Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this dog should be destroyed and the owner imprisoned?

208 replies

YaWeeFurryBastard · 23/03/2023 17:15

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/victoria-park-police-horse-dog-attack-crime-london-b1069385.html

Apologies if there’s been another thread on this but I couldn’t see one! A police horse has been attacked an injured by an off-lead dog in London. No prizes for guessing the breed 🙄.

AIBU to think if the dog is capable of attacking a horse (I think we can assume unprovoked) then there is a serious risk of fatal consequences to a human from this dog and therefore it needs to be put down?

Dog seized after attack on police horse in east London

Police told owners ‘Keep dogs on a lead if you can’t recall them or get them under control’

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/victoria-park-police-horse-dog-attack-crime-london-b1069385.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dawngreen · 28/03/2023 13:58

These types should be banned from owning dogs. Its always the same, and its the dogs who pay the price.

Ginmonkeyagain · 25/03/2023 08:34

A lot of young men with these strong dog breeds have no idea how to control them.

I had to grab a pitbull from a teen boy the other day as it was about to pull away from him and run in to a busy road.

WiddlinDiddlin · 24/03/2023 19:06

Oh totally... long line, if you can't bet the house your dog will recall from aaaaaaaaany distraction, then use a long line instead of off lead completely.

Maverickess · 24/03/2023 18:53

WiddlinDiddlin · 24/03/2023 18:31

Mmm... I don't disagree that the owners behaviour and lack of effort to recall his dog, stop his dog etc, were pathetic..

But...

The situation of 'dog chases/tries to bite/tries to nip to make move... a ridden horse' is VERY difficult to resolve.

It is also not something that ONLY xl bullies etc will do, many many dogs will do this.

The rider is stuck - they can't do much from on top but try to control the horse. If they get off to deal with the dog they have LESS control over the horse.

The owner is also stuck though... if the dog is not responding to voice cues, and it almost certainly isn't at this point as its off its tits super aroused, not capable of listening...

If they get closer, they're at risk of giving the dog MORE confidence to continue its behaviour.

Shouting is likely to be interpreted by the dog as encouragement/owner joining in, so again, will make the situation worse.

An unknown human chasing a dog around a horses legs puts the human at risk of being booted in the head, and is likely to unsettle the horse further, putting everyone involved and innocent bystanders at risk.

Chuck in the rider yelling and slashing wildly with a whip, which is perfectly understandable... you have utter chaos and its VERY difficult to put an end to the situation.

The situation should not happen in the first place - dogs should be trained to ignore ridden horses (and other dogs, other people, other animals..... a whole ton of stuff).

Dogs do NOT generalise well - if you teach your dog to ignore and recall away from cats, it won't translate to sheep or horses or cattle or..

You have to train in multiple situations, multiple levels of distraction, and many many species - and even then, horses with riders present an unusual event for dogs.

Dogs who have not seen a human get on, and get off, a horse, do not read a 'horse and rider' as that. They read it as some sort of weird horse/human hybrid monster weirdo thing. It truly baffles them, can really scare them and that confusion can increase the chances of them behaving out of character and ignoring cues.

Very few people have the opportunity to access lots of ridden horses in appropriate environments/contexts to train a dog, effectively and reliably, to ignore them and listen to voice cues.

I make a point of taking puppies up to a local stables where they can see ridden horses at a distance, and in particular, see people get on and off horses (with permission from the owner), but I live in an area where theres practically a livery yard or riding school on every corner.

Some people live in places where the only horses you'll ever see are police horses and you've no idea when, or where.

Few puppy owners seem to understand exactly what 'socialisation and habituation' really mean, nor how to go about if they have heard of it. I can't imagine many people who live in urban areas, would EVER consider they should habituate their dogs to horses if they're something they rarely or never (to date) see!

I agree with all those points but....... Putting it on a lead would have prevented the whole situation in the first place, and if you're unsure of your dogs reaction then put it on a lead.
The only way the that the dog would have got to the horse in the first place would be by the owner tripping or something and letting go - it happens and it's happened to me, but that's a genuine accident and although a horrible outcome, it's unavoidable - this was avoidable.

WiddlinDiddlin · 24/03/2023 18:31

Mmm... I don't disagree that the owners behaviour and lack of effort to recall his dog, stop his dog etc, were pathetic..

But...

The situation of 'dog chases/tries to bite/tries to nip to make move... a ridden horse' is VERY difficult to resolve.

It is also not something that ONLY xl bullies etc will do, many many dogs will do this.

The rider is stuck - they can't do much from on top but try to control the horse. If they get off to deal with the dog they have LESS control over the horse.

The owner is also stuck though... if the dog is not responding to voice cues, and it almost certainly isn't at this point as its off its tits super aroused, not capable of listening...

If they get closer, they're at risk of giving the dog MORE confidence to continue its behaviour.

Shouting is likely to be interpreted by the dog as encouragement/owner joining in, so again, will make the situation worse.

An unknown human chasing a dog around a horses legs puts the human at risk of being booted in the head, and is likely to unsettle the horse further, putting everyone involved and innocent bystanders at risk.

Chuck in the rider yelling and slashing wildly with a whip, which is perfectly understandable... you have utter chaos and its VERY difficult to put an end to the situation.

The situation should not happen in the first place - dogs should be trained to ignore ridden horses (and other dogs, other people, other animals..... a whole ton of stuff).

Dogs do NOT generalise well - if you teach your dog to ignore and recall away from cats, it won't translate to sheep or horses or cattle or..

You have to train in multiple situations, multiple levels of distraction, and many many species - and even then, horses with riders present an unusual event for dogs.

Dogs who have not seen a human get on, and get off, a horse, do not read a 'horse and rider' as that. They read it as some sort of weird horse/human hybrid monster weirdo thing. It truly baffles them, can really scare them and that confusion can increase the chances of them behaving out of character and ignoring cues.

Very few people have the opportunity to access lots of ridden horses in appropriate environments/contexts to train a dog, effectively and reliably, to ignore them and listen to voice cues.

I make a point of taking puppies up to a local stables where they can see ridden horses at a distance, and in particular, see people get on and off horses (with permission from the owner), but I live in an area where theres practically a livery yard or riding school on every corner.

Some people live in places where the only horses you'll ever see are police horses and you've no idea when, or where.

Few puppy owners seem to understand exactly what 'socialisation and habituation' really mean, nor how to go about if they have heard of it. I can't imagine many people who live in urban areas, would EVER consider they should habituate their dogs to horses if they're something they rarely or never (to date) see!

GoTeamTired · 24/03/2023 18:09

My dog is not used to being around horses, sheep, cows, etc. So we put her on a lead when we see them at a distance.

I don't think she would bother them, she is very meek. But not worth the risk

This man is an idiot.

Cerealkillerontheloose · 24/03/2023 17:44

This was one of my fears with my horse!!! I carried a really big hunting whip for this kind of thing not that it might have been much help. Poor horse.

yes the book should be thrown at dog and owner!

SoShallINever · 24/03/2023 16:49

I thought that police dogs and horses had the same status as police officers, in which case the dog attacked a Police officer?
It needs to be destroyed and its owner jailed.
The horse deserves a gallantry medal, it did so well not to bolt.

FrostyFifi · 24/03/2023 16:28

This situation reminded me of the dog who killed Freddie the seal in London. Anyone remembers?

Yep, owner happily let her dog off-lead and that happened, then legged it. Are people that stupid, honestly? Yes dogs have a prey drive but as a responsible owner ffs mitigate it. It was a terrier-type dog so she should have known.

Novita · 24/03/2023 16:17

Once I was walking in more deprived part of the city and a man with bully was there. No lead and the street was busy. Ugh.

xogossipgirlxo · 24/03/2023 16:14

This situation reminded me of the dog who killed Freddie the seal in London. Anyone remembers? I was furious when I found out. It's always the bloody owners who can't keep their dogs on lead in public places. So annoying.

Theskyoutsideisblue · 24/03/2023 15:58

I had 2 dogs cross a river to attack my horse. I came off and got a stud in the knee. She had been cross country so had studs in. Still have the scar. Dog owners legged it while everyone was trying to catch my hors and sort me out

FrostyFifi · 24/03/2023 15:53

@ChardonnaysBeastlyCat my huge sympathies lie with you and other responsible dog owners, it must be so stressful knowing that a percentage of dogs out there are both dog-aggressive and owned by absolute melts like the idiot in this case, and that your own cared-for pet might be at risk.

I still remember a really upsetting post in the Doghouse where someone's puppy was mauled to death right in front of her.

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 24/03/2023 15:52

Just watched it - wow.

That owner is a piece of shit. His 'efforts' to stop the dog were laughable. I found myself rooting for the poor horse to just kick the dog in the head, and that's not something I thought I would say.

My first thoughts were surely it needs to be euthanised - she cannot be trusted.

But, it's actually the owner that is the issue. The owner can't be trusted.

With the correct owner, it could be that the dog could go on to have no further incidents like this.

I think my stance would be very different if he genuinely seemed ashamed, took responsibility for his fuck up and actually made a decent effort to stop the attack.

I do think she will be put to sleep though, I think it would be foolish of them not too. This is a chance to show a zero tolerance approach.

I would rather see the owner served with prison time, a hefty fine and a lifetime ban on owning any animal.

Greensleeves · 24/03/2023 15:45

The dog has to be euthanized, and the owner should be prosecuted and jailed.

The breed (and those similar, which account for the majority of the recent spate of lethal attacks on people and livestock) should be banned.

I would also suggest the following measures be introduced:

All dog ownership should be subject to prior vetting and licensing
All dogs must be microchipped and DNA tested, with a central database holding all the information
Any dog which attacks and injures a human being should be euthanised
Dog wardens should be reintroduced in all areas, and dog shit left in public should be DNA tested and the owners fined, with repeat offenders banned from owning dogs
All dogs should be on leads in public unless they are in an area specifically designated for off-lead dogs (certain open spaces, dog areas of beaches etc)
As part of licensing and registration, all dog owners should have to attend accredited training programmes, with certificates of completion issued which can be shown to police/dog wardens on request.

I'm so fucking sick of shit dog owners, shit dog behaviour, and...shit. Everywhere.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 24/03/2023 15:24

Crocodilla · 24/03/2023 14:39

Definitely OP. I think all bull breeds should always be muzzled and on a lead and I say that as an owner of 11 dogs one of which would be considered a bull breed (by default I hasten to add as her owner died.)

I am sick to death of hearing about innocent people and animals being mauled and terrified by idiots and their vile dogs. No dog should get a second chance in situations like that. There's plenty of lovely dogs needing homes. Put all these horrible bastard aggressive dogs to sleep. When they're an endangered species, we can think again. Fed up with it the bastard things and their twat owners.

I'm sick to my back teeth of this and I have dogs.

I'm sick of the attacks, I'm sick of reading about attacks, and of all dogs being tarred with the same brush, even though in most cases it's the family dogs that caused some injuries. I worry it will lead to call for muzzles and no off lead exercise for all dogs and dogs like mine, lovely, well behaved and well loved will suffer.

I'm sick and tired of seeing idiots with statement dogs with absolutely no idea about how to train said dogs.

I'm sick with worry that they might attack one of my lovely boys or me.

What happen to human decency and common sense? Why are we drowning in fuckwittage like the one with the bully owner?

OriginalMama · 24/03/2023 14:50

Experts will be assessing the dog. The human should be put down though. Idiot. We all know what sort of person he’ll be.

Poor horse. So upsetting.

Wolfiefan · 24/03/2023 14:41

But the type of owner who was involved in this attack wouldn’t comply. There is already the law that dogs must be under control in public. That doesn’t happen and isn’t enforced.

Crocodilla · 24/03/2023 14:39

Definitely OP. I think all bull breeds should always be muzzled and on a lead and I say that as an owner of 11 dogs one of which would be considered a bull breed (by default I hasten to add as her owner died.)

I am sick to death of hearing about innocent people and animals being mauled and terrified by idiots and their vile dogs. No dog should get a second chance in situations like that. There's plenty of lovely dogs needing homes. Put all these horrible bastard aggressive dogs to sleep. When they're an endangered species, we can think again. Fed up with it the bastard things and their twat owners.

EdithStourton · 24/03/2023 11:47

Gah, pressed send by mistake!

People should get dogs in line with their abilities, not their ambitions. If you don't want to deal with high prey drive and massive tenacity, don't get a dog whose ancestors were bred to take down bulls or kill other dogs.

EdithStourton · 24/03/2023 11:45

Pei^^

OopsAnotherOne · 24/03/2023 10:06

Disgraceful incident of poor dog ownership and the kicker for me? The fact that even though their dog aggressively attacked a horse for a sustained amount of time before someone (not the owner) was finally able to stop the attack, injuring the horse who had not provoked the dog, after all of that happening the owner still blames the horse. "If it had killed someone" "if it kicks me", NEITHER OF THOSE THINGS HAPPENED. He made it all about himself and how it wasn't his dogs fault as apparently horses are capable of killing him.

The horse was not threatening to kick him or his dog, the dog approached the horses who were otherwise minding their own business. If the rider had fallen from the horse, which was bucking and rearing to try and escape the dog's jaws, and injured herself or died as a result of the fall would he have accepted that would also have been his fault? I doubt it.

If you cannot control your dog, or if it's recall isn't 100%, don't take it off the lead in places where there are animals or people. Don't let your dog approach anyone or any animal. If your dog cannot remain under your control for the entirety of the walk, keep it on a lead. It's not difficult.

SpinningFloppa · 24/03/2023 09:50

Yes it should be put down but I hate all dogs. Dd is scared of dogs and I’m so sick of the rude owners who mostly shout at her for being scared, she had someone shout at her the other day saying “it’s only a fucking dog!!” Well not everyone likes dogs.

Leonberger · 24/03/2023 09:46

I really believe the penalty for anyone with a dog out of control needs to be much higher. This owner shouldn't be allowed to own a pet, never-mind one of this size and breeding as he clearly has not got the capacity to understand where he has gone wrong.

People get away with owning untrained, annoying and dangerous dogs, both big and small and it really needs to be stamped down on asap.