Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 24/03/2023 12:33

Those who are degree educated - regardless of what degree they have, or what job they choose, earn more on average than those without a degree.

Well, this is true if you compare them to people working in KFC etc (not meant nastily).

However, somebody who is interested in making a reasonably decent salary will most likely do something like learn a trade if they don't go to uni, and average trade salaries are higher than average graduate salaries and average office worker salaries - e.g. average graduate salary is £35k against the average trade salary of £45k.

Also, most students will graduate in their early 20s with loads of debt and then get a £25k job. A young tradesperson will have several years experience by this point and possibly be earning £20k more, might be well on the way to getting on the property ladder.

Where I'm contracting atm the PAYE truck drivers are on £200 a day and the owner/operator ones are making loads - some take home £5k a month after tax.

Of course the lad in question may not be very keen on trade/site work but it's worth knowing the options. There's guys in their early/mid 20s making over £50k where I work and they're not even the sharpest tools in the box for the most part. I feel like most middle class professionals are pretty blind to this realm.

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 12:32

I come from a very poor background so encouring someone NOT to further their education doesn't seem right to me personally.

The OP is encouraging him not tp go yet, not stopping him from going ever.

Namechange192727171 · 24/03/2023 12:31

There's nothing wrong with wanting to go to Uni for the experience IMO.

He can have fun, meet new friends, learn skills and get a degree out of it.

He can also get a part time job. It could be the making of him.

I come from a very poor background so encouring someone NOT to further their education doesn't seem right to me personally.

Has he thought about apprenticeships etc?

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 12:31

SophiaSW1 · 24/03/2023 12:06

@RampantIvy full of random assumptions there!

I'm not quite sure what you are referring to TBH.

I think a lot of posters have misread the OP. She isn't saying he shouldn't go to university ever, but he shouldn't go to university yet.

A lot of jobs ask for degree level educated (when IMO it isn't necessary for many positions), and many degrees provide transferrable skills, so the question isn't what he should study, but what would interest him enough to motivate him to do well.

And @Goinganon321 is saying that nothing is just now, so I agree that just going to university for the experience (and probably being supported by parents) and not doing any work is a good enough reason not to go.

Going to university for the experience, making new friends, partying, learning to live independently and working hard to gain a good degree is a good reason to go.

Sunnytomorrow · 24/03/2023 12:29

Hongkongsuey · 24/03/2023 11:49

To the people suggesting working the ski season etc? Is this still possible for British kids?

Ah, that’s a good question @Hongkongsuey ! I had initially assumed it was still an option (as there seems still to be plenty of young Brits working in French ski resorts ) but I admit I didn’t factor in Brexit. It has probably scuppered things a bit.

Anyfeckinusername · 24/03/2023 12:22

Jesus, I'd be delighted he isn't narrowing himself down yet - he will find his place - more likely to find inspiration at uni than in McDonalds.

There is absolutely nothing by wrong with studying Arts based subjects such as Sociology and plenty careers are springboarded from here. I find it odd personally that anyone at 16 or 18 or whatever is supposed to know what they want to do for the best few decades. Far safer/better/more exciting and rewarding to get a degree than get some experience in a fast food chain.

OopsAnotherOne · 24/03/2023 12:18

Many jobs just require someone to be degree educated with specifying what degree is necessary. If a job specifies a certain degree needed for the job, some degrees can be converted. If he is unsure of what he wants to do in his future, getting a degree will open many more doors for him than not having one. Non-STEM degrees are also valuable in the workplace and don't underestimate the "uni experience", it can be fantastic way for a teenager to get their first taste of the "real world" and often, opportunities and interests in certain subjects and areas stem from the networking that comes from University.

Also remember that if you do persuade him not to go to University, despite him wanting to go, he might hold this against you in the future if he is being turned away from jobs he would loved to have worked in as he doesn't have a degree. It's not certain this will be the case of course, but it's a scenario worth considering.

