Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
YouSetTheTone · 24/03/2023 19:15

Over 1,000 votes and 97% say it is unreasonable that this man is playing in women’s sport. Are you reading this Labour Party?

Emmamoo89 · 24/03/2023 19:13

Its ridiculous

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 19:12

Yes, the sad truth is that a third space would make it very clear that they are not in fact women.

There is a conflict of interests here which cannot be resolved by compromise. They want to be in women's spaces. Women don't want them to be in there. There is no option where everybody gets what they want.

YouSetTheTone · 24/03/2023 19:12

and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

No. They can compete or exercise in sport in their sex category. What part of ‘being a woman’ do they need while playing sport? If it’s ‘presenting’ as a woman, well, most women tie their hair back and wear athletic clothes while exercising. Many don’t wear make up because they’ll get sweaty and hot. No one needs to ‘affirm their identity’ by putting on a costume of a woman while playing sport because most sporting women don’t adhere to those stereotypes while playing.

So basically what they want is the advantages it brings physically, or the thrills of running around with women, is that right?

No thank you.

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 24/03/2023 19:02

What I hope is someone comes up with a solution where everyone 'fits' without compromise.

There is such a solution, @Curiosity101

A third space. But transwomen don’t want that.

They want unfettered access to women’s single-sex spaces. Nothing less will do.

This disingenuous trope that trans people just want to get on and live their lives.

Oh, that that were true. If it were, this debate wouldn’t be raging.

If they were just getting on with living their lives, they wouldn’t be insisting on access to women’s single sex spaces. They wouldn’t be colonising our language and silencing us.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 18:42

And you can't please all of the people all of the time.
Now they can go & fuck off. Trans need to stop latching onto the lgb groups who have worked tirelessly for years to get the freedom the have now.

They need to jog on & stop infiltering women's spaces & sports. Like lgb women's groups have worked tirelessly to get women the level of equalilty we have now.

Trans need to focus on getting trans spaces & trans sports. Trans leave lgb groups & women the fuck alone.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/03/2023 18:35

now might have something they care about denied to them

Well sorry, but we can't always get what we want.

This. The end.

Turfwars · 24/03/2023 16:55

...and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

I wanted to join the Gardai, or the Army, or if not become an Air Hostess.
Except at the time, I didn't meet the minimum height requirement.

The careers I cared about were denied to me by something I couldn't help being. Should the rules that were built around protecting the safety of the employee, or affecting their ability to do the job, be disregarded just short-arse me wanted the job?

Whether we like it or not, there are many many things that exclude us from things we would like to do. I just have to suck it up that my body is built the way it is and that I can't identify into a 5ft 9" body - or that I can demand that everyone pretend to be looking up at me because my feelings get hurt when I'm made aware of my ahem, shortcomings.

The truth of it is that for many transgender women, they don't want the third space. It's never been about them wanting a safe place to piss. If they had that space it's just a room and it doesn't validate them in the same way. I know I'm not explaining it right but they will never accept third spaces, third categories in sports. Everything is about pushing into womens spaces, and beating us at being women.

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 16:50

...and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

But what they care about is being allowed to compete in sporting categories for the opposite sex.

No other group has the right to do this.

All they are being denied is the right to do something no one else is allowed to do either.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 16:39

@Weallgottachangesometime exactly. Nothing stopping them from being included within their own sex or setting up their own trans games!

OP posts:
Weallgottachangesometime · 24/03/2023 16:37

...and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

They aren’t being denied entry into sport though. They just have to stay without their own sex category. Everyone doesn’t have a right to access whatever they want

FOJN · 24/03/2023 16:33

...and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

I care about single sex spaces and fairness in sport but some men feel entitled to them so I will be denied them through no fault of my own.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 16:31

Exactly @Rainbowshit & had the trans athlete competed with men like himself he would more than likely be bottom of the pile. Lazy shites. There's a method to their fucking madness all right, conniving fucks.

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 24/03/2023 16:26

Someone who has already had a tough time becoming ok with themselves as a person, and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

And what about the female athletes who have worked so hard to get to the top of their field. Who have made huge personal sacrifices to be the best they can be at their sport.

Then they are denied a medal, or a placing or a scholarship that they really care about by a male who is nowhere near as talented, hasn't worked anywhere near as hard and has got there by virtue of being male.

FUCK THAT

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 16:20

"Those people as a whole have not sought to find solutions - they were part of 'no debate' if they were there using the female spaces, words and sports."

I mean that those people as a whole have not sought to find solutions - they were part of 'no debate' if they were there using the female spaces, words and sports - even if they were not yelling 'no debate' at women. They need to accept that they were complicit.

And if they never came forward, why? Because they were actually comfortable with using spaces some without the permission of women as a whole gave them permission to sue?

