Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 24/03/2023 13:40

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:54

So, to summarise the feedback so far, DS should go to uni even though he is not enthused by any subject and primarily wants the ‘student experience’. My idea that he takes a year out, works and thinks about it is misguided! Let’s leave it there for now - posting on MN late at night often results in strange views!

Humanities uni lecturer here.
Please tell him that if he isn’t really bothered about what subject he will study I don’t want him in my class and neither will my colleagues in other institutions.
I would make it very clear to him that you’re not supporting him to get the ‘uni experience’. Both of mine are well aware that that is my attitude. He needs to demonstrate some maturity here, research courses and institutions, and understand that poor attendance and engagement which tend to stem from lack of interest in s subject, might well lead to termination of studies pretty quickly.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/03/2023 13:40

Did you go to uni, OP? If not, I wonder if this is colouring your views.

Lots of kids haven't decided what they want to study in Year 12. If he wants to go to uni, I don't really understand why you would discourage him.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 24/03/2023 13:39

@UnicornRidge @RampantIvy

I learnt the hard way. Was always very good at reading/writing (reading age of 16 at 10yo etc) and never questioned the fact I was going to uni.

I think my parents would've supported me in whatever I wanted within reason, but neither they nor my school/careers advisor ever really mentioned trade jobs so I was none the wiser.

I hated office work tbh. Hated being stuck inside on sunny days in the summer, and in winter I hated leaving home in the dark and returning in the dark having barely seen a breath of fresh air all day. I worked in a sales-y role where my writing and English degree were useful but it actually killed my passion for reading etc as I spent all day looking at words and drafting lengthy proposals.

I took a big jump into the construction sector in my late 20s and five years later I still love it. Never stuck in one place, get to see genuinely interesting stuff rather than endless meetings, corporate politics, and engagement bullshit. I can drive tippers/mixers and quite a few other trucks now (which I love) and I can comfortably deliver/pour concrete, mortar, aggregates, or just help managing projects.

Being a woman has never been an issue as I'm not the type to have a heart attack if a bloke calls me 'love'. I actually feel like I get more respect having started as a truck driver than the young trainee managers who come to site fresh out of uni never having got their hands dirty.

Next step is either to get trained as a site manager (employer is pushing for this) or to get my operators license and go self employed. Can make decent money just as an owner/driver but if I add another 2-3 trucks I'd be laughing.

I just wish I'd started in my late teens. I'd probs be pretty minted by now rather than just doing comfortably, but like many youths it just wasn't on my radar and I didn't know anybody in the sector. I really feel like this is a blind spot in our society. Usually the types who moan about 'not enough women in xyz sector' are the least knowledgeable themselves!

Mycatisaqueen · 24/03/2023 13:37

Nosleepforthismum · 24/03/2023 06:28

Thanks for a refreshingly honest post. I also don’t think that going to uni suits every kid and I won’t be encouraging mine to get into shed loads of debt for the “experience”. One of the smartest kids I know has done his research and has landed a really impressive apprenticeship and moved 150 miles away from his parents at 17. The company pay for his accommodation and all his training and he lives with three other trainees. Having a degree is no longer the be all and end all.

Well said - my son joined the Army as a mechanic. He never wanted to do anything else! He matured massively during the basic training, and now has every driving licence going, as well as qualifications in engineering. All this time he's saved up about £20k in 4 years. No debts, a good CV, and good mates.

Of course, in the military, there are opportunities for all kinds of professions, not just mechanic - trades, medical qualifications etc.

These days, I don't think degrees are so special, when so many people achieve them.

Daffodilfrog · 24/03/2023 13:35

I’d be thinking about a degree with Spanish and something else or something like PPE

I think there’s a lot of growing up done by going off to university though appreciate the associated costs are pretty off putting

roarfeckingroarr · 24/03/2023 13:35

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:21

Is there any way he can do a part time course while working part time?

Abive all, he wants to go to uni and live away from home and get the full student experience. Wouldn’t be interested in a part time course. I have nothing against him going to uni but he has no idea what to study and seems to view it as a placeholder/entitlement.

Why shouldn't he have the full experience?