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 12:13

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 11:14

*Covid and the internet has completely changed Uni life. It can now be a pretty miserable place unless you're 100% focussed on your chosen subject or are in to the heavy partying social side of things.

My son went in 2020 and really suffered with covid as literally nothing was done face to face for the entire 20/21 academic year*

Are you aware they've gone back to face to face teaching now?

Why would you have to be either 100% focussed on work, or on the social side?

Is a balance of both impossible?

They havn't all gone back to F2F though. As I said in my post, at my son's, there is still a lot of online only happening on his course, including a couple of recent modules that were wholly online.

The 20/21 crap year "set the scene" for that cohort. He tried to put it behind him and "reset" for the 21/22 year, but a lot of the socials/freshers week etc were aimed at freshers, so for many, he didn't even know they were happening. His flat mates from his first year said the same. They're pretty much a "forgotten" year at his Uni.

I'm sure the 22/23 intake are having a more normal Uni experience, but that's no consolation to those in the two earlier years who had a crap 1 or 2 years, and even now, again as I said in my post, there are fewer clubs & societies even now because they died during the covid years and there are no older students running them.

The heavy social/partying students aren't as badly affected as they, by and large, ignored the covid restrictions anyway and partied, but the vast majority who aren't the heavy partiers really suffered and there's no getting back those wasted years of "normal" uni life.

SophiaSW1 · 24/03/2023 12:06

@RampantIvy full of random assumptions there!

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 11:52

Covid and the internet has completely changed Uni life. It can now be a pretty miserable place unless you're 100% focussed on your chosen subject or are in to the heavy partying social side of things.

It changed university life for a short period of time.

Hongkongsuey · 24/03/2023 11:49

To the people suggesting working the ski season etc? Is this still possible for British kids?

Sunnytomorrow · 24/03/2023 11:44

IMHO, the ultimate choice is up to him (he’s an adult now) but it makes sense to have a family chat and weigh up all the choices available to him. I know you don’t particularly see the benefits of uni right now, but try to stay neutral on it and let him come to his own conclusion. I know that, if he were my son, my thinking would be as set out below.

Reasonable choices:

  • Uni. Even if he doesn’t know what he wants to do long-term, at least he’s shown an interest in going and he’d be working towards a qualification and having some fun experiences while he’s there. He could do an English and Spanish degree perhaps. It doesn’t really matter that he doesn’t know what he wants to do afterwards as he still has time to do that while he studies and he could do a post-grad if needed. He can also work in part time jobs in the (long) holidays or the weekends to help with some of the costs.
  • If you both agree that uni isn’t feasible right now, then a gap year abroad but persuade him to use it to expand current skills or gain new skills or experiences. For example, he could work the ski season in a French resort and learn both skiing and French, then TEFL in the summer in Spain to perfect his Spanish. He’d have a brilliant year and could then, in 2024, head to Uni to do a combined French and Spanish course or similar if he still wants to.
  • A similar option but, instead of abroad, apply for work experience or internships closer to home in an area in which he may be interested for a career. For example: law, teaching, etc. The aim is that he ends the year with a better CV/prospects than when he started.

Poor choices:

  • A year in a relatively menial job with mediocre long term prospects, eg, McDonald’s. Ending up in a branch management role is not guaranteed, plus the service industry does not necessarily offer him great long-term career satisfaction if it’s not something he’s ‘chosen’ to do.
  • A year dossing about at home while he thinks about what he wants to do. If he’s generally unmotivated and uninspired currently, then the reality of unstructured time is likely to involve lots of going out, playing video games, etc. This seems like a waste of a year ‘treading water’.

Whatever he decides, please do support him as best you can in whatever ways you can, as it’s a hard stage of life.

GasPanic · 24/03/2023 11:32

agriefobserved · 24/03/2023 10:48

I wasn't sure what I really wanted to do at uni, and I deferred for four years before I gave up on the idea of going. Hands down it was the best decision I ever made.

I didn't need that "university experience", I had loads of money in savings and has no debt until I got a mortgage.

Working at McDonald's is pretty good actually as you can easily move up the (fast food) chain to gain managerial experience, even as a young employee. He could transfer that experience to another role in his early twenties and beyond. If you have space to let him stay at home, he can save a decent wad of cash.

McDonalds are very good at spotting talent. If you are smart and want to get on in a year you could learn a lot about businesses, employees, customers and business management. IF you are interested, watch what is going on and get involved. So much more than just "burger flipping" as some people make out.

This sort of job, and talking to the people in it might help focus his mind on exactly what it is he wants to do - or maybe tell him what he doesn't.

britnay · 24/03/2023 11:30

If he is good at languages, would he be interested in translation work in the future? Certainly nothing wrong with studying languages at Uni.

Oblomov23 · 24/03/2023 11:16

How many lecture hours and how much f-2-f v online is an important question. For open days for those currently applying, it would be one of my questions! I too feel sorry for those who Uni was badly affected by covid. I wouldn't want to pay £9k for online course. But some prefer on line. You can do open uni course at home for less. Fortunately ds1 is having a blast at Uni.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 11:14

*Covid and the internet has completely changed Uni life. It can now be a pretty miserable place unless you're 100% focussed on your chosen subject or are in to the heavy partying social side of things.

My son went in 2020 and really suffered with covid as literally nothing was done face to face for the entire 20/21 academic year*

Are you aware they've gone back to face to face teaching now?

Why would you have to be either 100% focussed on work, or on the social side?

Is a balance of both impossible?

Bramshott · 24/03/2023 11:12

I'm sorry that your DS has had a rubbish time @Kazzyhoward. I do really feel for the kids who started uni in 2020. FWIW my daughter is in her second year at the moment, doing a non-STEM subject, with no idea what she wants to do afterwards. But she is having the time of her life - broadening her horizons; making a wide range of friends; discovering what she loves (both academically and hobby-related); growing up in a supportive setting; maturing and taking responsibility for her own life, housing and budgeting etc. etc. I wouldn't change it for the world.

Oblomov23 · 24/03/2023 11:11

If he's only year 12 he's got time to think about all this. Is his school good? Because Ds1's (started Uni this year) and Ds2 (choosing GCSE options) their care is superb. They spend hours and hours and hours of tutor time, assembly time, talking to all the kids about what they want. How are they going to achieve this, what route they're going to take, interview techniques, CV advice, do you wanna go to uni, do you wanna take a course, choose the right GCSEs that you can choose the right A-levels, so that you can go to do the job that you wanna do. or whatever it is that is you want. Go to college for being an electrician or brick layer or whatever. and the pastoral care and their guidance generally, the care of the Oxbridge students, is 2nd to none, and I have been extremely impressed with the schools care and careers advice generally. and sitting down the children and giving them appointments to talk about what they want if they're unsure.

Does your school do similar?

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 10:51

Uni isn't the same as it was 10,20 or 30 years ago, so a lot of the posters saying it was the best years of their life, etc., aren't comparing like for like.

Covid and the internet has completely changed Uni life. It can now be a pretty miserable place unless you're 100% focussed on your chosen subject or are in to the heavy partying social side of things.

My son went in 2020 and really suffered with covid as literally nothing was done face to face for the entire 20/21 academic year, the teaching/lecturing staff weren't even on campus and the departmental blocks were closed throughout. Even the library, sports centre, etc were closed for most of the year, as were the non-food shops such as the book shop, post office, etc.

He's now in year 3 and coming to the end, but he's still basically a hermit because he didn't meet or gel with other students in that first year. Even this last term, two of his modules were still 100% online and the lecturers weren't even in the country, let alone on campus, so no face to face at all, except for the odd tutorial session run by phd students! Even where lecturers are on campus, they'll often randomly cancel face to face lectures & seminars and do them online instead. This is his last week of term so last week of "formal" tuition etc (it's all revision after Easter), and he's only been on campus for a couple of hours one day this week - everything else was online. It's the "covid" effect that so much has gone online and the Uni don't seem to regard face to face as important anymore.

