Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DS to go to the best university?

419 replies

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:36

DS now has five offers from universities: three Russell Group, one a well-regarded uni but not RG and one a newer university (former poly years ago) offering him BBC (he is predicted AAB). The courses are pretty similar at all five unis (can't go into more detail because he would be furious if he found out I was posting on MN!).

He is adamant that he wants to go to the former poly because he likes it the most. He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into. So he is going to firm the ex-poly (he won't have/need an insurance as it is his lowest offer).

AIBU to want him to firm one of the more prestigious Russell Group unis and insure the former poly? DH says I am as it is DS' decision and he's the one who will be going to uni.

OP posts:
adriftinadenofvipers · 24/03/2023 02:27

MFL are greatly undervalued in universities overall. Eldest started the degree in a post 1992 and then they abandoned all MFL courses! She fortunately transferred to an RG uni for French and Spanish but even there the options were limited. The UK as a whole is shite so far as languages are concerned.

They opted for a PGCE in another RG uni with a bursary of £26k because the profession is so desperate to recruit languages teachers!! Now in 3rd year teaching having had two one year contracts but permanent full time now.

Streamside · 24/03/2023 00:00

My daughter attended a Russel group uni and found them to be very focused on their foreign students.She went into her course knowing no-one but most of the local students had arrived en masse from the local catchment schools so didn't socialise outside their friendship groups. Group Work was extremely difficult and she felt very isolated.Her masters was completed at an ex poly and she was so impressed with their teaching and the social aspects of the course.

Wiltingflowers · 23/03/2023 23:56

Plenty of students don’t get grad work at all. Ex polys do work related degrees very well and modern engineering and sciences. MFL is virtually untaught by them. Don’t try and go to a poly if you are great at MFL!

Notable exception @TizerorFizz is Sheffield Hallam. Their MFL courses are great and v highly rated. Friend’s DD doing French and Spanish with business and loves it. 18 months spent abroad (not just the normal year) and graduate job prospects are fantastic. Other than that, I agree with you and can’t think of ex polys that are good for languages

AutumnLeaves23 · 23/03/2023 23:51

Yes I do think some parents are a bit lazy/snobby and just look up RG universities, without actually thinking about how good a University actually is in that area or for that student. It takes time to investigate a University. I also think it’s so that parent can hold up their head to ‘other parents’. Honestly as soon as I I hear parents mention ‘RG’ I do judge them, not the way that they want!

Onthenosecco · 23/03/2023 23:44

AutumnLeaves23 · 23/03/2023 17:13

That’s crazy, many non RG universities are as good if not better than RG. I went to a really excellent University in the UK, it’s just not in the Russell Group, but was one of the best in my subject and it was quite hard to get in. Not every University even wants to be in the Russell Group - it’s not an independent verified ranking of Universities - its’ a group of Universities who set up the group themselves!

I agree.

I got accepted into two RG universities and turned them both down to take a less prestigious university.

Although not as “prestigious”, the uni I went to did a very niche course which was EXACTLY what I wanted to do.

The RG unis would have eventually led me to the same place, but it would have taken a year more to get there; and I’d have less job specific training.

I was also able to have a better standard of living by living in a cheaper city. My money went much further.

TizerorFizz · 23/03/2023 23:38

To correct something: 50% of lawyers don’t have law degrees. In order to compete, you need RG plus. You need an academic degree. University and degree matter.

Employers might not look at university , but RG still wins out overall. Elite courses at elite universities win out even more. Doctors do best of all. Scientists mostly get jobs. Arts students struggle. Plenty of students don’t get grad work at all. Ex polys do work related degrees very well and modern engineering and sciences. MFL is virtually untaught by them. Don’t try and go to a poly if you are great at MFL!

So on the job application, there might not be university but there could well be A levels and lots of other info. There might also be spelling mistakes, poor grammar and basically a poor application.

