Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
BoogieFun · 24/03/2023 11:10

whereaw · 24/03/2023 11:05

What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality?

Surely homosexuality is 'anti-trans' - feeling attracted to people based on their sex rather than their 'feels'... so perhaps the trans community would like this idea.

The reason a lot of lesbian women pulled out of the Pride movement and parades was because they were accused of bigotry and transphobia for not wanting to have sex with a 'female penis'.

maddening · 24/03/2023 11:08

Redebs · 24/03/2023 10:03

Sadly then you need to find out more about him. He is an example of the worst kind of woman-hating narcissist, in the same camp as Andrew Tate.
There is a real problem with these right wingers latching on to the gender transformation issue. They want to know that the women they oppress and abuse are purely xx chromosomed.

In your opinion, there is nothing.anywhere that shows he is the same as Andrew tate - nor that he is right wing - and quite frankly the right wing stuff is thrown around to readily in order to silence debate - imo.

And please lose the patronising tone.

BoogieFun · 24/03/2023 11:08

NewCarOldCar · 24/03/2023 10:54

Does it ever happen the other way? Transmen playing in soccer teams? No. Why? Because biological women aren't stupid enough to think it is acceptable

Yep. They know no matter how much testosterone they inject, they will never, never beat a biological man in any competitve arena. And will actually be at physical risk of harm if it's a contact sport.

Same as trans-men aren't wanting to be housed in men-only hostels or go to male.

Because despite identifying as male or wanting to be viewed as male, they are biologically not. And they know they would be extremely vulnerable due to their female biology, in a biologically male environment.

I don't know of any case anywhere where a trans-man wants to be in a male prison. Even if they did, a government or prison authority would not approve it. Why? Because they'd be at huge risk.

Whereas when it comes to men identifying as women and wanting to be housed in women's prisons, they aren't at risk from the women. Just the numerous women around them are potentially at risk from them. Which is okay apparently and the people saying 'no' are the nasty transphobic bigots.

ImAGoodPerson · 24/03/2023 11:07

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 10:08

You've missed my sarcasm which is easy to do on a written post. I post fairly regularly on FWR.

Men are never women.

Just seen this, I was very confused

whereaw · 24/03/2023 11:05

What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality?

Surely homosexuality is 'anti-trans' - feeling attracted to people based on their sex rather than their 'feels'... so perhaps the trans community would like this idea.

ImAGoodPerson · 24/03/2023 11:04

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 09:43

All of you who are saying he's not a trans woman or he is taking the piss out of genuine trans women are so bigoted. There is no wrong way to be a trans woman. He doesn't have to make any effort. That's what Self ID is.

And once a person is a trans woman they are a woman. And if they are a woman we can't exclude them from anything that is only for women.

I really hope you are joking

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:03

JudgeJ · 24/03/2023 10:58

It is ridiculous! Especially as he isn't trans,

It is ridiculous irrespective of whether or not he's trans. The Athletics Federation have called it right in banning this nonsense.

Now is the time for other sporting organisations to seize the moment & slap a ban on all trans in women's sport.
They need to be told go play with the big boys like themselves or start your own trans leagues.

OP posts:
TheGreatATuin · 24/03/2023 11:03

What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality?
I believe this is already happening. They're called Mermaids residential weekends.

JudgeJ · 24/03/2023 11:01

If he in any way touches a woman inappropriately during a football match hopefully he will be arrested for sexual aasualt and stuff his 'feelings', the woman's feelings should take precedent.

JudgeJ · 24/03/2023 10:58

It is ridiculous! Especially as he isn't trans,

It is ridiculous irrespective of whether or not he's trans. The Athletics Federation have called it right in banning this nonsense.

whereaw · 24/03/2023 10:56

@NewCarOldCar or it's proof that men have a biological advantage which a trans man can't compete with.

NewCarOldCar · 24/03/2023 10:54

Does it ever happen the other way? Transmen playing in soccer teams? No. Why? Because biological women aren't stupid enough to think it is acceptable

BoogieFun · 24/03/2023 10:50

FOJN · 24/03/2023 09:40

We spent years pandering to the demands that we moderate out language to avoid offending anyone and simply ended up gaslighting ourselves.
What you are seeing here is women telling the truth in plain language, there is no hate towards the trans community, just a determination to defend our rights using very clear language.

Human beings cannot change sex, staying that this person will always be a man is a fact, not an insult. If this man thinks they are a woman despite the obvious physical evidence to the contrary, how would you describe that? Would you agree with with someone who has anorexia that they are morbidly obese?

All our pandering has lead to an adult male playing in a young woman's sports team, elite female cyclists being sidelined as mediocre male cyclists use the women's division as their retirement plan, women being injured because they are too frightened to lose their sponsorship or place on a team if they refuse to compete with males and naked adult males parading naked in female changing rooms and any young women objecting being offered counselling to address their bigotry.

What will it take to make you say enough and describe the problem in clear unambiguous language?

This:

What happened was of course, most people wanted trans-people to be who they wanted to be and not be discriminated against or abused.

