Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
THisbackwithavengeance · 24/03/2023 08:37

If he wants to go to uni then why would you stop him?

No one on here can predict the future. Yes, he might end up with a mediocre degree and it not benefit him at all. I know someone with a history degree who works at M&S on the tills - was it worth it; some might say not. Or it might be the pathway to an interesting and lucrative career? We don't know as yet and your DS is still young.

I think going to uni particularly if you move away from home is so much more than study. It teaches you independence and opens your eyes to the world out there. If he studies Spanish, he will be expected to spend at least some time in Spain or South America I would imagine?

Yes he can get a local job instead. He might do well and they might promote him. But you'll never know if he would've done better if he'd got a degree.

Racingadmin · 24/03/2023 08:36

Dd chose not to go to uni while the vast majority of her friends did this September.

She seems to have the best of all worlds at the moment . Lives at home in the week , earning and studying for her accountant qualifications. Come Friday night she packs up her car and heads off to a different uni to visit one of her mates for the weekend .

Does all the clubbing and hanging out that she could want and then comes home Sunday night to a clean, quiet house for the working week .

No worries about debt and she's got more fun money that any of her student mates

JussathoB · 24/03/2023 08:36

Schoolchoicesucks · 24/03/2023 08:23

Why don't you value non STEM subjects? Why do you think a degree in Spanish, Sociology, English would be useless? What job do you do, OP?

Many (many) jobs now require a degree, any degree. Even if they are not directly related.

Many (many) students work part time alongside a full-time degree. Of course they can't usually earn enough to support themselves on this and still need loan/parental support.

It's not the only route, a year out, a trade, an apprenticeship are all great options. But all you can do is present options to him. If he is set on going away for the university experience, I don't think you should stand in his way or be negative about his study subject choices. Does he have a good careers service at school/college?

I agree

AuntiePhoenixClaw · 24/03/2023 08:32

As an ex University admissions officer who has met hundreds of young students and sifted through too many applications to remember there is nothing wrong with delaying applying for University and working. They mature and learn other life lessons.

My DS worked loading and unloading freight for 2 years. He gave us rent, which we didn’t need at all but he learned about money and saved up 8k. He met people from all walks of life and ages. He is now doing a degree apprenticeship fully paid with no student debt with a guaranteed job that is exactly what he wants to do.

I think a bit of manual grafting is good for the soul, DH worked in a lab and also a factory for a year before he went off to Cambridge and I worked doing various jobs such as chambermaid and shop work for a few years before I decided to go to University.

I would imagine many people on here were applying for graduate schemes when the percentage of graduates was much lower. Graduate numbers have doubled since 1992, the amount of graduate schemes places has not doubled.

To actually get a place on a graduate scheme now with a general degree is much harder now than when many of the parents on this website did due to numbers. My friend was head administrator of the research dept of the RG University we both worked in, she had no degree. Towards the end of her career she joked how she couldn’t even employ the lowest grade secretary unless they had a degree and that she would have had no chance.

We both took early retirement as have many of our friends in HE, mainly becuse the entire situation overall was just miserable.

As a headline, all those graduates, experiences, widening participation and opportunities sound great but it really isn’t for many graduates.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 24/03/2023 08:26

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:21

Is there any way he can do a part time course while working part time?

Abive all, he wants to go to uni and live away from home and get the full student experience. Wouldn’t be interested in a part time course. I have nothing against him going to uni but he has no idea what to study and seems to view it as a placeholder/entitlement.

Moving away from home for the student experience imo is the best part of uni. Teaches them some independence, they get to make ailly mistakes without their parents watching anf create their own lives.

Sassyfox · 24/03/2023 08:26

Also if he wants to go to uni then let him, even if it’s a degree he’s picked out of a hat.

He needs to be responsible for his own choices and often our mistakes are what makes us more successful in the long run.

Spirini · 24/03/2023 08:25

If he's determined to go to uni for the student life etc I don't think there's much you can do. I think what you're advising is a good idea but we all know what young adults are like, they need to figure these things out for themselves.

The one thing I'd be worrying about is him failing, particularly seeing that he's so disengaged from learning and applying himself. And of course that he's no idea what he wants to do.

He's a classic candidate for a degree in a business subject some kind. I'd recommend supply chain management or hr, they both lead to lots of job opportunities

Sassyfox · 24/03/2023 08:24

Yes definitely give him the option of taking a year out.

I’ll be encouraging my DD to do the same.

You do not appreciate uni at such a young age, especially when you have been in education your entire life.
Taking a year out just gives you that break and you appreciate uni so much more.

I went as a mature student and although I missed out on the partying side, I absolutely loved it because I was studying something that I loved and it was a choice, instead of doing it because I think I should.

There is no point doing a degree just for the sake of it when it is £9k a year debt.

He can take a year out and work until he decides what he wants to do.

He needs to get a full time job though.
He could even look for live in jobs or jobs abroad just for the experience.