Or because they were scared?

And if they were scared of their own community, why the fuck are people in that community (not you, this is a general point) making their own people and members scared of speaking? And why the fuck is that community declared to be so wonderfully loving and tolerant as I have seen so often on MN?

Because I believe that there were trans people who were and remain scared of their community. It is defies belief that people try to spin the lie that a group that allows women to be screamed at, threatened, assaulted and silenced know one fucking thing about tolerance. And I doubt they know anything about 'love' either.

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 16:12

Curiosity101 · 24/03/2023 15:42

I feel like my comments might have been taken slightly badly by some.

But to answer one question someone posed about why I wouldn't want some of the people who I know who have transitioned excluded.

It's not so much that I have an opinion on whether it's right or wrong for them to be included in sports in particular. I can see a lot of scientific research that has been shared here that gives good reason to why you'd keep them separate!

But a large part of me empathises with the individuals. Someone who has already had a tough time becoming ok with themselves as a person, and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them. I still don't have strong feelings one way or another about what's right, although clearly I can see there obviously is plenty of research to suggest keeping a biological sex based separation so logically that's probably the right decision. But I still empathise for what is possibly a sizeable population of people who (sport aside) still don't feel like there is always a place in society for them.

What I find extra difficult (slight tangent) is the fact that there will be some trans women who are excluded from women's spaces and forced to use men's (just because that's how society is set up). And I empathise with how I would feel to have to use the men's space, and how uncomfortable I would feel but on the flip side I can see that it can put women at risk and that shouldn't be the case either. At the end of the day those most at risk/most vulnerable should probably be protected first, which in this case would be biological women. But it still makes me sad when I think about the individuals I know and how life is for them. What I hope is someone comes up with a solution where everyone 'fits' without compromise. Feels like a fantasy though, which is what leaves me in the grey area without a strong opinion either way.

I think you need to accept that in the cases of female single sex spaces, third spaces has been discussed for a long time.

And rejected.

Maybe even by your friends. Rejected because for some male people, it is not a safety issue, it is the women in those spaces being needed for whatever reason those male people demand. To validate is but one reason they demand access to the female single sex spaces.

Once women see this, then why should any woman support males accessing these spaces.

Just like the sports issue, what other male person who has 'worked so hard' to be who they are should be allowed access to female sports or single sex spaces. The logic fails every single time.

Sorry, no male has 'by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them'. Female spaces and sports were NEVER for them to access. Nor was any description of 'woman' theirs to take.

This might sound blunt and uncaring, however it is the raw and unvarnished truth.

Any male who has ever sought to access female spaces and sports on account of how they felt did so without once respecting the female half of the population. Whether they intended to or not, this was misogynistic of them.

If these males want to build their sports category to suit their needs, go for it. But instead, every one of those males who accessed female spaces and sports in this way needs to take responsibility that they chose to do so instead of finding a solution that worked.

Blame Stonewall. Blame allies. Blame women who told these males it was 'ok' when it never was. But a male who valued female people of all ages who did this need to take responsibility. Those people as a whole have not sought to find solutions - they were part of 'no debate' if they were there using the female spaces, words and sports.

I join you now in hoping that they can find solutions that work to fit their unique needs. But it is time to be honest about this.

OP posts:
SpoonfulofArsnicMakesTheMedicineGoDown · 24/03/2023 15:52

now might have something they care about denied to them

Well sorry, but we can't always get what we want.

I mean I want Henry Caville to be my sex slave. I identify as his lover. I'm really sad about the restraining order. I should just have Henry as I am sad and really want it and I am the most vulnerable ever. I'm in at least two intersectional vulnerable categories. Henry as a white male is privileged. He needs to give in.

Or maybe that's fucking ridiculous as is you granting women's rights and spaces for men because of hurty feels.

Tough shit. Life's not fair.
Sorry, too abrupt?
I mean, I'm empathetic and respect blah blah blah but ultimately a compromise isn't possible.

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 15:50

Someone who has already had a tough time becoming ok with themselves as a person, and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them.

But you seem to be glossing over the fact that they never had any rights to that thing in the first place.

It doesn't matter how marginalised people are or how tough things have been, it doesn't legitimise them taking things that are meant for others. Others who have also had their own 'tough times' to deal with.

If they had campaigned for their own spaces and categories to begin with, none of this would have happened.

So no grey areas at all, I don't think. Just people who went about things the wrong way.

Curiosity101 · 24/03/2023 15:42

I feel like my comments might have been taken slightly badly by some.

But to answer one question someone posed about why I wouldn't want some of the people who I know who have transitioned excluded.

It's not so much that I have an opinion on whether it's right or wrong for them to be included in sports in particular. I can see a lot of scientific research that has been shared here that gives good reason to why you'd keep them separate!