But then goalposts were moving from someone being a trans-person who had gone through a formalised process to become who they wanted to be, no process being required. And the forcing of wanting to remove the word 'trans'. Then forcing of nor only removing the word trans, but wanting to remove the words or concepts that were not only biologically accurate, but had been used for millennia.

And any objection to the distortion of those words or concepts was screamed at as bigotry or -phobia. A woman became 'anyone who tells you she is' and women have penises and men have uteruses and can be pregnant and give birth. It wasn't enough to say trans-women can have penises and trans-men have uteruses and give birth.

So it bizarrely became accepted that men have uteruses and give birth and women have penises and no cervix but should be invited for a cervical smear test.

And you can't mention that the woman that just literally beat you up in the MMA ring was quite recently a male member of the US armed forces. Or the woman that beat you at college athletics was a male till recently and still has all the biological male physical advantages.

You can't complain that you're a woman who has experienced gendered violence from men and then you're in a rape crisis group, or a DV shelter or a prison and a male bodied woman comes in and makes you frightened or even physically or sexually assaults you.

Cause then you're a bigot. And a transphobe. You're a privileged 'cis' person who should stop discriminating against a vulnerable population. If you don't stop complaining, then people will die because of you.

And I was in this debate from the beginning. And really was thinking a lot of concerned people were transphobic at the start. I thought it would never happen that biological male sex offenders would be placed with vulnerable women in hostels and prisons.

I never thought biological males would want to compete in women's sports.

I never thought biological males would want to get awards or job roles that were specifically for women.

I was naive. And the announcement by Seb Coe yesterday about athletics brought it home to me as I thought 'thank God, that's actually sensible' and realised how mad it had all become that that had to happen. That it was ever considered okay in the first place.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 10:49

I’m confident you can hold gender critical beliefs, be appalled by the behaviour of individuals within a group without assuming that’s how everyone in the group thinks/acts.

No one thinks that but the number of men who say they are women who do behave badly outnumber the trans people who just want to get on with their life.

We have been living with the GRA since 2004, if the trans community hadn't been colonised by an incel/MRA movement then we wouldn't even be discussing this because the number of people who the GRA applied to was tiny but the provisions for trans people made in both the GRA and EA have been exploited by men in ways that now put women and children at a disadvantage and in danger. I don't blame the trans people you know being worried, their movement has been hijacked, but rather than thinking women should shut up and accept the risks we now face they need to take it up with their MP.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 10:49

Beowulfa · 24/03/2023 10:37

I'm so sorry your daughter and team mates have been treated like this.

Sports bodies that do this are essentially saying to women and girls:

-you exist only to validate males
-the feelings of males are more important than anything else
-you must never say No to a male

The misogyny is just shameless. Why can't the liberal Left see it for what it is?

I have long pondered this and conclude that the liberal left stands for misogyny.

They can't claim not to see it. The evidence is all there. Yet we still have labour politicians calling rapists SHE and claiming that babies are born without a sex.

Labour on women

The link is taken from another thread on the feminism boards.

https://twitter.com/OkBiology/status/1639067289508102145?s=20

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:48

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 10:43

You already had your own women only league.

The men should have started their own men only league!

I've also heard trans activists say we should campaign for "cis woman only" toilets and changing rooms.

We already did that once! Why don't you campaign for trans ones??

Absolute cheek of them. I hate that term cis women... We are women!

OP posts:
whereaw · 24/03/2023 10:47

If we take out of the equation biology and sex for a minute (not that we should)... but if we do....
If context and identity and feelings and experiences are EVERYTHING, all encompassing and meaningful, then trans women can never be women... they will always be TRANS women - because they share a unique identity, standing and position in the world, of transitioning and all the hurt and pain and difficulties that brings which women DO NOT share.
And women share their own history and past and shared experiences of being girls and women and everything it brings.

It is not anti trans to say trans women are not women.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:45

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 10:35

Perhaps those nice trans people should start campaigning for third spaces so that they can feel safe using toilets and changing rooms etc without using women's spaces.

I mean, it would be good if they could loudly denounce all the people who give the trans community a bad name, but they're not to blame for that behaviour any more than ordinary Muslims are to blame for ISIS.

However, it would be helpful if they could do something to show that they understand that their own rights, safety and dignity shouldn't come at the expense of ours.

Completely, no one is excluding trans from competing they just need to compete with their biological sex.
Also why can't they have their own trans events? Trans Olympics etc..
They need to stop trying to infiltrate women's sports & spaces.

OP posts:
SidewaysOtter · 24/03/2023 10:45

Sports bodies that do this are essentially saying to women and girls:

-you exist only to validate males
-the feelings of males are more important than anything else
-you must never say No to a male

And that encouraging women's participation in sport is not important.

Why can't the liberal Left see it for what it is?

Because they are so kiiiiind. Unless you're a woman of course, in which case the self-appointed guardians of liberality want you to fuck off back into your box. And I say that as a fairly lefty person who feels immensely let down by current left-wing politics.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/03/2023 10:44

My daughter prefers boys clothing and short hair. She’s mistaken as a boy all the time and sometimes it bothers her but we’ve never suggested she can’t do as she pleases when it comes to her style and we’ve consistently told her that even though some people think it’s really important girls/boys only wear certain things, have certain hairstyles or like certain toys that’s just because they don’t understand that everyone is different and likes different things.