To answer a question, some elite employers do target certain universities. They really do know who they want!

novalia89 · 23/03/2023 23:24

mintich · 23/03/2023 16:47

It really depends on the subject. I'm an optometrist and you can only study optometry at a few universities. Some are RG, some former polys. In our industry, no-one will care where the degree came from

Yes, I want to change careers to optometry and the closest one is Salford. There are no RG or even red bricks in the area.

Dotcheck · 23/03/2023 22:14

RachelSq · 23/03/2023 15:45

I went to a top tier uni (requirement AAA, but would now include A* now that these are a thing). I flunked it and got a 2:2, as did a good chunk of my year in my subject (about a third of us).

My sibling did the same subject at an ex-Poly and got a 1st (and had BBC as A Levels).

Honestly the calibre of his course was terrible compared to mine (I could have passed his final year after my first year easily) but he still managed to get the unrelated graduate jobs whereas I was the one struggling to get one because of the 2:1 requirement.

In the end I’ve jumped him again career wise, but I still begrudge that he had a more fun time at uni and got a better grade meaning his start in professional life was easier.

So I’d say go for the ex-Poly unless you actually think you’re academic research material where the better course actually matters.

How unpleasant

RampantIvy · 23/03/2023 22:12

The worst snobbery on that other thread was from overpaid lawyers.
I was told that DD's degree wasn't worth the paper it was written on by the snobbiest of the lot (1st class, accredited by the RBS from an RG university that wasn't top 10)

My own personal feelings are when you’re 18, you are an adult and responsible for your own decisions.

A popular MN myth. You are legally an adult at 18. However, a great many 18 year olds are not mature and responsible enough to make the right decisions without guidance.

I feel like a lot of MN view life as an airport with the ultimate goal being a seat in first class. It's such a joyless way to view life.

Oh, well said @Clymene - first class in many cases being a career in law or in the city with a 6 figure salary.

Have there ever been threads of strict/controlling parents who refused to let their kids move away from home for uni?

Sadly, yes, but on the WIWIKAU Facebook page @nandos12 and The Student Room. Often it is parents from other cultures who don't want their daughters to go away to university. They want them to go to the local university and live at home.

In many cases finances will come into it, which is why we need to get rid of the notion that students from non RG+ (by + I also mean, Bath, Loghborough, Lancaster and St Andrews) aren't worth employing. Many students go to the local non RG universities for many reasons not related to their academic ability.

bungaloid · 23/03/2023 22:06

Whilst I am reasonably open minded, I absolutely think differently when I see someone who has studied a relevant degree or PhD somewhere well known for that subject (science).

Bunnycat101 · 23/03/2023 21:59

But… even with institution blind recruitment those from elite institutions tend to to be more successful in getting into grad schemes. That might be because they are cleverer or possibly more affluent so have had more chances to develop some of the softer skills or polish required (and therefore nothing to do with the university) or those universities might offer better preparation for grad recruitment either through the course itself (eg tutorial system at oxbridge) or simply peer pressure, higher expectations etc.

Good students can do well regardless of institution but the stats will be more in the favour of those at certain universities.

Bunnycat101 · 23/03/2023 21:51

@Madcats the cv blind will tend to be a standard application often looking at competencies looking at team work etc. The extent of ‘blindness’ will vary from personal details like name to university/classification, other employers etc. Most likely there would be maths and verbal reasoning tests too to cut the numbers down.

Madcats · 23/03/2023 21:28

Forgive me (but I have a teen figuring out what to do and where):
How on earth do Unis choose
How on earth do employers choose

Do the big employers still do milk rounds ir are they all expecting kids to canter about the country to do interviews? If they are are recruiting CV blind, how does that work?

Motherhubbardscupboard · 23/03/2023 20:27

I recruit graduates and our recruitment is blind, I don't see the candidates' CVs at all. However, that will only apply to his first job, and not at all employers. For subsequent jobs his uni will be on his CV and certain uni's do impress more.

adriftinadenofvipers · 23/03/2023 20:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I worked years ago for what was then one of the big 5 consulting firms - they loved Oxbridge then Durham. That was a long time ago though.

