Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the majority of teenagers would benefit from going away to boarding school

215 replies

Covidisstillanissue · 24/03/2023 09:08

I’m just musing based off those who I know personally. Clearly, this is unlikely to ever become a widespread idea but thinking hypothetically. Also, while I think for the majority of teenagers this would be beneficial it wouldn’t be for everyone.
First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised. I think with boarding often you become far more independent than your peers who live at home and go to day school.
Secondly, socially I think it would be beneficial as they live with their friends and often form far stronger friendships and (tied in with independence) a bit more maturity in terms of how they deal with their friendships. In schools nowadays it feels like parents and pastoral staff are constantly dragged in to even the most minor disputes between friends, sometimes with kids age 15/16 - an age you would expect them to be gearing up to be behaving more like adults.
To be clear, I do not think that boarding school is good for children under the age of about 13 (year 9) however, for teenagers I do think they would benefit.
There’s other things I could say but overall Aibu to think that for most teenagers boarding school would be beneficial?

OP posts:
megletthesecond · 24/03/2023 11:07

I often think this. DS is at army cadets with boarding school kids and he likes the idea of it. From what I've seen there's a lot to be said for part time boarding during the teen years for teens who would like to do it.

AskAwayAgain · 24/03/2023 11:06

If you are terrible at parenting your child might be better at boarding school. Otherwise it is a terrible idea.

AskAwayAgain · 24/03/2023 11:05

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 24/03/2023 10:52

The option for local, weekly boarding/home at weekends at 6th form level would be a really good, gentle ease in to uni independence.

It is not. I did this and had less independence at school and knew more about taking care of myself than my fellow pupils did.

MrsOrange · 24/03/2023 11:03

But isn't becoming independent and living with your mates what university or first jobs are for? Surely the issue is given cost of university or cost of living young adults aren't moving on to independence at 18/20ish?

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 11:01

Boris Johnson is a prime example of boarding school kid.

He's a self-interested narcissist who apparently doesn't respect himself and he respects other people even less. Look how he's treated women over the years.

RedHelenB · 24/03/2023 11:00

Boarding schools are very institutionalised. Everything on tap, you don't naked your own tea, navigate going to a concert with friends etc etc
I think the opposite of what you are saying is true, apart from those with really helicopter parents

bamboonights · 24/03/2023 10:58

Pseudonamed · 24/03/2023 09:16

No I think if people want to subcontract out their parenting they should revise having children.

Agree.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:55

Tinypetunia · 24/03/2023 10:50

Hard to believe the number of posters who seem to think that only children from disfunctional families benefit from boarding. Lots of children from perfectly normal, loving families are boarders.

Do you know any personally?

None of my friends who went to boarding school came from dysfunctional families but most of them were dysfunctional in some way by the time they left boarding school.

bigdecisionstomake · 24/03/2023 10:55

My DP went to boarding school from age 11. It is responsible for the majority of the problems in his life now. YABVVVVVVU.

I'm sure some kids benefit but like everything in life there is no one size fits all and boarding schools definitely do not/would not benefit every teenager - in some cases they cause extreme emotional harm.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:54

oldwhyno · 24/03/2023 10:43

It's completely alien to the vast majority of people so it's always going to be unpopular. But given that probably less than 5% of children actually board, I think it's very interesting that almost 20% of people agree with you on here so far.

If I could afford it, I would offer my kids the chance to do weekly boarding (4/5 nights a week) from age 13, and termly boarding for sixth form.

I'd like to think they'd already be independent enough by then to at least give it due consideration.

Of course they might be independent enough to do it, but why would they want to? I was home, outside, playing with my mates every night when I was 13.

My idea of independence would not have been living at my school. How independent can you really be when you're under the supervision of a boarding school?

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 24/03/2023 10:52

The option for local, weekly boarding/home at weekends at 6th form level would be a really good, gentle ease in to uni independence.

Tinypetunia · 24/03/2023 10:50

Hard to believe the number of posters who seem to think that only children from disfunctional families benefit from boarding. Lots of children from perfectly normal, loving families are boarders.

Lamelie · 24/03/2023 10:49

Not the majority no, but there are benefits for some kids.

Greenolivetrees · 24/03/2023 10:48

I think the problem is more that too many parents don't understand that their job as parents is to teach their children to be independant and well rounded people by the time they're 18. It's an 18 year long process, not mollycoddling them till 17 and 3/4 and then tell them to figure it out because their age suddenly makes them adults.

AskAwayAgain · 24/03/2023 10:46

If your family is dysfunctional or abusive boarding school is better. But for children from normal loving families institutional care is not the answer.

carriedout · 24/03/2023 10:43

Tinypetunia · 24/03/2023 10:26

Boarding schools have changed massively since the era of boarding school syndrome. If pupils have any issues now, they're straight on the phone to their parents. Boarding schools are businesses - if the pupils are not happy, they can't function. My granddaughter goes to one and she loves it. She has the choice of either sleeping at school or coming home. She usually sleeps over a couple of nights a week. Most boarding schools today have the same options.

Those options only exist for the kids who are local.

Maybe your in your GD's case being away from the family home is better, and in some families that will always be the case, but the family is the global norm for good and proven psychological reasons.

oldwhyno · 24/03/2023 10:43

It's completely alien to the vast majority of people so it's always going to be unpopular. But given that probably less than 5% of children actually board, I think it's very interesting that almost 20% of people agree with you on here so far.