But a large part of me empathises with the individuals. Someone who has already had a tough time becoming ok with themselves as a person, and who by no real fault of their own now might have something they care about denied to them. I still don't have strong feelings one way or another about what's right, although clearly I can see there obviously is plenty of research to suggest keeping a biological sex based separation so logically that's probably the right decision. But I still empathise for what is possibly a sizeable population of people who (sport aside) still don't feel like there is always a place in society for them.

What I find extra difficult (slight tangent) is the fact that there will be some trans women who are excluded from women's spaces and forced to use men's (just because that's how society is set up). And I empathise with how I would feel to have to use the men's space, and how uncomfortable I would feel but on the flip side I can see that it can put women at risk and that shouldn't be the case either. At the end of the day those most at risk/most vulnerable should probably be protected first, which in this case would be biological women. But it still makes me sad when I think about the individuals I know and how life is for them. What I hope is someone comes up with a solution where everyone 'fits' without compromise. Feels like a fantasy though, which is what leaves me in the grey area without a strong opinion either way.

Helleofabore · 24/03/2023 15:12

Curiosity101 · 24/03/2023 13:17

It all feels very much like a grey area to me. At what part are you womanly enough to play with biological women? I don't have a strong enough opinion either way on it because I know men that have transitioned or are transitioning who I would not want to be excluded, but equally appreciate that a man could claim to be transgender for nefarious reasons and that in sports this definitely could confer some unfair advantages to the person who has transitioned.

If the issue was just physical safety in a contact sport then theoretically it'd be sensible to impose size limits (upper and lower) or introduce weight categories similar to boxing? Cause you could still have large biological women playing on teams with very small biological women.

By the way Curiosity are you aware that females have more delicate skulls, and inside those skulls are brains with more delicate nerve fibres.

This makes female people so much more prone to concussion and serious brain damage. Including, no less, early dementia from repetitive damage to the brain.

The 'power' of a 'large biological woman' for so many reasons will not be the same as a 'small weakened male'. Just because they might have one limiting factor, they still have skeletal and muscular type advantages. FFS. Even bone density is greater.

A 'large biological woman' could very likely cause damage. But it is hugely more likely that a 'small weakened man' will cause more damage.

The lies that certain groups are very deliberately spreading is very harmful for all female sports people at any age. And those attempting the 'whataboutery' of size categories are some of the most ideologically driven and dishonest in my opinion.

Happy to provide you with links to the brain component research. Or you can look it up . It was done by the Swansea University.

summersanchez · 24/03/2023 15:09

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 14:55

Rather than using facts and data to justify the exclusion of trans women from women's sports, I prefer to flip it round.

How do you justify their inclusion?

What do they have in common with natal women and girls, such that it makes sense for there to be a sporting category which includes them both?

They do not share a biological sex.

They do not share any kind of identity.

The "gender identity of woman" appears to be something that only transgender males actually have.

So if you have a sporting category consisting of "transgender male athletes who believe their gender identity is woman, and female athletes of any or no gender identity provided they are not on testosterone"... why?

What is the purpose of this category? Justify its existence to us, please.

Agreed

Jimboscott0115 · 24/03/2023 14:59

From a sporting perspective it's really black and white, anyone who has undergone make adolescence has a significant advantage in numerous areas to anyone who underwent female adolescence in areas of

Lean mass, muscle mass, bone mass and various other areas, even in men and women who are ostensibly the same height and weight.

asbmr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1359/JBMR.041005

As for the guy in the OP, he's an embarrassment.

RosaBonheur · 24/03/2023 14:55

Rather than using facts and data to justify the exclusion of trans women from women's sports, I prefer to flip it round.

How do you justify their inclusion?

What do they have in common with natal women and girls, such that it makes sense for there to be a sporting category which includes them both?

They do not share a biological sex.

They do not share any kind of identity.

The "gender identity of woman" appears to be something that only transgender males actually have.

So if you have a sporting category consisting of "transgender male athletes who believe their gender identity is woman, and female athletes of any or no gender identity provided they are not on testosterone"... why?

What is the purpose of this category? Justify its existence to us, please.

TheSingingBean · 24/03/2023 14:52

TheKeatingFive · 24/03/2023 14:48

There's no such thing as being 'fake' trans or a troll however. You're trans if you say you are. That's the only criteria. Acceptance without exception.

This is where it all unravels, isn't it?

It's why Nicola Sturgeon couldn't bring herself to say 'he' when discussing Isla Bryson, because 'I am what I say I am' is the foundation on which the whole edifice of Self ID rests.

Once you start to say, well that person isn't REALLY who they say they are, the tower collapses. As it must.