Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
turbonerd · 24/03/2023 13:14

Nanny0gg · 24/03/2023 12:49

How is that the same thing at all?

Gay people are not suffering from a mental illness or body dysphoria. They want to be who they are. They also don't want to take away anyone else's rights. Transpeople want to be who they're not. What does being a woman or a man actually mean?

And biologically they WILL always be the sex they were born.

Exactly. Well said.

Abitofalark · 24/03/2023 13:11

gencritdd · 24/03/2023 08:31

I think your title reads wrong?

It certainly reads long.

ThreeblackCats · 24/03/2023 13:07

Just remember dear Mumsnetters, that ‘men’ who can only win at sport by pretending they identify as ‘women’ are basically just shit at their chosen sport and the only way they can hope to win is by playing as the gentle sex!
So a 19 stone woman called Rita instead of Peter who still sports a full beard is just a rubbish footballer/cyclist/ swimmer.

Sassyfox · 24/03/2023 13:07

There have been a couple of instances where women (wrongly or rightly) have been banned from playing because their natural testosterone levels are too high and it would be unfair.

Yet there are men who are allowed to compete who have had years of much higher testosterone levels and benefitted from the effects of it their entire lives.

It is very unfair.

CandyLeBonBon · 24/03/2023 13:07

@BoogieFun

'...And a biological male Autistic person who waa seeking treatment to transition who told me they wanted to transition because 'women are much better at being empathic and understanding other people's feelings'.
*
So to me, their desire to transition was because being a 'woman' would magically stop them from having the social communication, interaction and imagination difficulties that were part of their ASC. And they have sensory things and just preferences where they liked soft fabrics so thought that wanting to wear silks, satins and the physical freedom of shirts and dresses so they meant they must really be a woman?'*

Yes. I think this is very possibly what's going on. Thankyou for putting into words what was a nebulous mess in my head!

ChateauMargaux · 24/03/2023 13:01

In 2021, the Sports Council Equality Group who represent the governing bodies of Sport England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland said:
'Competitive fairness cannot be reconciled with self-identification into the female category in gender- affected sport.'
'sports should retain sex categorisation'
'testosterone suppression is unlikely to guarantee fairness between transgender women and natal females in gender-affected sports:',
‘Case-by-case’ assessment is unlikely to be practical nor verifiable for entry'
'Categorisation by sex is lawful, and hence the requirement to request information relating to birth sex is appropriate.'

Any UK sporting organisation permitting trans identifying male persons from competing in female sport should be challenged based on the guidance from SCEG.

The example in the OP is from Ireland, where self id has been in place for somtime and no such guidance exists.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:59

FOJN · 24/03/2023 12:55

Too busy trying to make out that trans people have been banned from playing sport whilst giving very little attention to Uganda which has just introduced the death penalty for homosexuality.

@TheKeatingFive you're so right. They're too concerned about their first world problems 🙄
What's happening in Uganda is absolutely horrific.

OP posts:
Theeyeballsinthesky · 24/03/2023 12:58

The thing is @whatkatydid2013 back in the day before we realised how unrelenting TRA demands would be, many of us are where you are now

‘surely if we’re all reasonable we can find a solution, third spaces’ etc but then we realised that the relentless threats, anger, encroaching on women’s spaces was a feature not a bug

i think it was Datun who really crystallised this and she puts it much better than me but essentially the point of the spaces is the women in them. Without women in the room, it’s just a room. They need women to be in the space too for it to be validating. Hence the likes of Hannah mountcey being so angry at being asked to shower separately or the TW at work who when they found out women were using a different toilet to them (because you know not wanting to share with a man) tried to force them to use the same toilet as they did.

they don’t want third spaces, they want womens spaces

FOJN · 24/03/2023 12:55

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 12:51

Stonewall is very well funded. They could be ploughing millions into third space provision.

Why aren't they?

Too busy trying to make out that trans people have been banned from playing sport whilst giving very little attention to Uganda which has just introduced the death penalty for homosexuality.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:53

Again kudos to mumsnet this week for keeping up the discussions. Common sense is prevailing finally.

OP posts:
Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:52

@TheKeatingFive they just want to be in women's spaces & faces.. It's a joke.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 12:51

Stonewall is very well funded. They could be ploughing millions into third space provision.