Add to that clubs and societies didn't run in 20/21, and many havn't restarted as there were no 20/21 intake students to take them over in 21/22 or 22/23. The societies my son was interested in are still shown on the Uni marketing website, but in reality, no longer exist!

Students are suffering MH issues at Uni in ever greater numbers, and numbers of students giving up are also at record highs. It's not the same experience that today's parents enjoyed 20/30 years ago! Maybe that's part of why today's students are struggling - they've been led to believe the "best years of my life" which they may have been for today's parents, and are so disappointed with the reality of today's student life as it's not what they've been led to believe.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:49

It should be noted that you can work in McDonalds while studying at university.

agriefobserved · 24/03/2023 10:48

I wasn't sure what I really wanted to do at uni, and I deferred for four years before I gave up on the idea of going. Hands down it was the best decision I ever made.

I didn't need that "university experience", I had loads of money in savings and has no debt until I got a mortgage.

Working at McDonald's is pretty good actually as you can easily move up the (fast food) chain to gain managerial experience, even as a young employee. He could transfer that experience to another role in his early twenties and beyond. If you have space to let him stay at home, he can save a decent wad of cash.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:47

I agree with this. I really cannot see the point in going to uni without a clear view of the end goal, in fact I strongly disagree with this.

I didn't know what I wanted to be when I started uni.

I knew by the end. And I'd also had four great years and some formative experiences that I'd have missed out on by staying in my small town. I now work in a job I couldn't have dreamed of achieving without a university degree.

Everyone's different.

Onthenosecco · 24/03/2023 10:47

Toadintheroll · 24/03/2023 10:11

Sure it can be, many fields in the arts though for example are extremely competitive (and poorly paid but that's an aside)- to have a chance at securing the job you want you have to be doing additional work and experience alongside your degree; shadowing, volunteering, making up a portfolio etc. Similar-ish for humanities, unless you have a specific goal that requires that particular degree you'll be up against all sorts of other degrees for grad schemes or jobs that require any degree, not always easy.

Nought wrong with those paths at all, I'm a huge advocate for the arts and stuff like that but realistically if you don't know what to do and aren't making a converted effort to aim for a particular career then they don't afford as many opportunities generally as STEM subjects. If you study maths for example even if you have no clue what you want to do it'll open up all sorts of career paths, funded further study, grad schemes because there's a shortage.

Actually, geography - a humanities subject - has one of the best employment rates of any undergraduate degree.

https://www.ucas.com/explore/subjects/geography

Geography

Thinking about studying geography? Find out why you should study it, entry requirements, and what jobs you can do with a geography degree.

https://www.ucas.com/explore/subjects/geography

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 10:46

I do agree with this however surely you should do a degree with some thought that it is something you will want a career in and that the degree will help you get a job in that field. Obviously people may change their minds on job choices, that's understandable but to just pick any old degree to get a 3 year piss up is wrong IMO.

It's really not unusual for an 18 year old to not have a clear career idea. Picking 'any old degree' is not necessarily a bad thing as around 80% of graduate jobs don't specify a degree subject - just a degree! Choosing something you are good at and enjoy is really sound advice. I would also advise these students to engage with the university careers service as soon as they arrive as they will support them in developing their career ideas.

MaryMcCarthy · 24/03/2023 10:45

If he doesn't know what he wants to do, university's the best place for him.

He can't compete with his peers for jobs, apprenticeships, training etc in the real world if what you say is correct and he's not motivated and doesn't know what he wants to do. Employers will see that.

He might get a job for a year and that might be good for him, but it's unlikely to be a job with strong prospects. Unless you think managing a KFC is a strong prospect. Without experience or direction he's going to fall into something he might not like and he'll rue it for a long time. I speak from personal experience.