ruinously expensive and selective. Harry only got into Eton because of who he was. He wouldn’t have stood a chance otherwise.

Bramshott · 24/03/2023 09:41

Your statement is far too sweeping OP - how you can you possibly know what's best for the 'majority of teenagers'. If you'd said "AIBU to think that going away to boarding schools can sometimes be a positive experience for teenagers older than 13", many more people would have been willing to listen and engage with your arguments.

Simonjt · 24/03/2023 09:40

My husband attended boarding school, he didn’t have a name, he had a number, he had no privacy, he couldn’t even dress, wash or use the toilet in private, he was relentlessly bullied, his belongings were stolen or destroyed and his clothing regularly hidden. How did this benefit him?

Brefugee · 24/03/2023 09:37

also don't underestimate the effect on parents. I was at boarding school due to being a military family, and there is no doubt that i benefitted HUGELY from a stable (and good, independent school) education. That is not in doubt in my mind.

However, my parents really missed me, i missed them and in hindsight we might have muddled through with my schooling anyway.

What the actual boarding part did? (i cry, so i'm not repressed - although maybe i cry more because of school? who knows. I did a lot of crying there and at various airports and train stations). What it did is make me good at communal living and generally knowing how to let things go that aren't deal breakers, and how to address things that are. I learned how to stand up to bullies, and how to call out my peers who were bullies or exhibiting bullying behaviour.

I learned how to keep secrets. I learned the value of good friendships and teamwork. I am still in touch with my good friends from school and we were there in the 70s/80s.

I learned how to choke down food that i don't really like, if it was the choice between that and going to bed hungry. I learned how to make the contents of my tuck box last a whole term, and how to share a tray of delicious food (which we occasionally got) so everyone got their fair share. And how to share a tray of horrible food so the younger ones weren't bullied into eating more (we were disciplined by lecture if we didn't eat all our food). I learned, from the dining room, how to negotiate deals ("the rest of your jug of milk for the rest of our butter and jam" type of thing)

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 24/03/2023 09:36

Or perhaps i stead of taking the easy option parents could start actually parenting and teaching their kids how to be self sufficient, capable and worthwhile adults?

ACynicalDad · 24/03/2023 09:36

I'm far from convinced it is for everyone. It can have huge value for children from troubled homes, or in kinship care, grandparents and aunts/uncles may cope with these kids for holidays when full-time care is not practical. Sadly most boarding schools use their charitable requirements to find bright kids that can push their grade averages up, but taking on these kids and getting them reasonable grades and keeping them out of the care system would be way more charitable.

Bobbybobbins · 24/03/2023 09:36

BeetyAxe · 24/03/2023 09:15

No I don’t think most teens would benefit from it. I think most teens would benefit from proper parenting, being given responsibility in the home and at school, taking part in physical activities, reading a variety of fact and fiction, and having part time jobs. All that would teach them how to behave as adults and to hopefully grow into mature reasonable adults who can think for themselves. No school is a substitute for proper parenting and life experience.

This!

CurlewKate · 24/03/2023 09:35

Also, people often confuse independence and emotional detachment. One is good- the other less good.

Whaeanui · 24/03/2023 09:34

If you’re being bullied at school, you never get a break from it if you’re boarding. It’s horrible.

TomatoSandwiches · 24/03/2023 09:34

I don't know about that but if they made boarding schools for 39yr old mothers of teenagers I'd sign myself up ASAP 😁

TrashyPanda · 24/03/2023 09:34

One of my best friends at school boarded.
he hated it, and it really fucked up his relationship with his parents. He hated his father so much for going to work abroad.

JustHavinABreak · 24/03/2023 09:33

As someone who was sent to boarding school, I think it's a dreadful idea. The scars never ever went away.

MrsBigTed · 24/03/2023 09:33

alexaisrising · 24/03/2023 09:28

The points you raise are valid in regards to ensuring greater independence, less infantilising etc.

Assuming that boarding school is the route to improve this is batshit crazy. Can't we just parent differently?

The 4 most emotionally repressed people with the worst relationships with their family I know all went to boarding school. Their adult lives reek of what they went through.

