Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:46

Link to the springer article isn't working for me from MN. Here's a link to twitter, it's Sharon Davies TL, where the article is linked.

twitter.com/sharrond62/status/1639248099045679106?s=20

TodayInahurry · 24/03/2023 13:46

Just a man bullying women😡 and Keir Starmer won’t say what a woman is, so he won’t attempt to stop this evil

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 13:46

User339406 · 24/03/2023 13:42

I also have kids involved in GAA, I've written to them to object. I have no idea if they'll care.

We're in Scotland where gaelic football is very much a minority sport and the reason ds started playing was because of their inclusive, family friendly nature, compared to soccer which is obviously much more popular and therefore competitive so he wasn't getting a decent game (because he's not very good).

If this happened at our club I would be strongly protesting. Many of our women's players are only in their late teens, early 20s. They should not be put in a position where they either have to play against a man or publicly refuse to play against him. A woman of any age shouldn't be in that position but at least in my 40s I'd have no problem saying no.

Absolutely sports bodies need to be doing all they can to keep teenage girls active in sports. They don't give a hoot & the GAA are actually sponsored by a pharmaceutical company which produces hormone blockers & other trans medicines.. Money always talks with the GAA.

OP posts:
SidewaysOtter · 24/03/2023 13:45

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 12:51

Stonewall is very well funded. They could be ploughing millions into third space provision.

Why aren't they?

Because it's easier to take someone else's rights than create space for new ones, and because there's better headlines mileage in creating a 'them and us' situation by demonising women standing up for their rights because if you're one of us then you'll be donating to our coffers, right?

SillySausage81 · 24/03/2023 13:45

When I was younger I genuinely thought the word misogyny was hyperbole. I didn't think anyone hated women, and I didn't think sexism stemmed from hatred of women. (lol yeah, I know 🙄I was naive).

But there is simply no other explanation for some of this stuff, including this instance.

In order to think this is acceptable, you really have to believe women are worthless. That our safety counts for nothing. That the hopes and dreams of female athletes count for diddly squat next to the feelings of a bearer of The Almighty Penis.

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 13:45

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:42

Ta very much. I reached by a link in twitter, could that be where the foul up happened?

No. The legacy link from break it down is broken too.

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 13:44

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:21

Clip from morning Ireland which had a transgender scientist in to say science backs up trans playing in women's sports. No woman athlete on air to give a woman's perspective

Well he's wrong.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3

There are now many more studies which prove men maintain their advantage from male puberty and higher testosterone levels even after taking female hormones and suppressing testosterone.

Here is a different perspective with very similar conclusions from Harper.

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/55/15/865

Joanne Harper does continue to be brought into these discussions but the reality is that Harper knows. Harper is trying to prove now that Emily Bridges performance is significantly reduced but it seems like a very dodgy methodology.

Harper keeps trying to position it as 'inclusion' because they know that there is no fairness.

https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/55/15/865

OP posts:
User339406 · 24/03/2023 13:42

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 08:59

@HoneyPotBee i think we need to keep all this fresh in people's minds. I have three daughters who love sport including GAA here in Ireland. Why should one of my girls have to face him on the playing field. Him who says he's perfectly comfortable with his "genitals"..

I also have kids involved in GAA, I've written to them to object. I have no idea if they'll care.

We're in Scotland where gaelic football is very much a minority sport and the reason ds started playing was because of their inclusive, family friendly nature, compared to soccer which is obviously much more popular and therefore competitive so he wasn't getting a decent game (because he's not very good).

If this happened at our club I would be strongly protesting. Many of our women's players are only in their late teens, early 20s. They should not be put in a position where they either have to play against a man or publicly refuse to play against him. A woman of any age shouldn't be in that position but at least in my 40s I'd have no problem saying no.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:42

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 13:41

oopps. Let's try that again.

Hey everyone, this link seems to be broken. they must have moved it.

There is a copy if you plug the link into archive (dot) ph. I cannot post that link.

link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3

Ta very much. I reached by a link in twitter, could that be where the foul up happened?

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:41

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 13:27

@FOJN its so frustrating as an Irish woman that we weren't given a voice re the Athletics ban. We heard from a transgender scientist & a male doctor. It was like women didn't exist.

You think women can talk about science? You must be one of them feminazis. I bet you don't shave your legs or wear lipstick! 😂

Misogyny never goes out of fashion.

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 13:41

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:21

Clip from morning Ireland which had a transgender scientist in to say science backs up trans playing in women's sports. No woman athlete on air to give a woman's perspective

Well he's wrong.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3

There are now many more studies which prove men maintain their advantage from male puberty and higher testosterone levels even after taking female hormones and suppressing testosterone.

oopps. Let's try that again.

Hey everyone, this link seems to be broken. they must have moved it.

There is a copy if you plug the link into archive (dot) ph. I cannot post that link.

link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 13:38

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

FourTeaFallOut · 24/03/2023 13:38

Living as a woman certainly doesn't seem to include pulling your weight in unpaid labour.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:36

Curiosity101 · 24/03/2023 13:17

It all feels very much like a grey area to me. At what part are you womanly enough to play with biological women? I don't have a strong enough opinion either way on it because I know men that have transitioned or are transitioning who I would not want to be excluded, but equally appreciate that a man could claim to be transgender for nefarious reasons and that in sports this definitely could confer some unfair advantages to the person who has transitioned.

If the issue was just physical safety in a contact sport then theoretically it'd be sensible to impose size limits (upper and lower) or introduce weight categories similar to boxing? Cause you could still have large biological women playing on teams with very small biological women.

