Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:39

Resiliencerequired · 24/03/2023 10:29

NC, I wanted to add a personal experience to this thread.

My teenage daughter plays ladies hockey and there is an opposition player in their South East Oaks league who is a trans women. This player scored five goals over the two matches DD2 played in and it was just a horrible spectacle. They had so many physical advantages (speed, strength etc) over other female players - they stood out from the rest of their team. DD2 and some of the colts (U18) on their team (and some of the ladies too) were so deflated and angry after the game - it’s so hard to keep teenage girls engaged in sport, and going head to head with a biological man is so unfair.

Prior to the game, we were told there was a trans player and the ladies had to be their ‘most inclusive selves’ which is wrong on so many levels. I know the level of hockey is quite low, it’s Division 3 out of 5 or similar, so not national level - but ladies who play grass roots sport deserve the same respect and right to fair play as Olympians !

YANBU that trans women should be able to play sport - but that shouldn’t be competitively in women’s leagues, even at grass roots level. And particularly hockey, which has many opportunities to play mixed.

I lived in Australia for a while where netball is huge. I was part of a women's team which was all mainly for exercise, socialising and a bit of fun. The 'league' (not a league in the true sports sense) became mixed because "some boys were asking to play" and it was a University league so they bowed to the students' demands, so we then had all these mixed sex teams. You then have women aged between mainly 25 - 45 playing against young men who are stronger, fitter, faster. The game that finished it for us was when one of our team got a broken arm from basically being barged over by a man and we were beaten 42-nil. The 'mixed sex' team we were playing had two young women and five men. Their goal shooter and goal keepers were in the 6 foot tall bracket. Two of the guys also played aussie rules football so were totally ripped.

And before anyone says.....you should have just started your own woman-only league - why should we have had to??? Why couldn't it have just stayed as it was ie a woman's only league? It's so demoralising to have so many male apologists who are happy to run rough shod over their own sex.

Beowulfa · 24/03/2023 10:37

Resiliencerequired · 24/03/2023 10:29

NC, I wanted to add a personal experience to this thread.

My teenage daughter plays ladies hockey and there is an opposition player in their South East Oaks league who is a trans women. This player scored five goals over the two matches DD2 played in and it was just a horrible spectacle. They had so many physical advantages (speed, strength etc) over other female players - they stood out from the rest of their team. DD2 and some of the colts (U18) on their team (and some of the ladies too) were so deflated and angry after the game - it’s so hard to keep teenage girls engaged in sport, and going head to head with a biological man is so unfair.

Prior to the game, we were told there was a trans player and the ladies had to be their ‘most inclusive selves’ which is wrong on so many levels. I know the level of hockey is quite low, it’s Division 3 out of 5 or similar, so not national level - but ladies who play grass roots sport deserve the same respect and right to fair play as Olympians !

YANBU that trans women should be able to play sport - but that shouldn’t be competitively in women’s leagues, even at grass roots level. And particularly hockey, which has many opportunities to play mixed.

I'm so sorry your daughter and team mates have been treated like this.

Sports bodies that do this are essentially saying to women and girls:

-you exist only to validate males
-the feelings of males are more important than anything else
-you must never say No to a male

The misogyny is just shameless. Why can't the liberal Left see it for what it is?

FOJN · 24/03/2023 10:36

Resiliencerequired · 24/03/2023 10:29

NC, I wanted to add a personal experience to this thread.

My teenage daughter plays ladies hockey and there is an opposition player in their South East Oaks league who is a trans women. This player scored five goals over the two matches DD2 played in and it was just a horrible spectacle. They had so many physical advantages (speed, strength etc) over other female players - they stood out from the rest of their team. DD2 and some of the colts (U18) on their team (and some of the ladies too) were so deflated and angry after the game - it’s so hard to keep teenage girls engaged in sport, and going head to head with a biological man is so unfair.

Prior to the game, we were told there was a trans player and the ladies had to be their ‘most inclusive selves’ which is wrong on so many levels. I know the level of hockey is quite low, it’s Division 3 out of 5 or similar, so not national level - but ladies who play grass roots sport deserve the same respect and right to fair play as Olympians !

YANBU that trans women should be able to play sport - but that shouldn’t be competitively in women’s leagues, even at grass roots level. And particularly hockey, which has many opportunities to play mixed.