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 13:33

He's hardly going to want to go to the local college to do a plumbing or electricians course with a load of school leavers once he's been to Uni and got a degree is he?

Does he want to do an apprenticeship in plumbing anyway?? Apprenticeships are highly competitive and they want people who want to train to do that job.

And there are different levels of apprenticeships undertaken by people of all ages.

Scarlettpixie · 24/03/2023 13:33

Has he been to some uni open days and looked at what course he can do with his chosen a levels? He may find his spark once he looks into it. There is still plenty of time for that to happen if he is year 12. If he wants to go to uni I would encourage him tbh. Wanting a gap year is something that has to come from him really, not you.

My son is good at stem subjects but wants to do a level 3 in an art subject instead of a levels. I am encouraging him to look at all the oprions and do what will make him happy. We started attending uni open days last year (year 10) and it helped him plan his route. He is looking at doing animation.

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 13:31

Jobs pay you money. They give you work experience. Many apprenticeships do the same.

There's a difference between getting a job and an apprenticeship.
Getting a job while you consider your options is one thing bit apprenticeships require commitment and you'll struggle to get one of you are unable to show a passion and desire to train to work in a specific job or sector. They're often incredibly competitive.

Meandfour · 24/03/2023 13:30

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 13:28

He's hardly going to want to go to the local college to do a plumbing or electricians course with a load of school leavers once he's been to Uni and got a degree is he?

Is it even possible for a graduate to do an apprenticeship course in the trades aimed at school leavers, or does having been to Uni close doors to that kind of apprenticeship?

There’s a lot of competition for a good apprenticeship and the attractive ones tend to be the school leavers as you can train them exactly how you want them to work. We’ve never had an graduate applicants.

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 13:28

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 13:20

I can't believe so many posters think your ds should head to uni with no idea what he wants to do.

Actually advising someone gets a job or an apprenticeship when they have no idea what they want to do is much worse advice.

People running apprenticeships and employers want people who show a clear commitment to that very specific sector or job.

For someone who is academic but unclear about their career plans then university is a good option. It gives you time to think about your career in a place that is designed to support you in doing exactly that!

I'm very pro apprenticeship and technical education but only for those who know that's what they want to do.

He's hardly going to want to go to the local college to do a plumbing or electricians course with a load of school leavers once he's been to Uni and got a degree is he?

Is it even possible for a graduate to do an apprenticeship course in the trades aimed at school leavers, or does having been to Uni close doors to that kind of apprenticeship?

Meandfour · 24/03/2023 13:28

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 13:23

@UnicornRidge

Many middle class parents don't realise qualifying in a trade can get them more money, higher job security and potentially higher job satisfaction.

A lot of it is also snobbery. In the Blair years, we got one of those "technical" secondary schools built near us, which was supposed to be aimed at the less academic pupils to learn trades and practical work. It closed after about 5 years because of low numbers of pupils. Parents simply didn't want the stigma of their little darling going to such a school and potentially doing a "dirty hands" job. They'd far rather they struggled, got MH issues due to not being able to do the school/uni work, and end up either crashing out of Uni, or working in a call centre or shop with their low grade degree.

My sister was that type of parent. It was clear from an early age that my nephew wasn't "academic", but my sister pushed him and pushed him and he managed to scrape a few "passes" at GCSE and then did A levels in which he crashed and burned, being thrown out of sixth form after the first year. She still didn't get the message, and pushed him into going to the local college of FE to do some kind of business studies diploma, in which he struggled and crashed & burned, being thrown out after the first year, again. Since then he's done a succession of minimum wage jobs, including van driving, shop work, etc. I said many times during his teens to her that she should suggest he went into the trades, but she was having none of it - apparently he was "too good" to be a tradesman! In the next breath, she whinges about how expensive plumbers are and that she can't get a decent one and also the cost of having a TV aerial installed a few weeks ago saying the same as people on here, that "why" do plumbers, aerial installers, etc charge so much!

She really doesn't see it! The thing is that nephew would have been a brilliant tradesman, he's always been into doing things with his hands, does a lot of work on his own and his friends' cars (sister also complains how mechanics are too expensive!), has done a lot of work to his home, etc.

