Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the majority of teenagers would benefit from going away to boarding school

215 replies

Covidisstillanissue · 24/03/2023 09:08

I’m just musing based off those who I know personally. Clearly, this is unlikely to ever become a widespread idea but thinking hypothetically. Also, while I think for the majority of teenagers this would be beneficial it wouldn’t be for everyone.
First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised. I think with boarding often you become far more independent than your peers who live at home and go to day school.
Secondly, socially I think it would be beneficial as they live with their friends and often form far stronger friendships and (tied in with independence) a bit more maturity in terms of how they deal with their friendships. In schools nowadays it feels like parents and pastoral staff are constantly dragged in to even the most minor disputes between friends, sometimes with kids age 15/16 - an age you would expect them to be gearing up to be behaving more like adults.
To be clear, I do not think that boarding school is good for children under the age of about 13 (year 9) however, for teenagers I do think they would benefit.
There’s other things I could say but overall Aibu to think that for most teenagers boarding school would be beneficial?

OP posts:
PEARLJAM123 · 24/03/2023 18:39

Have you been watching a lot of Malory Towers?

anon666 · 24/03/2023 18:37

It might seem so but no, I think it can be really harmful.

So many men in particular are emotionally damaged and stunted from boarding school that there's a terms for it "boarding school syndrome".

Not saying it's a hard no - everyone is different. But your question was whether they all inevitably benefit. To which I would say not necessarily.

LittleLegsKeepGoing · 24/03/2023 18:27

My 15 year old cooks, cleans, helps with laundry and does a paper round at 6am 5 days a week. She also regularly travels around the city centre using trains or buses.

When she finishes school she gets to come home to a loving and secure environment where she's welcome to invite friends if she wants.

I really can't see how boarding school would be an improvement on any of that.

YABU to think that boarding school is beneficial outside the circles where knowing the right people is more important than ability...and frankly most aspiring teens wouldn't fit in because their family net worth makes them unattractive companions.

MistySkiesAreGone · 24/03/2023 18:18

I went to private school on an academic scholarship as a day pupil and I did a term of boarding aged 11 and aged 15 and it was great for independence. However it's bloody expensive and at the time pastoral care at private school was not great. I think there are other ways - there used to be the citizenship scheme where young people could do residentials over the summer etc.

blickgeek · 24/03/2023 18:13

It's also important to consider that sometimes the home environment may be far from ideal. So boarding school might be a better option.

JMSA · 24/03/2023 18:11

If you need a couple of guinea pigs to test your theory, my teenage daughters are up for grabs Grin

blickgeek · 24/03/2023 18:11

EffortlessDesmond · 24/03/2023 17:57

I think @blickgeek has outlined the benefits well. About half the people I know well and consider friends went to boarding schools (mostly service families often deployed overseas, so for continuity of education). We're all competent and self-reliant and emotionally independent. My DH can still cry and has friends from 50 years ago. Skills like laundry, shopping and cleaning are hardly difficult to learn at university. It doesn't work for everyone, acknowledged, but there is actually some value in learning young that the world doesn't revolve around any one individual and in impartial discipline for the good of the community. "It isn't fair" gets nowhere as a complaint if the rules are uniformly applied. You learn quickly that you are not more special than anyone else to the house parents, and it's very nice to go home where you are special.

Thanks. I wasn't sure if my post resonates with others.

Do you think that whole thing about just being able to pick up and go and fit anywhere is something that is specific to people that went to boarding school ?

Timesawastin · 24/03/2023 18:09

Merrow · 24/03/2023 09:12

I'm married to someone who went to boarding school. YABU.

So am I. And I don't think it did him any harm.

Season0fTheWitch · 24/03/2023 18:06

Boarding school nearly killed me, and many of my friends from school are now severely mentally damaged, some dead and others with highly successful lives but no family. I'd rather send my kids to school ran by children than to a boarding school.