There are also many apprenticeship degrees or trainee programmes that may be more suitable for him if he decides uni isn’t his thing.

Schoolchoicesucks · 24/03/2023 08:23

Why don't you value non STEM subjects? Why do you think a degree in Spanish, Sociology, English would be useless? What job do you do, OP?

Many (many) jobs now require a degree, any degree. Even if they are not directly related.

Many (many) students work part time alongside a full-time degree. Of course they can't usually earn enough to support themselves on this and still need loan/parental support.

It's not the only route, a year out, a trade, an apprenticeship are all great options. But all you can do is present options to him. If he is set on going away for the university experience, I don't think you should stand in his way or be negative about his study subject choices. Does he have a good careers service at school/college?

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 08:21

balconylife · 24/03/2023 07:53

Apprenticeship in a trade, that's what I'd recommend. Electricians and plumbers will always be employed and earn good money.

And if her son has interest these trades? What then?

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 08:20

OldTinHat · 24/03/2023 08:17

Let him make his own decisions about his life. If he wants to go, then please let him.

I'm 51 and still have great resentment that my DM wouldn't allow me to go to uni and I had a clear career path in mind that I was desperate to follow.

She isn't stopping him from going to university. She is suggesting that he takes time to think through properly what he wants to do. She will be expected to top up his maintenance loan, and if all he going to do is the minimum amount of work so that he can party hard I can understand her reservations.

Do you actually know how the current system of maintenance loans work BTW?

Badbadbunny · 24/03/2023 08:18

OldTinHat · 24/03/2023 08:17

Let him make his own decisions about his life. If he wants to go, then please let him.

I'm 51 and still have great resentment that my DM wouldn't allow me to go to uni and I had a clear career path in mind that I was desperate to follow.

The difference is you had a "clear path in mind". The OP's son doesn't and is just going to Uni for the fun of it.

Badbadbunny · 24/03/2023 08:17

MissMarplesbag · 24/03/2023 07:58

But not everyone is able to learn a trade and maybe that's why we have so many shoddy trades people. If kids aren't academic they were encouraged to learn a trade. However, some weren't cut out for that either and don't have the talent to be a decent trades person. Hence l, all the threads on here about cowboy builders & shite plumbers.

Gas engineers and electricians need to be intelligent as their exams (which they need to work unsupervised) aren't easy. Same with aspects of other trades. It's not all about hard graft anymore unless you're say a bricklayer or roofer or scaffolder. More and more electricians are setting up very complex computer controlled "smart" homes or heating systems, complex alarm systems, solar panel systems, etc. Likewise plumbers who need the GasSafe qualification to work with gas who are more likely these days to be setting up complicated heat source air pump systems or whole house heat retention systems. We've moved a long way from plumbers who just "bend pipes" or electricians just replacing a socket.

The educated/able tradespeople are taking the best, highest paid, complicated work. That leaves behind a kind of void or chasm which the unqualified "chancer" type of grunt worker comes in, and they're the ones who give the industry a bad name. That happens because too few "decent" people in terms of education, ability, etc., go into the trades. Small firms don't take on apprentices anymore because they don't get decent applicants - they generally get the bottom of the barrel ones who can't even be bothered to turn up on time, simply because kids who have decent qualifications go to Uni instead, often for no particular reason, they just drift into it, because they're not encouraged to go into the trades. Small firms would be more inclined to offer apprentice jobs if the applicants were of a better standard. The few decent kids with decent qualifications get sucked into the big firms, many of whom have entry qualification criteria of good GCSE and sometimes, good A Levels!

Other, once "manual" work has gone the same way. Train and tube drivers can earn over £50k because it's not just pressing a button - it's operating a computer that controls a very complex system.

We really do, as society, need to realise that manual work is just as important, often better paid, more valuable to society, than someone going to Uni and getting a 2:2 humanities degree, for no real reason other than it's the "done thing", and then whinge when they end up in a call centre or supermarket on minimum wage!

OldTinHat · 24/03/2023 08:17

Let him make his own decisions about his life. If he wants to go, then please let him.

I'm 51 and still have great resentment that my DM wouldn't allow me to go to uni and I had a clear career path in mind that I was desperate to follow.

Bingbangbongbash · 24/03/2023 08:17

Seeing this from a different angle - when I was in education it was just expected that I would do A’s then go to uni. I really struggled after uni because for the first time the next step wasn’t mapped out for me.

Could it be that your son is worried about stepping off the ‘given’ path? Would it help to reassure him and support him through this?

I also don’t think a humanities degree is useless - it will depend a lot on where he studies. A degree from a good uni is worth it regardless of subject (with the exception of fluff degrees like media studies). Modern foreign languages will never be pointless.

Is there a middle path? He applies for uni this year and sees how he gets on with a spot at a good uni. If that doesn’t work out, he could take a year out, do an extra part time A-level and work / travel.

A degree is still important to job prospects in many (most?) careers not necessarily for the content, but for the way it reaches you to learn and shows commitment to education.

