Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this man (who has undergone no transitioning) should be allow play on women's teams. Sick to my stomach this is happening.

388 replies

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 07:43

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

This man (in red) has undergone no attempt to transition. Yet he's playing on women's GAA football teams in Ireland because he feels he's a woman.
Imagine him tackling a poor woman would have no chance. Prior to that he played women's rugby.
Why is this happening in women's sports, prisons, changing rooms, toilets.
Why are trans women's rights more important than ours.
This man (who is in no way a woman or even a trans woman) needs to play with a team where the rest of the players have penises too or else start his own trans league. Get out of women's sports & spaces.

transgender

Transgender GAA Player: 'I Wish To Leave Lasting Legacy'

Transgender GAA player Giulia Valentino has broken her silence after a controversy erupted when a referee said she couldn't continue playing because of her

https://extra.ie/2022/09/09/news/transgender-gaa-player-speaks-out

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
whatkatydid2013 · 24/03/2023 09:37

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 24/03/2023 08:42

I’d tell him he’s perfect the way he is. He is the best and only version of him and he doesn’t need to change a thing.

He should present as however he wishes (there are no laws on men wearing dresses, make-up and having long hair - you realise this, right?). But he can’t change sex.

So he should embrace himself, just as the people who love him do.

❤️

I’ve been to some diversity training at work and there are a couple of trans women who regularly present at them. One is in her early 50s and has only recently transitioned and it’s heartbreaking really hearing the way her family reacted to her wanting to wear dresses and make up when young. She talked about her mother hitting and berating her and making it clear she wouldn’t be welcome in the family if she turned up dressed in women’s clothing.

I do wonder if Trans people feel like they must be in the wrong body primarily because people are so rigid in their ideas about what it is to be a boy or a girl.

My daughter prefers boys clothing and short hair. She’s mistaken as a boy all the time and sometimes it bothers her but we’ve never suggested she can’t do as she pleases when it comes to her style and we’ve consistently told her that even though some people think it’s really important girls/boys only wear certain things, have certain hairstyles or like certain toys that’s just because they don’t understand that everyone is different and likes different things.

If she tells me when she’s older she feels like she’s a boy I would be supportive in her exploring why she feels that way and ultimately if she wanted to transition I would support that too (though not as a child). I really think it’s helpful to separate gender identity, gender presentation and sex when having discussion about trans issues. It would also be helpful if it could be agreed what terminology will be used for sex (eg male/female) vs gender (eg him/her and man/woman)

So if someone whose gender presentation is generally more masculine identifies as a woman and decides they would prefer to use she/her then I don’t see it as an issue and think everyone should try to accommodate that regardless of their sex. Sure you might forget sometimes and correct yourself but deliberately using different pronouns than you’ve been asked to is just rude and, knowing how much it can upset people, pretty nasty.

Regardless of what your gender identify and gender presentation are your sex won’t change so if there are single sex spaces it’s appropriate you use the one for your sex. If doing so might cause safety issues there should be the possibility of providing an alternative without that being using the facilities for the other sex. In the case of sports you could easily have male only, female only & open. In the case of changing rooms, toilets etc you could provide more individual facilities suitable for anyone to use (could also use as a mechanism to increase availability of bathrooms for disabled people). In the case of things like prisons, refuge centres, rape crisis centres etc where females are very vulnerable you could have a separate service for males or in the latter case specific times with open/male sessions.

While most of what is being asked for in terms of protection of single sex spaces is totally reasonable I find it unsettling how nasty many women are about it. Some are not but many describe trans women in such awful terms and it seems like they think they are all disgusting or sexually deviant or deliberately trying to hurt females. Surely you can have some compassion for people who are trans and having a really tough time while also being firm that single sex spaces are important and should be protected?

Redebs · 24/03/2023 09:36

@maddening please don't quote Jordan Peterson. He's a seriously messed-up misogynistic

loislovesstewie · 24/03/2023 09:35

Please do not conflate homosexuality with men who want to pretend to be women. No matter what a person does to their body they will still have XY chromosomes. And I am heartily fed up with those who conflate DSDs with trans.

BoogieFun · 24/03/2023 09:34

If you're biologically male and actively seek out situations where you can physically or emotionally harm biolgical women, you're not 'identifying as a woman' at all. You're a man who doesn't care about women and doesn't care if you harm them.

