Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want DS to go to the best university?

419 replies

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:36

DS now has five offers from universities: three Russell Group, one a well-regarded uni but not RG and one a newer university (former poly years ago) offering him BBC (he is predicted AAB). The courses are pretty similar at all five unis (can't go into more detail because he would be furious if he found out I was posting on MN!).

He is adamant that he wants to go to the former poly because he likes it the most. He also reasons that he will have a more enjoyable and less pressurised time there and that he is more likely to get a good class of degree (2.1 or 1st) from the ex-poly - rather than a 2.2 from a Russell Group uni that he just scrapes into. So he is going to firm the ex-poly (he won't have/need an insurance as it is his lowest offer).

AIBU to want him to firm one of the more prestigious Russell Group unis and insure the former poly? DH says I am as it is DS' decision and he's the one who will be going to uni.

OP posts:
Sunshine275 · 24/03/2023 08:25

Let him go where he wants to go, it’s his life and he’ll be living there/experiencing it not yours. Push him into going somewhere he doesn’t want to he’s more likely to quit.

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 08:06

TizerorFizz · 23/03/2023 23:38

To correct something: 50% of lawyers don’t have law degrees. In order to compete, you need RG plus. You need an academic degree. University and degree matter.

Employers might not look at university , but RG still wins out overall. Elite courses at elite universities win out even more. Doctors do best of all. Scientists mostly get jobs. Arts students struggle. Plenty of students don’t get grad work at all. Ex polys do work related degrees very well and modern engineering and sciences. MFL is virtually untaught by them. Don’t try and go to a poly if you are great at MFL!

So on the job application, there might not be university but there could well be A levels and lots of other info. There might also be spelling mistakes, poor grammar and basically a poor application.

To answer a question, some elite employers do target certain universities. They really do know who they want!

Going to an RG Uni doesn’t mean that you aren’t going to make spelling and grammar errors on an application form.

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 08:04

MeridaBrave · 24/03/2023 07:59

That was my experience in graduate recruitment - for ex poly they wanted a 1st, for RG a 2:1 and Oxbridge a 2:2. But that was years ago. And would depend on what graduate job, that was for accountancy at big firm.

Most of the Big 4 accountancy firms and some of the mid tier now recruit cv blind as do some of the law firms. They have done their own research and determined that exam success doesn’t necessarily mean that you are going to be the best employee.

ChocSaltyBalls · 24/03/2023 08:03

TizerorFizz · 23/03/2023 23:38

To correct something: 50% of lawyers don’t have law degrees. In order to compete, you need RG plus. You need an academic degree. University and degree matter.

Employers might not look at university , but RG still wins out overall. Elite courses at elite universities win out even more. Doctors do best of all. Scientists mostly get jobs. Arts students struggle. Plenty of students don’t get grad work at all. Ex polys do work related degrees very well and modern engineering and sciences. MFL is virtually untaught by them. Don’t try and go to a poly if you are great at MFL!

So on the job application, there might not be university but there could well be A levels and lots of other info. There might also be spelling mistakes, poor grammar and basically a poor application.

To answer a question, some elite employers do target certain universities. They really do know who they want!

But not all lawyers want to work for large/magic circle law firms anyway. I couldn’t imagine anything worse!

MeridaBrave · 24/03/2023 07:59

Ishefuckingkiddingme · 23/03/2023 15:00

Do you work in graduate recruitment? If so, yeesh

That was my experience in graduate recruitment - for ex poly they wanted a 1st, for RG a 2:1 and Oxbridge a 2:2. But that was years ago. And would depend on what graduate job, that was for accountancy at big firm.

Parker231 · 24/03/2023 07:51

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:26

MFL is mostly a joke degree for not very bright students. So many Europeans grow up speaking 2-3 (or even more) languages by the time they even start high school. The idea that you should be "wasting" your degree trying to learn French or Spanish is completely and totally absurd. If you want to know hose languages then you should learn them when you are young.

A 21 year old MFL graduate literally has the same skills that a 12 year old Swiss kid has (who knows English, Dutch and French by default). Its absurd to say that you should waste your degree on this rather than learning an actual skill or academic discipline.

DD - all A’s at GCSE and A level has done a MFL degree. She got a first. In part helped by growing up trilingual but she has also added several other languages. Now works as a conference translator for the EU.
Not bad for someone obviously not bright! You haven’t a clue what you’re talking about!

btw - Swiss children don’t grow up learning Dutch!

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 07:41

I think some people have such a narrow view about work. DD has a biological sciences degree and is working in a healthcare setting and has applied to do a healthcare related masters.

This won't bring her a 6 figure salary in London, but she would absolutely hate an office job, and does not want to live in London.

Yet the assumption from highly paid London based lawyers/bankers and other city career driven posters is that everyone wants to do that. These people then look down their noses at anyone who doesn't have aspirations to go to a top 10 university. They should have their own threads.