Sharon Davies agrees with you. I doubt she will give up until there is fairness in female sport at all levels of competition.

twitter.com/sharrond62/status/1638974939901448192?s=20

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2023 10:36

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition.

The 'clarification' in brackets reminded me of this!

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.
validnumber · 24/03/2023 10:36

SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 10:32

I've seen a lot of people refer to men, like in the op as transmen.
Just a reminder that as per trans ideology, women who want to be men are transmen and men who want to be women are transwomen.

I feel it's important these words are widely understood as I do feel their meaning is deliberately evasive to play on people's ignorance.

Ifor example polls where the public deem 'transwomen in women's wards' fine might not actually be telling you what it seems on the surface. As the unclear language could mean participants incorrectly thought they were talking about natal women with beards not natal men with penis.
Of course the language is designed this way. To confuse and distort reality.

This is a very good point.
I am not well versed in this area and when I read I have to keep reminding myself what the words mean.

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 10:35

whatkatydid2013 · 24/03/2023 10:31

Honestly I don’t believe the trolls on Twitter posting a load of derogatory hatred about women and thugs who have punched women in the face at protests are representative of the average trans woman. I really don’t want to lower my own behaviour to match the worst individuals in a community. If you think of the people you know in real life who are trans are they anything like that? The few I know aren’t at all. They are decent, hardworking professionals who are feeling pretty worries at the moment about the way the world is. I honestly don’t know if they believe they actually can change sex as it’s not really a topic discussed at work but I’m confident you can hold gender critical beliefs, be appalled by the behaviour of individuals within a group without assuming that’s how everyone in the group thinks/acts.

Perhaps those nice trans people should start campaigning for third spaces so that they can feel safe using toilets and changing rooms etc without using women's spaces.

I mean, it would be good if they could loudly denounce all the people who give the trans community a bad name, but they're not to blame for that behaviour any more than ordinary Muslims are to blame for ISIS.

However, it would be helpful if they could do something to show that they understand that their own rights, safety and dignity shouldn't come at the expense of ours.

SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 10:35

I really don’t want to lower my own behaviour to match the worst individuals in a community.

You've seen lots of women sending rape and decapitation threats then?

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 24/03/2023 10:35

Nothing helpful to add but just wanted to say how glad I am this is being discussed on AIBU so that everyone can discuss/read openly. I know it comes up on the Feminism board but I always feel that’s a bit exclusive.

SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 10:32

I've seen a lot of people refer to men, like in the op as transmen.
Just a reminder that as per trans ideology, women who want to be men are transmen and men who want to be women are transwomen.

I feel it's important these words are widely understood as I do feel their meaning is deliberately evasive to play on people's ignorance.

Ifor example polls where the public deem 'transwomen in women's wards' fine might not actually be telling you what it seems on the surface. As the unclear language could mean participants incorrectly thought they were talking about natal women with beards not natal men with penis.
Of course the language is designed this way. To confuse and distort reality.

whatkatydid2013 · 24/03/2023 10:31

Happylittlechicken · 24/03/2023 09:46

While most of what is being asked for in terms of protection of single sex spaces is totally reasonable I find it unsettling how nasty many women are about it. Some are not but many describe trans women in such awful terms and it seems like they think they are all disgusting or sexually deviant or deliberately trying to hurt females. Surely you can have some compassion for people who are trans and having a really tough time while also being firm that single sex spaces are important and should be protected?

that used to be my stance, but too many times seeing women degraded, bullied, castigated and threatened for requesting basic human rights and dignity knocked that right out of me. Where is the compassion from trans people for women having a really tough time having their rights eroded? Or is the compassion only supposed to go one way? I got called a TERF for saying a violent male rapist did not belong locked up with vulnerable women. Have you seen the “kill terfs”, “rape terfs” signs. These are the people you want women to be compassionate to? Why would we want to do that?

Honestly I don’t believe the trolls on Twitter posting a load of derogatory hatred about women and thugs who have punched women in the face at protests are representative of the average trans woman. I really don’t want to lower my own behaviour to match the worst individuals in a community. If you think of the people you know in real life who are trans are they anything like that? The few I know aren’t at all. They are decent, hardworking professionals who are feeling pretty worries at the moment about the way the world is. I honestly don’t know if they believe they actually can change sex as it’s not really a topic discussed at work but I’m confident you can hold gender critical beliefs, be appalled by the behaviour of individuals within a group without assuming that’s how everyone in the group thinks/acts.

