Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
2023forme · 24/03/2023 11:57

JackiePlace · 24/03/2023 10:40

I was replying to @PinkFlamingo888 post about being paired with a trans person at her judo class.

@JackiePlace - that's even worse then! PinkFlamingo888 clearly stated she had been injured by a physically stronger male - yet you are suggesting that mixed classes are a good thing - bonkers.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:56

I just saw a Facebook comment on a pro trans page suggesting trans only events. The poster was attacked & accused of wanting transgender athletes "segregated"..

OP posts:
SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 11:50

including many women who have some very unpleasant views about trans people) don’t agree and think gender roles are very importantt

There may be people like that but by definition they are not gender critical. To be gender critical you have to reject not embrace the idea of gender stereotypes as important.

Naunet · 24/03/2023 11:48

Happylittlechicken · 24/03/2023 11:44

@whatkatydid2013 so let me get this right, women are threaten, bullied and assaulted for standing up for their rights but your biggest gripe is people are not being nice??? Really? Have you told the TRA to stop being nasty? Or is it only women you want to #bekind?

Come on now, be nice to your oppressors ladies, be kind to those men who seek to take your rights and infiltrate your spaces. Be welcoming to the men that wish to redefine you and reduce you to nothing more than a performance that they are able to do better than you ever could. If men in dresses threaten to rape you with their lady dicks, just remember how oppressed and marginalised the poor little victims are. 🥺

BoogieFun · 24/03/2023 11:48

maddening · 24/03/2023 11:08

In your opinion, there is nothing.anywhere that shows he is the same as Andrew tate - nor that he is right wing - and quite frankly the right wing stuff is thrown around to readily in order to silence debate - imo.

And please lose the patronising tone.

100% hyperbole to say Jordan Peterson is in the same vein of Andrew Tate.

That's the kind of nonsense that results in people expressing that opinion being seen as ridiculous and ignored.

I'm not a Jordan Peterson fan but come on...

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:45

@whatkatydid2013 what's your stance on men violating & infiltrating women's sports & spaces. Men with penises. People would be much more compassionate if they started lobbying for trans sports teams, toilets, changing rooms etc.. But no their aim is to invade & take over women's activities, spaces & freedoms.

OP posts:
Happylittlechicken · 24/03/2023 11:44

@whatkatydid2013 so let me get this right, women are threaten, bullied and assaulted for standing up for their rights but your biggest gripe is people are not being nice??? Really? Have you told the TRA to stop being nasty? Or is it only women you want to #bekind?

LuvSmallDogs · 24/03/2023 11:43

I have a transman relative chasing me up for my BRCA results after my young breast cancer diagnosis. They recognise biology when it suits them.

whatkatydid2013 · 24/03/2023 11:38

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 09:57

While most of what is being asked for in terms of protection of single sex spaces is totally reasonable I find it unsettling how nasty many women are about it. Some are not but many describe trans women in such awful terms and it seems like they think they are all disgusting or sexually deviant or deliberately trying to hurt females. Surely you can have some compassion for people who are trans and having a really tough time while also being firm that single sex spaces are important and should be protected?

Being kind has resulted in -

-Rapists in women's prisons.
-Lesbians being called bigots for rejecting penises in their dating pool.
-Children being put on harmful medical pathways.
-Mediocre men winning and taking places from women in what should be female sport.
-Unisex toilets being introduced in schools.
-Children being taught there are 100 or more genders.
-Drag queen story time for pre-schoolers.
-Girls being molested by transwomen in supermarket toilets.
-Males running rape crisis centres telling women to reframe their trauma and that they are bigots if they want single sex therapy.

This is not an exhaustive list.

If she tells me when she’s older she feels like she’s a boy I would be supportive in her exploring why she feels that way and ultimately if she wanted to transition I would support that too (though not as a child).

I have a gender non conforming autistic daughter, I will never tell her that is not really a girl. There is no wrong way to be a girl or a woman. I find it shocking the number of autistic or otherwise vulnerable girls who are having mastectomies in the name of this ideology. That's not being kind. It's horrific.

Having some compassion isn’t the same thing as “being kind” in the sense you mean it which is to put up and shut up with anything and everything. It’s being able to disagree with a position without being horrible about individuals. I have no issue with people stating facts. It’s impossible to change sex, it’s not reasonable or fair to allow male people in female only spaces like prisons/shelters etc regardless of their gender identity or expression.

