Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this dog should be destroyed and the owner imprisoned?

208 replies

YaWeeFurryBastard · 23/03/2023 17:15

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/victoria-park-police-horse-dog-attack-crime-london-b1069385.html

Apologies if there’s been another thread on this but I couldn’t see one! A police horse has been attacked an injured by an off-lead dog in London. No prizes for guessing the breed 🙄.

AIBU to think if the dog is capable of attacking a horse (I think we can assume unprovoked) then there is a serious risk of fatal consequences to a human from this dog and therefore it needs to be put down?

Dog seized after attack on police horse in east London

Police told owners ‘Keep dogs on a lead if you can’t recall them or get them under control’

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/victoria-park-police-horse-dog-attack-crime-london-b1069385.html

OP posts:
Ostryga · 24/03/2023 09:38

Just saw the video. Absolutely horrific.

I personally think all bully breeds need to be banned now. There is a tiktok of a little one year old in london who’s entire left side of her face was crushed by the family xl bully. And the parents are showing videos of how ‘gentle’ the dog was when it was incredibly clear it was stressed.

The damage these dogs cause (even through no fault of their own due to their fucking idiot owners) is too great.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/03/2023 07:45

I am surptyriaed the police did notndestroy the dog on site tbh. My dad is a sheep farmer and farmers ar.elwgally allowed to shoot dogs that "worry" their sheep.

"Sheep worrying" is a very mild term for an awful thing. Out of control dogs can chase and bite sheep and as herd animals the sheep can get so frightened they run as a flock towards danger - in to roads, in to streams or fences or many die of heart attacks they are so frightned.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/03/2023 07:42

@ALifeofChaos what a horrible experience. The guy sounds like an idiot, Belgian Malinois are known to be breed that need a lot of training and exercise. They are not a breed to take on lightly or for most people to have as pets.

WillowKnicks · 24/03/2023 07:35

About 4 years ago, my DD was riding her horse on a beach when a big, bull type dog came flying at them. Luckily, my DH saw what was going to happen & just shouted "DD GO!!!"

It chased them for a good while, snapping & biting & tore y

dawngreen · 24/03/2023 07:26

The owner was the problem not the dog.

HoppingPavlova · 24/03/2023 04:28

The dog should have been in a lead and controlled, without a doubt.

However, I don’t think only ‘evil dog breeds’ will attack a horse. Once upon a time I agreed to house sit a small hobby farm for 6 months. I didn’t have to do anything with the animals, they engaged someone else to do this in their absence. I was just occupying the house. Anyway, there was a horse. My lovely, genuinely ‘wouldn’t hurt a fly’ dogs, never an issue with any other dogs or people, took exception to this horse and tried to attack/bite the legs. The fact it would kick them in the head for their trouble (resulting in yelping, running off and not bothering for the rest of the day) was quickly forgotten the next day. They were a Lab and a Cocker Spaniel. I had to go to great expense to temporarily fence around the house to contain them so they couldn’t attack the horse. It also wasn’t great as they had a farm dog which never bothered the horse or other farm animals which then was unhappily restricted to a small area around the house as opposed to its usual wide ranging area as it couldn’t freely come and go without mine getting out as well.

Zebedee55 · 24/03/2023 04:27

Yes, it should be destroyed, but these dog attacks on humans/other animals seem to be getting more common.

Sooner or late, we are going to need to enforce leads/muzzled/both on dogs in public.

A shame because there are many lovely, well behaved dogs around.🙁

sanityisamyth · 24/03/2023 04:11

@Maverickess Absolutely brilliantly put.

Maverickess · 24/03/2023 00:25

I don't know about the dog, attacking a horse is different to attacking a human, she's an XL Bully - Bull - Bull Terrier, it's literally what her breeding is about, taking down large prey animals like bulls, or horses.
It's a logical conclusion to draw that a dog with breeding like that will be more likely to go after a horse if unrestrained and the owner clearly doesn't understand that because he's saying the dog was intimidated by the horse - highly unlikely for a dog of that size, strength and breeding imo.

It's like me taking my JRT somewhere there are small and furries and claiming I didn't know that she'd be likely to do that because she's good with people. I know she's more likely to go after a rabbit or rat because that's what she's bred to do, possibly even a smaller cat. I have trained her with cats, but you can never train instinct out entirely and so she stays on the lead in a situation where there might be a risk. Tbh she grew up with a cat who put her in her place from a tiny puppy, and she's normally wary of cats for that reason, but I wouldn't trust her 100% with one because of her breeding and because she's a relative size - around a horse, not an issue of strength and size, but still capable of causing a problem none the less.

But, these dogs are attacking people too, and I do believe that breeds have traits that we've bred into them and although I'm loathe to condemn a breed because they often attract idiots, unfortunately they attract these idiots for a reason - what we've selectively bred into them. Size, strength and aggression with these types of breed as a show of force and for the 'thrill' of thinking they can control a dog like that.

But I'm clear on the fact that it's the idiots at fault, and I feel desperately sorry for these dogs that end up in these situations because they're doing what instinct tells them, without training to counteract that, and they haven't been given a bloody chance by irresponsible breeders and owners, by even something as simple as putting the dog on a lead in public or keeping them away from children - as you should with any dog.

This owner is beyond belief, playing the victim about people being 'rude' to him and bleating how the dog is his baby girl and keeps him going - I call bollocks, she's a statement dog and that statement is 'Look how hard and Gangsta I am'. And he's right about getting kicked by a horse being dangerous, but it was his responsibility to stop that attack and he didn't even try. Tells me everything I need to know, more bothered about his own neck than stopping her attacking the horse, or trying to protect her from the hooves - if he loved the dog as much as he claims and thought she reacted in fear, why didn't he try and stop it for her protection, even if he didn't give a shit about the horse. I hope that if it gets to court and he has his 'say' it's explained to him in small, on syllable words how fucking ridiculous he is.

That dog is as much of a victim as the horse.
And I say that as a horse lover, that was awful to watch, and it's so lucky the horse didn't go down because he looked like he was going to a couple of times and that would have been catastrophic for the horse and dangerous for the rider and those around.

Been in the horse world a long time and dog attacks aren't rare, I've experienced two and most horsey friends have also had at least one incident - but they're rarely dealt with, and they're becoming more common, along with dog on dog attacks and dog on human attacks. I love my dogs and dogs in general, but, we have a serious problem developing with the growing number of dogs that aren't under control, trained or restrained and people owning them who don't care and are putting their dogs in these situations, as well as the other animals and people getting hurt or worse. Something needs to be done.

FrostyFifi · 23/03/2023 23:13

OK, so if a cat kills a bird, then do you think you should scoop them up and take them to the vets to be killed?
Because that is batshit, and is what you are suggesting for dogs

No, obviously that's extreme, but I do think responsible dog owners, horse-riders, farmers etc have the right not to have their animals injured or killed by out of control dogs. It would put the onus on the owner to ensure that the dog is kept under control.

This is already partially the situation as it is, given that a farmer can obviously shoot dogs worrying his animals.

XenoBitch · 23/03/2023 23:10

FrostyFifi · 23/03/2023 23:01

I don't think just being dangerous to humans should be a criteria for a dog being destroyed, I think it's reasonable in cases where they are a danger to other dogs and livestock as well.

Clearly if they manage to maul another animal then the owner isn't capable of controlling them.

OK, so if a cat kills a bird, then do you think you should scoop them up and take them to the vets to be killed?
Because that is batshit, and is what you are suggesting for dogs.

FrostyFifi · 23/03/2023 23:01

I don't think just being dangerous to humans should be a criteria for a dog being destroyed, I think it's reasonable in cases where they are a danger to other dogs and livestock as well.

Clearly if they manage to maul another animal then the owner isn't capable of controlling them.

Onahillagain · 23/03/2023 22:52

Muzzle and lead at all times in public for all dogs.

That won’t solve the problem though. These idiots who are buying these types of dogs won’t obey any laws, they’ll continue to allow them to be off lead, or escape etc and there won’t be any police around to stop them. Not until it’s too late.

The only way will be to stop the existence of them altogether. Stop them being imported. Stop them being bred.

begoneday · 23/03/2023 22:52

XenoBitch · 23/03/2023 21:17

But this dog did not attack a person. It attacked a prey animal. Dogs who attack other animals are not automatically euthanised.
JRT who go for rats would be put to sleep, a greyhound who catches a squirrel in the park would be put to sleep, a lab who attacks a sheep would be put to sleep.
As has been said many times... dogs know the difference between other animals and humans.

XL bullies must be the stupidest dogs on earth then because they keep attacking and killing humans.

Ricco12 · 23/03/2023 22:47

I don't think the dog should be destroyed but absolutely taken from that idiot and rehomed to a responsible owner

The only way to combat the current issue with out of control dogs is to what some other countries do

Muzzle and lead at all times in public for all dogs.

BounceyB · 23/03/2023 22:37

Breeds should never be banned. I think all dogs should have to be insured, chipped and licensed. All owners should have to be prepared to do mandatory dog training. Until the dog has completed an appropriate of training (6 months) they shouldn't be allowed off lead. It took me a year to train my dog and I'm always learning more - I feel like this is how it should be.

kirsty2023 · 23/03/2023 22:34

Chesneyhawkes1 · 23/03/2023 22:00

There is zero point in banning XL bullies. The type of people who own them won't care or will just move onto another breed.

I don't know what the answer is but we need to stop idiots owning and breeding dogs.

There's a fair few around where I live and I feel nervous walking my little dogs. I've never felt that way around other dogs before. They are often off lead even by the road and I known I've got zero chance of fighting one off.

As a former horse owner that was tough to watch. The horse was a saint. It's a shame he didn't double barrel the dog.

Same where I live loads of them around never on a lead and always seem to be with young lads I've got a pug and I normally walk her with a friend and her dog but stopped going to the same place as a few dogs have been killed there in the past month I hate going on dog walks now as always have to keep a look out my dog is never off her lead unless she's in the garden...

PhoenixIsFlying · 23/03/2023 22:33

Also, the highest number of attacks by dogs that people seek treatment in hospital for is by Labradors . Maybe we should put Labradors on the dangerous dogs list.

Bobshhh · 23/03/2023 22:31

All XL bullies and all XL bully owners should be shut together in a compound for the next 500 years until they both die out.

XenoBitch · 23/03/2023 22:26

EggInANest · 23/03/2023 22:23

Thank goodness the humans are safe from this dog. Bit tough on the next sensitive horse that gets its skin ripped off though. Or whatever 'prey' animal it identifies next.

My dog has caught a squirrel before. Does that mean she will go and chomp on a baby? Utterly ridiculous to assume she would.

EggInANest · 23/03/2023 22:23

XenoBitch · 23/03/2023 22:16

I agree... and how people assume that a dog who attacks an animal will go for a human next.

Thank goodness the humans are safe from this dog. Bit tough on the next sensitive horse that gets its skin ripped off though. Or whatever 'prey' animal it identifies next.

Saschka · 23/03/2023 22:21

WeWereInParis · 23/03/2023 17:20

And unsurprisingly the owner has described the dog as "so friendly"

Aren't they bloody always.

And bitching that people were being “really rude” to him, and blaming the horse for forcing the dog to attack it by being horsy in public Hmm

We just need “only playing” and we’ll have shit owner bingo.

XenoBitch · 23/03/2023 22:16

PhoenixIsFlying · 23/03/2023 22:14

I honestly find it shocking how quickly everyone can just say, yes put it down. It's a life. OK so it attacked a horse but that is the fault of the owner not the dog. I see quite a few bull breeds walking my dog and they are perfectly friendly. I just hate how we can think its OK to destroy a life just like that. On the whole dogs are much better behaved than humans but we don't put humans down.

I agree... and how people assume that a dog who attacks an animal will go for a human next.

piedbeauty · 23/03/2023 22:16

The owner is a total bellend.

PhoenixIsFlying · 23/03/2023 22:14

I honestly find it shocking how quickly everyone can just say, yes put it down. It's a life. OK so it attacked a horse but that is the fault of the owner not the dog. I see quite a few bull breeds walking my dog and they are perfectly friendly. I just hate how we can think its OK to destroy a life just like that. On the whole dogs are much better behaved than humans but we don't put humans down.