That said, I wish I’d take a year out to grow up a bit before studying. I did really well but I think I was too immature to fully engage with the opportunities offered by university.

C8H10N4O2 · 24/03/2023 08:15

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 02:56

He is 16, not 18. In Year 12 with June birthday.

16 is still quite young, especially if he is a later maturing boy. I'm inclined to agree with @Sceptre86 and with you OP - he is basically saying he wants to spend >40k on a party plus a sizeable contribution from you. A mid ranking degree from a mid ranking university is unlikely to get him the career to recoup the costs so you need to see some other benefits. (assuming he stays the course and doesn't drop out or fail)

Some children do suddenly get the work ethic at university as they were late developers but that is more of a pointer to take a gap year. He is viewing a gap year as "flipping burgers" but what about a gap year spent working in tourism in Spain or other work abroad? An opportunity to grow up a bit and work out what he really wants to do, potentially have a lot of fun and maybe bring back some cash.

Maybe the answer is the right sort of gap year work so that he sees it as an opportunity rather than a delay.

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 08:13

I just don’t think DC should go to uni and incur debt etc unless they are enthused by degree course and want to study. DS no idea about what to study and shows no enthusiasm - other than for a uni experience!

I totally agree with you. University is not school. The tutors and lecturers don't chase the students or remind them about outstanding work. The onus is on the student to work. If he fails his first year exams and the resits he will be asked to leave. Lecturers don't want unmotivated students. His reasons for wanting to go to university are the wrong ones.

It's a period of growth and it would be a real shame to deny him of that!

Taking a gap year is hardly denying him that.

I can't believe how many posters think they are the right reasons to get into debt. You could suggest that he goes to universitybut you aren't prepared to fund his party lifestyle, so he can work in the local McDonalds if he wants beer money.

He’s unlikely to go back to uni after working full time for a year.

That is utter nonsense. DD took a gap year after unsuccessfully applying for medicine. She decided to regroup and look at other courses as she decided that medicine probably wasn't for her. She worked, volunteered and travelled. It was the best thing for her, and she was more than ready to go to university after her gap year. She graduated last year with a first and walked into a job straight away. I also know loads of people who just took a regular full time job for a year before going to university.

KvotheTheBloodless · 24/03/2023 08:10

If he was predicted poor grades I'd agree with you, but BBB is pretty good - university isn't for everyone, but if he's bright, then a few years living away from home, studying, possibly with a year abroad, will likely be the making of him.

Smoky1107 · 24/03/2023 08:10

I read everything until the year 12 bit! He's got ages to decide and in a 16 year olds world things charge all the time! I'd be picking your battles on this one, talk about uni be excited with him and look at options.
My daughter in year 12 wanted to take a year out and work in a pub. And yes I was upset because I thought she would soon get bored of that.
Now, she's working, she's doing a degree and lives at home with freedom and support from us. I didn't fight with her about her choices, I let her work it out herself and she isn't doing a STEM subject but she's a very happy and motivated 19 year old.
You actually have 18 months until he needs to make a decision and will likely change again before then. Make sure he applies, looks at unis and give him choices in august 2024. Nothing is set in stone until then

ouch44 · 24/03/2023 08:07

Do you know about the WIWIKAU (what I wish I'd known about University) group on Facebook? My DS sounds about the same age as yours so I joined at the beginning of the year. The general consensus on there if your child doesn't know what course they want to take or whether Uni is the right route for them IS TO take a year out. There are a couple of courses where taking a year out is considered a bad idea such as Maths. But generally it's looked on as a good thing with plenty of young people doing it to save money for the course as well as gain experience
Has he checked out Liberal Arts courses?

My DS would like a year out but I'm concerned his plan is to spend it on his Xbox!! Also one of the courses he's interested in is Maths.
Also I've encouraged him to check out degree apprenticeships.

AllOfThemWitches · 24/03/2023 08:05

Uni isn't the be all and end all, I know lots of former students in crap jobs.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 24/03/2023 07:59

I agree uni isn't for everyone Particularly now that it's so expensive. A year out can be a good thing. He doesn't have to work in maccas

I work in a tourist attraction and we have loads of people with amazing qualifications there on minimum wage. Not everyone with a free free ends up better Paid.

But it's his life so all you can do is give him options.

MissMarplesbag · 24/03/2023 07:58

balconylife · 24/03/2023 07:53

Apprenticeship in a trade, that's what I'd recommend. Electricians and plumbers will always be employed and earn good money.

But not everyone is able to learn a trade and maybe that's why we have so many shoddy trades people. If kids aren't academic they were encouraged to learn a trade. However, some weren't cut out for that either and don't have the talent to be a decent trades person. Hence l, all the threads on here about cowboy builders & shite plumbers.

owiz · 24/03/2023 07:57

Coding, IT security

It is not necessary to have a degree to go into these fields.

Swipe left for the next trending thread