You can believe all that without being derogatory about trans people (which people regularly are on threads on this site). My personal belief is that gender shouldn’t be a big thing because people should be free to express themselves as they wish regardless of their sex but many people (including many women and including many women who have some very unpleasant views about trans people) don’t agree and think gender roles are very important. Anyway you seem to be suggesting that just offering trans people the basic courtesy of using the name/pronoun is the issue but it seems to me like the only issue is a failure to clearly differentiate gender identity and sex. I’ve recently challenged our work policy on equality (not the only one who did) because it’s been changed from mentioning only gender (by which at the time they meant sex) to mentioning gender identify and expression but not sex. It’s getting changed to add sex so all three are clearly defined characteristics they are committed to not discriminating on the basis of. I feel like if we could do a bit more campaigning around that (sex matters do currently) and a bit less foaming with vitriol about individuals it would be a better approach.

It’s awful if anyone is making significant and permanent changes to their bodies without being challenged to consider alternatives or without fully understanding what it means for them in the future. If however they understand and it’s what they believe will make them happiest I would hope families are supportive & try their best to understand their children’s point of view. As I said I wouldn’t accept my kids transitioning medically as minors. I don’t think for a second they could fully understand the implications at that age and I don’t think it’s something any parent should support for a child. I saw the message earlier about the famous five and George. It’s true that we are going backwards vs forwards if we are getting less accepting of people not conforming to gender norms. I totally agree there is no wrong way to be a girl or to be a boy but I’m also aware we are pretty much in the minority thinking that

ImAGoodPerson · 24/03/2023 11:35

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 11:17

I wish I was too.

I give you Self ID.

Which is something the Labour Party will introduce if they have their own way.

It's terrifying isn't it. I raised this to campaigners at my door, they seemed shocked to be questioned at all and had nothing to say at all about it.

It makes me feel sad and angry in equal measures.

0hs0s0rry · 24/03/2023 11:34

So if I say I feel like a 10 year old, does that mean I can use that to my advantage? Cheaper tickets, free entry to places etc etc?

TheOrigRights · 24/03/2023 11:33

MaryHinges · 24/03/2023 08:29

I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman.

I admit I would be concerned. He's not quite 14 so such big thoughts are a lot to deal with. I would support and listen to him and advise him to give it some time.
I would also be surprised as I believe I would have had an idea by now that he was transgender.
Regarding the sport issue, I would inform him that as he is going through puberty he would be unable to compete alongside women/girls because he has and always will have a body that has been exposed to high levels of testosterone.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:30

SealHouse · 24/03/2023 11:25

It really is censorship. I don't want to derail your thread here with discussion of the compliant and complacent Irish media (because that's a whole other thread in itself) but just for the benefit of UK posters, it might seem paranoid from a UK perspective to think that the Irish state exerts undue influence over the media here but it really is not too far from the truth of how things work in Ireland. For example, regarding the Barbie Kardashian story, by Wednesday evening the Independent's eye-catching headline article with Leo’s comments about biological males in women's prisons was redirecting online to a different article with Simon Harris's more wishy-washy statement. The original article actually disappeared. It’s almost as though someone from Leo’s press office made a phone call to the editor….

@SealHouse please discuss at length. As an Irish woman with three girls living in Dublin I'm sick of being silenced.
Ireland is actively partaking in state controlled censorship.
There is also lots of trans propaganda in all Irish media bar The Gript.

OP posts:
Brightshinylight · 24/03/2023 11:30

Yep, sure I have seen something similar in a horror film. Just more proof that heavy makeup, wig, fake tits and ‘feminine pink’ clothing does not make a woman. There is a bit more to it than that which some feeble male minds cannot, or won’t, accept.

in mean why do they always wear pink (or orange)? I posses nothing in pink, not even a pair of knickers.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/03/2023 11:28

I think I’ve seen this discussed before. It feels like this man is just taking the piss out of trans people

I think it's women who are the butt of the joke, more than "trans people".

MarshaBradyo · 24/03/2023 11:26

I’m confident you can hold gender critical beliefs, be appalled by the behaviour of individuals within a group without assuming that’s how everyone in the group thinks/acts

That may be true but if you are GC it’s likely you disagree that people can change sex and that women deserve single sex spaces and sports

So the outcome is the same. No males in female sports, prisons and so on

SealHouse · 24/03/2023 11:25

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 10:21

Morning Ireland had a transgender scientist on this morning discussing the "science" of trans athletes & how they have no advantage 😩 the trans propaganda continues. No woman athlete or scientist was on Morning Ireland to give a woman's perspective. Just the transgender scientist to give his trans agenda.
Its propoganda & state controlled censorship.