OMGitsnotgood · 23/03/2023 19:56

Can't they just look at a candidates LinkedIn page? Everyone dd knows has a very comprehensive LinkedIn profile including uni, school and degree grade

They can if they think it's relevant. For us it genuinely wasn't important which university someone went to. It's true as PP said that the graduate recruitment team was more active on some uni campuses than others. Doesn't stop anyone applying and being considered equally with anyone else, regardless of uni.
Caveat as previously stated: might not be true of all professions/niche roles but I know for sure that the majority of recruiters do not take university into consideration.

MorningMoaner · 23/03/2023 19:53

Can't they just look at a candidates LinkedIn page
Could be a bit tricky without knowing the candidates name.
Every application I have looked at in recent years has had all identifying details removed prior to shortlisting and I have only known who the candidate is at interview.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 23/03/2023 19:46

Stugs · 23/03/2023 19:41

Can't they just look at a candidates LinkedIn page? Everyone dd knows has a very comprehensive LinkedIn profile including uni, school and degree grade

In the civil service at least the names aren’t revealed to those sifting through the applications so they couldn’t. Even in situations where they have the name the recruiters are going to follow the guidelines they have. What’s the point in giving yourself extra work by looking up people on the internet when you’re judging them by their application.

Stugs · 23/03/2023 19:41

OMGitsnotgood · 23/03/2023 19:36

I don't believe this. An employer will want to know where someone has gone to Uni!

This is simply not true for the majority of employers. Might be true for a few specific companies/professions. Although the major corporate I worked for did know which uni someone went to (they might be blind now I don't know) it made no difference whatsoever where someone got their degree from. A degree simply shows that someone has a particular academic ability (we only wanted 2:1 or a first). Selection is more about all the other skills/competencies/characteristics that make a candidate a good match for the company and the role.

Can't they just look at a candidates LinkedIn page? Everyone dd knows has a very comprehensive LinkedIn profile including uni, school and degree grade

ThomasinaLivesHere · 23/03/2023 19:40

There are quite a few saying a 2:1 at a top uni is equivalent to a 2:2 at a lower rated one. I think in terms of difficulty it may be true but not for value in applying for jobs. With exceptions like law.

I know someone that got a 2:2 at St Andrews and they found it really hard to find a position as most graduate positions require a 2:1 minimum. They just ended up in a job they could have got without a degree. Had they gone to a uni with a lower rating and got a 2:1 there I’m sure they’d have had better prospects.

OMGitsnotgood · 23/03/2023 19:36

I don't believe this. An employer will want to know where someone has gone to Uni!

This is simply not true for the majority of employers. Might be true for a few specific companies/professions. Although the major corporate I worked for did know which uni someone went to (they might be blind now I don't know) it made no difference whatsoever where someone got their degree from. A degree simply shows that someone has a particular academic ability (we only wanted 2:1 or a first). Selection is more about all the other skills/competencies/characteristics that make a candidate a good match for the company and the role.

SophiaSW1 · 23/03/2023 19:18

Yea YABU. He needs to go where he will be happy

WandaWonder · 23/03/2023 19:15

As you know it is up to him but to simplify it, yes to me notcaying you are, it comes across as a 'it sounds better if to go to Oxbridge' not that it is better

He needs to do what is right for him

Parker231 · 23/03/2023 19:05

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:44

"lots of employers now haven’t got access to where you did your degree only what you did and what grade"

Amazed by this if true. So there's literally no advantage in going to a prestigious uni like Oxford or St Andrews when it comes to getting a job? That does make me feel better about the ex-poly!

Many employers now use cv blind recruitment particularly for graduate schemes

AlecTrevelyan006 · 23/03/2023 19:03

piedbeauty · 23/03/2023 17:04

lots of employers now haven’t got access to where you did your degree only what you did and what grade.

What about CVs??

I don't believe this. An employer will want to know where someone has gone to Uni!

In larger companies with HR dept they remove details such as name of school/college/uni before passing info to the hiring manage. It’s becoming very common practice to leave out this, plus any other info relating to sex/age/religion etc