Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
LittleLentils · 24/03/2023 09:13

I voted YANBU. I did French at uni, now I work for a 'Big 4 company'. You need a degree to get a lot of jobs, doesn't matter what it is most of the time. So he's better doing something he enjoys, if he's OK with a corporate job later on. Obviously not if he wants to be a DR or anything though!

Also, I think its good for personal growth. I had a lot of fun, but also had my first taste of independence at uni. Sounds cheesy but made me realise who I am etc.

Annoyingwurringnoise · 24/03/2023 09:08

I agree, OP. I’ve told mine that unless they’ve got something specific they want to do or they’re happy to pursue a career in teaching then to try and find another route into work. Going to Uni to piss about doing a worthless degree for three years with no clear plan is grand if you’re a middle-class kid with financial support from mummy and daddy, but for a working-class kid whose parents can’t afford to support them it’s just incurring debt for no reason. They can get a job in Costa at 18 if they like, save themselves the burden of 100k debt.

Obviously this doesn’t apply if they want to do a useful degree with a good career path, but I don’t see the point pissing around for three years doing a media studies degree. You need to have rich parents to indulge in that kind of vanity, and my kids don’t.

ilovewispas · 24/03/2023 09:07

If he gets a good degree, which if he's getting BBB is absolutely possible, he will have so many graduate opportunities open to him.

My company (a consultancy) take on over 1000 graduates every year starting on £34,000. They take them with all degrees. Spanish and English would be a great combination. They then provide training, professional exams, etc.

You are literally limiting his options.

owiz · 24/03/2023 09:07

But she'll suddenly hit a ceiling in her org years down the line when someone of equal intelligence but with a degree will get promoted above her due to being "more qualified"

Not true in my experience. Outside of professions that require a set degree, in my experience, degrees are like GCSEs and A Levels, once you've got to the next level no one gives a shit about the previous bit. My degree did accelerate the start of my degree to get into a graduate traineeship, but at this stage of my career the degree is worth diddly squat, someone without a degree could easily beat me in a job interview for a promotion if they had more experience in the field I'm in, the fact I did a history degree 20 years ago won't advantage me!

GiveMyHeadPeaceffs · 24/03/2023 09:05

@Goinganon321 I went to uni and wasn't overly enthusiastic about my subjects, I did ok, had an absolute blast as a student, getting pissed and partying. Do I think it was a good idea? Not particularly. My degree was in social sciences and I've yet to use it (my A levels and GCSEs have been far more beneficial).
I honestly think if I'd taken a year out, travelled, worked, etc I'd either never have spent 3 further years studying or I'd have got a job and be earning far more than I am now and probably be mortgage free.
I think some of the answers you've got on here are a bit odd. Certainly I wouldn't be encouraging my DS to go to uni and piss about and get into debt because his mates are!

Toadintheroll · 24/03/2023 09:04

If he doesn't know what he wants to study then i would discourage him wasting £££s.

What I did which I personally think worked really well was to work full time in retail after A levels. This not only meant I had money so I could learn to drive etc, but also meant I had some time to think about what I wanted to do. I visited my friends at uni for nights out and stuff which was great fun, it was useful hearing what they thought of their uni and their course and helped me to choose what I wanted to do. I did decide to go to uni, I applied for the following year and not only had some savings, also transferred in my job so could work when I wanted. Similarly though I'd have been open to looking for different jobs and apprentiships, it was valuable not having the pressure of deciding when you don't actually know.

I'd just remind him that it's not uni this year or never at all!

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 09:03

I wouldn't be impressed with part funding my dc to piss about at uni for 3 years because of the party and experience.

I agree. I think a lot of posters on this thread don't understand how the current maintenance loan system works. Would all the posters saying let him go be happy to fund a lazy student's partying? I doubt it.

DD only graduated last year. She made new friends, socialised and partied, but she was also self motivated and worked hard. She knew what she wanted to do because she took a gap year. She had time to really think about what she wanted to do without the pressure of A levels hanging over her.

It comes as no surprise that posters employed by universities are advising a gap year as well.

junebirthdaygirl · 24/03/2023 09:01

Agree about Spanish being a great option and that will benefit him in the future. I haven't read everything but a business and Spanish degree could be a worthwhile choice. Remember he is a bit immature at the moment but along the path in college he will up his game as he grows up a bit. My ds headed off to college with very little in mind except friends and fun but 4 years later he was a different lad with a first under his belt. He did the Erasmus year which your ds could do in Spain and become a great Spanish speaker which would lead to opportunities. He doesn't need to have done business to take it up in college so definitely a bit of practical stuff alongside the language and he will be fine.

NBLarsen · 24/03/2023 08:58

OP, you are obviously very bitter about the lack of STEM subjects for your son's alevels, you mention it so many times on this thread!

People are different, everyone has different interests, people are naturally good at different subjects. If your son is predicted BBB then he's doing fine in his own area.

"DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age."
I very much disagree! I am earning a 6-figure salary - I studied a humanities degree. The workplace is not as narrow minded as you seem to think it is (or as you clearly are).
If not humanities, studying Spanish will open up a whole world of global business to your son.

You don't need to have a clear career path in mind before you go to university! I did not even have a career chosen when I graduated, nor when I took my first job. My career formed as I went along.

Let your son make his own choices and follow his own path.

OnlyFannys · 24/03/2023 08:56

I'm 36 and still dont feel enthused by any particular career path. He wants the student experience and he should go for that as it can be the best days of your life (my experience was amazing). I just picked a well respected subject that I knew I could get a job with (Law) and worked it out as I got older.

cartagenagina · 24/03/2023 08:54

Honestly OP, you need to take a huge step back. I understand you love your son and want the best for him.

If you demonstrate anything that looks like pressure, he will hold it against you for many years to come if life doesn’t go the way he imagined.

Personally, I think going to Uni is a fantastic experience for most, not all young people. If he wants to do that, give practical support. Take him to lots of open days etc.

Much of the world is Spanish speaking. It’s not a dead end subject by any means.

MrsMiagi · 24/03/2023 08:54

I wish I hadn't gone. Saddled with uni debt for a degree I don't use. I should have worked.
Now a chunk comes out of my salary for repayment each month

ladykale · 24/03/2023 08:53

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:54

So, to summarise the feedback so far, DS should go to uni even though he is not enthused by any subject and primarily wants the ‘student experience’. My idea that he takes a year out, works and thinks about it is misguided! Let’s leave it there for now - posting on MN late at night often results in strange views!

Uni helps students focus their minds on what they want to do with job fairs etc.

Unless he is into a trade, not going to uni would be a big mistake as he will end up earning minimum wage unless he can study a professional qualification. Unlike 50 years such a large % are going to uni so many people will be ahead in the pecking order if he doesn't go.

Many people don't know what they want to do until after they study. He does need to be focused on getting a 2.1 though so if he wants a year of fun, a gap year partying & working abroad might be fun, but if you don't have the means to fund that working in a low paid job for a year won't change much

Choconut · 24/03/2023 08:52

You say he has no real interest in doing a degree - but it sounds like he has no real interest in getting a job either - so he might spend his gap year doing precisely nothing, then realise he likes doing nothing and not get a job or go to uni.

At least going to uni is a positive step forward, he won't have to pay back the debts unless he is earning over a certain amount and it gives him a bit of time to grow up. When he sees all his friends applying for jobs at the end of uni that might spur him on to find something then too.

Therellbenobutterinhell123 · 24/03/2023 08:52

To go against the grain, I agree he shouldn't go to Uni (yet). I moved away at 18 to study a Humanities course not knowing what i wanted to do. Years later i have huge regrets, it has taken me years and years to pay this back and is a huge barrier to doing another degree in the subject I now actually want to do. If you only get 1 chance to go, I think you have to have a degree of certainty about your future.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 24/03/2023 08:52

He doesn't really need to know what he wants to do unless he needs a vocational degree for it.

If he's doing humanities A Levels then he would likely to a humanities/art/language degree anyway.

And they're very employable outside of STEM vocations you know.

History, English, Spanish etc are very employable degrees. There's no point in a STEM one if he doesn't want to work in STEM

YearsOfStagnation · 24/03/2023 08:51

I have two STEM uni kids and one humanities child. The humanities one has much fewer contact hours. But they are studying interesting subjects and really getting a broad view of the world, and have so much to talk about, related to the course.

I wouldn’t dismiss non-STEM subjects. They very much have their place in the world.

