Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
MaryBeardsShoes · 25/03/2023 08:12

YABVU about STEM/non-STEM.

NotLovingWFH · 25/03/2023 08:11

DS is at Uni studying a Humanities subject. He took a gap year as he didn’t know what to do, traveled and worked and generally matured a bit. He’s very happy at Uni and I think it is the right decision to go for him even though he will come out with debts and a degree in a non stem subject. He is gaining valuable life experience that he would simply get nowhere else and a degree in pretty much anything opens doors that are otherwise shut no matter how driven you are.

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 25/03/2023 08:10

The posters that went 30'years ago etc are living in la la land.

Uni is soooooo expensive now It's a whole different ball game.

Needmorelego · 25/03/2023 08:06

@Hongkongsuey I will say that indeed I have no clue what a MFL degree involves. The problem is a lot of teens choose subjects to study (for GCSE, A-Level and university) because they are 'good' at it rather than what jobs that subject can actually lead too.
There's a possibility he has chosen to study Spanish simply because he got a good grade and a teacher once said "ooh you're good at this".
I always assumed people went to university to study something that leads to a specific goal and am shocked to discover that many people go for an 'experience'. That concept never was on my radar until reading Mumsnet.
If he is good at Spanish then working in Spain for a bit could be fun for him.

RampantIvy · 25/03/2023 07:52

Do most of the "let him go" posters actually understand that the OP will be expected to make up the maintenance loan?

Would they be as happy to let their DC go to university and fund their three years of partying?

Do they know that students only get 4 years of funding?

Have they bothered to read the university lecturer's posts saying they don't want unmotivated students?

I wanted DD to go to university and have a great time partying etc because she wanted to study and get a good degree.

Sindonym · 25/03/2023 07:43

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:16

Not struggling particularly, no - no more than others anyway. I just don’t think DC should go to uni and incur debt etc unless they are enthused by degree course and want to study. DS no idea about what to study and shows no enthusiasm - other than for a uni experience!

I think wanting the uni experience is valid.

My youngest won’t go (which is the right decision for him at this moment, maybe that will change, maybe not) and I agree with you about the debt etc - in that I think you need to want to go to incur debt. But if he wants to go for the uni experience that’s a good reason.

Not sure why you are so down on humanities or languages (written as someone who has worked in academia in both science & social sciences).

thecathasbeenfed · 25/03/2023 07:38

The main thing is that it's his decision not yours. If he wants to go then that's his choice.

Non STEM subjects are still very valuable - the majority of uni courses are non STEM so I find your logic on that a little odd..

Let him go and have this experience and get a good level of education. Don't make him stay back and miss out, I can't imagine how sad that would make him feel to be left behind.

vestanesta · 25/03/2023 07:24

Like a pp I am from a family who have all gone to uni - it was expected for us and I went and did my best subject at A level. My parents were as supportive of going for the experience as the actual degree (even though they did STEM and I did English ;)).

But that was 30 years ago and none of us came out with mountains of debt (pre fees). I had a good time and was pleased I went but I actually preferred/had more fun once I started work. My job is not connected to my degree at all and never has been other than doing well in the literature round at the Christmas quiz.

What is the uni experience now though - I was talking to someone who works in a big RG uni back office function and she said col, and the pandemic has really impacted student life. A lot done virtually and high drop out rates.

My own kids are early teens and whilst one is definitely uni bound (medicine or medical adjacent) the other wants to do engineering of some kind and likes the idea of learning and earning together.

Onthenosecco · 25/03/2023 06:59

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 23:17

Being a year older than the others at uni is still a weird experience

Utter nonsense. That really, really isn't true.

I started uni (for the second time) at 20; I definitely felt noticeably older than other freshers (especially because I chose to live in halls of residence)

roundcork · 25/03/2023 06:58

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

sianyflewog · 25/03/2023 06:57

Has he already applied? The UCAS deadline closed in January so universities do not have to consider his application at this stage.

His degree does not have to be a degree in a subject he has already studied. Many degree schemes ask for entry requirements only in terms of points, and not actual certain subjects. For example, to study Law at Bristol, the typical A level offer is A*AA but it does not state that this needs to be in certain subjects, Business in Birmingham asks for AAB and required subjects are only GCSE Maths & English, Journalism in Swansea is BBB. That is not to say that subjects are completely irrelevant but A levels in humanities based subjects will demonstrate a skill set that opens up many possibilities to him. Following graduation, he would be best following a graduate scheme - again this may not be the same title as his degree, but having the degree opens up big opportunities. For example, the General Management, Finance, Policy & Strategy and HR graduate schemes for NHS all ask for “any degree” at 2:2. There is absolutely nothing wrong with A levels and degrees in humanities.

Options other than university are degree apprenticeships whereby the employer will pay for the degree to be done alongside you working for them. This doesn’t mean a boring life - the other degree apprentices are likely to be around the same age so they do still get the social aspect that university brings, just slightly different. Some universities such as University of South Wales also offer schemes for employment & a degree alongside each other - look at Network 75 as an example. Lots of my students are also applying for these opportunities after completing UCAS applications and will decide later.

The advice I give my own students is to consider the costs. If you do want to go, consider it a graduate tax (with tuition fee loans of £9000+ each year alone, not to mention maintenance loans), they leave with a huge amount to repay which may never pay off. They need to do it because they want to do it and not because everyone else is going (which is hard when you’re 17/18). Look at all the options and consider which is best for you, apply to them all and make your choice later - absolutely nothing to lose and nothing is set in stone.

(I am a sixth form tutor - happy to help further if I can).

Hongkongsuey · 25/03/2023 06:47

JudgeRudy · 25/03/2023 00:39

Suggest he defers n gets a job until he's learnt to drive. Maybe he'll be tempted to stay earning and get a car.
Why does it need to be Maccy D. Try NHS modern apprenticeships - lots of corperate openings in Comms with support for business qualifications.
If I wanted to learn Spanish....I'd go to Spain. Anything, bar work, tour rep...ibiza part animal? Just immerse yourself in it. Again, defer. Sept to April, save save save, out for the season...back for next year (if you haven't changed your mind).

If my child wanted to go to university, I would never advise them to go and work in a bar in Spain instead. This poster has no idea what’s involved in a MFL degree. The main thing is that this person has expressed a desire to go to uni. Random suggestions based on jobs that posters think are better alternatives than what he wants-why? I can understand she wants him to defer a year-and that’s great for people who want to do that-but this kid doesn’t. It could be that he decides that’s what he’s going to do by the time he’s in upper sixth-but that should come from him.

JudgeRudy · 25/03/2023 00:39

Suggest he defers n gets a job until he's learnt to drive. Maybe he'll be tempted to stay earning and get a car.
Why does it need to be Maccy D. Try NHS modern apprenticeships - lots of corperate openings in Comms with support for business qualifications.
If I wanted to learn Spanish....I'd go to Spain. Anything, bar work, tour rep...ibiza part animal? Just immerse yourself in it. Again, defer. Sept to April, save save save, out for the season...back for next year (if you haven't changed your mind).

MayMi · 25/03/2023 00:28

Maybe he could do a course that has a flexible subject like business?
That way he can get a degree that can be used for lots of different kinds of jobs as business study has a lot of transferable skills.
Or he could use it to set up his own business in the future.

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 23:17

Being a year older than the others at uni is still a weird experience

Utter nonsense. That really, really isn't true.

housemaus · 24/03/2023 23:14

I think YABU for quite a few reasons.

  • There's plenty of value in non-STEM subjects, find it very strange you think otherwise
  • Being a year older than the others at uni is still a weird experience - if you've gone on some big exciting gap year less so, but even that is rarer these days. At 18/19, a year's age difference (and the life experience of having worked) will feel bigger - I can still remember which people in my college at uni were a year older.
  • He's just delaying getting his independent life 'started' and will probably feel resentful of it when his friends are all experiencing uni life and have moved away and he's alone at home working a boring job he's got no intention of staying in
  • He should be making this decision for himself
  • Plenty of people switch degree subjects - if he really hates what he's doing, he can do that
  • Plenty of people work in careers that are nothing to do with their degree subject - most places care that you have a degree and that's it. Unless you're going into a career that needs a specific degree which he evidently isn't as he doesn't know what he wants to do
  • Having the experience of university is a good enough reason to go
MysteriousDuck2110 · 24/03/2023 22:28

Speaking from experience, although it was the opposite for me, I didn't want to go to university straight away for so many reasons. I wanted the gap year, work 6 months, save up and travel for 6 months but I was forced to go to university without a gap year by my mother. Nearly 20 years later, I still resent her for not allowing me to make my own decision. Yes, I have a degree but it cost me well over 20grand in student loans, still paying it back and not doing anything related to it. My degree is in fine art, but majority of my jobs have been in some kind of care setting, and I still have no idea 'what I want be when I grow up!' Please allow your DS to make his own choice with this, and support him whatever he decides.

Hankunamatata · 24/03/2023 22:13

I get where you are coming from. Very few can afford uni for the experience these days. I wouldn't recommend uni unless he has a career path or a burning desire for a subject he is doing.

Beneficialchampion2 · 24/03/2023 22:11

In my group of friends those of us who did apprenticeships are earning nearly twice that of those with decent degrees. Personally I would recommend apprenticeship route, some employers offer degrees through them now anyway. Experience counts for a lot more than a meaningless degree in my experience and field (Engineering/Aerospace). Not to be dismissive but the subjects chosen don't scream high paying job to me, but it's what your son wants at the end of the day?

RMNmama · 24/03/2023 22:07

I totally understand the concern if he has no real interest in any particular subject and just wants the uni experience with no real plan given the student debt and costs of accommodation etc. I hope my experience might make you feel a little better about it maybe!
I went to uni at 18 with no real interest in much other than the uni experience and dropped out at the end of the 2nd year to work full time as my heart wasn’t in it - I already worked part time through uni to pay for nights out and living costs and I enjoyed the job and having money! Thankfully though I did end up finding my passion while at uni which is now my career (related to the degree I didn’t finish but I went back later and gained a nursing degree!). The previous experience at uni in a random course has actually helped me climb the career ladder for sure.
I don’t regret going to uni - it was a brilliant experience, I learnt so much and gained friends for life and so many priceless memories.
I think it’s worth talking to him about what his interests are for a career post uni and try and go down a degree route that will help him towards that if possible. Even look at careers that Spanish would be useful for - interpreting, teaching, some companies require bilingual employees for some business roles etc. If he’s set on going then at least he’ll be able to get on graduate schemes for employment afterwards even with an unrelated degree.

Grasshopper30 · 24/03/2023 22:03

Please don't try and stop your son going to Uni, there is a very good chance that it will lead to resentment and you will be blamed every time things don't work out as he wants, he will forever think you stopped him for fulfilling his dreams. At the end of the day it's what he wants that matters and not you. Support him, but put your own boundaries in place which may well be financial. I have read others saying "my child dropped out and earns a ton of money etc etc" which is great, because that is what their children chose. It isn't all about money, and your scepticism should stay as yours only. Don't clip his wings before he has even learned to fly.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 24/03/2023 18:30

He might find a gap year more appealing if he does something a bit more exciting with it. Working abroad for example or volunteering or just travelling.

However I think if he wants to go to university you should support him. Not knowing what he wants to do at this stage is hardly unusual, in fact often it is preferable to have a flexible approach rather than a fixed plan.

He's clearly bright if he's getting Bs without much effort so a degree is unlikely to be a waste of time.