If I could afford it, I would offer my kids the chance to do weekly boarding (4/5 nights a week) from age 13, and termly boarding for sixth form.

I'd like to think they'd already be independent enough by then to at least give it due consideration.

Shabang21 · 24/03/2023 10:40

I used to work in a boarding school pre-dc’s. The grounds and buildings were gorgeous, the teaching and pastoral staff were lovely and the house parents were incredibly kind. Regardless of all that, the majority of kids there felt abandoned, had real problems with self-esteem and attention seeking, and did not have a great relationship with their parents. All the staff were aware of it and tried their best to negate it, but there’s only so much a parent-substitute can do. I didn’t know a single member of staff who would have considered sending their own children to board. Not one.

There is no way in hell I would send my DC’s to one - I can teach them to be self-sufficient without them feeling abandoned.

Grimbelina · 24/03/2023 10:32

Boarding schools have changed massively since the era of boarding school syndrome. If pupils have any issues now, they're straight on the phone to their parents. Boarding schools are businesses - if the pupils are not happy, they can't function. My granddaughter goes to one and she loves it. She has the choice of either sleeping at school or coming home. She usually sleeps over a couple of nights a week. Most boarding schools today have the same options.

That is great for your granddaughter, but I know from talking to current boarders and parents that many of the same issues that I experienced 30 years ago are ongoing: abuse, bullying etc. etc. and some of the parents of boys who are suffering are leaving the boys in that situation because the don't want to move them as it will interfere with their own lives (amongst other reasons). It is incredibly sad.

Simonjt · 24/03/2023 10:31

Tinypetunia · 24/03/2023 10:26

Boarding schools have changed massively since the era of boarding school syndrome. If pupils have any issues now, they're straight on the phone to their parents. Boarding schools are businesses - if the pupils are not happy, they can't function. My granddaughter goes to one and she loves it. She has the choice of either sleeping at school or coming home. She usually sleeps over a couple of nights a week. Most boarding schools today have the same options.

15 years isn’t a huge amount of time, my husbands little brother now goes to the same school, it certainly doesn’t seem to have changed since he left, if anything its worse as instances of SA are now filmed.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:30

I know quite a few boarding school kids and they're invariably damaged in some way.

It's not all bad though, they're generally well educated enough and have the self awareness to understand and rationalise exactly how boarding school damaged them.

Brefugee · 24/03/2023 10:30

Being on her period have an acident and having to give to someone else to wash it that she doesn't know, while she would prefer to wash it, dry it and manage it herself.

Mine was a girls school with day pupils too, and the number of times we helped out day girls with hygiene supplies, spare pants sometimes, helping them get cleaned up etc, are without count. (and their mums often sent us nice treats as a thank you) That wasn't an issue

When I went to boarding school we had to do housekeeping chores for ourselves and the larger group such as laundry and cleaning the dorms and day rooms.

same. We had to wash up after every meal except lunch (but lunch at weekends too) and clean the dining room. We had to clean the dorms and bathrooms after use, but there were cleaners who did the toilets and ablutions properly.

We did have midnight feasts though, and just general silliness that the day girls didn't have.

Independence? in many ways yes, and in other ways, no. For eg most of us flew in and out of the country and had to make our way from the airport, across London, and then on the train to our town and then get to the school (bus for preference because most parents gave us taxi money)
We got pocket money - parents sent it to school and we had to request how much we wanted in any given week. So budgeting was a thing.
We had to wash our own clothes (by hand) and so on, so we learned how to do that.
But i do miss that i don't have a fantastic sibling relationship because we were at different schools and didn't really grow up together outside holidays (and there weren't many family holidays because boarding school is expensive, even with grants)

AskAwayAgain · 24/03/2023 10:29

MorningMoaner · 24/03/2023 10:21

My teenage niece is currently at a well known boarding school. The single thing she dislikes about it most is the lack of independence and self determination.
My DD shared a flat with a girl who had boarded when she started University. Her flat mate could do nothing domestically speaking. She didn't know how to cook simple meals or wash her own clothes. She'd had it all done for her at school since she was 11 and when she was home in the holidays her parents pampered her because they'd missed her and she never had to lift a finger. She followed my DD round like a little lost sheep unable to look after herself for ages.
It's certainly not guaranteed that boarding fosters practical independence.
From my observations of lots of friends and family members who have boarded I'd say it fosters emotional detachment which might come across as independence but that's not something I wanted to encourage in my children.

I 100% agree with this. I went to Boarding School at 16, I had way less independence and was shocked at basic things the other kids did not know.

AskAwayAgain · 24/03/2023 10:27

You think putting children into institutional care is better for them than being with their family?

Tinypetunia · 24/03/2023 10:26

OldBaguette · 24/03/2023 10:19

This.

Boarding schools have changed massively since the era of boarding school syndrome. If pupils have any issues now, they're straight on the phone to their parents. Boarding schools are businesses - if the pupils are not happy, they can't function. My granddaughter goes to one and she loves it. She has the choice of either sleeping at school or coming home. She usually sleeps over a couple of nights a week. Most boarding schools today have the same options.