Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 12:36

I really don’t get why this is such a with us or against us issue for people. It’s got to be possible to find a solution where you protect single sex spaces and make provision for transgender people.

TG people can campaign for third spaces/categories. There, sorted.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 12:34

I really don’t get why this is such a with us or against us issue for people. It’s got to be possible to find a solution where you protect single sex spaces and make provision for transgender people.

I thought exactly this about 6 years ago. I can hardly believe how naïve I was.

Women no longer have energy or resources to spare to support trans people campaigning for additional resources for themselves because we are exhausted trying to hold onto what we have a claw back what we have.

Are you even aware of all the attempts to prosecute women who have campaigned for womens rights. In nearly every case the charges have been dropped after we have crowd funded legal costs and the subject of the complaint has endured months of stress. In one case a complainant alleged that suffragette ribbons tied to a fence were shaped like a noose and were therefore a threat to him. In another case a transwoman was even taken to court for speaking factually about this issue, the case was thrown out on day one. There are a small number of TRA's who are serial vexatious litigants. Women are worn out trying to fight this nonsense.

TRA's are not fighting for resources for trans people, they simply want to take womens. Why should we campaign on their behalf?

I signed the petition started by Fionne and Miranda when it was first started a couple of years ago and you can see how much support the trans community has given it.

2023forme · 24/03/2023 12:30

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:28

@2023forme they are women hating womenphobes.

Even having a man announce for the world athletics organisation what women's rights should be.. Men dictating to us little women yet again.

Indeed. Just waiting for someone to pop up saying...."I showed this thread to DH and he thinks yadda yadda yadda" 😂

Untitledsquatboulder · 24/03/2023 12:28

porridgecake · 24/03/2023 08:12

Fallon Fox already fractured Tamika Brents' skull. Nobody cares

Actually a hell of a lot of people care and are trying to change things. You could join us. A good start is raising awareness of the issue.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:28

@2023forme they are women hating womenphobes.

Even having a man announce for the world athletics organisation what women's rights should be.. Men dictating to us little women yet again.

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 24/03/2023 12:25

Your heading led me to believe you think he/she should be allowed.
I think it's wrong and I'm happy with the decision of Seb Coe.

2023forme · 24/03/2023 12:22

Naunet · 24/03/2023 12:10

Oh those Olympic regulations that allow men to keep male hormone levels and still play against women, rather than reduce them to female levels?

@Naunet - was about to say the exact same thing!

Speaks volumes that the IOC go to great lengths to rule out an unfair advantage with biologically intersex women who have higher levels of testosterone, competing against XX women. They are basically saying its not fair to allow women with disorders which cause hyperandrogenism to compete against "normal" women as it gives them an adavantage. But its okay to allow men, who have higher levels of testosterone than women, to compete against women.

I fail to understand why any sane person cannot see the whole agenda is discriminatory against women and continue the whataboutery about trans rights.

fUNNYfACE36 · 24/03/2023 12:20

JockSmashnova · 24/03/2023 11:19

However, in a martial arts class (not a sport) surely this is an ideal opportunity to train... (you're not hoping to only be capable of defending yourself against women, are you?)

id take issue with this. Martial arts are so much more than just ‘self defence against a man‘. Martial arts teach fitness, camaraderie, self esteem and are damn good fun. In my experience Sparring with a bloke, unless it’s an instructor, often doesn’t teach you much because they can usually overwhelm you the second they get within reach (and their reach is longer and reactions are faster anyway). I’ve done judo, karate, MMA and sword sports. Even with a weapon like a sword, an average male can just smash through any attempt to block them. You try to parry a strike and just end up being hit with your sword, then theirs and spraining a wrist as well.

if it’s self defence you want, you’d be better off doing a specific self defence course — and even then, the strength difference is such that the expert advice to women is more along the lines of ‘try not to get into a situation like that, and if you do, don’t fight, just bloody well run‘

I think it was z fault of the instructor pairing unsuitable opponents in the post where the op says she was onjured by a transwoman.Most martial arts classes are mixed.Absolutely no treason why they should not have been there

musingsinmidlife · 24/03/2023 12:19

Naunet · 24/03/2023 12:10

Oh those Olympic regulations that allow men to keep male hormone levels and still play against women, rather than reduce them to female levels?