Aethelred · 24/03/2023 17:59

You can build independence at home (and boarding school is often very structured and regimented so not necessarily promoting independence in many things). You can build family ties as well as socialisation with friends at home. You don't need to live with friends to socialise with them. If there are children who bully them, they can escape it more easily in a home away from them. I would prefer to be there to support and guide my children myself. I prefer to parent / bring up my own children. Other people are free to do what they think suits their children best as I am sure that there are different perspectives and positives. Different children will thrive in different environments and some children would not suit boarding school.

EffortlessDesmond · 24/03/2023 17:57

I think @blickgeek has outlined the benefits well. About half the people I know well and consider friends went to boarding schools (mostly service families often deployed overseas, so for continuity of education). We're all competent and self-reliant and emotionally independent. My DH can still cry and has friends from 50 years ago. Skills like laundry, shopping and cleaning are hardly difficult to learn at university. It doesn't work for everyone, acknowledged, but there is actually some value in learning young that the world doesn't revolve around any one individual and in impartial discipline for the good of the community. "It isn't fair" gets nowhere as a complaint if the rules are uniformly applied. You learn quickly that you are not more special than anyone else to the house parents, and it's very nice to go home where you are special.

Zanatdy · 24/03/2023 17:51

My son has got his independence at Uni. He didn’t need to leave home before then to be able to cook or wash his clothes

pinkySilver · 24/03/2023 17:50

I agree OP. I went, my DC went. Great fun. - but people have ridiculous views on boarding school. It's cruel and wicked - apparently. And 16 and 17 year olds are innocent children who must be protected at all costs in their loving families (because all families are loving and wonderful and teach kids properly, right?). - And yet at 18 they are adults and should go away and their parents MUST not interfere or help them out because they are ADULTS! 😂

MooseBreath · 24/03/2023 17:16

Those I know who went to boarding school were far less independent than those who didn't. The people I know who were boarders are emotionally stunted adults. That's not to say that's the case for everyone, it's purely anecdotal from my experience.

Frankly, I think parents need to step it up and teach basic life skills like cooking, cleaning, DIY, and budgeting. All information is readily available online if parents don't know it themselves. Schools are relied upon far too heavily.

user764329056 · 24/03/2023 17:13

Have met loads of people in life who were boarding school kids, each and every one is fucked up and admit it was a deeply traumatic experience

Popsicle42 · 24/03/2023 17:04

premicrois · 24/03/2023 09:17

Nah, for me independence came from security, not being separated. People often confuse being independent and it's being alone as well. It's not the same thing.

Absolutely this.

Shoppingforclothes · 24/03/2023 17:01

Yabu. Don't know anything about boarding school and certainly do not like the idea.

But why can't kids learn independence living at home? I accept that teens are a bit more cooped up these days in their rooms on gadgets. But they can still learn life skills. Cooking, washing, gardening, cleaning. Helping with shopping. They can get themselves to and from school and go out to meet friends. They could do part time jobs.

Packing teens off on their own to learn the hard way doesn't always end well.

Why do people al why's have to be so down on the younger generations?

blickgeek · 24/03/2023 16:57

I went to boarding school from age 13-18. So exactly the years you're describing. I do think I'm independent and can go anywhere and I'm not afraid for things to end and change. I know that's a really broad thing to say. But sometimes I see people getting emotional about moving house or leaving a job or generally chapters ending. I don't really mind that. I've been really used to it, since I was young. Not sure if that's because of boarding school though.

In terms of independence, I don't know. I was absolutely hopeless when I left school at 18. At school there was a rule for everything and everything was very controlled and regimented. I found it really difficult to sort myself out without these rules and do normal adult stuff. I'm not sure how it would have been, had I been at home. I was very rebellious at school..

Going to uni was an absolute doddle for me, as I was so used to living away and it was basically like school but without the rules. I found it very difficult to be responsible with money etc and missed classes a lot. Again, I don't know how it would have been, had i stayed at home for school.

I think my school could have given us slightly more autonomy to set us up for the big wide world. But again, I had lots of friends who didn't mess around like I did once they left school. They just got on with it. So this could just be my personality.