We really need to tackle the snobbery about "hands on" and practical work.

This kind of attitude really makes me laugh. Too good to be a tradesmen? Many trades will earn in multiples of many degree educated people and yet they still think they can look down their nose at them.
I will point out that you do need to be clever to make it as a successful tradesmen though. None of this “not academic” or “barely scraped through” they might make an ok employee or decent labourer but they won’t be in the top earners with their own business if they’re not academic.

Broadbeachshallow · 24/03/2023 13:26

Actually advising someone gets a job or an apprenticeship when they have no idea what they want to do is much worse advice.

Jobs pay you money. They give you work experience. Many apprenticeships do the same.

The worst that happens is you have a year of earnings and work experience. Uni will cost over £9000 + debt for living costs. A gap year is a great time to learn independence, work ethic and options for further study/career direction.

Uni is an expensive gamble for those who don't know what they want to study.

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 13:23

@UnicornRidge

Many middle class parents don't realise qualifying in a trade can get them more money, higher job security and potentially higher job satisfaction.

A lot of it is also snobbery. In the Blair years, we got one of those "technical" secondary schools built near us, which was supposed to be aimed at the less academic pupils to learn trades and practical work. It closed after about 5 years because of low numbers of pupils. Parents simply didn't want the stigma of their little darling going to such a school and potentially doing a "dirty hands" job. They'd far rather they struggled, got MH issues due to not being able to do the school/uni work, and end up either crashing out of Uni, or working in a call centre or shop with their low grade degree.

My sister was that type of parent. It was clear from an early age that my nephew wasn't "academic", but my sister pushed him and pushed him and he managed to scrape a few "passes" at GCSE and then did A levels in which he crashed and burned, being thrown out of sixth form after the first year. She still didn't get the message, and pushed him into going to the local college of FE to do some kind of business studies diploma, in which he struggled and crashed & burned, being thrown out after the first year, again. Since then he's done a succession of minimum wage jobs, including van driving, shop work, etc. I said many times during his teens to her that she should suggest he went into the trades, but she was having none of it - apparently he was "too good" to be a tradesman! In the next breath, she whinges about how expensive plumbers are and that she can't get a decent one and also the cost of having a TV aerial installed a few weeks ago saying the same as people on here, that "why" do plumbers, aerial installers, etc charge so much!

She really doesn't see it! The thing is that nephew would have been a brilliant tradesman, he's always been into doing things with his hands, does a lot of work on his own and his friends' cars (sister also complains how mechanics are too expensive!), has done a lot of work to his home, etc.

We really need to tackle the snobbery about "hands on" and practical work.

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 13:21

Oh, and I say that as a qualified careers adviser who specialises in post 18 options so I'm more than qualified to offer that advice.

TearsforBeers · 24/03/2023 13:20

I can't believe so many posters think your ds should head to uni with no idea what he wants to do.

Actually advising someone gets a job or an apprenticeship when they have no idea what they want to do is much worse advice.

People running apprenticeships and employers want people who show a clear commitment to that very specific sector or job.

For someone who is academic but unclear about their career plans then university is a good option. It gives you time to think about your career in a place that is designed to support you in doing exactly that!

I'm very pro apprenticeship and technical education but only for those who know that's what they want to do.

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 13:15

We need an entire culture shift towards understanding the wide range of manual/practical careers available (it's where the shortages are and will only get worse), and we need to lose the stigma of people getting their hands dirty as being only for the uneducated/neanderthals.

👏👏👏👏
Hear hear

Broadbeachshallow · 24/03/2023 13:14

I can't believe so many posters think your ds should head to uni with no idea what he wants to do. That's mad. It's tens of thousands of debt. Which is well worth it once you have a plan, very much not if you don't.

Of course he should take a year out. Work, research and figure out what he wants to do and how to get there.

He could continue his Spanish, which is an amazing concrete, marketable skill.

I agree that MN is a bad place to seek advice on this.

Kazzyhoward · 24/03/2023 13:13

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 13:00

I feel like most middle class professionals are pretty blind to this realm.
MN is biased. Considering most women did a non-STEM degree and most did not go into a trade. They can't see the benefits of the other side.

I agree with both of these statements.