YearsOfStagnation · 24/03/2023 08:48

MFL language graduates are in decline. We need more!

My nephew is doing Spanish at Oxbridge. The real pain is arranging the placement abroad. After Brexit, it’s become a lot harder for students to sort this out.

SoShallINever · 24/03/2023 08:47

Gap year sounds perfect for him.
I was at uni in the 80s and the culture has changed so much since I was there.
Very low contact hours.
It all feels like a bit of a scam to me.

One of my DC graduated from a nursing degree last year and shared a house with 11 other students (not nurses) who sat around smoking dope every single day. They had no motivation to do anything and they would still be in their pyjamas when DC got home at 9pm after working a 12hour shift.
Drugs are absolutely rife and as someone who has no particular passion for a subject, I'd be worried your DS would get sucked into that lifestyle.
University is a huge expense, not just for him but for you as you will be supporting him. It's not something to drift into. I sometimes think its an opportunity that is wasted on 18year olds.

We have another DC (21) that has just completed a tech degree apprenticeship (turned down a place at Durham to do this). They have now got a first class degree, industry experience, £22K in their savings account, no debt and about to start a job on almost £45k. At the time people said they were mad not to go to uni.

Have a look at degree apprenticeships and see if they float his boat. If he doesn't like it he can always leave and go to uni, its harder to do it the other way round.

caringcarer · 24/03/2023 08:46

My son who did A levels in Maths, ICT and Psychology decided not to go to Uni. All his friends went. He had higher grades than most his friends. He said he did not want to spend 3 more years studying. He now works in a warehouse picking car parts. He gets bored out his skull. He is on a little over minimum wage. His friends all went and did ICT degrees and now all eating between £55-67k in West Midlands. My son now finally wishes he went to uni. I have told he we would support him if he wanted to go now but he is adamant he missed his chance.

ladykale · 24/03/2023 08:43

SabbatWheel · 24/03/2023 01:34

DD started uni and dropped out very quickly. 8 years down the line she is earning 10k more than her mate who has a first class degree in Maths and owns her own flat because someone gave her a chance in a job. She no longer does that job, in fact something very different, but working and earning flicked her switch. Uni isn’t for everyone.

But she'll suddenly hit a ceiling in her org years down the line when someone of equal intelligence but with a degree will get promoted above her due to being "more qualified"

Sad but true

Largeflaskoftea · 24/03/2023 08:42

Racingadmin · 24/03/2023 08:36

Dd chose not to go to uni while the vast majority of her friends did this September.

She seems to have the best of all worlds at the moment . Lives at home in the week , earning and studying for her accountant qualifications. Come Friday night she packs up her car and heads off to a different uni to visit one of her mates for the weekend .

Does all the clubbing and hanging out that she could want and then comes home Sunday night to a clean, quiet house for the working week .

No worries about debt and she's got more fun money that any of her student mates

Sounds great!

cafesandbookshops · 24/03/2023 08:41

A Spanish degree isn’t so useful nowadays? There are more than 400 million native Spanish speakers and it’s an official language in many international organizations. Language degrees give you the chance to study another language from scratch alongside, study culture, history and politics, business and education and live abroad.

I did a Spanish degree and then became an English teacher, lived in many different countries and then could have taken my pick of many roles in education, international business or gone on to further study in international law or something else. I still do some translation and interpreting on the side for extra money. For that comment alone about it not being very useful, you come across as extremely ignorant. Maybe broaden your horizons slightly?

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 24/03/2023 08:40

I wouldn't be impressed with part funding my dc to piss about at uni for 3 years because of the party and experience. If there is a career path they are looking at then fine, but otherwise its a waste of time and money. A gap year is a good idea, he could look at doing some internships, short college courses etc and work out what he really wants to do.

LysHastighed · 24/03/2023 08:40

I agree with you that the cost/value relationship of studying has completely changed. You don’t get a job just for speaking another language (I speak five so I do know), you need other skills too.
Gap year to find a direction sounds useful if things don’t change and visiting friends at uni at the weekend can be very enlightening.
I would also consider doing the whole degree in a Spanish-speaking country. The costs will likely be lower and the benefit of the experience higher.
If he really loves languages he could consider ab initio Arabic and/or Chinese and consider a UN career.

Swipe left for the next trending thread