Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DS to go to the best university?

419 replies

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:36

DS now has five offers from universities: three Russell Group, one a well-regarded uni but not RG and one a newer university (former poly years ago) offering him BBC (he is predicted AAB). The courses are pretty similar at all five unis (can't go into more detail because he would be furious if he found out I was posting on MN!).

He is adamant that he wants to go to the former poly because he likes it the most. He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into. So he is going to firm the ex-poly (he won't have/need an insurance as it is his lowest offer).

AIBU to want him to firm one of the more prestigious Russell Group unis and insure the former poly? DH says I am as it is DS' decision and he's the one who will be going to uni.

OP posts:
rwalker · 23/03/2023 18:38

You never thrive in an environment your not happy in

being polite this is his life his future and his choice

have an opinion by all means offer advice but leave it there
the apron string need to go I’m afraid

DrPrunesquallor · 23/03/2023 18:37

Flesh · 23/03/2023 18:16

Someone on WIWIKAU's DC firmed Essex over a UCL offer.

I thought that was a strange choice.

Well the housing is definitely going to be cheaper.
One of my DS dropped UCL and Imperial for others.

Just because they’re big names doesn’t mean everyone’s supposed to be desperate to go there or indeed that they are suited to everyone.
In that sense they’re the same as everywhere else.

Maybe they wanted a campus based uni, maybe they hate London, maybe they didn’t want to spend so much on rent, maybe they hated the course or assessment methods. So many very good reasons.

Leggingslife · 23/03/2023 18:36

FrenchandSaunders · 23/03/2023 14:43

I agree with your DS, his choice, his future. Happiness is more important than a RG uni! He sounds great.

100%

notthisagainforest · 23/03/2023 18:31

It's his choice as an adult 18 is more than capable of choosing his life choices You should back off

Rayn22 · 23/03/2023 18:25

My daughter went to a RG Uni and dropped out after the first year as felt it was. Just concerned with academia and no life skills! She qualified with a 1st at a non RG Uni and the support for jobs, mental health, peer support was amazing.

She was a straight A student but the RG Uni did not suit her.

GasPanic · 23/03/2023 18:21

Nosleepforthismum · 23/03/2023 18:08

Let him make the decision. Half the point of going to uni is to experience being an adult, away from home and that comes with making their own decisions (including any mistakes).

Anecdotally, out of my friendship circle the highest earning friend didn’t go to uni at all and went down the apprenticeship route and the one that got a 2.1 from Oxford is on a very average wage so in the long run I really don’t think it matters.

Umm yes. But one of the balances in parenthood is to let your kids experiment far enough to learn, without doing themselves significant damage in the process.

It's important to save your interventions for when not intervening might cause significant damage. In this case, potentially significant lifetime financial damage.

I would still maintain that someone who wants to choose a specific university for a course because they think it will be an easy ride is not really making the choice for the right reasons and should be encouraged to defer making that choice until they have a more mature outlook and are more clear about what they want to do in life and how they want to go about doing it.

DrPrunesquallor · 23/03/2023 18:20

adriftinadenofvipers · 23/03/2023 17:44

@DrPrunesquallor curious about your comment, " Actually I did recommend Queens to another DS who’d avoided it because we re Catholic ( I think he’d got carried away with old news articles )" - I'm not sure why that would affect anyone's choice?

Queen's has pretty much always had a large population of Catholic students. This is from 2019:

"It said: “Of those who declared a religious affiliation, 35.8 per cent of students at Queen's identified themselves as Protestant, 50.6 per cent identified themselves as Catholic, with 13.6 per cent other/not declared.”

There's been a tendency for more students from a Protestant background to study elsewhere in the UK.

Re the OP, it's horses for courses. A huge amount depends on what your DS want to do. Eldest DC did their primary degree in a RG, and postgrad in another RG. The source of the primary degree matter not a jot though, because their career choice is totally dependent on the postgrad. 2nd DC also did their primary degree in a RG but the most crucial part of that degree was the placement year. Without that experience, they wouldn't have a cat in hell's chance of getting to where they want to be.

My primary degree was in a RG too, but subsequent postgrad and MSc were post 1992, same one. I actually hated the place! Not the course so much but the building - drab and utterly soulless compared to the lovely historic red brick!

I don’t know either.
I think he got carried away reading about Irish history and was scared something would happen to him.

He obviously didnt have all the incite you do.

Luckily I advised him otherwise.

Timesawastin · 23/03/2023 18:20

TheChoiceIsYours · 23/03/2023 14:48

There’s a lot of snobbery around ‘former polys’. As someone who has studied at one, as well as a RG university, the quality of course and the teaching was STREETS ahead at the old poly. There was a general air of striving for improvement and betterment, aiming high and pushing the boundaries. Staff were more dynamic, with a more forward thinking and I suppose energetic approach to research and teaching. At the RG uni I felt there was a huge amount of navel gazing and a slightly smug air of self satisfaction, almost. They were trading off their reputation and the teaching quality just didn’t back it up.

So, don’t assume that RG means best because in my experience that absolutely wasn’t the case.

And my experience was the exact opposite. Too many variables to let either of our experiences sway OP.

MMUmum · 23/03/2023 18:18

My Dd missed out on Manchester by one grade, needed AAA for law, got AAB, she ended up at Manchester met(ex poly) and has absolutely thrived. Start of university is stressful.enough without being somewhere you really don't want to be.

JamesGiantPledge1 · 23/03/2023 18:17

I have worked in graduate recruitment at a firm which would be considered an aspirational place of work in MN world. Yes, we do remove university name for the first round of assessment so RG or not, it doesn’t matter. However we leave in Alevel grades and use them to assess candidates. Generally university standing and Alevel grades are closely linked.
Obvious exception is law, then university definitely matters.

EveryoneButSam · 23/03/2023 18:16

KStockHERO · 23/03/2023 17:07

It's cell engineering which needs cell culture labs plus aseptic units.

I genuinely do work in a similar field and I agree with pp that only employing RG graduates is elitist. I actually went to an RG uni, got no hands on cell culture experience and have had a successful career for >20 years. We employ graduates from all backgrounds and manage to train them up just fine even if they haven't had this specific experience.

Flesh · 23/03/2023 18:16

Someone on WIWIKAU's DC firmed Essex over a UCL offer.

I thought that was a strange choice.

Pinkespressomachine · 23/03/2023 18:15

Hi OP,

I understand your thoughts.

Speaking from a personal perspective I have studied at a former poly & a old traditional/highly regarded uni.

I genuinely regard the knowledge base of lecturers, quality of teaching & practical experiences offered to me to have been superior at the former.

Perhaps this was exceptional, I can only speak
for myself.

I don’t know how recruiters would view this, perhaps they are judgemental on these matters.

Perhaps your son just had a gut instinct that the old poly was more appealing, it needn’t have been that he thought he’d have an easier life there.

I know in terms of pay etc, I haven’t had the edge over others for completing my education at the posher pile of bricks.

thing47 · 23/03/2023 18:13

No. Lots of RG universities attract funding enough to have these facilities. Non-RGs don't consistently attract those funding levels.

Interesting @KStockHERO . How does that stack up against the fact that there are 5 or 6 non-RG universities in the top 20 rankings for biology and biological science?

DD1 was at Nottingham Trent some years ago and chose it because the labs were so much better than most other unis for her particular interests.

Ditto with DD2 here @GnomeDePlume, though the nightlife might have been a factor too! She had a great time, lots of partying, lots of representing the university at sport all over the country. Oh, and she did well enough to go and get a Masters (with Distinction) from a university ranked above Cambridge and every other RG university bar Oxford for her particular field of STEM. She has experience in biosecure labs and is currently looking into PhDs. If she were into cell engineering I'm pretty sure she could cope in KStockHERO's DH's lab despite her first degree being from a post-1992 university.

nokidshere · 23/03/2023 18:13

lots of employers now haven’t got access to where you did your degree only what you did and what grade. What about CVs?? I don't believe this. An employer will want to know where someone has gone to Uni!

@piedbeauty as I said further down the thread DS1 is a graduate applying for jobs now and the majority don't accept a CV and the application form is blind. So no information on sex, uni, grade, religion etc. They match to the person & job spec only.

AliMonkey · 23/03/2023 18:12

RG does not mean automatically mean good student experience. It's based on research capability so the teaching could be rubbish (the theory is that if they do great research then they have interesting things to teach, but they could still be rubbish at teaching it). Yes it might be a mistake but I suspect it isn't. He needs to be somewhere that he wants to be with a course he wants to do, and that's so much more important than being somewhere prestigious, as long as the course isn't something so specialist and unusual that it would put off most employers.

As an employer, we decide who to interview with details like uni removed from the CV (by someone not involved in the decision). When we do look later in process, often someone from a more middling uni in terms of reputation is a better fit to come in at a graduate level than someone from a prestigious uni who thinks they are too important to do the basic graduate level tasks. We also have good experiences with grads who didn't do so well at school but did brilliantly at uni - they are generally on an upwards trajectory, often having had to battle hard to get to uni in the first place.

I've visited lots of unis with DD over the last year and her decisions have been based on course, campus, city, students, staff, and just generally how it felt when she was there. Her firm choice is the one with the second lowest grades of her five offers and I absolutely think it's the right choice for her, even though she will probably get the grades required for the others as well. It happens to be RG but I'd have still supported her if it wasn't.

All you can do anyway is give your opinion and hope that it works out well for him. And if it doesn't he hopefully can't blame you - though teenagers can usually find a reason to blame their parents for everything!

nicknamehelp · 23/03/2023 18:10

It's his life and he's the one who's got to live in that place and attend that Uni so should go where he feels he will be happiest.

Nosleepforthismum · 23/03/2023 18:08

Let him make the decision. Half the point of going to uni is to experience being an adult, away from home and that comes with making their own decisions (including any mistakes).

Anecdotally, out of my friendship circle the highest earning friend didn’t go to uni at all and went down the apprenticeship route and the one that got a 2.1 from Oxford is on a very average wage so in the long run I really don’t think it matters.

VickyEadieofThigh · 23/03/2023 18:08

I agree with those saying it must be his choice. But this bit puzzled me:

"He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into."

He'd have to achieve the grades requested, so how would that mean he had "just scraped" into it?

RoseBucket · 23/03/2023 18:07

@Oilrigger apart from the snobby ex poly term I can understand your concern.

My daughter was offered places at University’s ranked 1, 2, 3 and 5 for her subject, only number 5 was a RG Uni.

Anyway she completely changed her mind where she wanted to go and is at number 54. The teaching is very hit and miss but she is enjoying the course and has made great friends.

What does make a difference is it offers extra vocational hands on qualifications separate to the degree but directly related to the subject and that is what I think we make her stand out to future employers.

I was very worried but she is now an adult and it’s working out well in the end.

TizerorFizz · 23/03/2023 18:05

@Oilrigger
He really won’t get a 2:2 at a RG university. Very few do. With his predicted grades he’s not got an offer from Oxbridge or Imperial has he? So he’s really academically ok and should do as well as the majority. A 2:1 from many RG plus universities is better than a first from a lower regarded one.

I also think careers are seen as important by more grads at RG. They expect certain careers. They learn with others who are ambitious. This isn’t everywhere and on every course but lots of students see the elite RG as a stepping stone on the cv.

Plenty of DCs have fun at university. It’s not all work and no play. Also I agree with local students choosing local universities skewIng the student body. They probably don’t have much ambition to leave their city, ever.

A 2:1 from a top 15 RG is worth more. He would get this! Employers don’t always look at university but they do tests to choose the candidates to take forward to interview . RG university grads still do better and earn a premium over others so it’s possibly false to think he will do just as well with a first from a bottom 50 university. It also depends on what degree subject. A lot!

Another issue sometimes considered is why a AAB student didn’t challenge themselves. Recruiters know where they could have gone! So they might question the decision. They might think DC is lazy and unambitious. If he is. That’s it really. Sounds like it.

nandos12 · 23/03/2023 18:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lovemusic33 · 23/03/2023 18:03

OP, there was a post on here a few months ago where a mum was feeling guilty for forcing her dc to go to a Russel group uni, they were miserable and wanted to drop out.

My dd had offers from 3 Russel groups, they offered her A*,A, B which was her predicted grades. She had her heart set on Exeter Uni until we viewed other unis and she fell in love with a non Russel group who offered her B,B,C. I was worried when she wanted to secure the non Russel group uni but I had to let her make her own choice. Taking a uni offering B,B,C took a huge amount of pressure off her and meant she has no worries about not meeting the grades. She’s now coming up to the end of her first year and is loving uni life and the course she chose, she 100% made the right choice.

Digitalisaredangerous · 23/03/2023 17:59

I recruit for somewhere graduates want to work. It's blind on school, university and name. I'm interested in the cv, personal statement and competency examples at the first sift.

clary · 23/03/2023 17:59

Hi OP - I see you are not keen to say course or uni, which is a shame as advice would be more meaningful.

Here are my thoughts:

  • He needs to want to go where he goes so he should make that decision,
  • However, if his main reason is that it will be easier to get a higher class of degree, then I agree that that is a poor reason (and very possibly not even true)
  • RG is certainly not the be-all and end-all - depending on the course
  • There is something in the suggestion from PPs that the grades others achieve will have a bearing on your experience. DD went somewhere where a lot of students had similar grades to her at A level (BBC) and she felt that it was a more relaxed vibe and not as cutthroat as she suspected it might have been at Warwick. But a friend's DD got A-star and two As and is at a uni which offered her BBC - and I think she is finding that a bit of an issue. I recall one of the best things about my uni experience was suddenly being among people who were so much better at my subject than I was. That's unlikely perhaps if you are a low-aiming high-achiever, to coin a phrase.
  • Please PLEASE can we stop talking about 'ex-polys'! Few of the students at them were even born when they were polytechnics. They are universities. And Lincoln Uni is not an ex-poly fwiw. No such thing as Lincoln Poly.
Swipe left for the next trending thread