Yes, and they're the ones who are aghast when a tradesman wants to be paid more than minimum wage! They don't seem to realise that a lot of "manual" or "practical" jobs are actually very well paid and still require people with a brain, not just brawn.

They're also the ones who won't even consider their little darlings going into manual/practical work and push them into academic pursuits, like arts or humanities degrees that they're not interested in and not really capable of doing.

We need an entire culture shift towards understanding the wide range of manual/practical careers available (it's where the shortages are and will only get worse), and we need to lose the stigma of people getting their hands dirty as being only for the uneducated/neanderthals.

One of my close friends at school was a "A" grade pupil at a time when it was the exception rather than the norm (i.e. someone getting a string of A's was really, really rare back then). Sixth form tutor kept hassling him because he hadn't filled in his UCAS application (or whatever it was called back then). He left after getting his A levels, and became his father's apprentice (who was a plumber). He's now long retired, driving around in his porsch and living in a million pound house after a very successful and lucrative working life as a plumber & gas safe heating engineer. We used him to fit a boiler and his work was excellent - the best we've ever seen from any tradesman - he came to do the quote on time, provided us with a professional written quote, started the job on time, finished on time, and even painted the exposed pipework for us having boxed in what he could, he also cleaned up and vacuumed at the end of each day! What more can you want? Far better than the knuckle dragging neanderthal plumber we suffered more recently who was boasting that he didn't bother at school and got no qualifications (and did a shoddy/messy job!).

Spectacledbear67 · 24/03/2023 13:08

Sound like he is bright and would be perfectly placed to study tourism or languages if he has a knack for it? Is he interested in travel?

UnicornRidge · 24/03/2023 13:02

@StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar Completely agree. Many middle class parents don't realise qualifying in a trade can get them more money, higher job security and potentially higher job satisfaction.

I have close family members doing a trade. They are not smart. It is fine. They earn more than most people who a liberal arts degree. They are never unemployed.

One left school after Yr9. He became a qualified plumber, gas safe engineer and electrician. He is never unemployed. He always has a lot of jobs. He consistently earns over £80k. No mortgage by the time he reached 40. The job gives him huge satisfaction. Age discrimination is not that rampant. People value his experience.

Another one dropped out before Yr9. He was not smart enough to pass any of the plumber / electrician exam. It was still fine for him to make a living. You don't need to pass exams to do some of the jobs. He was still earning more than an average qualified accountant!

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 13:00

I feel like most middle class professionals are pretty blind to this realm.
MN is biased. Considering most women did a non-STEM degree and most did not go into a trade. They can't see the benefits of the other side.

I agree with both of these statements.

UnicornRidge · 24/03/2023 12:52

MN is biased. Considering most women did a non-STEM degree and most did not go into a trade. They can't see the benefits of the other side.

Ask on a male dominated forum.You will get a different answer.

https://www.bbc.com/news/education-52999315

https://www.savethestudent.org/news/students-reveal-the-degrees-that-are-the-best-and-worst-value-for-money.html

Students in a classroom

More students say university not value for money

Almost a third of students think their courses were poor value in a year of campus strikes and Covid.

https://www.bbc.com/news/education-52999315

Mamagiraffe · 24/03/2023 12:49

I completely agree with you OP. I am your son in the future- did it for the experience, couldn't be arsed whilst there and should have left. I got talked into seeing it through and ended up with a rather pointless 2:2 in a subject I wasn't largely interested in and alot of debt. 15 years on and I've been declined for various funded level 3 courses I have been enthused about and have been finally mature enough to try at and would have led to better employment prospects because I "already have a level 3 qualification" and bitterly regret the whole experience. See if you can interest him in things like working ski seasons or camp america- same sort of experience and he won't end up paying for it- he'll get paid but as they also house and feed you it's not enough for him to get used to the money.

Artisticpaint · 24/03/2023 12:37

Mc Donald’s is a fantastic employer so don’t dismiss the opportunities that might give him.
there is the open university if he wants to study later on in life,
personally I think going to uni for the lifestyle is a poor life choice, he could always get a residential job in any number of hospitality venues where he’d be living with young people, earning money and not getting into 70k of debt.