Bookist · 24/03/2023 09:32

No one has ever successfully explained to me how these men can 'feel' like a woman inside? They aren't women and never have been so how can they possibly know how we feel inside. And being a woman isn't a collective consciousness anyway, we are not a hive mind. Some days I will be looking feminine and doing girly stuff but equally I can be smeared with engine oil and wearing a teenage boys tracksuit.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 24/03/2023 09:32

Women’s’ sport should be female only. Nobody who has a penis or has ever had a penis should be allowed anywhere near it. A blanket ban on any men or boys in womens’ sport, no matter how they identify, how special they think they are, how many drugs they’ve taken or watt operations they’ve had.

maddening · 24/03/2023 09:32

SaysRelaaxxx · 24/03/2023 09:25

I agree!!! I do understand the point being made that there are physical differences that might make competing together in sport unfair/unsafe. But my word, the horrible attitudes of people on this thread! “No matter how many hormones they take, they will always be a MAN”…”it’s all a delusion in their head”…wow. What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality? Pitchforks and torches?

A majority of trans identifying children that do not get transed end up as gay - transition is homophobic gay conversion.

MarshaBradyo · 24/03/2023 09:32

SaysRelaaxxx · 24/03/2023 09:25

I agree!!! I do understand the point being made that there are physical differences that might make competing together in sport unfair/unsafe. But my word, the horrible attitudes of people on this thread! “No matter how many hormones they take, they will always be a MAN”…”it’s all a delusion in their head”…wow. What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality? Pitchforks and torches?

They are male do you not agree, do you think they have changed sex?

Redebs · 24/03/2023 09:31

Howyiz · 24/03/2023 08:09

It is ridiculous! Especially as he isn't trans, he just has a fetish about wearing women's clothes. So women are being put in danger of injury so he can get his rocks off! It's disgusting!

Thank God some sporting bodies, like Athletics are starting to see the light.

"Valentino identifies as a woman and appears to have been diagnosed with gender dysphoria. A post on his Facebook wall suggests he has been prescribed wrong-sex hormones. However, in a podcast published in 2021, trans-identifying Valentino claimed to be "completely comfortable with my genitals."Beside women's football, he also engages in BDSM and fetish communities - a fact he advertises on his publicly available Facebook wall. Before moving to Ireland, under the pseudonym "DJ Mav," he played regularly at two "fetish clubs" in Rome: Ritual the Club and self-professed "world’s largest Fetish and Body Art Club" Torture Garden."

Sounds like he enjoys hurting people and the sports authorities are colluding in him hurting women.

KimberleyClark · 24/03/2023 09:29

World Athletics have banned transgender athletes who have undergone male puberty from women’s events. So that’s something.

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2023/mar/23/world-athletics-council-excludes-transgender-women-from-female-events

heathspeedwell · 24/03/2023 09:29

World Rugby conducted the most comprehensive research to date on having male people play contact sport against women. They found that women are significantly more likely to receive fatal or life-changing injuries when playing against a male.

Anybody who argues that it's 'kind' to allow male people to put women's lives at risk in sport is clearly showing that they don't believe women have any rights of our own.

Women are not just support fodder to validate men's feelings.

SheDoneAlreadyHadHersess · 24/03/2023 09:29

I am so sick of these fetish freaks being humoured.

Turnipworkharder · 24/03/2023 09:28

It's like something from a comedy film except it's not funny and it's not a film, unfortunately it's happening in real life.

Rainbowshit · 24/03/2023 09:28

SaysRelaaxxx · 24/03/2023 09:25

I agree!!! I do understand the point being made that there are physical differences that might make competing together in sport unfair/unsafe. But my word, the horrible attitudes of people on this thread! “No matter how many hormones they take, they will always be a MAN”…”it’s all a delusion in their head”…wow. What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality? Pitchforks and torches?

It's the biological truth FFS. This incursion into women's rights is happening because People have been bullied and scared into not telling the truth. It's over. Done. We will no longer comply with your attempts to control our speech.

Gay people did not ask anyone to deny reality.

loislovesstewie · 24/03/2023 09:28

More to the point, who are the 1% who think you are being unreasonable?

user1471538283 · 24/03/2023 09:27

It is always us that lose out whatever happens.

Even fully transitioned transwomen should not be allowed to compete with women. They've had the advantage of puberty and are stronger and faster.

This one though - just attention seeking. I know there are transwomen who are genuine but my god we are seeing more and more that just wants the good bits of being a woman (don't we all) and shacking up with lots of other transwomen and getting lots of attention.

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 09:27

maddening · 24/03/2023 08:54

Totally agree, there is not a "trans story" which comes without an underlying mental health issue, except for the AGPs which come from sexual fetish. Addressing the underlying issue should be the first port of call.