You might improve independence but it will come at a cost of something else for young developing children.

The points you raise are valid in regards to ensuring greater independence, less infantilising etc.Assuming that boarding school is the route to improve this is batshit crazy. Can't we just parent differently?

I agree with @alexaisrising.

I also think most kids benefit from some time away from their parents - school residentials, club camps (brownies, football etc) and it would be good to make these experiences available to all.

Whaeanui · 24/03/2023 09:33

I went to boarding school from age 13. I hated it. It feels like you’re at school 24:7 with no proper home life. It felt very lonely even with friends around. I concluded for me that it was a completely horrible way to raise your kids and very detached. It is a very English thing to send kids away young too. I would never send my kids away like this. Family life is too important to development and well being.

Mirabai · 24/03/2023 09:32

Rather than making kids more independent it actually makes them less - at boarding school everything is done for you. Time is very structured, including prep lessons, all food is prepared, the cleaners tidy up, you’re not travelling to get to school, and you’re not free on weekends to explore your local area and hang out with kids from different schools, background.

This is all stuff you can learn afterwards but boarding certainly doesn’t teach students independence it simply institutionalises them.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 24/03/2023 09:31

I don't think boarding school supports real independence. Emotional detachment type independence and trust issues possibly. However the day-school pupils are much more likely to develop life skills through being asked to pop in to sainsburys on their way hope from school to pick up a few things, or to cook a meal once or twice a week, or to have daily or weekly chores like unstacking the dishwasher, sorting out the bins and recycling and taking a turn cleaning the family bathroom - whereas I am sure that boarding school pupils would rarely have this kind of input into the mechanics of running a household.

I'm sure there are some older teens who enjoy aspects of boarding but it's a long way off the majority. What the majority need is a really supportive and reliable loving parental home which yes they might be starting to rebel against and be starting to find too restrictive, but releasing them from it into an environment where they don't have their parents looking out for them isn't the right solution to that. What someone wants isn't always what they need.

Grimbelina · 24/03/2023 09:31

I boarded. Apart from the very serious sexual and other abuse that took place, there were absolutely no attempts to teach any life skills at all. All laundry and cooking was done for you for instance.

As multiple PPs have said, good and engaged parenting, encouraging independence from the home, part time jobs, teaching children to navigate actual life, not the artificial environment of boarding, is what is important.

I also think it is incredibly important that my children have conversations with multiple adults in a relaxed atmosphere and can share any worries they have rather than just speak with (a very homogenised group of) peers or a housemistress/master.

Ponoka7 · 24/03/2023 09:30

What was the demographic of the school you worked in? I don't recognise the teens described on here. I live in Liverpool, in a low income area. Teens pitch in with the family, they have to get street smart (I'm already teaching my primary GC about knife crime), they don't get taxied about ( most people don't have cars), they could be left at home from 16 etc etc. If the MC aren't churning out responsible teens, that's on them.

GOODCAT · 24/03/2023 09:30

BeetyAxe · 24/03/2023 09:15

No I don’t think most teens would benefit from it. I think most teens would benefit from proper parenting, being given responsibility in the home and at school, taking part in physical activities, reading a variety of fact and fiction, and having part time jobs. All that would teach them how to behave as adults and to hopefully grow into mature reasonable adults who can think for themselves. No school is a substitute for proper parenting and life experience.

Completely agree with this

alexaisrising · 24/03/2023 09:30

RudsyFarmer · 24/03/2023 09:23

am so self reliant that I can't cry - 11 year old me realized early on that no one is going to help, it won't change anything, what's the point. In my dreams I often cry as an emotional outlet, but haven't cried irl for the last 12 years. It is very emotionally damaging in my opinion.

I posted my reply, then read yours. My OH said exactly the sane to me. You learn very early on that crying is futile. So you stop.

My best friend says EXACTLY the same about giving up on anyone being there for them and suppressing all emotion as a child.

MumofSpud · 24/03/2023 09:30

But as others have said at boarding schools you aren't independent at all - meals cooked / cleaning done for you / even set time for homework!

You become emotionally independent and independent from family but that's not what you meant!

Swipe left for the next trending thread