Now that World Athletics has banned all transwomen regardless of testosterone level (they have banned anyone who went through male puberty from participating in women's sports), I don't think we will see these athletes at the Olympics

Rainbowshit · 24/03/2023 12:18

Dotjones · 24/03/2023 11:58

On the point of sports only, I don't have a problem with men and women competing together because sport should be a meritocracy. Elite sports don't award top prizes based on effort or someone doing their best, all that matters are the results and that is often down to biology - a person who is naturally shaped for a particular sporting role has an inherent advantage. In my view there should be no division based on gender, race, sexuality, religion or age, the only division should be based on performance.

You don't play any sports do you?

MarshaBradyo · 24/03/2023 12:13

inventinglouise · 24/03/2023 12:08

Do you genuinely not realise that no women would win anything, ever, if this were the case? Do you seriously have so little concept as how to much stronger and faster men are?
Or do you just not care about women?
Or are you taking the piss?

Not sure what their motive is, if they’re male or female, but it’s not right

Naunet · 24/03/2023 12:10

Sensibletrousers · 24/03/2023 12:09

Quoted from the article:

“Valentino, of medium height and slim build, said five years of hormone therapy had eroded any physical advantage and made her testosterone levels compliant with Olympic committee regulations.”

That is transitioning?

(I am on the fence by the way)

Oh those Olympic regulations that allow men to keep male hormone levels and still play against women, rather than reduce them to female levels?

Brightshinylight · 24/03/2023 12:10

I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman.

I would be supportive but also encourage him to do this respectfully and with consideration for others rather than have an no argument sense of entitlement that everyone should give up their rights, privacy and safety for him. Genuine trans people actually get this and live their lives without infringing on others rights.

I would also be checking his internet history to ensure they are making an informed decision and not been railroaded by a pressure group.

Sensibletrousers · 24/03/2023 12:09

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 08:06

Isn't it just lunacy.. Just because he says he's a woman, they have to include him! Still has his penis, undergone no transitioning but just wants the physical advantage of playing against women to make himself feel like a big man.

Quoted from the article:

“Valentino, of medium height and slim build, said five years of hormone therapy had eroded any physical advantage and made her testosterone levels compliant with Olympic committee regulations.”

That is transitioning?

(I am on the fence by the way)

musingsinmidlife · 24/03/2023 12:09

Male puberty gives males an advantage that no other characteristic really gives. HIgh school boys outperform Olympian and world record holding women.
https://boysvswomen.com/#/ Some of these are outdated too for example the boys 5K high school record is 13:30 now. Most female Olympians have similar personal best as top <16 year old boys.

I used to play hockey and was one of the stronger female players when I played on a woman's team. Then I played on a rec co-ed lead and a guy who weighed less than I did and was out of shape checked me and I flew and was injured. This strength just from being male was overpowering to my female in shape fit athlete strength.

If boys are faster than elite female athletes, should males compete in female athletics?

See how the best high school boys stack up against the best female Olympians and World Record holders in Track & Field and Swimming.

https://boysvswomen.com/#/

inventinglouise · 24/03/2023 12:08

Dotjones · 24/03/2023 11:58

On the point of sports only, I don't have a problem with men and women competing together because sport should be a meritocracy. Elite sports don't award top prizes based on effort or someone doing their best, all that matters are the results and that is often down to biology - a person who is naturally shaped for a particular sporting role has an inherent advantage. In my view there should be no division based on gender, race, sexuality, religion or age, the only division should be based on performance.

Do you genuinely not realise that no women would win anything, ever, if this were the case? Do you seriously have so little concept as how to much stronger and faster men are?
Or do you just not care about women?
Or are you taking the piss?

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 12:07

After @Dotjones disgusting comments on another thread on a similar subject, I'm concluding that they're just out for attention.

I don't want to engage with the possibility that the meant the comment on the thread about Barbie Khardashian

Naunet · 24/03/2023 12:07

SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 11:59

What a brilliant way to encourage women and girls into sport and ensure the safety of participants.
Slow hand clap.