90% of children that present with actual dysphoria (the trendy aspect we seeing currently imo shows that there are people without dysphoria being captured) self resolve if no social transition or medical transition is undertaken. 80% of early presenting dysphoric children that self resolve turn out to be homosexual.

I have two friends who were tomboys in their early teens. They are now two of the most glamorous, feminine women I know.
Now in their early 40s they shudder to think what road they would have gone down in their teens & what irreversible damage they would have done to their bodies.
This was the time a time of no social media or bloody prounons. They were fully accepted for what they were harmless tomboys. Nooone in their ear saying you should identify as he/him cos you don't wear dresses... You hate make up, girly stuff & pink...you're definitely trans.
They thank the lord they didn't grow up in this era.

OP posts:
Bookist · 24/03/2023 09:25

thethinendofthewedge · 24/03/2023 09:04

It feels to me like the new way men can control women. We’ve become more powerful and independent, so now rather than crushing us, men want to be us. It’s conquering from within.

The backlash comes in many forms. Do they want to be 'us' though? Maybe their own warped version of femininity. Cherry picking the parts of gender that suit them. I don't mind people being whatever they want to be until it encroaches on someone else's rights, security, privacy and dignity.

The man in this article (no, not even a transwoman) is just pissing about.

Most definitely cherry picking. I think very few trans men would happily undergo the monthly crippling pain and heavy flooding that my best friend suffers. Or the debilitating pre menstrual migraines that put my poor Mum in bed for 3 days every month. As for child birth................

SaysRelaaxxx · 24/03/2023 09:25

I agree!!! I do understand the point being made that there are physical differences that might make competing together in sport unfair/unsafe. But my word, the horrible attitudes of people on this thread! “No matter how many hormones they take, they will always be a MAN”…”it’s all a delusion in their head”…wow. What’s next, off to camp to be cured of homosexuality? Pitchforks and torches?

mushypeasontoast · 24/03/2023 09:23

IncompleteSenten · 24/03/2023 08:19

Because women's safety is unimportant.

In Judo the sexes train together and with a good uki (partner), this is not an issue. The most problematic stage is in the teen years when the girls hit puberty and are naturally self conscious, and the boys are conscious of grabbing the wrong place. Once they work through this and effectively go back to treating each other as bodies there are no issues.

If you are feeling unsafe in training then the club has issues and I would suggest trying an alternative club. I would also reach out to the safeguarding team.

I have no problem with the above, however, a male sexed person should never be allowed to compete with a female sexed person. That would be dangerous and reckless in my opinion and the male player would definitely be at an advantage. Within the BJA (governing body) though, they are making changes to make it easier for transmen to compete in the male section. I have my concerns about this but anyone who's objected so far has been labelled unsupportive and bigoted. If transmen are allowed into the women's game it will kill the support for many women who will never be able to compete due to the physical differences.

FOJN · 24/03/2023 09:21

MaryHinges · 24/03/2023 08:29

I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman.

If I had a son who wanted to cheat in women's sport I would think I had failed as a parent but I would support his right to wear whatever clothes he wanted.

Do you think it's unreasonable for women to want fairness and safety in sport or do you think we should acquiesce to every demand men make so that we don't appear mean?

freddyfox · 24/03/2023 09:19

It’s shocking and not right. I played football as a young girl, always playing against boys as no girls played it where I live. I was a good player and could hold my own against the boys, however when I reached about 15 I simply couldn’t compete physically anymore against them, they were stronger and faster. I knew my limits. Women cannot compete against men at physical sports. It’s not right and it should never be happening

Mommymoments · 24/03/2023 09:17

MaryHinges · 24/03/2023 08:29

I do wonder how some people on this thread would cope if their son told them he thought he was in the wrong body and wanted to live as a woman.

The first thing I would do is get him psychologically assessed. Then explain to him he'll always be a man no matter what mutilation road he goes down. I wouldn't be sugar coating it to appear a liberal, woke, mother. He'd get the hard facts & a few trips to the psychologist.

OP posts:
YouSetTheTone · 24/03/2023 09:17

‘Womanphobe’ is a good one, I’ll use that. I say I’m pro-women’s rights and that people spouting the TRA lines are misogynists but ‘womanphobe’ echoes back nicely the ‘transphobe’ jibe.

icelolly99 · 24/03/2023 09:16

Can I recommend following and supporting the organisations Sex Matters and Fair Play for Women if you're interested in protecting sex based rights for women.