A man can never be womanly. He can adopt a feminine presentation but he can not adopt a womanly presentation. A woman will alway be female no matter how masculine she presents.

Why do you think the male transitioners you know should not be excluded?

What would be your criteria for inclusion/exclusion?

How can we tell the difference between a man pretending to be trans and someone more sincere in their identity?

A man will always be stronger and faster than a woman of a similar size and age. Men in their late 40's are trouncing female cyclists who are at the peak of fitness and in their 20's.

MMA fighters are separated into weight categories and yet a trans fighter fractured the skull of a female opponent.

https://www.sportskeeda.com/mma/news-when-transgender-fighter-fallon-fox-broke-opponent-s-skull-mma-fight

When transgender fighter Fallon Fox broke her opponent's skull in MMA fight

Fallon Fox, the first MMA fighter to come out as transgender, once fractured the skull of her opponent in an MMA fight in 2014.

https://www.sportskeeda.com/mma/news-when-transgender-fighter-fallon-fox-broke-opponent-s-skull-mma-fight

WickedSerious · 24/03/2023 13:35

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 09:17

The first thing I would do is get him psychologically assessed. Then explain to him he'll always be a man no matter what mutilation road he goes down. I wouldn't be sugar coating it to appear a liberal, woke, mother. He'd get the hard facts & a few trips to the psychologist.

If my son wanted to 'live as a woman' I'd insist that he lived as me for a couple of weeks.

Not that he'd last a couple of weeks.

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 13:33

Sassyfox · 24/03/2023 13:07

There have been a couple of instances where women (wrongly or rightly) have been banned from playing because their natural testosterone levels are too high and it would be unfair.

Yet there are men who are allowed to compete who have had years of much higher testosterone levels and benefitted from the effects of it their entire lives.

It is very unfair.

To be clear though, these are NOT female athletes at all.

No woman has a 'natural testosterone' level that is 'too high' for playing sport. They are male people with differences of sex development. But they are definitely male. And most likely have realised they were male from puberty.

And therefore to be very blunt, which you may not like to hear, there is very little difference except they may have, or may not have after puberty, been brought up a woman.

Unfortunately the media has stated they are 'women' but they are not. These males though have made the choice to compete when they know they are not female and that if a female took testosterone they would be banned.

Happylittlechicken · 24/03/2023 13:29

It all feels very much like a grey area to me. At what part are you womanly enough to play with biological women?

when you’re female. HTH 😀

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 13:27

@FOJN its so frustrating as an Irish woman that we weren't given a voice re the Athletics ban. We heard from a transgender scientist & a male doctor. It was like women didn't exist.

OP posts:
Weallgottachangesometime · 24/03/2023 13:26

I’m having some back and forth on TT about this at the moment. I really struggle with the basic premise of the argument that seems to be that sex isn’t that important in sport.

Yet when you ask basic questions there is no logical answer…

*If sex isn’t relevant then why do men outperform women in almost every sport. I literally can’t think of any, where the male and female sport is the same, where females outperform men.

*If some people believe that sex isn’t relevant why would you ask for transwomen to be admitted to the female category instead of asking for all sex categories to be abolished.

*If trans hormone treatment make that much difference where are all the tea males competing in male sports and beating the best times.

Weallgottachangesometime · 24/03/2023 13:22

Curiosity101 · 24/03/2023 13:17

It all feels very much like a grey area to me. At what part are you womanly enough to play with biological women? I don't have a strong enough opinion either way on it because I know men that have transitioned or are transitioning who I would not want to be excluded, but equally appreciate that a man could claim to be transgender for nefarious reasons and that in sports this definitely could confer some unfair advantages to the person who has transitioned.

If the issue was just physical safety in a contact sport then theoretically it'd be sensible to impose size limits (upper and lower) or introduce weight categories similar to boxing? Cause you could still have large biological women playing on teams with very small biological women.

The thing is there is a multitude of physical advantages that males have over women in sport not just height and weight, there are hormonal, lung, bones density etc.

A 5ft male runner would beat a 5ft female runner because of all the other advantages being male includes.

Is it realistically possible to check all those things and put people into categories on the basis of all the different biological advantages. No.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 13:21

Clip from morning Ireland which had a transgender scientist in to say science backs up trans playing in women's sports. No woman athlete on air to give a woman's perspective

Well he's wrong.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3

There are now many more studies which prove men maintain their advantage from male puberty and higher testosterone levels even after taking female hormones and suppressing testosterone.

Transgender Women in the Female Category of Sport: Perspectives on Testosterone Suppression and Performance Advantage - Sports Medicine

Males enjoy physical performance advantages over females within competitive sport. The sex-based segregation into male and female sporting categories does not account for transgender persons who experience incongruence between their biological sex and...

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-020-01389-3

Curiosity101 · 24/03/2023 13:17

It all feels very much like a grey area to me. At what part are you womanly enough to play with biological women? I don't have a strong enough opinion either way on it because I know men that have transitioned or are transitioning who I would not want to be excluded, but equally appreciate that a man could claim to be transgender for nefarious reasons and that in sports this definitely could confer some unfair advantages to the person who has transitioned.

If the issue was just physical safety in a contact sport then theoretically it'd be sensible to impose size limits (upper and lower) or introduce weight categories similar to boxing? Cause you could still have large biological women playing on teams with very small biological women.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 13:17

Joanna Harper, scientist and trans athlete speaks to Kate Varley as the World Athletics Council announces they are to ban transwomen from participating in female category events; Prof Donal O'Shea, Endocrinologist, also gives his reaction to the decision.

Please watch the above link & see the trans propaganda that is currently ruling Irish media

OP posts:
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread