Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
Bagsundermyeyestoday · 24/03/2023 06:25

Backstreets · 24/03/2023 05:59

Op’s view will probably become the majority one over time as costs of living and expectations for parental support rise and rise. Wouldn’t have traded my uni experience or living independently at 18 for work though, god knows you’ll spend enough of your life doing that.

This is a good point, you have your whole life to work. There will be plenty of people who didn't go to uni saying it's a waste of time (some based on insecurity), I'd say most that did go to uni won't say they regret it. Support your son with his choices

Redebs · 24/03/2023 06:23

Mine did apprenticeships for technical careers and it was massively useful to them long term.
One went straight into engineering with A levels in non STEM subjects
For cultural reasons we wanted to avoid student loans.
One went on to do OU degree sponsored by employer while working full time. Another had no need for a degree because too busy progressing projects and promotion in the industry.

I don't think the typical path from sixth firm to university serves everyone well. Student debt is a massive problem.

pixietinkdust · 24/03/2023 06:19

Hey OP,

Your concerns are absolutely justified… my parents had exactly the same ones. I was always above average intelligence, never really had to apply myself academically but got good grades that sort of thing. When everyone else was discussing Uni I went with the flow, decided to apply for Unis and at the time was going to study Social Work.

I did a lot of soul searching (well, as much as you can at 18!) up to A Level results day and decided I didn’t want to go to Uni at all and I wanted to go to work instead. My parents were furious, thought I was going to waste my life and talents and end up working in a low paid job I hated etc. My Dad was particularly, vocally, disappointed but in the end they had to trust me to make my own way.

I’m now 31 years of age, from the North East but work in London and I’m head of a Service Management department for a software company earning 6 figures - not quite a Social Worker! However there are parts of me who still wish I went to Uni purely for the life experiences it would have given me. I think it teaches young people so much in terms of resilience and forces them to mature and deal with real adult life.

Sorry if it took a long time to get to my point but what I’m getting at is… he can still go to Uni and do even a ‘Mickey Mouse degree’ and it counts for something, there are so many opportunities and career paths that he won’t even be aware exist yet and him going to Uni might consist of the first year getting drunk and doing very little - but that’s a life experience and a learning curve in its own right.

Please trust him to do what he wants to do, have faith it will be alright either way. Even if he decides to go to Uni and then drops out, that doesn’t mean he’s a failure. Everyone has different paths. Try and be supportive rather than judgemental, 9 times out of 10 it’ll work in your favour I promise!❤

MysteryBelle · 24/03/2023 06:17

Restlessinthenorth · 24/03/2023 06:16

I'm an assistant professor at a university. Unless for a very specific career path that can only be achieved via university study, I will actively discourage my children from going to university.

In the days when higher education was free, then I would have encouraged anyone willing and able to go for the wider experience that living away from home brings. But now, students often leaving was 60k + debt for a mediocre course with limited specific earning potential? Hard no from me. Far better to find an apprenticeship and get on with earning whilst obtaining industry specific training. No reason not to rent a house with mates whilst doing this for the independence skills, especially given the cost of uni accommodation which is also outrageous.

As sad a situation as it is, there is FAR more to life for young people than university in 2023

That’s easy for you to say, you got your education. Let this young man get his.

Restlessinthenorth · 24/03/2023 06:16

I'm an assistant professor at a university. Unless for a very specific career path that can only be achieved via university study, I will actively discourage my children from going to university.

In the days when higher education was free, then I would have encouraged anyone willing and able to go for the wider experience that living away from home brings. But now, students often leaving was 60k + debt for a mediocre course with limited specific earning potential? Hard no from me. Far better to find an apprenticeship and get on with earning whilst obtaining industry specific training. No reason not to rent a house with mates whilst doing this for the independence skills, especially given the cost of uni accommodation which is also outrageous.

As sad a situation as it is, there is FAR more to life for young people than university in 2023

Sartre · 24/03/2023 06:15

I’m feeling defensive about the humanities here as an English lit lecturer! Of course the humanities are still vital (every bit as vital as STEM) and lead to fantastic career progression. Unsure if you’re aware that law falls under humanities, we’re not all useless bums sitting around reading Dickens in coffee shops. I can’t believe you wouldn’t be impressed if he did a Spanish degree either, teaching English as a foreign language is hugely lucrative.

Kindly, you’re being an arse. His future, his choice. STEM is not the be all and end all, unsure why you hold it in such high regard. Without English, we would all be illiterate.

RedHelenB · 24/03/2023 06:08

SabbatWheel · 24/03/2023 01:34

DD started uni and dropped out very quickly. 8 years down the line she is earning 10k more than her mate who has a first class degree in Maths and owns her own flat because someone gave her a chance in a job. She no longer does that job, in fact something very different, but working and earning flicked her switch. Uni isn’t for everyone.

Maybe not, but OPs son wants to go so it makes sense for him to try it. He has years of working ahead of him.

Adviceneeded234 · 24/03/2023 06:07

@Goinganon321 i completely agree with you for many reasonS and it’s sad to see the old view of uni is best regardless of the situation

i applied to uni despite not wanting to go or having a passion on a particular subject. decided to not go two months before and went to work.

best decision ever bcos it has led to the most amazing career and I am now a senior manager within a department that deal with apprenticeships and technical education. Basically an alternative route of education and especially to uni. There are so many degree apprenticeships one can do, all the way from midwifery, law, to a dr.

If he really wanted to, he could do an apprenticeship and he would be miles ahead of his colleagues without debt and making money as he works and study. We work very close with employers in the industry and the feedback is they mostly always prefer someone who has done an apprenticeship than a degree as they have hands on work experience and the theory too.

the U.K. is moving towards this now as uni is not the route for everyone. At 28 I am miles ahead and earning a lot more than most of my friends who went to uni.

your job is to show him his options and let’s hope he makes the right decision for himself.

good luck.

Backstreets · 24/03/2023 05:59

Op’s view will probably become the majority one over time as costs of living and expectations for parental support rise and rise. Wouldn’t have traded my uni experience or living independently at 18 for work though, god knows you’ll spend enough of your life doing that.

MarquessofPembroke · 24/03/2023 05:58

You had uni supportive parents, the kid in this op doesn't, he has a mum who wants maximum income minimum outgoings from as soon as possible unles he's going to be a doctor

What an unpleasant thing to say and it's clearly untrue.

SnailKite · 24/03/2023 05:49

I’m surprised at all those saying ‘He’s unlikely to go after a gap year.’ Surely it’s not unusual at all to take time to decide, apply post-results, and earn some money as a backup fund before you go?

All of my kids did that (in fact one of them took three years out first). They weren’t the only ones in their year to do so, and the school even had a ‘year 14 advice day’ for those taking a year out.

MissMarplesbag · 24/03/2023 05:47

I had no idea what I wanted to do at university, what 18 year old does tbh. I had a vague idea of publishing but didn't do this and I'm now in operations for a developmental organisation.

I studied humanities at university and this has really helped in my career journey. It equipped me with critical thinking & and research writing skills. The ability to prioritise multiple deadlines and priorities. Whilst you're at university you get to know more about what your interests are. You create networks & discover opportunities that take you beyond university and this is what people don't understand.

nzeire · 24/03/2023 05:45

my Daughter is entering into year two doing a degree that may or may not lead to a job. After the three years of hell they have been through, with uncertainty, fear, lockdowns and cancellations of nearly everything fun, I want her to have a good time. I want her to live away from home, keep learning, hang with people her age and be surrounded by motivated people, be inspired and maybe find something she is truely passionate about… she’s just switched up her subjects and I can see ideas forming for her future.

im thrilled for her.

Autienotnautie · 24/03/2023 05:32

Going to uni is about so much more than acquiring debt! Being educated to a higher level, showing commitment, living away from home, budgeting, being more responsible for own life choices, meeting new people and yes having fun. I could understand a gap year to go travelling but if he's not doing that then it's great he's got a plan while he figures out what he wants todo . He can work while doing degree too, you saw he works at mcds they will usually transfer students and he can pick up shifts when home too. A lot of people don't know what they want to do at 18. This seems like a sensible idea while he figures it out. And either his career chose won't need a specific qualification in which case a degree will enhance his cv or it will and he can figure a plan from there.

Blueberry40 · 24/03/2023 05:14

MysteryBelle · 24/03/2023 02:37

Trying to understand why you’d rather your son work at McDonald’s instead of going to college…🤯

Exactly this! Plenty of people go to uni for the experience more than a burning enthusiasm for the subject they are studying…a huge part of going is learning independence, how to budget, widening your social circle, increasing your job prospects. If your son ends up dropping out then he can come home and work in McDonald’s- at least give him a chance!

MrsMikeDrop · 24/03/2023 05:13

daretodenim · 24/03/2023 05:09

I see where you're coming from OP.

I took a gap year and went travelling. I applied to uni during the gap year. That meant my gap year came to an end - I could easily have dragged it out otherwise!

Is this something you'd consider or he'd consider? I did it alone but plenty of people did something like Bunac where they help you get settled and meet people. It's basically a work and party year and just being free.

The impact it had was that when I started uni I was a year older than those who were away from home for the first time and didn't get caught up in all the "just moved away from home" drama, which involved a lot of partying like you've never been free to party before.

Once at uni I also changed my degree - not radically, like from humanities to stem, but I went stuck with my initial course selection.

One thing I'd say I'd be careful you don't give him the impression that his subjects and his predicted results aren't worth as much as stem ones of higher marks. You may have a point, but if the goal is for him to pick an area of study that he is enthusiastic about, anything that implies he's not quite good enough is counterproductive. Like I said in the beginning, I get your point, but from what you've written in your posts I'm not entirely sure you feel supportive of his academic choices or abilities. It sounds like you'd prefer he was able to do if he interested in STEM subjects that align with a particular career path. Maybe you don't my point is that you may unintentionally be giving him that impression, as it's the impression a few people on here also have.

I agree, you don't appear particularly supportive or to value a degree. If he's just going to uni to party for a few years, well obviously that's stupid but he sounds like he wants the whole experience. If it's just partying then he's not going to get past the first semester anyway. If he studies a subject he enjoys, it won't be a bad thing as it will lead to other things.

daretodenim · 24/03/2023 05:09

I see where you're coming from OP.

I took a gap year and went travelling. I applied to uni during the gap year. That meant my gap year came to an end - I could easily have dragged it out otherwise!

Is this something you'd consider or he'd consider? I did it alone but plenty of people did something like Bunac where they help you get settled and meet people. It's basically a work and party year and just being free.

The impact it had was that when I started uni I was a year older than those who were away from home for the first time and didn't get caught up in all the "just moved away from home" drama, which involved a lot of partying like you've never been free to party before.

Once at uni I also changed my degree - not radically, like from humanities to stem, but I went stuck with my initial course selection.

One thing I'd say I'd be careful you don't give him the impression that his subjects and his predicted results aren't worth as much as stem ones of higher marks. You may have a point, but if the goal is for him to pick an area of study that he is enthusiastic about, anything that implies he's not quite good enough is counterproductive. Like I said in the beginning, I get your point, but from what you've written in your posts I'm not entirely sure you feel supportive of his academic choices or abilities. It sounds like you'd prefer he was able to do if he interested in STEM subjects that align with a particular career path. Maybe you don't my point is that you may unintentionally be giving him that impression, as it's the impression a few people on here also have.

MrsMikeDrop · 24/03/2023 05:07

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 02:26

I had no idea that taking a year out to make up one’s mind on which subject to study at uni - rather than just go for the fun- would be so controversial. Amazed. Night all

Wanting to go for the experience isn't a bad thing in itself, he's likely to find something he likes and flourish. I ended up changing what I was doing in the first semester. If you genuinely want him to go then you should encourage it. He's unlikely to go a year later once he starts making money (however little that is) and if his friends are established there doing their own thing. Only you know your son, so perhaps that is why you seem to be so against it. Personally I'd do anything that would increase better outcomes for my children

emptythelitterbox · 24/03/2023 04:56

OP did you go to uni?

yossell · 24/03/2023 04:51

My father was from a working class background - he got into Cambridge to do English in the 50s - it was a life changing experience and he had a lifelong love of literature, plays and poetry.

That said - outside if the very best universities - the explosion in higher education plus it's commercialisation has led to a complete devaluation of humanities-based degrees. Even at Russell group universities the majority of students have little interest in their subject and get very little from their courses. They now end up in massive debt and remember university for the parties and social life. People who aren't passionate about their non-stem subject really shouldn't be going.

MysteryBelle · 24/03/2023 04:49

PsychoHotSauce · 24/03/2023 04:39

Going against the grain here from personal experience but I'm not sure it will give you a solution OP.

My brother was a straight A student, until A levels. He became distracted by the social life when he went from a single sex to mixed sixth form and his grades tanked.

There was never a question, in his mind, whether he was going to uni. It was happening. Like your son he had no set idea of what degree to take, and it became very clear that he just wanted to go "for the experience".

He really struggled, and his uni work was sort of fitted around his social life rather than the other way around. He refused part time work to give him some structure, only doing seasonal work in a supermarket in the holidays he bothered to come home for.

He was broke and failing. He finished the three years with a 2:2 while his peers were flying because they wanted to.

He then had the bright idea of staying to do a masters. Borrowed more money. His friends were going off and landing London jobs on good wages with their firsts and I think he didn't want to fail in the job market.

He got kicked out of the masters after a few months for failing to keep up. He walked away with basically a worthless degree and £60k of student loans.

I'm not saying a 2:2 is a worthless degree, but the field he chose was highly competitive and he had lofty ambitions of walking into a 50k a year job, without doing any work.

It sounds like this is what you're worried about happening, but tbh I'm not sure how you can stop it. If I could go back in time, I can't think of any way I could have persuaded DB not to go, or if he went, to actually put the work in/choose the right degree. He was blinkered that uni was as you say an entitlement but imo was just going so he could make new friends and party. An expensive lesson.

Do you have a good relationship with your brother?

MysteryBelle · 24/03/2023 04:47

He doesn’t have to take STEM. If you push him into subjects he hates of course he will not do well. It’s important for him to study what he’s interested in, he may not get job in exactly his subject but the degree will help and as pp said, not everybody has to do STEM, and can still find employment. Better to study what interests him and not be miserable in a job he hates for decades just to please your idea of what he should be.

user1492757084 · 24/03/2023 04:47

He wants to go.

If he studies Spanish he might become a teacher or have a Spanish speaking service or travel business.
He might also see what the others are studying and take a fancy to another subject.
Let him go to uni. . Encourage him to get a job for the Summer and at holidays.

Cieloazzurro · 24/03/2023 04:40

I sense a huge disappointment from OP that he isn’t studying a STEM subject. This is not the only way to a successful career. I know plenty of people with well paid, fulfilling jobs who didn’t study STEM; lawyers, journalists, headteachers, civil servants. If he wants to go to uni, support him. He’ll do a lot of growing up and probably leave with a better idea of where he’s heading in life.