I've recently been rediscovering a bit of childhood nostalgia and watching some of the old Famous Five TV adaptations. I know there are some 'issues' with Enid Blyton, but for all the talk nowadays of censoring and rewriting 'outdated' children's books, I find it refreshing how George (in the FF) likes to embrace traditional/stereotypically masculine pursuits and characteristics, but at no time does she ever claim to actually BE a boy: she is very definitely a girl, but she is her own kind of girl - the individual that she wants to be (who happens to be female), which is surely the obvious route for everybody to take for themselves. Isn't it interesting how far we've 'progressed' from those days all those decades ago....

Rightsraptor · 24/03/2023 10:44

Nobody would be unreasonable if they object to him being on a women's team.

It's beyond unreasonable that be is allowed to be on one.

And 'transitioning' makes no difference whatsoever to that.

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:44

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:39

I lived in Australia for a while where netball is huge. I was part of a women's team which was all mainly for exercise, socialising and a bit of fun. The 'league' (not a league in the true sports sense) became mixed because "some boys were asking to play" and it was a University league so they bowed to the students' demands, so we then had all these mixed sex teams. You then have women aged between mainly 25 - 45 playing against young men who are stronger, fitter, faster. The game that finished it for us was when one of our team got a broken arm from basically being barged over by a man and we were beaten 42-nil. The 'mixed sex' team we were playing had two young women and five men. Their goal shooter and goal keepers were in the 6 foot tall bracket. Two of the guys also played aussie rules football so were totally ripped.

And before anyone says.....you should have just started your own woman-only league - why should we have had to??? Why couldn't it have just stayed as it was ie a woman's only league? It's so demoralising to have so many male apologists who are happy to run rough shod over their own sex.

Forgot to add - I can see no real reason why these men wanted to play other than to humiliate women. They already played multiple sports and they were certainly not getting any exercise or competition playing us. In fact, the goal shooter and goal keeper probably took about 20 steps the whole game - literally just stood in their positions waiting to receive the next ball then score or save.

They were literally laughing at us - it was one of the most horrible experiences of my life - to see in action how some men view women.

If my DS was like that, I'd be so ashamed of him.

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 10:43

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:39

I lived in Australia for a while where netball is huge. I was part of a women's team which was all mainly for exercise, socialising and a bit of fun. The 'league' (not a league in the true sports sense) became mixed because "some boys were asking to play" and it was a University league so they bowed to the students' demands, so we then had all these mixed sex teams. You then have women aged between mainly 25 - 45 playing against young men who are stronger, fitter, faster. The game that finished it for us was when one of our team got a broken arm from basically being barged over by a man and we were beaten 42-nil. The 'mixed sex' team we were playing had two young women and five men. Their goal shooter and goal keepers were in the 6 foot tall bracket. Two of the guys also played aussie rules football so were totally ripped.

And before anyone says.....you should have just started your own woman-only league - why should we have had to??? Why couldn't it have just stayed as it was ie a woman's only league? It's so demoralising to have so many male apologists who are happy to run rough shod over their own sex.

You already had your own women only league.

The men should have started their own men only league!

I've also heard trans activists say we should campaign for "cis woman only" toilets and changing rooms.

We already did that once! Why don't you campaign for trans ones??

Happylittlechicken · 24/03/2023 10:40

Honestly I don’t believe the trolls on Twitter posting a load of derogatory hatred about women and thugs who have punched women in the face at protests are representative of the average trans woman. I really don’t want to lower my own behaviour to match the worst individuals in a community. If you think of the people you know in real life who are trans are they anything like that? The few I know aren’t at all. They are decent, hardworking professionals who are feeling pretty worries at the moment about the way the world is. I honestly don’t know if they believe they actually can change sex as it’s not really a topic discussed at work but I’m confident you can hold gender critical beliefs, be appalled by the behaviour of individuals within a group without assuming that’s how everyone in the group thinks/acts.

So if these decent transpeople don’t want to be represented by these “trolls” as you call them, why aren’t they speaking out against it.? Unfortunately these individuals calling for women to be killed and raped are the public face of the gender ideology, and no amount of “well I know a really nice transwoman so just all stop being mean ok” is gonna cut it any more. As for lowering behaviours, how many rape threats, death threats and assaults on transpeople have you seen from gender critical feminists? How many women are invading transpeoples spaces demanding access? How many women are demanding language change for “inclusion”. They go low we go high is what got us into this mess.

JackiePlace · 24/03/2023 10:40

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:29

@JackiePlace - I don't get the point you are trying to make here?

Are you trying to compare men competing against women in sports where they have a biological advantage to men and women consensually training together?

The two scenarios are poles apart.

And as for your last point- yes, I suspect many women are taking martial arts classes to help them defend themselves against men - I'm not sure the reverse is true.

I was replying to @PinkFlamingo888 post about being paired with a trans person at her judo class.