All that matters is winning, not health and fitness, not having fun, not safety or fairness. I’d say expand it though, we want the best, and humans aren’t the best at most things. I’d say we should start introducing other animals to sport too, specifically bears to male MMA and wrestling…

whatkatydid2013 · 24/03/2023 12:06

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:45

@whatkatydid2013 what's your stance on men violating & infiltrating women's sports & spaces. Men with penises. People would be much more compassionate if they started lobbying for trans sports teams, toilets, changing rooms etc.. But no their aim is to invade & take over women's activities, spaces & freedoms.

I already said

“I have no issue with people stating facts. It’s impossible to change sex, it’s not reasonable or fair to allow male people in female only spaces like prisons/shelters etc regardless of their gender identity or expression”

Clearly you are choosing to ignore that. Would people be more sympathetic if “they” did various things to campaign for third spaces? I’d like to think you are right but I suspect the more likely response from many would be that it was unreasonable to request or too expensive. There have been campaigns from trans people for third spaces in the past. Not from lobby groups necessarily but definitely from individuals and they seem to have got limited exposure (example I found with minimal effort - https://www.change.org/p/boris-johnson-a-plea-for-third-spaces-for-transgender-men-and-women)

I really don’t get why this is such a with us or against us issue for people. It’s got to be possible to find a solution where you protect single sex spaces and make provision for transgender people.

Sign the Petition

A Plea for Third Spaces for Transmen and Transwomen

https://www.change.org/p/boris-johnson-a-plea-for-third-spaces-for-transgender-men-and-women

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 12:04

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:56

I just saw a Facebook comment on a pro trans page suggesting trans only events. The poster was attacked & accused of wanting transgender athletes "segregated"..

Well then how about instead of trans only events, people who believe they have gender identities can set up their own sporting competitions with different categories according to gender identity, and any women who identify as "cis women" and want to be allies can go and compete as trans women.

Of course, it could end up with only male athletes qualifying and winning in the men's, women's and non binary categories, but if that happens, the "cis women", female non binary people and trans men (provided they aren't on testosterone) can just compete as women in regular sporting competitions.

maddening · 24/03/2023 12:01

Dotjones · 24/03/2023 11:58

On the point of sports only, I don't have a problem with men and women competing together because sport should be a meritocracy. Elite sports don't award top prizes based on effort or someone doing their best, all that matters are the results and that is often down to biology - a person who is naturally shaped for a particular sporting role has an inherent advantage. In my view there should be no division based on gender, race, sexuality, religion or age, the only division should be based on performance.

And let's cancel the para Olympics while we are at it.

heathspeedwell · 24/03/2023 12:01

@Dotjones there would be no such thing as women's sports or the Paralympics in your warped vision of sport.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 12:00

whatkatydid2013

You are mistaken about so many things.

Most women do not value gender roles, they are oppressive. The clue is in the name gender critical, women who describe themselves this way are critical of gender, it should be redundant in a progressive society.

The confusion about sex and gender in equality policy and law is entirely down to Stonewall. There is a reason they want to erase the distinction and in fact they campaigned to have "sex" removed from the EA and replaced with gender. They tried to do it by stealth and then denied that's what they had tried to do.

This is a movement that hates women. I will not tie myself in knots trying to find language which does not offend anyone to describe the problem, that would be a doomed mission.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.
SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 11:59

Dotjones · 24/03/2023 11:58

On the point of sports only, I don't have a problem with men and women competing together because sport should be a meritocracy. Elite sports don't award top prizes based on effort or someone doing their best, all that matters are the results and that is often down to biology - a person who is naturally shaped for a particular sporting role has an inherent advantage. In my view there should be no division based on gender, race, sexuality, religion or age, the only division should be based on performance.

What a brilliant way to encourage women and girls into sport and ensure the safety of participants.
Slow hand clap.

Dotjones · 24/03/2023 11:58

On the point of sports only, I don't have a problem with men and women competing together because sport should be a meritocracy. Elite sports don't award top prizes based on effort or someone doing their best, all that matters are the results and that is often down to biology - a person who is naturally shaped for a particular sporting role has an inherent advantage. In my view there should be no division based on gender, race, sexuality, religion or age, the only division should be based on performance.