Clymene · 24/03/2023 07:22

I think living in a little place in the highlands with a dog and doing creative things sounds idyllic

Stugs · 24/03/2023 07:15

Dd is in lower sixth and says she'll "go somewhere and do something". She's got a fantastic work ethic, working at Bs currently with the hope of maybe one or two As. She'd really be happy mucking out in a stable yard and riding horses all day and tbh I'm more than happy for her to pick a nice place to study and have fun for three years. My older dd was obsessed with RG, flogged herself to the brink of MH problems, got into an excellent uni and cries regularly about workload and pressure. It's just not worth it IMO.

Stugs · 24/03/2023 07:11

PhotoDad · 24/03/2023 05:50

Can we post this on all the multiple threads about uni choice?

Obviously earning a living wage is important, but...

FWIW, what I mostly enjoyed about each of the four degrees I have (currently working on a fifth) was the academic content. I'm a teacher. DD's dream life would be scraping a living as a freelancer doing the creative career she loves, in a little place somewhere in the Highlands, maybe with a dog. Fingers crossed for her.

I love this!

OMGitsnotgood · 24/03/2023 07:08

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:26

MFL is mostly a joke degree for not very bright students. So many Europeans grow up speaking 2-3 (or even more) languages by the time they even start high school. The idea that you should be "wasting" your degree trying to learn French or Spanish is completely and totally absurd. If you want to know hose languages then you should learn them when you are young.

A 21 year old MFL graduate literally has the same skills that a 12 year old Swiss kid has (who knows English, Dutch and French by default). Its absurd to say that you should waste your degree on this rather than learning an actual skill or academic discipline.

Well you just lost any credibility you might have had with that post.

RampantIvy · 24/03/2023 06:40

Your posts are deliberately goady and ignorant @jfl
Not everyone wants to live in London. Southampton is RG, and £50k is a pretty good salary where I live.

I done a maths degree from one of the above places

Your command of English grammar is wanting and you are a crashing snob.

Clymene · 24/03/2023 06:24

I missed that @Alaimo GrinGrin

And he done a maths degree and all!

Bunnycat101 · 24/03/2023 06:22

“MFL is mostly a joke degree for not very bright students.”

@jfl this is just not true. The language learning aspects of most MFL degrees is a small component. They are basically history/literature degrees with added language skills.

The course options at Cambridge don’t exactly look like a doss for example- eg this is history module with core texts in Russian. https://www.mmll.cam.ac.uk/sl11

SL11: Russia in Revolution 1861-1917 | Faculty of Modern and Medieval Languages and Linguistics

https://www.mmll.cam.ac.uk/sl11

PhotoDad · 24/03/2023 05:50

Clymene · 23/03/2023 17:45

I'm old enough to remember when having a degree was supposed to be a really fun and engaging experience before joining the drudgery of work. Yes, working hard was important (I got a 2:1) but it wasn't supposed to be the next stage on the travelator to retirement.

I feel like a lot of MN view life as an airport with the ultimate goal being a seat in first class. It's such a joyless way to view life.

Can we post this on all the multiple threads about uni choice?

Obviously earning a living wage is important, but...

FWIW, what I mostly enjoyed about each of the four degrees I have (currently working on a fifth) was the academic content. I'm a teacher. DD's dream life would be scraping a living as a freelancer doing the creative career she loves, in a little place somewhere in the Highlands, maybe with a dog. Fingers crossed for her.

Alaimo · 24/03/2023 05:47

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:26

MFL is mostly a joke degree for not very bright students. So many Europeans grow up speaking 2-3 (or even more) languages by the time they even start high school. The idea that you should be "wasting" your degree trying to learn French or Spanish is completely and totally absurd. If you want to know hose languages then you should learn them when you are young.

A 21 year old MFL graduate literally has the same skills that a 12 year old Swiss kid has (who knows English, Dutch and French by default). Its absurd to say that you should waste your degree on this rather than learning an actual skill or academic discipline.

The fact that you think Swiss kids grow up learning Dutch clearly shows you have no idea what you're talking about.

OMGitsnotgood · 24/03/2023 05:37

Yes, I want to change careers to optometry and the closest one is Salford. There are no RG or even red bricks in the area.

Manchester?!

Stugs · 24/03/2023 05:35

Isn't Southampton an RG uni?

PhotoDad · 24/03/2023 05:35

I have degrees from Oxbridge and RG in an academic subject. I was happy (although I had to work very hard).

DD is studying at a Post-'92 for a vocational subject. She is happy (although she has to work very hard).

