Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DS would be better off getting a job rather than going to uni

366 replies

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 01:04

My son wants to go to uni but has no idea what to study. 75% of his cohort (non-selective state school) usually apply and go and he says it’s the norm.

He is taking English, Spanish and Sociology for A level (so no STEM) and will probably be predicted BBB. He does the bare minimum for his A-levels (no super-curricular stuff at all) so I question why he wants to go to uni.

AIBU to say he should take a year out, work and think about it? He says I am because working shifts in Maccy D’s for a year won’t change a thing and most of his friends don’t have a clue what they want to do for a career so are just choosing a degree related to their ‘best subject’ at A-level. Difference is that most of them are doing at least one STEM subject! DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age.

On the other hand, having him resentfully living here and working shifts for a year while all his (equally undecided) friends are at uni isn’t exactly an attractive prospect either…. Help!

OP posts:
MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 24/03/2023 07:15

@Goinganon321 I agree with you. Your son wants to go for the student lifestyle. Not to study. Are you expected to top up his fees as well?? If so then yes a year out to discover what he wants to do is better in my opinion.
I know a lot of people who have been to uni, got into lots of debt and working in jobs that do no require a degree. They took subjects such as psychology, history and english.
The people who have done better are apprenticeship style courses where they have done their degree around work.
I went to uni and studied for nursing so it was specific for me

Calmdown14 · 24/03/2023 07:12

I would encourage him to apply but also to explore other options.

He is best to go through the UCAS system and get a place somewhere. But he could also look at apprenticeship options. There are many that are not your traditional apprenticeship now.

If he was a more commited student I'd say it doesn't really matter be doesn't know what he wants to do but the combination of both is a problem.

I'd encourage Spanish as the best option. He can take electives alongside it. But a languages degree is not usually an easy ride.

harkerlee · 24/03/2023 07:12

Goinganon321 · 24/03/2023 02:13

my son’s motivations for going to uni are a) most of my friends are applying b) I want a fun student life even though I don’t enjoy studying and can’t pick a subject. Good motivations I think not! A year out to mature and reflect is needed IMHO. I hope he will then go

It's a tricky one, OP.

Ultimately, you need to let your son decide.

I would sit down with him and look at the reality of the debt he will incur from going, it's really more of a tax now that he will pay for most of his working life.

He needs to understand that and balance it with the benefits he gets from going to uni.

Lots of young people do go to uni not really knowing what they want to do and that's OK, as long as he will actually finish the course.

Coming out with a third in a humanities subject because he just wanted to party is really not worth the effort or money.

Just talk it all through with him and let him make the decision - it's his life.

stayathomer · 24/03/2023 07:10

The only thing I’d say about the student experience’ is he’s so h to ping it’s no more of a waste than if he went travelling or working in a job that isn’t what he’ll do for life in the long run. It all helps make us- you’re out in your own, away from home, and it could potentially show him what he does or doesn’t want to do. Everything you do in life is a risk- there’s as much chance he figures it out in university as working (where he might be bitter in the future that he didn’t get to do the whole university thing). Personally I’d say there’s less focused people who are heading in a specific direction at that age- I did science and a HUGE percentage of our class ended up taking totally different paths!!

redtshirt50 · 24/03/2023 07:07

Not RTFT

But Spanish is a great degree. Learning other languages is a useful skill, and he will have the chance to do a year aboard in Spain which would be amazing for him.

Im all for university and see it as a chance to stay young and enjoy life for a bit longer - no harm in that. Life can get pretty shit so I think make the most of it while you can.

I worked throughout the whole of uni and during the summers, which he can do too.

yes he might be better off financially if he didn’t go to university, a few of my friends who didn’t go have done VERY well for themselves. Just like some of my friends that did go have, and there’s also people who haven’t don’t so well.

I think uni opens up a lot of opportunities for people through the connections you make, and it allows you to boarded your horizons and learn there’s more to life that just your hometown

Lifeisnotabedofroses · 24/03/2023 07:07

Personally think a year out is a great idea. I had one and changed my mind re subject. Younger son had one. If he likes Spanish would suggest work to save and then travel in a Spanish speaking area.
Would he be open for applying for a differed place so he knows he’s got a place after the year?

Meandfour · 24/03/2023 07:06

WordtoYoMumma · 24/03/2023 07:02

I agree with you OP. I am.in the minority everywhere of people who think uni is a waste of time unless you have a career path that needs a degree. Especially going straight from school. Kids end up in tens of thousands of pounds of debt (no, it's not a "graduate tax", it is a debt that they will pay every month for the rest of their working lives, and every time they get a better job or a pay rise, that payment will go up, with most people never having any way to pay it off ever)

How are all these kids paying for uni? Us parents are supposed to fund them to go get pissed for 3 years? Potentially at the expense of other children at home (if my eldest goes to uni then we will be expected to top up his loan, we don't have this money spare so it'll be cutting back on everything for us at home, including money spent on the other two kids)

I went to uni. Have never had a graduate job. Am in debt forever for nothing. Have zero friends from my uni days, was basically left with debt, mental illness and regret. So i suppose it's hard for me to be impartial! But yeh I am pretty anti the university-as-standard approach that middle class families all seem to have. I don't think we should be pandering to kids who just don't want to get a job and instead want to live off loans and bank of mum and dad for 3 years.

I completely agree with you.

Meandfour · 24/03/2023 07:05

Phoebo · 24/03/2023 01:37

This. If he can, he should go to Uni, it's always better than not going (unless he doesn't want to of course)

How is it always better to go than not go? That’s far from my experience. All the degree educated striking professionals on a hell of a lot less money than a lot of people who never went to uni would probably disagree with you too.

MimiSunshine · 24/03/2023 07:03

So encourage him to do a Spanish degree at uni, I’m assuming that will include a year abroad (did when I was at uni) and having a 2nd language like Spanish is no bad thing.

many companies such as global banks would see that degree as an advantage in post studying applications.

I Just googled ‘vacancies compulsory Spanish’ and a whole list of jobs came up on Indeed that required Spanish. This graduate role seems pretty good and while obviously not something your son can apply for now, shows where his future may go. Just because he doesn’t apply himself too strongly now, doesn’t mean he won’t throughout his time at uni.
Graduate Spanish speaking role

MysteryBelle · 24/03/2023 07:02

Restlessinthenorth · 24/03/2023 06:33

@MysteryBelle what a bizarre post. OP asked for opinions. I shared mine, from both a parent and academic perspective. Don't try and shut me down because you disagree with what I have to say!

What’s bizarre is you accusing me of shutting you down, no I didn’t, I disagreed with you and gave my opinion, just two short sentences. As a professor, you should welcome opinions differing from yours. You’re the one trying to shut down anyone disagreeing with you. You were threatened by two little short sentences from me? Very weird. That young man wants to go to university. It’s his life, not yours. Not his mother’s. I think she should be supportive that he even wants to go.

WordtoYoMumma · 24/03/2023 07:02

I agree with you OP. I am.in the minority everywhere of people who think uni is a waste of time unless you have a career path that needs a degree. Especially going straight from school. Kids end up in tens of thousands of pounds of debt (no, it's not a "graduate tax", it is a debt that they will pay every month for the rest of their working lives, and every time they get a better job or a pay rise, that payment will go up, with most people never having any way to pay it off ever)

How are all these kids paying for uni? Us parents are supposed to fund them to go get pissed for 3 years? Potentially at the expense of other children at home (if my eldest goes to uni then we will be expected to top up his loan, we don't have this money spare so it'll be cutting back on everything for us at home, including money spent on the other two kids)

I went to uni. Have never had a graduate job. Am in debt forever for nothing. Have zero friends from my uni days, was basically left with debt, mental illness and regret. So i suppose it's hard for me to be impartial! But yeh I am pretty anti the university-as-standard approach that middle class families all seem to have. I don't think we should be pandering to kids who just don't want to get a job and instead want to live off loans and bank of mum and dad for 3 years.

Waahaawoowoo · 24/03/2023 06:59

I wonder how many posters on this thread have sent (and paid for) their DC to attend uni in the last 3 years?

DN is just finishing his final year. He is glad he did his degree but was disappointed with the 'uni experience'. Lectures and classes all online. Next to no one in halls or campus. There was hardly any socialising. A lot of money has been spent on accommodation when he could have stayed at home. My manager's son has started uni this year and reporting similar at a different uni.

I think the lifestyle and experience is not what it once was. Which makes sense seeing as it costs so much now to go. It sorts out the time wasters who just want a three year bender bank rolled by mum and dad.

I was like your DS. I went to uni with no clear path and did history. I struggled to get a graduate job (not cut throat enough, didn't want to move miles away). I joined the public sector and I think my degree has helped open doors at interviews etc. But not having one probably wouldn't have held me back either. Lots of people my age and rank have worked their way up without. It is only now I am in my 40s that my degree has been a necessity and being used to some extent. Those 3 years at uni were amazing, but I don't think they were worth the money TBH. And my parents spent a lot less than parents nowadays would. I still got a grant!

DH left high school at 16 with no qualifications. He worked manual minimum eage jobs before he studied to do an NVQ and got his Class 1 HGV. Needless to say he earns a lot more than I will ever will in my career path and can walk out of one job on Wednesday to walk into another on Thursday.

We will be encouraging our DC to look at all roads, not just uni. We already have DS1 struggling academically while I think DS2 will be capable if he wants to.

Velvian · 24/03/2023 06:57

If he enjoys Spanish, that's great, OP. Studying another language to degree level is very impressive to me.

I think studying at degree level is likely to help him find his particular passion in any subject. A degree is a great stepping stone for whatever he wants to move on to. It is great that he wants to do it.

Phineyj · 24/03/2023 06:50

Also she studied Social Anthropology, which she loved, but which has absolutely no relevance to anything she did subsequently as far as I can tell!

MumofSpud · 24/03/2023 06:50

I think I agree with you Op - going to Uni to do a subject you are not particularly interested in (and me paying for it!) just to have 3 years of partying is not great.
I am having the same discussion with my DD- she is looking at apprenticeships aswell - is that an option for your DS?
When my DS went to Uni I encouraged him to do a subject that would lead to a job.

Passerillage · 24/03/2023 06:49

A year spent working in Mac Donald’s here in the U.K. or Ireland or wherever you are, will not help. It’s just stalling and wasting his time, and not contributing to him growing up or working things out for himself.

But a year spent in Spain working in a cafe, or a winery, or a bar or whatever will get him fluent in Spanish, which you said he likes. It will put him in a new environment with new people and new ideas, and the penny may well drop about what he wants to do with himself.

This might be easier said than done post Brexit, but you could research it for him.

Phineyj · 24/03/2023 06:49

My sister (mid August birthday) took a gap year in similar circumstances. She had a cleaning job and did some administrative work, then went on a Tall Ships voyage. It was the making of her and she went off happily to university a year later with more commitment to study. She found not wanting to hoover pub carpets very motivating...

16 is very young.

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 24/03/2023 06:41

"DS doing a degree in humanities or Spanish not so useful in this day and age"

Erm...degree in a language not useful?!?! Of course it is! Knowing a 2nd language opens up so many doors to any given career. My DC has chosen to do a language degree at Uni, we visited 2/3 University talks about the courses and the opportunities available are fantastic. My DC is can't wait to learn more about the language, is engaged in educating herself and would be gutted to feel her degree wouldn't 'be so useful in this day and age'!!

But if your son has no clear subject interest, then uni will probably be a waste of time, effort and money. It's hugely expensive anyway so maybe a year out, working might be best for him.

Nappyvalley15 · 24/03/2023 06:38

He is reasonably bright and he wants to continue his education. You should be proud of him. It sounds as if he is under quite a bit of pressure to 'decide' a career path when lots of young people his age are not sure what they want to do.

I think you should support his aim to go to uni. Let him know you think that he is capable of getting a good degree. Humanities graduates have excellent prospects as many graduates schemes do not need specific degree subjects.

Encourage him to sign up for the open days of a few he might like - get a better idea of what it entails and what it costs.

If by the time he needs to apply, he really isn't sure about what subject to study, I would keep the idea of a gap year on the table. However I would encourage him to get a proper full time job that paid more than McDonald's. It would help him save for uni and also give him a better taste of working life which should help him decide his next step.

1Wanda1 · 24/03/2023 06:35

I felt the same as you OP. My DS actually left college saying he had no interest in further education as hated the whole education system of exams etc. He got grades similar to your DS's predictions.

I wanted him to get a degree apprenticeship, but he wouldn't even consider it. So he got a job in retail and after doing that for several months decided to go to uni. I was sceptical as he didn't seem to want to go for any reason other than to have fun and because he'd worked out that working on minimum wage isn't fun.

Year one was a bit of a disaster. He's in year 2 now and doing well. He's learned a lot of life lessons. He's got a lovely girlfriend. He's happy. Could he have learned these life lessons without incurring the uni debt? Probably. Will he end up with a job that actually requires him to have the degree he'll get? Maybe not. Does he even have a career plan? No. But it's his life, not mine, and on balance I am glad he's having the experience and is enjoying it. I'm sure he'll decide later on whether it was "worth it" but for now I think it is.

RosaGallica · 24/03/2023 06:34

What a strange load of responses. I guess you might be a bit older like me, op, and view University as a place to study rather than as a place for social lives.

And one that comes with a massive debt that no longer pays back. Many are turning away from that now, unless there is some family wealth to support the youngster through his 30s.

I would go with the gap year personally, but not necessarily to work in McDonalds. If your DS wants to study Spanish chances are he will end up as a teacher - and as a male, he will be enabled to rise as far as he wants over us mere females. Suggest he gets a year employment in a school first, perhaps even a special school. There are plenty of TA jobs going and that is genuinely valuable experience wherever he goes next that still provides a social life.

Restlessinthenorth · 24/03/2023 06:33

@MysteryBelle what a bizarre post. OP asked for opinions. I shared mine, from both a parent and academic perspective. Don't try and shut me down because you disagree with what I have to say!

pixietinkdust · 24/03/2023 06:32

Restlessinthenorth · 24/03/2023 06:16

I'm an assistant professor at a university. Unless for a very specific career path that can only be achieved via university study, I will actively discourage my children from going to university.

In the days when higher education was free, then I would have encouraged anyone willing and able to go for the wider experience that living away from home brings. But now, students often leaving was 60k + debt for a mediocre course with limited specific earning potential? Hard no from me. Far better to find an apprenticeship and get on with earning whilst obtaining industry specific training. No reason not to rent a house with mates whilst doing this for the independence skills, especially given the cost of uni accommodation which is also outrageous.

As sad a situation as it is, there is FAR more to life for young people than university in 2023

I wholeheartedly agree with the above. Sound advice.

MsWhitworth · 24/03/2023 06:32

Uni is more than a degree. It’s living away from home, meeting a wide range of people, working independently plus it elevates you into a different category in the future workplace.

Don’t worry about what subject he studies - I know loads of people who have careers in fields that are nothing to do with their degree.

Don’t encourage him to stay living at home with his mum and flip burgers!

Nosleepforthismum · 24/03/2023 06:28

Restlessinthenorth · 24/03/2023 06:16

I'm an assistant professor at a university. Unless for a very specific career path that can only be achieved via university study, I will actively discourage my children from going to university.

In the days when higher education was free, then I would have encouraged anyone willing and able to go for the wider experience that living away from home brings. But now, students often leaving was 60k + debt for a mediocre course with limited specific earning potential? Hard no from me. Far better to find an apprenticeship and get on with earning whilst obtaining industry specific training. No reason not to rent a house with mates whilst doing this for the independence skills, especially given the cost of uni accommodation which is also outrageous.

As sad a situation as it is, there is FAR more to life for young people than university in 2023

Thanks for a refreshingly honest post. I also don’t think that going to uni suits every kid and I won’t be encouraging mine to get into shed loads of debt for the “experience”. One of the smartest kids I know has done his research and has landed a really impressive apprenticeship and moved 150 miles away from his parents at 17. The company pay for his accommodation and all his training and he lives with three other trainees. Having a degree is no longer the be all and end all.