The only thing I can say is that I'm not afraid of many social situations and changes and I would pretty much move / go anywhere if it made sense for my family. I'm not tied anywhere or to anyone really. ( apart from my immediate family ). I do love my parents and I do see them regularly, but I'm just not tied to where they are. I was happy to move around at uni and after and it didn't bother me at all. I know lots of people who didn't board and always stayed in one place who would never do that kind of stuff. They'd miss their families and where they're ' from ' too much. They don't know who they are without their parents / siblings / communities they've grown up in. Whereas I don't feel like that. I have no idea if that is boarding school or just the way I am.

Oh I should add that I was an ' overseas ' student anyway. That may add to how I am too.

Will I send my kids ? Probably not. I want to know what's going on with them day to day and I want to be able here for them to advise them on heartbreaks and problems they face during those teenage years. I was relentlessly bullied at certain points and my parents had no idea.

All in all though, I absolutely loved it. Living with all your friends at that age is just so much fun !

elenacampana · 24/03/2023 16:43

No thank you! I’d rather have my daughter at home with us when she’s a teenager so I can teach her how to care for herself myself. She belongs with us until she’s an adult.

Thesenderofthiscard · 24/03/2023 16:39

'First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised.'

mmm, so that's bullshit. You may be infantilising your teens but that's not how we treat our kids, nor do any of the parents we know.

Your solution is to send kids to an institution where everything is scheduled and decided for them, where every minute of every day is timetabled, and they're handheld through everything? That's a bizarre concept.

If you consider having to learn how to hide emotions 'independence' then you do, but I call it being stunted.

icanneverthinkofnc · 24/03/2023 15:36

Boarding school syndrome is usually quoted on these threads, and yes, for some, it will be a problem. The huge number of kids in state schools with MH issues far exceeds those, though.
If the kids who board attended state, I bet they would still have MH problems, just a different one.

CurlewKate · 24/03/2023 15:04

WalkingOnTheCracks · 24/03/2023 14:05

First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised. I think with boarding often you become far more independent than your peers who live at home and go to day school.

So, regimented schedule. All meals cooked and washed up for you. No decisions to make about anything at all. Loads of rules designed to make it easy to run a home for scores of kids, rather than individuals. No social interaction with anyone other than other people your age.

How does all that make kids independent? I mean, more independent than having to cook for the family once in a while, and do the washing up? Or organising your social life, going to places on your own, getting home on time? Interacting with all sorts of people? Going to the baker's and the cornershop? Learning how to be yourself in a family whilst considering the other members? Having your mum and dad there, in case you need them? Learning how to be a parent by being parented?

Seriously - in short - how do you think that boarding schools make kids independent?

Independence is often code for emotional detachment. Which some people think is a good thing.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 24/03/2023 14:05

First off, I think it would massively benefit them in terms of independence. So many times nowadays teenagers (especially younger teens) are unable to even do the most basic things and are often very infantilised. I think with boarding often you become far more independent than your peers who live at home and go to day school.

So, regimented schedule. All meals cooked and washed up for you. No decisions to make about anything at all. Loads of rules designed to make it easy to run a home for scores of kids, rather than individuals. No social interaction with anyone other than other people your age.

How does all that make kids independent? I mean, more independent than having to cook for the family once in a while, and do the washing up? Or organising your social life, going to places on your own, getting home on time? Interacting with all sorts of people? Going to the baker's and the cornershop? Learning how to be yourself in a family whilst considering the other members? Having your mum and dad there, in case you need them? Learning how to be a parent by being parented?

Seriously - in short - how do you think that boarding schools make kids independent?

CurlewKate · 24/03/2023 13:31

I know you said post 13 only, but I can't help remembering the comedian Marcus Brigstock (who went to boarding school himself) saying that the problem with this country is that it's run by men who has their hearts broken at the age of 7. Haunts me, that does.

Dirtydiesel · 24/03/2023 12:50

I have a 16 year old with a learning disability. I do think it would benefit him to have several nights a week away locally learning how to live in a supported living environment, effectively continuing what he does during the day in school and getting used to not being with us all of the time.