It really is censorship. I don't want to derail your thread here with discussion of the compliant and complacent Irish media (because that's a whole other thread in itself) but just for the benefit of UK posters, it might seem paranoid from a UK perspective to think that the Irish state exerts undue influence over the media here but it really is not too far from the truth of how things work in Ireland. For example, regarding the Barbie Kardashian story, by Wednesday evening the Independent's eye-catching headline article with Leo’s comments about biological males in women's prisons was redirecting online to a different article with Simon Harris's more wishy-washy statement. The original article actually disappeared. It’s almost as though someone from Leo’s press office made a phone call to the editor….

Naunet · 24/03/2023 11:22

I’m confident you can hold gender critical beliefs, be appalled by the behaviour of individuals within a group without assuming that’s how everyone in the group thinks/acts

But can TRAs do the same? They’re very keen to pigeon hole people into a woman or man box depending on their behaviour and interests. I think you should go preach to them that their entire movement is based on outdated, sexist stereotype and to stop labelling people men or women based on what they like to wear or how they behave.

laveritable · 24/03/2023 11:19

Yes! It's his right! He should be allowed to play in the TODDLER's team ! Madness!

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:19

@CandyLeBonBon you sound like a wonderful mum💐

OP posts:
JockSmashnova · 24/03/2023 11:19

However, in a martial arts class (not a sport) surely this is an ideal opportunity to train... (you're not hoping to only be capable of defending yourself against women, are you?)

id take issue with this. Martial arts are so much more than just ‘self defence against a man‘. Martial arts teach fitness, camaraderie, self esteem and are damn good fun. In my experience Sparring with a bloke, unless it’s an instructor, often doesn’t teach you much because they can usually overwhelm you the second they get within reach (and their reach is longer and reactions are faster anyway). I’ve done judo, karate, MMA and sword sports. Even with a weapon like a sword, an average male can just smash through any attempt to block them. You try to parry a strike and just end up being hit with your sword, then theirs and spraining a wrist as well.

if it’s self defence you want, you’d be better off doing a specific self defence course — and even then, the strength difference is such that the expert advice to women is more along the lines of ‘try not to get into a situation like that, and if you do, don’t fight, just bloody well run‘

CandyLeBonBon · 24/03/2023 11:17

"@MaryHinges
I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman."

I have an adult son who cross dresses. I suspect there's an AGP element to it, based on his fashion choices, although he would probably deny it if asked. I'm betting on him 'coming out' with it the next 6 months. He's autistic and suffers with depression and ptsd from bullying. I don't make a fuss when he puts on a dress. But I absolutely do not affirm him as 'a woman'. He knows my GC stance, and my beliefs that you can't change sex. He attempted suicide last year (not related to the x dressing) and is now awaiting proper in depth therapy via the mental health team.

I would STILL be against him competing in women's sports, using women's changing rooms and taking women only spaces, simply to 'affirm' him. And if he threatened suicide if I didn't, I'd be involving the crisis team pronto.

Acceptance of reality is vital, for long term mental well-being. I love my son and accept he wants to appear 'feminine', even though that is, in my opinion absolutely buying into regressive stereotypes. However he's an adult and is allowed to do that. If he crosses a line by expecting me or anyone else to pretend he's an actual woman, that's when things get serious.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/03/2023 11:17

ImAGoodPerson · 24/03/2023 11:04

I really hope you are joking

I wish I was too.

I give you Self ID.

Which is something the Labour Party will introduce if they have their own way.

InWalksBarberalla · 24/03/2023 11:17

Transwomen are women plus. Just like women but even better, with their penises and all. Better at sports, better at work, better authors, artists, politicians, better at being women than the pesky women without penises women.

Naunet · 24/03/2023 11:13

2023forme · 24/03/2023 10:39

I lived in Australia for a while where netball is huge. I was part of a women's team which was all mainly for exercise, socialising and a bit of fun. The 'league' (not a league in the true sports sense) became mixed because "some boys were asking to play" and it was a University league so they bowed to the students' demands, so we then had all these mixed sex teams. You then have women aged between mainly 25 - 45 playing against young men who are stronger, fitter, faster. The game that finished it for us was when one of our team got a broken arm from basically being barged over by a man and we were beaten 42-nil. The 'mixed sex' team we were playing had two young women and five men. Their goal shooter and goal keepers were in the 6 foot tall bracket. Two of the guys also played aussie rules football so were totally ripped.

And before anyone says.....you should have just started your own woman-only league - why should we have had to??? Why couldn't it have just stayed as it was ie a woman's only league? It's so demoralising to have so many male apologists who are happy to run rough shod over their own sex.

Its not even legal there now to exclude males from female groups, is it? I’m sure I read something about lesbians not being allowed to arrange female only meetings as it was against the law to exclude men?