Resiliencerequired · 24/03/2023 10:29

NC, I wanted to add a personal experience to this thread.

My teenage daughter plays ladies hockey and there is an opposition player in their South East Oaks league who is a trans women. This player scored five goals over the two matches DD2 played in and it was just a horrible spectacle. They had so many physical advantages (speed, strength etc) over other female players - they stood out from the rest of their team. DD2 and some of the colts (U18) on their team (and some of the ladies too) were so deflated and angry after the game - it’s so hard to keep teenage girls engaged in sport, and going head to head with a biological man is so unfair.

Prior to the game, we were told there was a trans player and the ladies had to be their ‘most inclusive selves’ which is wrong on so many levels. I know the level of hockey is quite low, it’s Division 3 out of 5 or similar, so not national level - but ladies who play grass roots sport deserve the same respect and right to fair play as Olympians !

YANBU that trans women should be able to play sport - but that shouldn’t be competitively in women’s leagues, even at grass roots level. And particularly hockey, which has many opportunities to play mixed.

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:29

JackiePlace · 24/03/2023 10:18

I agree that trans men should not be allowed to compete in women's sports.

However, in a martial arts class (not a sport) surely this is an ideal opportunity to train... (you're not hoping to only be capable of defending yourself against women, are you?).

@JackiePlace - I don't get the point you are trying to make here?

Are you trying to compare men competing against women in sports where they have a biological advantage to men and women consensually training together?

The two scenarios are poles apart.

And as for your last point- yes, I suspect many women are taking martial arts classes to help them defend themselves against men - I'm not sure the reverse is true.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:28

https://twitter.com/SchoolAthletics/status/1638978785948192783/photo/1
Link to British schools stopping trans kids competing, cames minutes after the World Athletics announcement. Come on Ireland & follow suit!

https://twitter.com/SchoolAthletics/status/1638978785948192783/photo/1

OP posts:
Ofcourseshecan · 24/03/2023 10:27

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 10:16

Honest answer?

I would think I had failed as a parent to teach him that there is no such thing as girls' toys/clothes and boys' toys/clothes and that he could play with what he wants and express himself how he wants, that being a boy or a girl makes no difference.

I would have to find the best way of making it clear to him that he cannot change sex, and that all the puberty blockers and surgery in the world will not make it so, so it would be better if he found a way to accept himself the way he is.

I would still continue to love him unconditionally, even if that meant having to love him unconditionally whilst watching him dress in women's clothes and change the name that we lovingly chose for him and use feminine pronouns.

But I would never, at any point, support him making his gender dysphoria anyone else's problem. Competing in women's sports? Hard no. I could never support that.

Well said. Colluding with a delusion that may lead to harmful drugs and surgery is not a kindness.

Ofcourseshecan · 24/03/2023 10:24

HoneyPotBee · 24/03/2023 08:11

I think I’ve seen this discussed before. It feels like this man is just taking the piss out of trans people. Nice to see MN drawing attention to it.

It’s been discussed before because it keeps happening. It’s women they are taking the piss out of. And injuring and intimidating and gaslighting.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:21

SealHouse · 24/03/2023 10:07

Agree Mommymoments about keeping this stuff fresh in people's minds, but the problem here in Ireland is that the Irish 'mainstream' media are just useless on this issue. None of these stories ever really gain any traction here - even the Leo Varadker / Barbie Kardashian story has already disappeared. It's depressing.

RTE are today covering the World Athletics Council decision because it's an international story and 'safe' for them to do so - it's something happening 'elsewhere'. But did they, or the Irish Times, or the Independent even report the LGFA decision last summer, nevermind ask anyone from the LGFA for a comment? I don't think so. Where are the Irish female sports journalists on this?

PS. There are some Irish journalists not afraid to tackle gender woo - I'm thinking Eilis O'Hanlon, Mark Tighe, Brenda Power, Ciara Kelly on radio, and of course Gript (I'm sure there are others) and I'm grateful to them. But by and large it's all just studiously ignored.