Why aren't they?

RichardBarrister · 24/03/2023 12:51

In my view there should be no division based on gender, race, sexuality, religion or age, the only division should be based on performance.

I’m going to sweep the board in the KS1 races this sports day!!

Other athletes who are competing in categories not intended for them include Italian Valentina Petrillo 49.

A male athlete with a sight impairment, he not only competes very successfully in the able bodied women’s races (won all his races and set a new record) but he’s also allowed into the disabled women’s competition.

123wentaway · 24/03/2023 12:50

HoneyPotBee · 24/03/2023 08:11

I think I’ve seen this discussed before. It feels like this man is just taking the piss out of trans people. Nice to see MN drawing attention to it.

I think he’s taking the piss out of everyone.

Nanny0gg · 24/03/2023 12:49

SaysRelaaxxx · 24/03/2023 09:25

I agree!!! I do understand the point being made that there are physical differences that might make competing together in sport unfair/unsafe. But my word, the horrible attitudes of people on this thread! “No matter how many hormones they take, they will always be a MAN”…”it’s all a delusion in their head”…wow. What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality? Pitchforks and torches?

How is that the same thing at all?

Gay people are not suffering from a mental illness or body dysphoria. They want to be who they are. They also don't want to take away anyone else's rights. Transpeople want to be who they're not. What does being a woman or a man actually mean?

And biologically they WILL always be the sex they were born.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:48

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 12:43

They are allowed to compete in sports, which are categorised according to sex, not gender identity.

They could always compete in mixed sports, or as I said before, find some "cis" allies to set up sporting competitions which are categorised according to gender identity.

They need to set up their own trans leagues or play with the other big boys with penesis if they want to compete. They should no longer be permitted to bully & elbow their way into women's sports just because they "feel" like it. How was this ever allowed get this far?

OP posts:
SidewaysOtter · 24/03/2023 12:48

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 11:56

I just saw a Facebook comment on a pro trans page suggesting trans only events. The poster was attacked & accused of wanting transgender athletes "segregated"..

There was a FB/Twitter post I saw screenshotted a while back where the parent of a transgender/non-binary child suggested that there should be separate sports categories for those "AFAB" and those "AMAB" (in quotes, because no-one is assigned anything at birth) to allow for identities to be respected but the physical advantages to be recognised too.

I don't think it went down too well.

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 12:48

whatkatydid2013 · 24/03/2023 12:06

I already said

“I have no issue with people stating facts. It’s impossible to change sex, it’s not reasonable or fair to allow male people in female only spaces like prisons/shelters etc regardless of their gender identity or expression”

Clearly you are choosing to ignore that. Would people be more sympathetic if “they” did various things to campaign for third spaces? I’d like to think you are right but I suspect the more likely response from many would be that it was unreasonable to request or too expensive. There have been campaigns from trans people for third spaces in the past. Not from lobby groups necessarily but definitely from individuals and they seem to have got limited exposure (example I found with minimal effort - https://www.change.org/p/boris-johnson-a-plea-for-third-spaces-for-transgender-men-and-women)

I really don’t get why this is such a with us or against us issue for people. It’s got to be possible to find a solution where you protect single sex spaces and make provision for transgender people.

Hmm, 4,000 signatures. That's not many considering that there are estimated to be up to half a million trans people in the UK, and that petition will have been signed by people who are not trans themselves.

Could it possibly be that trans people don't actually want third spaces, they want to be validated as members of the opposite sex?

From my point of view, in principle I would support third spaces, even though it would cost an awful lot of money to accommodate a small number of people who already have access to facilities and sports for members of their own sex.

In practice, it would be a complete waste of time and money because they don't "just want to pee", they want to be in women's spaces. So we could spend all this money creating third spaces for trans people, only for transgender males to still use women's spaces.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 12:47

this was suggested on a Facebook article & trans posters said they did not want to be segregated 🙄 they have their rights & should be allowed to compete in women's sport not segregated!

Oh I know, right.

But they need to get used to the idea that they can't have every single thing they want.

There are solutions. If they're going to reject all these sensible solutions, then that's on them. It's not women's problem.

Naunet · 24/03/2023 12:46

2023forme · 24/03/2023 12:22

@Naunet - was about to say the exact same thing!

Speaks volumes that the IOC go to great lengths to rule out an unfair advantage with biologically intersex women who have higher levels of testosterone, competing against XX women. They are basically saying its not fair to allow women with disorders which cause hyperandrogenism to compete against "normal" women as it gives them an adavantage. But its okay to allow men, who have higher levels of testosterone than women, to compete against women.

I fail to understand why any sane person cannot see the whole agenda is discriminatory against women and continue the whataboutery about trans rights.

Yep, it’s pure male supremacy

BoogieFun · 24/03/2023 12:44

CandyLeBonBon · 24/03/2023 11:17

"@MaryHinges
I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman."

I have an adult son who cross dresses. I suspect there's an AGP element to it, based on his fashion choices, although he would probably deny it if asked. I'm betting on him 'coming out' with it the next 6 months. He's autistic and suffers with depression and ptsd from bullying. I don't make a fuss when he puts on a dress. But I absolutely do not affirm him as 'a woman'. He knows my GC stance, and my beliefs that you can't change sex. He attempted suicide last year (not related to the x dressing) and is now awaiting proper in depth therapy via the mental health team.

I would STILL be against him competing in women's sports, using women's changing rooms and taking women only spaces, simply to 'affirm' him. And if he threatened suicide if I didn't, I'd be involving the crisis team pronto.

Acceptance of reality is vital, for long term mental well-being. I love my son and accept he wants to appear 'feminine', even though that is, in my opinion absolutely buying into regressive stereotypes. However he's an adult and is allowed to do that. If he crosses a line by expecting me or anyone else to pretend he's an actual woman, that's when things get serious.

I work in mental health and have observed a huge rise in 'trans-identifying' Autistic people which is supported by the statistics and I'm so glad you brought this up

It got so huge that my local adult Autism service made groups for trans-identifying patients. Which everyone working there was concerned about.

Not because they are bigoted or transphobic but because Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder which effects the way that person experiences the world and their self-identity and how they interact with people close to them. And the world.

When we know that the recent massive increase in trans-identifying people includes many who have a diagnosis of ASC, there should at least be a pause in the thinking to try to understand why that is?

It doesn't mean to disregard those peoples thoughts or feelings but if the massive rise is in people with that neurodiversity, my question would be is it part of that neurodiversity?

I've personally met male individuals diagnosed as ASC who are saying they now identify as a woman and want to be called by a new name and she/her pronouns be used but they're wearing a skirt and have a beard. And when asked what they think a woman is? they can't say.

And a biological male Autistic person who waa seeking treatment to transition who told me they wanted to transition because 'women are much better at being empathic and understanding other people's feelings'.

So to me, their desire to transition was because being a 'woman' would magically stop them from having the social communication, interaction and imagination difficulties that were part of their ASC. And they have sensory things and just preferences where they liked soft fabrics so thought that wanting to wear silks, satins and the physical freedom of shirts and dresses so they meant they must really be a woman?

I don't want to gatekeep anyone's life experiences but the current paradigm is going against what has occurred for decades/centuries. It's eradicating cross-dressers and forcing people into being 'trans'

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 12:43

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:42

@TheKeatingFive this was suggested on a Facebook article & trans posters said they did not want to be segregated 🙄 they have their rights & should be allowed to compete in women's sport not segregated!

They are allowed to compete in sports, which are categorised according to sex, not gender identity.

They could always compete in mixed sports, or as I said before, find some "cis" allies to set up sporting competitions which are categorised according to gender identity.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 12:42

@TheKeatingFive this was suggested on a Facebook article & trans posters said they did not want to be segregated 🙄 they have their rights & should be allowed to compete in women's sport not segregated!

OP posts:
porridgecake · 24/03/2023 12:40

Untitledsquatboulder · 24/03/2023 12:28

Actually a hell of a lot of people care and are trying to change things. You could join us. A good start is raising awareness of the issue.

Indeed. I have been writing to my MP regularly since 2016. I have spoken to her in person a couple of times. I subscribe to as many you tube channels as I can and donate to every crowd funder I can afford. I share articles, blogs and books. I have a supply of stickers in my bag and use them.
I have no influence in the area of sport though, being an OAP in mediocre health.

Swipe left for the next trending thread