If he enjoys Spanish then I would encourage him to look at joint honours and doing Spanish with another subject if he doesn't fancy a language degree.

Language degrees are highly thought of and sought after by employers so don't discount that. It would lead to lots of employment opportunities, not just translator or teacher.

Humanities aren't the dead end you seem to think either, and he doesn't have to do something he has an A-level in, he could do a subject he has an A-level in or something connected. So say he has history A-level he could consider, a history degree or something like Ancient History, Archeology, Spanish and History, Ancient and Medieval History, Egyptology and History, History and Politics, Modern History, History and American Studies, History and International Relations etc.

As an example very few law undergraduates have an A-level in law, so he could consider a law degree but a fair percentage of solicitors and barristers have degrees in other subjects with humanities, English and Languages all being well represented. Subjects like politics, business, international affairs, might be worth considering.

It is entirely legitimate for him to pick a useful subject that he is good at and decide what to do with it later, he will still benefit from the degree and improve his job prospects. I wish I had done that!!!!

YearsOfStagnation · 24/03/2023 18:16

UnicornRidge · 24/03/2023 18:10

@YearsOfStagnation
Physics grad is in high demand. Even if the whole cohort of home physics grad go into teaching, they just about fill the number of physics teacher vacancies in the country. There is a big shortage of students taking physics / CS / maths at university level.

I work in finance and tech. We need people with quantitative skills with undergraduate level maths.

There are many jobs she can do:

  • Quantitative analyst, build mathematical model
  • Data Scientist, there are multiple stream she can specialise in, e.g.
Natural Language Processing (think ChatGPT), cyber security, audio (Amazon Alexa, Google echo dot), visual (driverless car, YouTube, vacuum robot, facial recognition, handwriting recognition), unstructured data extraction (many industries need that), consumer behaviour prediction (Expedia, Netflix, Tesco, Amazon, shein, Boohoo), geospatial (climate, weather, town planning, maps), medical and climate research.
  • Software Deveveloper
  • Data engineer
  • Associate in finance, data generalist with knowledge in finance and investment

Thanks so much @UnicornRidge I think I will save this post. Unfortunately she thinks she is ‘no good’ at computing but hopefully these jobs won’t all require coding skills.

I am old so most of these jobs didn’t exist when I was growing up and I don’t really know what some are! but I look forward to researching them.

Now I just need some advice for my humanities-studying child ;-)

I appreciate the advice.

UnicornRidge · 24/03/2023 18:10

@YearsOfStagnation
Physics grad is in high demand. Even if the whole cohort of home physics grad go into teaching, they just about fill the number of physics teacher vacancies in the country. There is a big shortage of students taking physics / CS / maths at university level.

I work in finance and tech. We need people with quantitative skills with undergraduate level maths.

There are many jobs she can do:

  • Quantitative analyst, build mathematical model
  • Data Scientist, there are multiple stream she can specialise in, e.g.
Natural Language Processing (think ChatGPT), cyber security, audio (Amazon Alexa, Google echo dot), visual (driverless car, YouTube, vacuum robot, facial recognition, handwriting recognition), unstructured data extraction (many industries need that), consumer behaviour prediction (Expedia, Netflix, Tesco, Amazon, shein, Boohoo), geospatial (climate, weather, town planning, maps), medical and climate research.
  • Software Deveveloper
  • Data engineer
  • Associate in finance, data generalist with knowledge in finance and investment
RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 17:58

Mumto2kids86 · 24/03/2023 17:33

I would say get straight to uni and get a part-time job. I never really see any value in taking a year out. That way he started his degree and is also making a bit of money on the side. The work experience will be valuable toO

Why?
Perhaps you should read the posts by university lecturers in this thread. They don't want unmotivated lazy students. Work experience during DD's gap year helped secure her a job after graduating.

I never see any value in going to university unless you actually want to get a good degree (as well as all the usual other experiences that you get at university).

Swipe left for the next trending thread