Morning Ireland had a transgender scientist on this morning discussing the "science" of trans athletes & how they have no advantage 😩 the trans propaganda continues. No woman athlete or scientist was on Morning Ireland to give a woman's perspective. Just the transgender scientist to give his trans agenda.
Its propoganda & state controlled censorship.

OP posts:
NKFell · 24/03/2023 10:21

Of course YANBU at all. I always hope common sense will prevail.

Some of these TRAs just don't get it though. I once had an argument on Twitter with someone who genuinely believed their pelvis changed position, they had a cervix, reversed puberty etc. He genuinely believed it though and part of me thinks that's so sad but it's so scary that I struggle to feel sorry for people.

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:20

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:05

We are bigoted?Well @lifeturnsonadime you my dear are a womanphobe & a woman hater.

"Widening the bandwith of how to be a woman". FFS - what does that even mean?

Try being pregnant, giving birth, 40 years of menstruating, breastfeeding, earning less, getting fewer chances at promotion, being silenced, being objectified and fetishised and generally being treated like a second class citizen. The irony of transmen wanting to be women but at the same time, denying women their rights is mindblowing.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 10:19

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:15

Apologies @lifeturnsonadime 😊yes I recognise your username now. So sorry!

No offence taken at all.

It's easy to miss when you know that there are people who actually hold those views!

JackiePlace · 24/03/2023 10:18

IncompleteSenten · 24/03/2023 08:19

Because women's safety is unimportant.

I agree that trans men should not be allowed to compete in women's sports.

However, in a martial arts class (not a sport) surely this is an ideal opportunity to train... (you're not hoping to only be capable of defending yourself against women, are you?).

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 10:18

3peassuit · 24/03/2023 10:07

Why can’t that Alex person broaden the bandwidth of what it is to be a man?

I know.

In the 90s in Brighton there were loads of men who dressed just like Alex. FWIW I think Alex looks amazing.

Difference was they didn't claim to be women or lesbians.

This ideology is so backwards. It's not what Alexi is wearing that I object to it's that he is imposing himself on women.

MarshaBradyo · 24/03/2023 10:17

CampervanKween · 24/03/2023 10:05

I feel like sanity might be returning due to the efforts of mainly women in the UK I am proud to say. Mumsnet feminist boards played no small part in the fight back starting with Man Friday and I Am Sporticus if anyone remembers that? I still have the t shirt 😁

Good pic and yes great stuff to all the women who started this on mn and kept it going. Against slurs, attacks and insults

All appreciated. Thankfully it seems to be paying off although some way to go.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:16

YouSetTheTone · 24/03/2023 10:12

If Stonewall had spent the past 15 years campaigning for safe third spaces, extra categories in sport and for society to be accepting of boys or girls who wished to simply ‘present’ as the opposite sex we wouldn’t be where we are now.
Forcing the T and Q and all the other letters onto gay rights, dropping the ball entirely with said gay rights (where are SW with all the recent horror legislation in places like Uganda?) and demanding the wholesale inclusion of men into ALL areas of society/ life traditionally reserved as women only for reasons of privacy, safety and dignity have resulted in this shit show.
Don’t blame women for any ‘lack of compassion’, blame Stonewall and all the other big organisations and governments who’ve done this.

And also the big pharmaceutical companies who are funding plenty behind the scenes to enable these organisations to reach their target audience.. Primary school children.

OP posts:
RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 10:16

MaryHinges · 24/03/2023 08:29

I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman.

Honest answer?

I would think I had failed as a parent to teach him that there is no such thing as girls' toys/clothes and boys' toys/clothes and that he could play with what he wants and express himself how he wants, that being a boy or a girl makes no difference.

I would have to find the best way of making it clear to him that he cannot change sex, and that all the puberty blockers and surgery in the world will not make it so, so it would be better if he found a way to accept himself the way he is.

I would still continue to love him unconditionally, even if that meant having to love him unconditionally whilst watching him dress in women's clothes and change the name that we lovingly chose for him and use feminine pronouns.

But I would never, at any point, support him making his gender dysphoria anyone else's problem. Competing in women's sports? Hard no. I could never support that.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 24/03/2023 10:15

MaryHinges · 24/03/2023 08:29

I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman.

No issue... Unless he wanted to play in natal female sports. (assuming they had gone through male puberty... No issue if not)