DD has far more contact hours than I had anywhere, but much the same amount of work to do. As many PPs have said, it depends on all sorts of things. Horses for courses! (Or courses for horses?)

jfl · 24/03/2023 05:07

Believe what you like. I done a maths degree from one of the above places and almost everyone in my class (including me) who wanted a City job got one without much effort. The idea that they would get rejected in favour of a candidate with a 2:1 from Southampton or Plymouth is absurd. I can only assume people posting this nonsense just dont live in the world in which these top jobs/degrees exist.

Clymene · 24/03/2023 05:00

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:40

"If you go to Oxbridge the employers seek you out. They nay not be allowed to ask but they know."

Pretty much. If an employer is "institution-blind" then this just tells you that they dont value intelligence and are prioritising a diverse workforce, which is a huge red flag.

If you are smart/talented then you want to work for someone who will value your intelligence. The companies which actually pay real salaries (£100k+ in your 20s) all have an enormous Oxbridge/Imperial/LSE bias. Most buy-side firms (hedge funds, PE, VC) recruit exclusively from those universities and (as you say) dont do much public advertising outside of them. And the top law firms, investment banks, MBB, FAANG, relevant tech startups, etc all heavily prioritise recruiting from top universities.

Its only the mid-tier firms (accountancy, lower tier engineering, legacy tech, etc) who make a big deal of "not caring about institution", since they know that its unlikely that top graduates would choose those firms anyway, since pay isnt competitive.

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:40

"If you go to Oxbridge the employers seek you out. They nay not be allowed to ask but they know."

Pretty much. If an employer is "institution-blind" then this just tells you that they dont value intelligence and are prioritising a diverse workforce, which is a huge red flag.

If you are smart/talented then you want to work for someone who will value your intelligence. The companies which actually pay real salaries (£100k+ in your 20s) all have an enormous Oxbridge/Imperial/LSE bias. Most buy-side firms (hedge funds, PE, VC) recruit exclusively from those universities and (as you say) dont do much public advertising outside of them. And the top law firms, investment banks, MBB, FAANG, relevant tech startups, etc all heavily prioritise recruiting from top universities.

Its only the mid-tier firms (accountancy, lower tier engineering, legacy tech, etc) who make a big deal of "not caring about institution", since they know that its unlikely that top graduates would choose those firms anyway, since pay isnt competitive.

Dyslexicwonder · 24/03/2023 04:33

Oilrigger · 23/03/2023 14:44

"lots of employers now haven’t got access to where you did your degree only what you did and what grade"

Amazed by this if true. So there's literally no advantage in going to a prestigious uni like Oxford or St Andrews when it comes to getting a job? That does make me feel better about the ex-poly!

If you go to Oxbridge the employers seek you out. They nay not be allowed to ask but they know.

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:26

MFL is mostly a joke degree for not very bright students. So many Europeans grow up speaking 2-3 (or even more) languages by the time they even start high school. The idea that you should be "wasting" your degree trying to learn French or Spanish is completely and totally absurd. If you want to know hose languages then you should learn them when you are young.

A 21 year old MFL graduate literally has the same skills that a 12 year old Swiss kid has (who knows English, Dutch and French by default). Its absurd to say that you should waste your degree on this rather than learning an actual skill or academic discipline.

jfl · 24/03/2023 04:22

Many of the replies in this thread are crazy

Yes its important for your child to be happy, but life doesnt end at 21. Yes, "university experience" is great and fun and important, but not being poor when you are 30 is even more important. You only have to spend some time reading mumsnet threads (let alone looking around in daily life) to see the lives full of misery that many people lead. Sure, its "fun" to do an arts degree or attend a 3rd tier university in a "nice" city, but what are you doing to do when you are 30 years old and only earning £30-40k and having to check your bank balance at the end of the month when you go shopping?

The reality is that smart people with good degrees find it easy to earn a lot of money in the modern era. A halfway intelligent person in London with a decent degree should easily be on £80k+ by their early 30s. On the other hand, you could do a "fun" course in media at Huddersfield and tell yourself that earning £40k is "good enough", while you worry about rationing your heating in winter and try to decide if shopping in Lidl will let you afford to run a car. This is surely not the sort of life you want for your child.

The above replies claiming that post-1992 universities are "really better than people think" are especially disingenuous. These universities are mostly all crap and will always be crap. Sure its elitism, but the reality is that they mainly cater to students that aren't very bright. Sure, most of the students there do "get jobs" but they are rarely well-paying jobs, and most will just fall into the usual £30-50k mediocrity. I do sometimes wonder how many of the posers who say this are really academics at post-1992s who werent able to secure academic jobs at Russell Groups and are dealing with insecurity issues.

Without wanting to overly emphasise the racial issue, I do think that this issue of low standards is mostly a white issue. Its bizarre how many middle class white families seem happy to sit back and let their kids make awful decisions that will lead to life-long poverty just because "it makes them happy" in the short term. Its almost impossible to imagine this issue even coming up in an Asian family, since "go to the best university you can" is so self-evidently obvious that its axiomatic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread